10 Best Episode Runs In Doctor Who History

Life with the Doctor involves an awful lot of running. But which of those runs was the best?

Doctor Who Human Nature Blink Utopia
BBC Studios

Doctor Who’s unique format means that its episode quality is all over the place. When you’re covering such a wide range of styles and genres, not every story is going to be universally loved.

However, occasionally, a stone-cold classic will come along – one of those episodes that is unquestionably brilliant, and everyone agrees. And more occasionally still, the show will score a winning streak, where a banger is followed by another… and another… and maybe even another. It’s rare, but not unheard of. The only question is... which of these streaks is the best?

For this list we’re only counting runs of three consecutive bangers or more (so great stories like The Girl in the Fireplace, Vincent and the Doctor, and World Enough and Time/The Doctor Falls are automatically disqualified, due to not being surrounded by other great stories). And since we're only focused on individual episodes, we’re only dealing with the revived series here.

Modern Who has had some truly incredible episodes, but when has it been most consistent? From exceptionally strong mid-series runs to epic era handovers, there’s certainly some stiff competition…

10. The Halloween Apocalypse - Village Of The Angels

Doctor Who The Halloween Apocalypse Swarm
BBC Studios

Doctor Who always responds to adversity with a plucky go-getter attitude. When faced with a global pandemic, the Chibnall-era production team opted to go bigger, not smaller, and gave us the show’s first series-long story in over 30 years.

And for the most part, the results were really quite good.

From the moment The Halloween Apocalypse opens on the Doctor and Yaz suspended upside-down on an acid planet, Flux is a rollercoaster ride that doesn’t let up. The serialised format opened up some fresh possibilities for the show (a recurring cast of characters, ongoing plot threads, weekly cliffhangers) and it worked so well that you have to wonder why it took so long for the revived era to give it a go.

War of the Sontarans and Village of the Angels are widely considered the standouts of the series, serving as terrific showcases for the Sontarans and the Weeping Angels. But kudos must also go to The Halloween Apocalypse for setting everything up so skilfully, and Once, Upon Time for being such a unique, trippy chamber piece. And throughout it all, Sam Spruell and Rochenda Sandall are exceptional as new villains Swarm and Azure.

Doctor Who Flux Village of the Angels Weeping Angel
BBC Studios

Unfortunately, Flux’s two closing episodes are far less remarkable than what came before. But those first four parts don’t really drop the ball.


9. The Day Of The Doctor - Deep Breath

Doctor Who The Day of the Doctor Matt Smith David Tennant
BBC Studios

When it came to celebrating Doctor Who’s 50th anniversary and writing out the Eleventh Doctor while introducing the Twelfth, Steven Moffat scored an absolute hat-trick.

Unlike previous multi-Doctor stories where old Doctors assemble simply for the sake of it, The Day of the Doctor is an introspective character piece, bringing three incarnations together for a very specific reason. It not only resolves a plot point from eight years prior, but sets the show up for the future, with a winning turn from John Hurt and a delightful cameo from Tom Baker.

Appreciation has grown for the following episode The Time of the Doctor over the years, and rightly so. The idea of the Doctor dropping everything to protect a town full of strangers is so simple, but so effective. And very very Doctor-y! And what better way to honour the impact of Matt Smith’s raggedy incarnation than by surrounding him with children and children’s drawings? It's an emotional, poignant conclusion for an all-timer Doctor.

And last but not least, Deep Breath is a tremendous start for the Twelfth Doctor, with some wonderful scenes between him and Clara as they rebuild their relationship. The feature-length runtime affords much more breathing space (pun intended) than the average Doctor debut, and Capaldi shines as a rougher, but no less enigmatic version of the character.

Doctor Who Deep Breath Twelfth Doctor Peter Capaldi
BBC Studios

It's a fantastic trio of episodes with some of the most fan-pleasing, gut-wrenching, and dramatic moments in the show. As episode runs go, it doesn't get much more memorable than this.


8. Father’s Day - The Doctor Dances

Doctor Who Father's Day
BBC Studios

Series 1 is regarded by many as one of Doctor Who’s best. Hell, if it wasn’t for Boom Town and The Long Game, the entire second half of the series could've made it onto this list.

Alas, the 2005 revival’s first run of consistently great episodes begins with Father’s Day, a story that takes the show’s rule of historical non-intervention and plays with it to devastating effect. The moment when Pete realises who Rose is, and what he has to do to save her and Jackie, is utterly heartbreaking.

The emotional consequences of time travel have been explored many times since, in stories like The Fires of Pompeii and Demons of the Punjab. But Father's Day did it first, and did it best.

Then came the equally groundbreaking The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances. The legacy of this story is hard to overstate – aside from the fact that it had children chanting “Are you my mummy?” up and down the country, it was the first outing for both Steven Moffat and Captain Jack Harkness, and the moment that cemented the Doctor as a romantic hero. Those scenes with Rose where he’s talking about “dancing” walked, so that his relationships with Reinette, River, and Rogue could run.

Doctor Who The Empty Child Dr Constantine
BBC Studios

It's chilling, it's genuinely funny, and it brings out the very best of the Doctor – it's Steven Moffat in a nutshell.

This story also gave us our first mention of Villengard, an organisation that continues to be a big part of the Whoniverse almost 20 years later.


7. The Power Of The Doctor - The Church On Ruby Road

Doctor Who The Power of the Doctor Thirteenth Doctor regeneration
BBC Studios

Doctor Who’s 60th anniversary was one to remember, not least because it was preceded by the BBC’s own centenary. As such, we were treated to five landmark stories over a 14-month period.

Things kicked off with Jodie Whittaker’s swansong The Power of the Doctor – a story with more returning elements than you can shake a sonic screwdriver at, from Paul “I don’t do robes” McGann, to the late, great William Russell. The result was a beautiful (if messy) celebration of the show’s legacy, where everyone gets the chance to shine.

Well, except maybe Dan. Poor Dan.

Then came the 60th itself – three anniversary specials, fronted by David Tennant and Catherine Tate. Though they perhaps didn't do the best job of celebrating the history of Doctor Who, it was a strong run of episodes overall, and there really was something for everyone to enjoy – from the family fun of The Star Beast to the craziness of The Giggle, via the wonderfully eerie horror of Wild Blue Yonder.

Finally, The Church on Ruby Road returned the show to Christmas Day with a simple yet heartfelt tale, which perfectly established Ncuti Gatwa and Millie Gibson as the new Doctor and companion. The mysteries around Ruby and Mrs Flood were tantalising, it was very Christmassy, and we even got a catchy musical number about goblins eating babies. What's not to love?!

Doctor Who The Church on Ruby Road The Goblin Song
BBC Studios

While this obviously isn't Doctor Who's best-ever run, it’s undoubtedly its biggest. It'll be a long time before we have three or four consecutive episodes on this scale.


6. The Waters Of Mars - The Eleventh Hour

Doctor Who The Waters of Mars
BBC Studios

David Tennant’s departure from Doctor Who was a pretty big deal – so much so that the BBC considered ending the show altogether.

Fortunately, Russell T Davies and Steven Moffat were there to steer the ship, ensuring that Tennant went out in style and that his replacement landed with a big bang.

Doctors’ penultimate stories aren’t usually that remarkable, but The Waters of Mars is the exception to the rule, combining the tried-and-tested base under siege format with one of the show’s freakiest monsters of all time. However, it’s the Tenth Doctor’s tragic downfall, as he briefly becomes the Time Lord Victorious, that makes it an all-time classic.

Then came the finale itself, a story so big it had to be split into two parts. The End of Time has everything, from the Time Lords and Rassilon to a rabid, skeletal Master. It raises the stakes higher than ever, only to deliver a brutal and truly shocking final twist – that kindly old Wilf is the unwitting agent of the Doctor’s demise.

What follows is the strongest debut for a new Doctor we've ever seen. The Eleventh Hour introduces us to Matt Smith's Time Lord through the eyes of a child and that instantly endears us to him, while the fairytale tone is wonderfully evocative, and Murray Gold has rarely been better.

Doctor Who Matt Smith The Eleventh Hour
BBC Studios

In retrospect, the BBC had absolutely nothing to worry about when Tennant and RTD left. This is easily one of the most confident era transitions in Doctor Who history.


5. Boom - Rogue

Doctor Who Season 1 Boom Fifteenth Doctor Ncuti Gatwa
BBC Studios

Fan reaction to the opening and closing instalments of Ncuti Gatwa’s first season was somewhat mixed. But there’s no denying that the middle four episodes were something special.

Anyone left scratching their heads by talking babies and a random musical number was immediately put at ease by Boom. Steven Moffat’s first episode in over six years is edge-of-your-seat viewing with shocks and surprises aplenty – from the debut of upcoming companion Varada Sethu to the “death” of the current one.

The equally compelling 73 Yards takes us from the Welsh coast to an apocalyptic alternate future, as Ruby comes to terms with a life of enforced solitude – and ultimately uses it to her advantage. It’s an unnerving, fascinating story that stays with you long after the credits have rolled.

The following week’s Dot and Bubble packed more of a punch than anyone expected. What could have been a simple, one-dimensional critique of social media was instead a cautionary tale about limited worldviews and echo chambers, with devastating implications for the Doctor, and Ncuti Gatwa's standout acting moment so far.

This run was capped off by Rogue, a highly entertaining Doctor romance played out against the backdrop of a sumptuous Regency setting. Jonathan Groff is spellbinding as the titular time agent, and the climactic scenes of him sacrificing himself to save Ruby were beautifully executed, and left you wanting more of the character.

If the middle segment of next year’s season is even half as good as this, we’re in for a treat!


4. Human Nature - Utopia

Doctor Who Series 3 Human Nature David Tennant Fob Watch
BBC Studios

There’s no denying that Series 1 and Series 2 have some brilliant standout episodes. But it wasn’t until Series 3 that we got a run of three consistently great stories.

First up was Human Nature/The Family of Blood, which asked the question, “What if the Doctor was human?”. It’s an inspired premise, played with to great effect as we watch the Doctor’s alter-ego John Smith build a life for himself on Earth, before it all comes crashing down around him. And the evil Family is deliciously creepy – particularly Harry Lloyd as the sneering schoolboy Jeremy Baines.

Then came a story that barely featured the Doctor at all. But let’s face it, when you’ve got a lead as compelling as Carey Mulligan and a monster as distinctive as the Weeping Angels, what more do you need? Blink’s unconventional format and intricate plotting was a risk – but one that undoubtedly paid off. Horror, thrills, brilliant use of time travel, and some gut-wrenching scenes and dialogue (“It’s the same rain..."). It's no wonder this one continues to top fan polls.

The streak concludes with Utopia, an episode that starts with the return of Captain Jack and ends with the return of the Master. It’s a gripping adventure with a foreboding tone throughout, a winning performance from Derek Jacobi, and the mother of all cliffhangers.

Doctor Who Utopia Derek Jacobi The Master
BBC Studios

In a way, there was little point following it up with the finale – Series 3 had already peaked!

The Sound of Drums and Last of the Time Lords are by no means bad, but the run of truly great episodes undoubtedly ended with Utopia.


3. Face The Raven - The Husbands Of River Song

Doctor Who Face The Raven
BBC Studios

The Twelfth Doctor’s era had many highlights, but the ending of his second series is difficult to top.

Face the Raven is an unnerving, doom-laden tale, which builds to a tragic yet inevitable climax. The final ten minutes is one of the best Doctor/companion interactions ever committed to screen, with Capaldi and Coleman saying so much, with so little.

And then what is there to say about Heaven Sent that hasn’t been said already? Putting the Doctor in a castle for an hour and making that the first part of the finale was a massive risk – but the lightning-in-a-bottle combination of Steven Moffat, Rachel Talalay, and Peter Capaldi rose to the challenge and delivered what is consistently and rightfully voted one of the greatest hours of television in 61 years of Who.

The trilogy was brought to a close with Hell Bent, which may not have been the Gallifrey-centric epic it was made out to be, but it's all the better for it. In the end, it all comes back to Clara and the Doctor, and for a duo that regularly pushed each other to some dangerous limits, their ending was absolutely perfect.

Points must go to The Husbands of River Song too. It's a banger of a festive story, starting off as a simple screwball comedy but becoming something much more poignant by the end.

Doctor Who The Husbands of River Song
BBC Studios

What's especially impressive about this run of episodes is that it's one long story, with Husbands serving as the epilogue. Mini arcs within Doctor Who don't get much stronger than this.


2. The Pandorica Opens - Day Of The Moon

Doctor Who The Pandorica Opens
BBC Studios

Between 2010 and 2011, Toby Haynes directed five consecutive Doctor Who episodes, all of which were penned by Steven Moffat – and all of which were bloody fantastic.

From the exhilarating, cameo-filled opening to the affirming ending that ties the whole series together in a neat little bow tie, The Pandorica Opens/The Big Bang is an incredible end to a near-perfect series. The scene of the Doctor at Amelia’s bedside never fails to bring a tear to the eye, and the notion of Amy bringing him back through the power of memory is simply beautiful.

The high quality continued with the 2010 Christmas special A Christmas Carol. Dickens’ classic tale of redemption was an obvious fit for Moffat’s signature, timey-wimey style, and the results were just as rewarding as you’d expect. There are plenty of smart twists (like the identities of the three ghosts), and Michael Gambon and Katherine Jenkins are outstanding as Kazran and Abigail.

To top it all off, The Impossible Astronaut/Day of the Moon is a truly epic start to Series 6, boasting some breathtaking American location work, an instantly-iconic new monster, and an almighty hook in the form of the Doctor’s “death”.

The zippy dialogue between the Ponds, River, and the Doctor is also something special here – has there ever been a more quotable Doctor Who story?

Doctor Who Day of the Moon Amy Pond
BBC Studios

Having a great series finale, a great Christmas special and a great series opener all in a row is no mean feat. Moffat and Haynes were on fire here – this is Doctor Who at the top of its game.


1. Silence In The Library - Journey’s End

Doctor Who Silence In The Library River Song David Tennant Alex Kingston
BBC Studios

On broadcast, Series 4 contained a week’s break after The Unicorn and the Wasp, to accommodate Eurovision.

To tide fans over, a special mid-series trailer was created – which is in itself one of the most exciting Doctor Who “things” ever televised. From Wilf worrying about the stars going out, to Sky Silvestry cowering in terror, to glimpses of Rose, the Daleks, and Davros, it’s spine-tingling stuff.

And when those episodes finally arrived, they didn’t disappoint. Indeed, so great is the second half of Series 4 that it’s all made it onto this list.

This is some of the show’s most ambitious storytelling, taking us from a planet-sized library to a giant Dalek flagship, via a stranded shuttle bus and a nightmarish alternate reality. There are scares in the form of the skull-faced Vashta Nerada, the horrifically-corrupted Miss Evangelista, and the all-mysterious Midnight Entity.

There are thrills, via the epic Torchwood/SJA crossover, the long-awaited return of Rose and the jaw-dropping cliffhanger to The Stolen Earth. And there’s heartbreak, through the tragic fates of River, Donna, and the Doctor, who once again ends up alone in the TARDIS.

To go a couple of weeks without a dud is one thing. But six weeks of bangers? RTD and the team were really cooking here, and it's hard to imagine we'll ever see a streak this good ever again.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Doctor Who fan/YouTuber and writer of GO FIGURE, the unofficial guide to Character Options' 5.5" Doctor Who action figures!