10 Buffy The Vampire Slayer And Angel Plots That Were Never Resolved
Which stories from these two shows simply died without any chance at resurrection?
In Buffy The Vampire Slayer and Angel, both shows combined began hundreds of different plots, many of which received perfect on-screen resolutions.
That will be the main crux of this article - on-screen. While several of the below points may or may not have been teased out in the comics, this article is specifically referring to what has been addressed in the continuity of Buffy The Vampire Slayer seasons 1 - 7 and Angel seasons 1 - 5.
While that is not to say that the comics and extended lore are not an excellent medium in their own right, there is something special about the filmed and released material that went with the original shows. At times, Buffy The Vampire Slayer was among the greatest television shows released. There were then other times when Angel arguably surpassed it in terms of depth and quality. Both shows introduced a fantastic core of characters, bringing many different walks of life together under one banner.
Both shows also suffered from quality issues throughout their runs. It would be fair to say that both had 'dud' episodes (these will be explored in a future list), yet that is true of almost any show that has ever been released.
These are the stories that the audience were denied a satisfying conclusion to, ranked in order of how badly they were needed!
10. Ms. French's Kids
Natalie French was everything that a school would want in a substitute teacher. She was passionate about what she taught. She was an excellent teacher. The students really liked her. The male students, in particular. The fact that she was a giant Preying Mantis was really just a sidenote, to be honest. The kids were learning and isn't that what's most important?
Her overall plan involved capturing virgin boys and using them to fertilise her eggs, which she had strung up in sacs all around her basement. Naturally, Xander falls for her charms (pheromones) and is taken captive, though he is saved by a combination of Buffy's fighting skills and Giles's research skills - skills that involve recording bat sonar.
All of the eggs in Mrs. French's house are destroyed and the group go about their business, with another (though not the last) failed romance to add to the cards.
However.
In the final shot of the episode, the closet door is slowly closed, but not quickly enough for the audience to miss the opening eggs of some more of Mrs. French's children. Did they survive? Did they escape Sunnydale? Were they living in the school the whole time? To be fair, Sunnydale High had such a mortality rate that it is very possible they could have operated without being noticed for a long time! But still....seems like a fairly large oversight!
9. The Guardians
In the penultimate episode of Buffy's final season, she is introduced to the Guardian. This woman is the last in a long line of those who watched over the Watcher's council, keeping secrets from them and keeping an ultimate weapon for the Slayer's final battle.
To be charitable, this was an interesting twist on the Slayer mythology. To be honest, this was a Deus Ex Machina in the worst possible way, as Buffy desperately needed to be wrapped up as it went into its series finale.
However - had the show been extended, it would have been fascinating to explore the idea of the Guardians more fully. The Watchers' Council was gone, so there was little to no help coming from there - despite Andrew's attempts to start a new one. This ancient power that the Guardian spoke of was something that most surely should have been expanded upon.
However, the role of the Guardian was relegated to being introduced and almost immediately killed, which didn't do much for their reputation as a power as old as the Slayer line has existed.
8. St. Vigeous
Spike's introduction is one of the most memorable in all of the Buffyverse. He slams his car through the Welcome to Sunnydale sign, symbollically smashing away everything that had come before him. One such thing that had come before was the Master and the Order of Aurelius.
With the death of the Master (and the failed resurrection), The Annointed One was left in charge of the Order. Spike pretended to play nice with him, joining their cult in an attempt to gain a foothold in Sunnydale. He arrived at the perfect time - just on the eve of the Festival of St. Vigeous.
This is described as an annual event when Vampires are at their most powerful, creating havoc and terror in the hearts of humans in a single night of horrific bloodshed. Spike, in a way that the audience would come to get very used to, ruins that year's festival by attempting to take on Buffy before he truly understood the situation around him.
While the episode ends with Spike firmly establishing himself as the new player in town, burning the Annointed One to dust, the Festival of St. Vigeous is never mentioned again. Considering the show is called 'Buffy The VAMPIRE Slayer', a huge, annual event where Vampires are at their most powerful seems like it should have been slightly more of an issue for Sunnydale than it proved to be!
7. Demon NAZIs
In Angel's first season, the audience are introduced to a group of Demon Supremacists named The Scourge. Their entire reason for being is purification and destruction of all humanity/half-breed demons. Doyle, it is revealed, has a connection to this group - in that he is absolutely terrified of them.
They are fanatics and, as such, both Angel and Doyle know that to fight them may prove to be impossible. Their plot when Angel encounters them is to use The Beacon - a device that will burn anything it touches to dust.
In typical Angel fashion, he prepares to sacrifice himself to destroy the device - only to be knocked down by Doyle, who sacrifices himself heroically to destroy it. At this point, the Scourge leave.
They are not destroyed and they are still out there. Later in the third season, they are mentioned in passing as potential threats to Connor, proving that Angel Investigations know that they are still a threat. However, they are never seen again.
Someone should probably deal with them at some point!
6. The Oracles
The Oracles are depicted as beings who are extremely powerful, controlling the flow of time and serve as Angel's connection to the Powers That Be. It is Doyle who first introduces them, even if they are not entirely welcoming on the first visit.
They appear three times in the first season. First, they give Angel back a day to ensure that he avoids an attack that makes him human (thus removing his ability as a champion.) Second, they refuse point blank to bring Doyle back after his heroic death.
Their third appearance sees their physical bodies destroyed by Vocah - a demon summoned by Wolfram & Hart. Angel does speak to one of them, even after they have died and then they are gone.
These are beings who can control the passage of time so, couldn't they have simply skipped back and avoided their own deaths? Particularly if they are able to manifest even after death? They were a very interesting addition to Angel's first season, bringing both a silliness and weight to his storyline.
5. Oz
Daniel Osborne was one of the core Scoobies in the third and fourth seasons of Buffy The Vampire Slayer. He was introduced back in the second season, before being quickly revealed as a werewolf. His stoic demeanor suited the story perfectly as his human and wolf sides were diametrically opposed to each other.
His affliction was accepted by the gang and he and Willow began seeing each other, with monthly chain up sessions to look forward to. Going into the fourth season, the writers decided to address how life was changing the way they were with each other, in keeping with the theme of college changing the teenagers.
Oz grows close to a fellow werewolf, Veruca. He cheats on Willow with her, leaving Sunnydale a broken man. He returns later, having learned to control the wolf side, only to find that Willow has moved on with Tara.
Though the door is left open to a further return and there were plans to introduce him to the never-produced sixth season of Angel, that is the last time the audience sees Oz. There was plenty of room for this story to continue growing, as he was the one person that had mastered being able to control the change at the Full Moon.
4. Out Of Mind, Out Of Sight
So, the US Government has a program where they recruit invisible people and train them to be assassins. It is a fantastic idea - one that is never once revisited in the seven seasons of Buffy. That is not counting the tiny homage that the seventh season pays to Marcie, where Buffy slaps a girl back to visibility!
The power of the Hellmouth is such that once Marcie Ross started to feel like she was invisible, she truly started to become invisible. This led to her descent into insanity, consumed as she was with the desire to exact revenge on Cordelia - who she saw as the reason behind all of her misery. To be fair, she wasn't entirely off base there.
As to be expected, Buffy manages to overpower her, as Marcie's only 'power' is that she can't be seen. She has no super strength or fighting skills to speak of.
Enter the US Government.
They quickly take her off Buffy's hands, before herding her into a seemingly empty classroom. It is full of invisible people like her, all who are being trained on convert missions and assassination technique.
With the later introduction of The Initiative, this absolutely seems like an asset that should have been revisited in the show!
3. Amy Madison
Elisabeth Ann Allen appeared in almost every season of Buffy The Vampire Slayer as Amy Madison, the initially innocent and then increasingly derranged witch, who the Scoobie Gang save from a body swap back in season one. They came to regret their actions over time, though none moreso than Willow, who unarguably suffers the most from her relationship to Amy.
Trapped as a rat for several seasons, Amy is finally made human again by Willow, as the latter grows increasingly dependant on her magic. Amy, however, while seemingly grateful to Willow for saving her, reveals that she is not the friend she lets herself on to be. Far from it, in fact.
Her first assault on Willow is to aid the witch in sinking deeper into her addiction and then, once that fails to destroy Willow entirely, curses her to become Warren - the man flayed alive.
She is revealed as the culprit and then - nothing. There is no resolution here, no depiction of what came next. Is Amy still free and roaming, creating havoc wherever she can? Has Willow managed to stop her from causing more harm?
Amy Madison is a player far too powerful to be left to tip the scales unchecked.
2. The Senior Partners
The Senior Partners of Wolfram & Hart are described as being evil beyond evil, with the ability to create and reign havoc in the extreme. However, they are almost never depicted on-screen. They have, throughout the passage of time, evolved from a point where they were, in Illyria's opinion, barely above the Vampire in the beginning, to becoming something of the dominant demonic force in existence by the early 21st century.
The only time the audience gets a glimpse of one is in the second season episode Reprise, when a Senior Partner comes to inspect the L.A. branch of Wolfram & Hart. The demon host is quickly, and somewhat easily, dispatched by Angel - though the scenes that follow are among the most grim in the entire Buffyverse, and that really is saying something.
By Angel's fifth season, the Senior Partners are described as playing such a long game that the various victories that Angel and other champions wage against them are all but meaningless. The defeat of the Circle of the Black Thorn, while a harsh blow to them, is hardly the doom that the good guys wish it to be.
The Senior Partners are often referred to in a manner that depicts them as the ultimate foe for all Champions and Slayers to come together and fight - if only the audience were ever given the chance to see that on film.
1. Kate Lockley
This may be the most egregious dropped storyline from the entire run of Angel. Kate Lockley, the detective-turned-reluctant ally, turned-foe of Angel Investigations. Elizabeth Rohm starred as the sometime-broken cop, trying to remain at the peak of her job while also struggling with her father and struggling to come to terms with discovering the supernatural side of LA.
Kate had a dark journey in the first two seasons of Angel, sinking further and further, following the death of her father at the hands of Vampire associates. She blamed Angel for this, despite the fact that he couldn't have prevented the murder without being invited into her father's apartment.
From that point on, she was openly hostile toward him, while chasing up any leads on any potentially supernatural cases in or out of her juristiction. This very hunt leads to her being fired from the force, as her superiors attempt to cover up some of the crimes of one of their own. Again, she blames Angel for this, although this time she goes further, downing a bottle of pills.
Angel rushes to her, saves her life and then later they share, if not a reconcilliation, then a greater understanding of their place in the fight. As Kate reminds Angel - she never invited him into her apartment, so he shouldn't have been able to save her.
This opened the door to the greater scale of the fight against evil and Angel's place in it. However, this was the last time the audience got to see Kate - a pure crime in itself. This, if nothing else, was a storyline that deserved further exploration.
Which Buffy The Vampire Slayer Character Had Which Hellmouth Experience?