10 Classic Doctor Who Enemies Who Need To Return

The Doctor has plenty of foes itching for a rematch, but which ones really deserve a comeback?

Doctor Who
BBC

The classic era of Doctor Who lasted for 26 years and 155 stories, offering fans an incredible array of adventures in time and space. Of course, besides The Doctor and his companions, one of the most important parts of these stories were the enemies they faced. Some of those enemies became household names, like the Daleks and The Master, while others were relegated to mere footnotes in the history of the show.

Since Doctor Who's revival in 2005, the various production teams have been slowly working their way through reintroducing the show's most iconic baddies. From Daleks and Autons in 2005, up to the Sea-Devils in 2022 (and who could forget the Macra in Gridlock?). However, there are still a lot of classic monsters and villains that deserve a return appearance, or could perhaps do with a modern upgrade. And with the show's 60th anniversary coming up and a new production team on the horizon, now is the perfect time to start thinking about who could make a return.

So out of the plethora of classic villains yet to be utilised, who could make the cut? From Axons to Zarbi and everything in between, there are a lot of options.

10. The Master Of The Land Of Fiction

Doctor Who The Mind Robber Second Doctor cardboard Jamie
BBC Studios

This Second Doctor enemy is arguably one of the most powerful foes the Doctor's ever faced. It's pretty crazy then that the character hasn't made a single TV appearance since their introduction. For those unfamiliar with 1969's The Mind Robber, it features the Doctor and his companions, Jamie and Zoe, becoming stuck in the Land of Fiction.

As the name suggests, this is a world populated by fictional characters and is ruled by a Master (not THE Master, mind you). The Master in that story was a human writer from 1926 who had been unwillingly forced into the role by a sentient computer known as the Master Brain.

The genius thing about this concept is that literally anyone can be put in the role of the Master of the Land, as long as they have a strong imagination. As with Time Lord characters, the possibilities are limitless.

Speaking of possibilities, there is so much that can be done with the Land of Fiction as a concept. Just imagine the crazy stories that could be told there, utilising modern effects and storytelling, especially if the production team can get some licenses to use a few pop-culture icons.

The Land of Fiction has appeared in other media, such novels and audios, with the Doctor's companion Zoe even briefly becoming the Mistress of the Land. However, it's high time for this fantasy realm and its Master to make a return to our screens. Its potential is quite literally only limited by a writer's imagination.


9. Fenric

Doctor Who The Curse Of Fenric
BBC Studios

Fenric is one of the Doctor's most interesting enemies, coming from the beginning of the universe itself. The two had been locked in a cosmic game of wits for centuries, until the Doctor defeated Fenric and imprisoned him off-screen. Yet despite this, this entity has only appeared in a single televised story, The Curse of Fenric - the penultimate story of the classic era. That story is highly regarded as one of the best of the Seventh Doctor's run, with deep and mature themes and some intense moments between the Doctor and his companion, Ace.

Fenric is a powerful enemy who is discovered to be responsible for events in Ace's past, making him a very modern sort of villain. However, the most interesting aspect of the Doctor's relationship with Fenric is the idea that the two of them have been locked this cosmic game of chess for centuries, with Ace being an unwitting pawn. The fact that the Doctor has to break Ace's faith in him in order to defeat Fenric is so diabolically brilliant and it leads to some devastating scenes.

It would make perfect sense for Fenric to return, manipulating events from the shadows in order to orchestrate a rematch. It could make for an amazing season arc, with the Doctor being unknowingly caught up in a subtle game, gradually turning to manipulate the people around them, including their companions. There's so much potential for some dark and psychological storytelling that would fit modern sensibilities perfectly.


8. The Movellans

Movellans Doctor Who
BBC Studios

Modern viewers may recognise these mop-haired robots all dressed in white from their brief appearance in Season 10's The Pilot. However, there's much more to the Movellans than an out-of-focus cameo for the sake of fan-service.

Since they only appeared in one televised story - 1979's Destiny of the Daleks - they've hardly made the biggest impact on the show's mythos, but they still play an important part in the show's history. You see, they were originally introduced as an enemy of the Daleks, with the two sides engaged in a fierce war. Things were so bad for the Daleks at that point, that it actually prompted them to revive their creator, Davros, to aid in their war effort.

Given how the modern era has built the post Time War Daleks up as an unstoppable force (that actually gets stopped all the time), it may surprise some to learn that the Daleks have even been engaged in war with anyone besides the Time Lords. That's why it could be a breath of fresh air to have one of their old enemies return. It could provide a different kind of Dalek story compared to what modern viewers are used to and maybe even help to turn the Daleks into a legitimate threat again.

Just imagine if that brief battle scene from The Pilot encompassed an entire episode, depicting a truly fierce and destructive war zone, with the Doctor and their companion siding with the Movellans. It could make for an interesting change.


7. The Meddling Monk

Doctor Who the Meddling Monk
BBC Studios

Now here's a mischievous man of the cloth who desperately deserves a return, especially with the show's 60th anniversary on the horizon. He's the Doctor's original recurring Time Lord nemesis, known only as: The Meddling Monk.

First introduced in the brilliant First Doctor story, The Time Meddler, in 1965, this Time Lord (never named on-screen, but dubbed Mortimus in other media) was pretending to be a monk in Northumbira, 1066. Here he was attempting to change the outcome of the Battle of Hastings to avert the Norman Conquest of England.

Details are slowly drip-fed to the audience and the characters throughout the story, before the big reveal that the Monk has a TARDIS. This was a huge moment in the show's history, as it was the first appearance of one of the Doctor's own people (before the term Time Lord had even been coined), aside from his granddaughter, Susan.

Unlike the Master, he's not strictly evil - rather, he just likes to mess with history for the sake of it. He'd go on to appear one more time on-screen, in the epic 1965-66 story, The Daleks' Master Plan, before disappearing from the show forever. However, he has had a healthy life in other media, where his origins and character have been fleshed out further.

This is a character that is long overdue for a return to screen, and given the significance he holds in the show's history, it's about time he receives a little more respect.


6. The Rani

Doctor Who Rani 2
BBC

Now this one's just a given, as fans have been waiting for her return for years. The Rani is a Time Lady and a scientist of morally dubious repute. Viewing most other species, including humans, as inferior life-forms, she's perfectly happy to use them as lab rats for her experiments. From the get-go, this is quite a unique characterisation compared to the Doctor's other enemies. She's not evil, just unethical. She doesn't want to conquer or destroy, she just wants to study and experiment.

Originally introduced in 1985's The Mark of the Rani, featuring the Sixth Doctor, she was intended to be a recurring foe who would serve as a female counterpart to the Master (who also appeared in her debut story). However, the show's hiatus between Seasons 22 and 23 saw her second appearance scrapped (along with the rest of Season 23's original scripts). She did make one more appearance though, in the Seventh Doctor's first story, 1987's Time and the Rani, as well as 1993's 30th anniversary Children in Need special, Dimensions in Time. In each of these appearances, she was played by the late Kate O' Mara.

Over the years the character has popped up in novels, comics and audios - with Big Finish introducing a new incarnation, played by Siobhan Redmond - but she's yet to make a return to TV. Which is a shame, because she could provide the perfect counterbalance to the more unhinged depictions of the Master/Missy that we've seen in recent years.


5. The Black Guardian

Doctor Who Enlightenment The Black Guardian
BBC Studios

Out of all of the enemies the Doctor has faced, few have been quite so celestial as the Black Guardian. Both he and his benevolent counterpart - the White Guardian - were introduced in the 16th season's Key to Time arc. Here, they were introduced as personifications of cosmic concepts, with the White representing order and the Black representing chaos.

During his first meeting with the White Guardian, the Fourth Doctor was tasked with finding the six pieces of the Key to Time, before the Black Guardian could. Naturally the Doctor and his new companion, Romana, were successful and the Black Guardian was defeated. He'd return a few years later though, for a trilogy of stories during the show's 20th season. Here, he manipulated Vislor Turlough, an exiled alien living on Earth, into becoming the Fifth Doctor's companion so that he could kill him. Once again though, the Guardian was defeated and Turlough chose to stand by the Doctor's side.

It's interesting to note that the Black Guardian's two stints on the show were both in rare moments of long-form story arcs spread across multiple stories - something which was uncommon for classic Who. It's clear then that the respective creative teams saw the character's potential as a large-scale threat. This demonstrates that he'd fit in perfectly with the modern era, perhaps in a heavily serialised Flux-style story. Especially since it would be nice to know just how the Guardians of Time were affected by that little old Time War.


4. The Rutans

Doctor Who Rutans
BBC

Here's an alien species that really deserves more attention and could definitely do with a modern update. The Rutans (or Rutan Host) only appeared in one televised story, 1977's The Horror of Fang Rock, but they're actually have an important place in the show's mythos. That's because they're the arch-enemies of the Sontarans, with the two species being locked in a centuries-long war.

It's actually kind of strange how the Sontarans have become one of the Doctor's most famous enemies (typically ranking third behind the Daleks and Cybermen), while their eternal enemies have been relegated to the most obscure corners of Doctor Who lore.

Given how the the potato soldiers have been a fairly regular appearance in New Who, it would shake things up to have the Rutans make a triumphant return. Because not only have they only made one appearance, but the two sworn enemies have never even appeared onscreen together. It would be such a treat to finally see the two races engaged in full-scale combat with one another, perhaps with the Doctor and friends trying to act as mediators.

What's more, in their sole classic appearance, the Rutans' design was... less than amazing. Resembling blobby green jellyfish, they had an interesting design that was unfortunately let down by the effects of the time. With modern effects they could really look like something special. Wouldn't it just be a sight to behold, to see a school of giant, glowing green jellyfish swarming platoons of Sontarans, tendrils lashing all about?


3. The Celestial Toymaker

Doctor Who The Celestial Toymaker
BBC Studios

Here's another First Doctor villain who had the potential to become a recurring adversary, but for some reason remained a one-and-done. Making his sole appearance in the 1966 story of the same name, The Celestial Toymaker is a cosmic being of immense power, who likes to pass the centuries by forcing lower lifeforms into high stakes games. Played by the late Michael Gough (whom you might recognise as Alfred in the Burton/Schumacher Batman films), it is established that the Doctor and Toymaker have history together.

The idea of god-like beings using humans as play-things is nothing new, but having one use literal toys makes for some interesting concepts and visuals. With such a unique M.O., it's strange that such a powerful and interesting villain never made a return to the screen. Perhaps it was because his first outing was beset with production problems which affected the finished product.

He was intended to return, once again played by Gough, in the Sixth Doctor story, The Nightmare Fair. However, that story, along with every script planned for Season 23, was scrapped when the show was put on a forced hiatus in 1985.

The Toymaker has appeared in other media, (including two adaptations of The Nightmare Fair), but he's practically screaming to be brought back to the screen. Sadly, Michael Gough is no longer with us, but there's no reason why the character can't be recast. Just think of the surreal and psychotic games the Toymaker could introduce to a new generation of fans.


2. Omega

Doctor Who Omega
BBC

Now here's a figure who not only plays an important part in Time Lord history, but who has a habit of popping up for special anniversaries. Omega made his first appearance in the 1972-73 story, The Three Doctors - the first story of the show's tenth season. Here he was established as one of the founders of Time Lord society, years before Rassilon was ever mentioned on-screen.

Omega was a stellar engineer who was responsible for giving the Gallifreyans the power of time travel, allowing them to be reborn as the Time Lords. He did this by using a stellar manipulator - dubbed the 'Hand of Omega' - to detonate a nearby star into a black hole, which became the power source for Gallifreyan time travel. However, Omega seemingly died during this act, leaving him to become a revered figure of Time Lord history.

However, it turned out that Omega survived, but was left stranded in an anti-matter universe, where he went insane after centuries of isolation. Omega's only other on-screen appearance was in the first story of Season 20, 1983's Arc of Infinity. Both stories saw the crazed founder seeking revenge on the Time Lords.

One of the most important figures in Time Lord history, it's kind of surprising he hasn't even been mentioned in New Who (although he may have been glimpsed in 2020's The Timeless Children). He does have a habit of showing up around anniversaries though, so why not bring him back for the 60th?


1. The Mara

Doctor Who Mara
BBC Studios

The Mara are one of the most interesting species in the whole Whoniverse, yet they've only ever made two TV appearances, broadcast a year apart. They're a sort of non-corporeal gestalt entity that inhabit the "dark places of the inside" and seek out hosts in order to inhabit the physical universe. They made their debut in the 1982 Fifth Doctor story, Kinda, in which they vied for control of the the Doctor's companion, Tegan. They made their second and final appearance the following year in Snakedance, which served as a direct sequel. It was a rare instance of continuity in Classic Who, with Tegan still dealing with her ordeal in Kinda.

The Mara do have a physical manifestation - that of a giant snake - but they are very much creatures of the mind. As such, they offer some truly bizarre and psychological visuals. In Kinda we are treated to some trippy dream sequences as Tegan fights for her mind, and it's captivating to watch. With this unique nature and imagery, it's no wonder that the Mara have remained popular among fans.

Now just imagine what could be achieved with modern special effects and storytelling conventions. Having a companion trapped in a nightmarish dreamscape, fighting for their mind, on the brink of sanity? It's fascinating stuff. While they're not the kind of enemy that could be a regular presence, like the Daleks, they definitely have the potential to make a huge comeback, perhaps even as a season-long antagonist. Make it happen, RTD.


Watch Next


Quiz: How Well Do You Know Classic Doctor Who?

Dr Who William Hartnell
BBC

1. Which Actor Was The First To Play The Role Of The Doctor?

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Just a socially awkward geek from Down Under who spends most of his time in some fantasy world or another. Usually seen accompanied by a bow tie.