10 Best Game Of Thrones Episodes

In honor of Season 4’s premiere, we’ll be counting down and analyzing the ten best episodes of the first three seasons.

Before 2011, most fans of A Song of Ice and Fire didn€™t believe that any show based on the fantasy series could possibly live up to their expectations. The books were too intricate, the characters and story too complex to be adequately portrayed on screen. And any hopes of mainstream success seemed way out of the question, as the series refused to adhere to audience expectations of the fantasy genre, or even the basic rules of fiction. There was just no way Game of Thrones could work. Forgive us for not being more optimistic about the show, as we book readers have become cynical after years of abuse from author George R.R. Martin. We should have had more faith in HBO, as Game of Thrones is an excellent adaptation of the novels we love and hate with all our hearts. And we should have had more faith in the general public, as they€™ve helped turn the show into an absolute phenomenon. (And we should really stop spoiling it for them. Seriously.) In honor of Season 4€™s premiere, we€™ll be counting down and analyzing the ten best episodes of the first three seasons. It wasn€™t easy to narrow it down, but the following are the best examples of what makes Game of Thrones so great. And brace yourselves. Spoilers are coming. (But only for the show)

10. Garden Of Bones (Season 2, Episode 4)

Much of Game of Thrones' unlikely success can be attributed to how much it downplays the more fantastical elements. In doing so, not only does it appeal to a larger audience that wouldn't normally be interested in "nerd shows," it also makes the magical moments all the more compelling. By this point in Season 2, the show was a certified hit, but this episode's finale was a true gamble. Dragons and zombies are one thing, but zealous witches giving birth to smoke demon assassins is another thing entirely. Thankfully, one of the coolest and weirdest moments from the books becomes one of the show's most memorable scenes. The spawn of Melisandre is a horrific and amazing creation, and its existence backs up the argument that R'hllor is the one true god of Westeros. Yet in true Game of Thrones fashion, this abomination isn't even the episode's true monster. No, that distinct honor goes to King Joffrey, a villain who's even more awful onscreen than he is in the books. When Tyrion buys him a couple of prostitutes to calm him down, he uses the opportunity to take advantage of them in sadistic ways. It's an effective way to demonstrate Joffrey's inhuman cruelty, and it reaffirms Joffrey's status as one of TV's most despicable characters.

9. Winter Is Coming (Season 1, Episode 1)

TV shows win or die based on the quality of their pilots, and thankfully Game of Thrones was a winner from the very beginning. The premiere episode had the Herculean task of immersing the audience in a believable fantasy world while also providing a story we could get invested in, and it succeeded on both fronts. As soon as we saw those Night€™s Watch rangers travel beyond the awe-inspiring Wall into the haunted forest, we knew we€™d be in this for the long run. We€™re gradually introduced to the show€™s major players throughout the hour: the honorable-to-a-fault Eddard Stark, the witty and wonderful Tyrion Lannister, the future Mother of Dragons Daenerys Targaryen, and many others. While much of the episode is just pieces being places on a chess board, it€™s hard to notice because the placement is so masterful. In less than 60 minutes, the pilot transports us to the world of Westeros, helps us understand the culture and customs, and thanks to that gut-punch cliffhanger ending, it guarantees we come back for more.

8. Second Sons (Season 3, Episode 8)

Understandably overshadowed by the following episode, €œSecond Sons€ is nevertheless a great hour of television despite its wedding scene featuring zero deaths. It may be the calm before the storm of swords, but on a show as turbulent as this, even the calms can tear the roof off your house. The aforementioned wedding of Tyrion and Sansa Stark is the centerpiece of the episode, providing the funniest and most heartbreaking moments. Tyrion threatening to castrate his sadistic nephew King Joffrey is a darkly humorous way of showing just how cornered and vulnerable the Imp felt about being forced into marrying a young hostage girl. And yet again, Tyrion proves that he€™s the most decent Lannister by refusing to bed Sansa, as he knows the poor girl€™s been through enough. Though really, she could do a lot worse than the handsome Peter Dinklage. Meanwhile, Dany continues to develop as one of the most powerful women on television, and she didn€™t even need her dragons this time. She stands defiantly nude before mercenary Daario to prove she fears nothing, although by this point she has nothing left to prove to anyone. But the bravest moment of the episode comes courtesy of Samwell Tarly, who goes from coward to slayer with the thrust of a dragonglass dagger. He becomes the first person to kill an Other (White Walker) in centuries, and his act of courage to save someone he cares about demonstrates that there€™s some hope left in this bleak, vicious world.

7. The Old Gods And The New (Season 2, Episode 6)

Book purists are always going to scoff at any deviations this show makes from the source material, even if the alterations are improvements. This episode is just bursting with changes to the original story, and many of these little tweaks help make it one of Season 2€™s best. Dany€™s story in A Clash of Kings (Book 2) was infamously dull, so the decision to spice it up a bit by killing off some of her khalasar and kidnapping her dragons was welcome. Changing Ser Rodrick€™s death scene has proven divisive, but his botched execution by Theon is one of the more emotionally wrenching moments of the season, and it really drives home how far Theon has fallen. And no one€™s going to argue that the scenes between Arya Stark and Tywin Lannister aren€™t brilliant additions to the story. But the episode€™s best scene comes straight off the page, as Joffrey and his entourage get attacked by peasants in a poor part of King€™s Landing. The scene is as exhilarating as it is harrowing; seeing Joffrey getting hit with manure and slapped by Tyrion is satisfying, but it€™s not worth having to sit through Sansa nearly being raped and murdered. Thank the gods a deformed child-murderer is there to save her.

6. Fire And Blood (Season 1, Episode 10)

€œIf you think this has a happy ending, you haven€™t been paying attention.€ The Bastard of Bolton has a point, as it€™s hard to imagine this show concluding with a €œhappily ever after.€ But for one brief, beautiful moment at the end of Season 1, we finally get that storybook ending the series typically tries to avoid. To date, the show has never provided an image as triumphant and powerful as Daenerys emerging from a funeral pyre, unharmed, wearing nothing but three newborn dragons. Subsequent season finales have tried to capture the magic of this moment, but neither €œValar Morghulis€ or €œMhysa€ live up to Season 1€™s final episode. What €œFire and Blood€ accomplishes so well is concluding the stories of the first season while perfectly setting up events for the second. Robb Stark becomes the King in the North and joins in the war for the Iron Throne to avenge is family. Jon Snow is recruited for an expedition to travel beyond the Wall to find his uncle. Dragons return to the world after everyone thought they were gone forever. All these moments subsequently provide the audience with closure for one story, and anticipation for more, which is what any great finale should do. It may not be a traditionally happy ending, but it€™s the closest this show has ever come.

5. And Now His Watch Is Ended (Season 3, Episode 4)

Speaking of awesome Dany-centric endings, here is an episode that concludes more like a season finale than the actual third season finale. Dany€™s babies don€™t get a whole lot to do in the show because they€™re so young (and expensive to render). But when they€™re finally unleashed, there are no words in the common tongue or High Valyrian to adequately describe the spectacle. Of course the episode is great even before the jaw-dropping finale. It€™s deeply satisfying to see Joffrey be manipulated by someone smarter than he is. And the Night€™s Watch rebellion and Lord Commander Mormont€™s death would be the standout scene in most episodes. But we€™re not dealing with most episodes. During the final scene, Dany actually appears to trade Drogon, her favorite dragon, for an army of dehumanized castrati. But the Mother of Dragons proves that you can have your cake, eat it too, and then burn the baker to death. After the dust and ashes settle, the slavers are all dead, Dany keeps all her dragons, and she even gets to keep all those Unsullied. Next stop: Westeros€ in like four years. Maybe.

4. Kissed By Fire (Season 3, Episode 5)

With so much ground to cover per episode, Game of Thrones usually doesn€™t have time to worry about thematic consistency. But with €œKissed by Fire,€ the writers are able to work in the motif of fire into nearly every plotline presented without it feeling forced. The flames bind each story together, and like Ygritte with her fire-kissed hair, it€™s what makes it special. Fire burns its way into the battle between Beric Dondarrion and The Hound, as the former sets his sword ablaze to strike fear into the heart of his pyrophobic opponent, resulting in the most visually-striking swordfight the show has yet produced. And then there€™s the fire brewing between Jon Snow and Ygritte, whose red hair gives the episode its title. The feisty wildling convinces Jon to break his vows of celibacy, leading to a genuine love scene with absolutely no sexposition. Finally, there€™s Jaime €œThe Kingslayer€ Lannister€™s scene with Brienne in the bath, where he delivers the show€™s greatest monologue to date. In a painful whisper, Jaime tells the true story behind his nickname, revealing that had he not broken his oath and killed Aerys, King€™s Landing would€™ve burned to the ground. Instead of being hailed as a hero, Jaime was branded a cowardly traitor by countless people who never got to hear the Mad King€™s haunting final words: €œBurn them all.€ Leave it to Game of Thrones to make you feel for a guy who sleeps with his sister and pushes kids out windows.

3. Baelor (Season 1, Episode 9)

Not a whole lot happens in this quiet, reflective episode. Tyrion, Bronn and Shae the funny whore share in an intimate and revealing conversation. Khal Drogo succumbs to his wounds, despite Dany€™s best efforts. The Starks and Lannisters engage in an off-screen battle due to budgetary limitations. Oh, and that guy you all thought was the main character? He dies. The execution of Ned Stark marks the exact moment when Game of Thrones transitioned from moderately popular TV show to pop culture sensation. It was a shocking scene in the novel for sure, but for television, this twist remains unprecedented. And for us book-reading elitists, the scene is so horrifyingly beautiful that it makes you wish you could€™ve experienced it on screen first. Once Joffrey commands Ser Ilyn Payne to bring him Stark€™s head, the camera frantically floats from place to place, as if it€™s desperately trying to find some way to prevent this atrocity. But as Sansa and Arya are restrained and Ned is moved into position for his beheading, everything slows down and we begin to accept the inevitable. Finally, the sword falls, the birds fly away, and millions of people watching learn that no one is safe on Game of Thrones. Except Tyrion and Dany of course.

2. The Rains Of Castamere (Season 3, Episode 9)

"And so he spoke, and so he spoke, / That lord of Castamere. / But now the rains weep o'er his hall / With no one there to hear." There was plenty of weeping to be had after €œThe Rains of Castamere€ originally aired, and unless you lack friends or an internet connection, you most definitely heard it. (I€™ll get this out of the way now and acknowledge the presence of things in this episode that aren€™t the Red Wedding. Jon turns on the wildlings. Bran uses his warg powers to save Jon. Dany gains control over a slave city. Cool moments, but they€™re not what sticks with you when the credits roll.) Okay, back to the Red Wedding. It€™s the scene that book fans had been dying to see for years. And it€™s one of the most shocking, disturbing, devastating scenes in television history. But as surprising as it was, it was a twist that was set in motion way back in the first season. This wasn€™t some cheap stunt to get publicity. This was a legitimately necessary part of the twisted plot. The late Walder Frey was never going to let Robb Stark get away with blowing off his engagement, but did anyone expect this? To have Robb and Catelyn both taken from us in the same episode? Sure, we readers knew that was coming, but what we didn€™t see coming was Robb€™s pregnant wife getting stabbed multiple times in the stomach. What makes this scene so painful to watch is its matter-of-factness. Unlike Ned€™s death, there€™s no beauty to it, no grace or tranquility. It€™s brutal, bloody, and completely unfair. It€™s also the reason people will be talking about this show for a very long time.

1. Blackwater (Season 2, Episode 9)

Game of Thrones is a flawed show by nature, albeit in a glorious way. As the story expands and becomes more epic in scope, it often loses focus, leaving certain characters and plotlines neglected (Hi Bran!). As great as most episodes are, they often bite off more than they can chew by trying to advance the progress of too many players in this massive game. But €œBlackwater€ is different. Abandoning the show€™s traditional sprawling structure by focusing the action entirely on the battle for King€™s Landing, it€™s the most narratively precise episode of the series. But at the same time, it€™s also the grandest and most bombastic. In short, it€™s the closest any episode has ever come to perfection. Unlike €œBaelor€ or €œThe Rains of Castamere,€ both great episodes made legendary by their final events, the entirety of €œBlackwater€ is an event. From the spectacle of wildfire on the bay, to the sickeningly gory combat sequences, it€™s the most impressive battle scene ever produced for television. But all the sweet kills and colorful explosions would be meaningless if it weren€™t for the smaller, more intimate moments peppered throughout the hour. The oncoming war takes its toll on the characters, causing them to react in surprising yet realistic ways. Sansa turns defiant, The Hound goes from fearsome to fearful, Cersei becomes strangely likeable after she€™s had a few, and Tyrion transforms into the leader we always knew he could be. €œThose are brave men knocking at our doors,€ the Halfman declares as he rallies his troops. €œLet€™s go kill them.€ Tyrion€™s speech isn€™t meant to provide inspiration or hope. It€™s a blunt and unsentimental reflection on the realities of war, much like the episode as a whole. What separates Game of Thrones from other fantasy stories is that even in a world full of dragons and magic, the inhabitants feel like real people. €œBlackwater€ plays off this unique strength by presenting these flawed characters in their most desperate hour, making this fantastical war feel shockingly real. Couple that with the masterful acting, writing, directing, and visual effects, it all adds up to the greatest episode of one of TV€™s greatest shows. It€™s so good, you€™ll almost forget about the chain. Almost.

Contributor
Contributor

J.D. Laney is an aspiring novelist and screenwriter from Cleveland, Ohio. When he isn't trying to write his own material, he is constantly consuming the work of others for analysis and, occasionally, for fun. He has a particular interest in film, literature, and video games.