10 Most Cringeworthy Doctor Who Moments From The '80s

Big hair, bright colours, and Doctor Who - what could possibly go wrong?

For those who lived through them, the '80s are a bizarre mixture of blissful nostalgia and everlasting embarrassment, and that goes double for the shows during that period. The early '80s have that interesting edge to them in which everything feels new, as Doctor Who did when John Nathan-Turner took over the reins. Then we moved into the mid-'80s, in which boundaries got pushed just a bit too far, as they did on Doctor Who (still being guided by John Nathan-Turner). And finally we moved into the late '80s, when nothing took itself seriously, especially Doctor Who (again, under JNT) - though Doctor Who seems to have gotten an early start in this area, if the costuming is anything to go by. The brands of cringeworthy moments in '80s Who are so variable, it's hard to imagine sometimes that they come from the same series, or that they all occurred under the same producer - but they did, every single one. Several of you have made suggestions for this list, but we're sure that we won't have hit all of them, so please feel free to tell us about any moments from our favourite show in the '80s that made you particularly embarrassed - and as usual, your mileage may vary!

10. Chatty Cybermen - Earthshock (1982)

The 1982 episode Earthshock is a high point in '80s Who. Seriously. It has everything: the death of a companion (albeit an unpopular one); the triumphant return of a deadly enemy; a lot of gory, messy deaths; a cracking plot (so long as you don't look too closely at it); and chatty Cybermen. OK. Maybe not so much that last one. In episode three, as Tegan and the soldiers from Earth are looking for an opening to attack a couple of Cybermen, they watch them very carefully - as said Cybermen are apparently having an animated conversation about cybermat futures, or just how soft they prefer their software, or something. Whoever these extras are, they seem not to have gotten the memo about Cybermen being the emotionless remnants of our former selves rather than gossipy pensioners for whom Cyberconversion is just another entry on the bucket list. Watch this scene alongside one featuring Cybermen from the new series, and the difference is clear: 100% less cringiness!

9. Oscar's Death - The Two Doctors (1985)

Robert Holmes is well known for his double acts, especially in his later scripts. Who could forget Jago and Litefoot, who were so popular that they got their own audio series? Or Glitz and Dibber from Trial of a Time Lord? Garron and Unstoffe? Oscar and Anita...? Yeah, that last one doesn't quite work, does it? Probably because, in order for a Holmesian double act to work properly, both characters have to have some variant degree of charm, and Oscar has none. If he did, then maybe his death scene in the second episode of The Two Doctors would be a bit more poignant and less...well, self-indulgent. Now, it's obvious that Oscar sees himself as a grand actor, and in his final moments he should be allowed a last performance - but just because he's already in a restaurant doesn't give him license to chew the scenery. The result is one of the few deaths in Doctor Who, of any era, that makes you want to laugh, cringe, and roll your eyes all at the same time. But tears? Nah. Even the Doctor's "Good night, sweet prince" quip seems more bemused than anything else. Still, it's better than "You're just desserts..." Honestly, what is it with that man in this episode?

8. "The Tree Won't Harm You!" - Mark Of The Rani (1985)

Now, it's going to seem like there will be a lot of beating up on Colin Baker a lot in the list, and it's not that, it's really, really not. Colin Baker himself is amazing. It's just that most of the stories that Colin Baker was actually in were various degrees of horrible. Mark of the Rani is actually one of the best ones, so long as you treat it as a Rani one-off and try to forget the second time she appeared (or that audio drama she was in...shudder). But it has its own moments of noteworthy cringe, including the Rani's bizarre trap in the forest, which is laden with mines. Regular mines would have been enough, but these turn people into trees. Yes, younger fans, you heard right: trees. No wonder so many of you don't want to watch the classic series, to which we respond: the new series has an episode all about singing to the sun, and farting aliens. Nyah. What makes all of this cringey is not the aforementioned arboreal transmogrification but what one of its victims does afterward. As Peri is about to walk into the trap, young Luke, who has been turned into a tree...um, grabs her with his limb and saves her. Think about that and let it sink in: a tree grabs Peri with its single limb. This leads to the Doctor's unintentionally hilarious line "The tree won't harm you!" No, because this isn't The Evil Dead, after all.

7. The Rani As Mel - Time And The Rani (1987)

What is it with Time Lords and Ladies playing dress-up, anyway? It wasn't so bad when Roger Delgado's Master did it, but then the Doctor started joining in (though that was admittedly only once, and probably to assuage Jon Pertwee's desire to do drag). By the time we got to Anthony Ainley and Kate O'Mara...oh, dear. It's all getting rather silly, isn't it? Mind you, in her first appearance, the Rani's disguise as the bathhouse hag (what a great character description!) was inspired. But in her second appearance, she decided to dress up as the Doctor's companion Mel. Yes, that Mel. It's still unclear whether she is trying to trick the Doctor into helping her or trying to annoy him to the point that he regenerates again from mental fatigue. Come to think of it, maybe that's why the Sixth Doctor regenerated... In any case, Kate O'Mara seems to capture everything that's annoying about Mel, from the spunkiness to the squeaky voice to the positive attitude that would make Pollyana look like a depressive. No doubt that, if the Rani had decided that having the Doctor rescue Mel would cement the deception, she'd have nailed that eardrum piercing scream, too. All of this doesn't make the entire concept any less cringey, though. Mel herself is bad enough but Rani as Mel takes the wincing to levels never before dreamt possible.

6. The Ergon - Arc Of Infinity (1982)

Time Lord also seem to have some trouble creating proper minions, or at least the ones composed of anti-matter do. Omega's first set of minions in The Three Doctors were hardly impressive, but they at least looked like they could be dangerous - if you were diabetic and mistook them for mounds of candy, that is. The Ergon, though, produces a reaction that is less "Oh my god, a monster, let's run and hide!" and more "What the hell is that thing?" That may account for why Tegan and her cousin just stand there and let it shoot them with its scary anti-matter ray thingy. Maybe they were just too afraid of what it would do if they laughed in its face, as Tegan is trying not to do in the image above. So, what exactly is that thing, anyway? A genetically enhanced chicken? A pigeon that Omega augmented to the point that it could understand nuclear physics? Whatever it is, it's a lucky thing we don't have to see much of it in this story - though those scenes on Gallifrey aren't exactly any less laced with cringe, either.

5. Whizz Kid - The Greatest Show In The Galaxy (1988)

Talk about biting the hand that feeds you... It was no secret that John Nathan-Turner had no great love for the more vocal fans of the show that he'd been producing for almost a decade, and in the final story of the show's next-to-last original season, he allowed a story to feature a character that deliberately made fun of them. A year later, the show went into indefinite hiatus. Makes you wonder, doesn't it? In retrospect, there's no other reason for a character like Whizz Kid, the self-proclaimed "biggest fan" of the Psychic Circus, to be here except to let him (and, by proxy, those annoying fans) to be killed horribly. It's a tribute to the former Adrian Mole himself, Gian Sammarco, that Whizz Kid is not more annoying than he actually is, it's still quite difficult to sit through any of his scenes as a fan and not feel uncomfortable. Maybe because we've all said variations of "It's not as good as it used to be, but I still watch it" at some point in our lives?

4. "A Mega-Byte Modem!" - The Ultimate Foe (1986)

Who could have guessed in 1986 that modems able to transmit huge amounts of data, far in excess of a megabyte, were just around the corner? Not writers Pip and Jane Baker, bless 'em. One of the big reveals in The Ultimate Foe, the final chapter in the, um, thrilling Trial of a Time Lord season, is that the Valeyard is using a "mega-byte modem" in order to kill all of the Time Lords in the courtroom...or something. The details are a bit hazy, as the story drops off in quality pretty quickly around this part. It could just be that our brains start shutting down preemptively when we know this scene is approaching, just to spare ourselves the embarrassment. Now, there have been many theories floated about this: that "Mega-Byte" could be the retro name of a powerful alien tech company that produces devices capable of delivering far more than megabytes; that the TARDIS has translated some weird bit of Gallifreyan tech's name into something that Mel, computer "genius" that she is, can easily understand; and so on. Or it could just be that dear Pip and Jane thought it sounded good in the computer dictionary. In any case, it still seems mean that Doctor Who Magazine once snarkily asked the pair what a "mega-byte modem" was at the end of one of their interviews, resulting in poor Jane answering, "I think it has something to do with computers..." That being said, that had to have been a less uncomfortable moment for them than it is for us watching this scene.

3. "No, Not The Mind Probe!" - The Five Doctors (1983)

What exactly is it about this moment in The Five Doctors that has overshadowed all of the other cringey moments in that gloriously silly anniversary story? Is it the fact that only in science fiction can a line like "No, not the mind probe!" even exist - although most writers would think not twice but many times before using it? Is it Paul Jerricho's oddly accented delivery of the line, as seen here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xrvh_jB6c70 Is it the bizarre notion that the Time Lords use such a thing, and that its use is both so horrifying that the Castellan is terrified of it and so mundane that his horror sounds more like...well, boredom? Who knows? Who cares? But when there's a moment like this in both the commentary tracks on the DVD that those involved have to stop whatever else they're talking about and acknowledge it, you know that something has reached an epic level of cringiness. It's not quite the Doctor Who equivalent of "Khaaaannn!" but it comes awfully close.

2. The Timelash - Timelash (1985)

Ugh. "Timelash-up," more like. It's common knowledge that Doctor Who always struggled with its budget, and the fact that the special effects and costume designers were able to do anything with the pittance they were given is a minor miracle. But there are times when that pittance went a longer way than others, and Timelash is not one of them. The Bandril Ambassador from this story was already included in the original cringeworthy moments list; and who can really leave David Chandler's performance, with the immortal line "Avaunt thee, foul fanged fiend!", off this list? But we're choosing to do so, mainly because the eponymous Timelash itself is far, far worse. The outer shell of it is little more than a doorway with tinsel draped over the opening while the interior, supposedly a tunnel through space-time, looks more like a scaling wall made out of styrofoam pylons and more tinsel. It's an active embarrassment, and no amount of hemming and hawing about "the budgets in that era" will ever get a non-fan to look at it with any sort of indulgence. Hell, fans can barely look at it without screaming, so why should anyone else care to?

1. Colin Baker's Coat Of Many Colours - Various

None of the Doctors during JNT's tenure as producer during the '80s fared that well in the clothing department: Tom Baker's iconic costume was supplanted by a maroon version that, while still looking pretty good, nonetheless screamed "costume" in a way that previous Doctors' outfits hadn't. And while Peter Davison looks good in that cricketers' outfit, that's still what it is at the end of the day, but with celery. (The Tenth Doctor himself made fun of this in Time Crash - can't say we blame him. Isn't everyone embarrassed about our wardrobe choices when we were younger?) As for McCoy's question mark jumper and umbrella, the less said, the better. But Colin Baker's costume takes the cringey cake, if such a thing exists. What can be said about this outfit that hasn't already been said hundreds of times before? Colin Baker himself despised this costume, wishing his Doctor could instead have been dressed all in black; and the need for an alternate costume was so acute that Big Finish's all-blue variant was even semi-canonized with an action figure version just a few years back. It's apparent that no one in fandom cares much for this outfit, which may be a very big reason why Baker's audio adventures are so much more highly regarded than his television stories - on audio, no one has to see that coat. So, what did we leave off this list that made you cringe particularly during the "me" decade? Leave your comments below and let us know.

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Tony Whitt has previously written TV, DVD, and comic reviews for CINESCAPE, NOW PLAYING, and iF MAGAZINE. His weekly COMICSCAPE columns from the early 2000s can still be found archived on Mania.com. He has also written a book of gay-themed short stories titled CRESCENT CITY CONNECTIONS, available on Amazon.com in both paperback and Kindle format. Whitt currently lives and works in Chicago, Illinois.