10 Current Doctor Who Problems And How To Fix Them

Sometimes it takes more than a sonic screwdriver.

As Peter Capaldi's debut series finally comes to a close after the spectacular events of Last Christmas, fans can finally take a moment to relax and prepare for the next episode, The Magician's Apprentice. But not every fan is overly anxious for Series 9. Some even feel patient for its arrival, as a rushed product often has less quality to it, whereas a delayed season can lead to further consideration toward the production before it reaches the viewer's television screen. The programme has always put fun before anything else, as evidenced by the appearance of Santa Claus this previous year, but sometimes it dilutes the drama, morphing it into a parody of itself rather than a legitimate form of entertainment. It's certainly a difficult task to continue a series after it's reached the age of 51, but sometimes the writers - the current showrunner Steven Moffat - make noticeable mistakes that damage the show, or they attempt to add a unique spin on something that later just becomes ridiculous and unenjoyable as a whole. Of course, eccentricity is one of the main legs of Doctor Who, and it has been for some time, but some things just don't work, and sometimes the things that fail turn into tropes and clichés. Here's a list of the top ten current problems with Doctor Who, as well as possible solutions.

10. A Pointless Sentence Is Always Important Later

This isn't a commonly mentioned problem with Doctor Who, hence why it's first on the list. But it's a silent issue that's been plaguing the programme lately. Commonly in the show, a character will mention something offhandedly, usually without having any reason to bring it up in the conversation, and the information they give out becomes useful to the Doctor later on in the episode, regardless of how unnecessary it initially sounded. In the episode In the Forest of the Night, for example, the character Maebh Arden is mentioned to occasionally hear voices and that it's likely a form of psychosis brought on by her sibling's disappearance. This later became vital to the plot when it was revealed that she was actually psychically connected to the Earth's trees. Events like these are not uncommon in general storytelling but it'd be much more effective if there was deeper character development that didn't prove to be necessary to push the story forward, maybe instead have Maebh just have her disorder and have her sister appear living in this newly grown forest, able to communicate with the agriculture instead of her younger sibling. You know, something that would've made sense.

9. Very Few Characters Return

Doctor Who has always had a lineup of interesting and fun characters since the original episode aired back in 1963. But after a character leaves the programme, they seldom ever return. Occasionally they will find their way back into the Doctor's life, of course, usually bringing with them a wave of nostalgia and the cheers of older fans. But the show's missing out on a more subtle way to go about it, and a way that could give Doctor Who a more fleshed out narrative. It's simple. Have characters return with more frequency. This isn't meant to appease the Whovians demanding Ian Chesterton's return to the show, but instead to just feature more recurring characters in general. Take Shona, for example. Following Last Christmas many fans have exclaimed confidently that she should return as a new companion, fighting evil alongside the Doctor and Clara throughout time and space, but here's a better idea. Have Shona appear in a new episode, have her discover the TARDIS, give the audience brief flashbacks of Last Christmas, and then have her get pulled away by Dave as they cheerfully go on their way. Not everyone who comes back to the show needs to be a previous companion or of high profile, instead just bring back characters from previous endeavours every once in a while, maybe have Alonso Frame appear with a group of survivors stranded on an alien planet, or have Journey Blue appear in the next Dalek episode, older and higher in rank.

8. A Lack Of Companion Diversity

This one's pretty self explanatory, and often discussed among the fanbase. It's arguable that there's more diversity in the companions than most people assume. After all, Rose was accompanied by Adam, Mickey, and Jack, and Amy was likewise followed by Rory. But that's the main issue. They were followers, mere companions to the companion, who has always been a British female since the show's revival in 2005. The main point of companions in Doctor Who is to act as a sort of avatar to the fans, letting the audience live vicariously through them with the Doctor. Therefore it makes sense that the individual is intentionally comparable to the viewer so they can make that attachment more easily, but it's causing the programme to become stale, making the characters virtually interchangeable. The simple solution is this. Give the fans a new companion of either gender and make them a humanoid alien, only going so far as to tweak a few features that can still avoid putting a significant dent in the budget, something like giving the actor coloured contact lenses that give them an unnatural eye colour, or giving them gloves that remove a finger from each hand. Simple. Cost effective. Unique.

7. The Daleks Are Boring

A subject often brought up in recent years is the Daleks, and how not many people feel frightened of them anymore. In all honesty the Daleks haven't been seen as scary for a long time, often being the butt of jokes in productions such as Looney Tunes, Robot Chicken and even a Futurama comic back in 2007. Along with this, a complaint that often coincides with the previous one mentioned is that the Daleks are being overused, appearing so often in the programme that many fans have fallen under the assumption that the BBC are doing it in order to retain the rights to the species. A fix for this is a little bit more difficult and thus a more detailed example is required. Have an episode occur in Series 9 or 10 wherein the Daleks are finally eliminated because of the events that were set in motion in Into the Dalek, then have complete silence about them for a few years before bringing them back full force in a mysterious way with minor tweaks in design, perhaps removing the plunger and replacing it with the alternative appendage seen in The Parting of the Ways. If the Doctor asks how they're still alive, have them reply that they truly don't know why. This would be the perfect setup for a new story arc, perhaps one that leads to other dead species coming back, culminating in an all out war between them, which the Doctor could return to from time to time for new episodes, running across survivors, landing in between small skirmishes that he decides to resolve, etc. The possibilities are endless.

6. An Inconsistent Mythology

Usually in comic books, fans get annoyed at the constant retcons, bringing characters back from the dead, and the repetition of storylines just so the company can make their product quickly enough to still rake in money. All this can also be said about Doctor Who, too, as throughout the show's 51 year old history, plenty has been rehashed, and plenty of the previous history is discarded. Even without bringing consideration towards the extended Whoniverse, plenty of events overlap or contradict. This can be kept away from, and has been avoided in the past. In Series 7 of Doctor Who, an episode was supposed to revolve around the assassination of the late president John F. Kennedy. The episode was discarded, partly due to the fact that the revived show's initial episode featured the Ninth Doctor being present at the shocking event. A simple way to avoid mistakes like this is to have the writers do some homework on the programme's history. If the script includes a reference to Atlantis, check to see if the underwater utopia has been featured before (which it has).

5. Humanoid Aliens

Back in the early years of Doctor Who, when William Hartnell was the TARDIS pilot, and the programme was yet to reach colourisation, many of the strange alien species that were encountered resembled human beings. This was obviously due to the technical limitations of the time, in conjunction with the limited budget given as well. But in the modern programme, aliens still commonly bear a humanoid resemblance. There's nothing wrong with this as it still saves the BBC money, and most of the creatures are still creative both visually and conceptually, demonstrating telepathy, teleportation, invisibility and other strange and distinct abilities. But the issue is that there's a lack of diversity in the visual department. The majority of enemies that te Doctor has encountered have been strangely equipped with two legs, two arms, two eyes, etc. Mixing it up, therefore, isn't a bad idea. Not a lot, but just perhaps an animal alien that resembles a dog? Something along the lines of a clearly inhuman alien. There has been a recent increase in exactly that, as evidenced by the Boneless this last year, but even they eventually adopted human-like qualities.

4. Next (And Only) Stop... Earth

The Earth itself provides the Doctor with a sort of home away from home (when your home's been locked away in a pocket dimension beyond your reach). So it makes sense to feature the planet in a number of adventures across the Doctor's lifetime. It also helps ease new viewers into the program by giving them a familiar planet, namely their own. But again, the idea is becoming stale. There's an easy fix to this that can still keep a decent number of Earth-centric episodes. Feature a new planet with its own unique history crafted by the hands of the show's writers and showrunner. Then include that planet on occasion with various stories. This can also help eliminate the cliche of humanities "forgetfulness" about their countless alien invasions, as this new unnamed planet could grow and evolve around their attacks. This could also give the grounds for one of the Doctor's adversaries to actually win, destroying or enslaving the planet, adding some real weight to the Doctor's enemies, which is something they desperately need as of late.

3. Valuing Spectacle Over Quality

In the original series, a single story was referred to as a serial since it would often take multiple episodes to conclude. Before its cancellation, Doctor Who's average serial length was roughly two hours, this allowed each adventure to unfold slowly, making the audience feel attached to the new characters because they were given enough time to get to know them properly. Of course, if a serial was disliked, the viewer would feel like the story was taking forever to finally end so they could start the next one. In modern Doctor Who, very few episodes stretch over the 45 minute mark. Of course storytelling has improved since the 60s, and fans likewise have less interest in elongating stories. But sometimes the episodes feel rushed, pushing from start to finish from the word go. Many Whovians bemoaned Moffat's removal of two-part episodes in Series 7 and likewise their absence in Series 8 (with exception to the finale). This shows that a longer story isn't necessarily a bad one. Of course, not every story needs to reach the two hour mark of the preceding show, but maybe it should just take the time to smell the flowers and actually build up an adventure's character before running off again.

2. Aiming The Show At Children

Did Doctor Who come across as a kids show in the first season when Eccleston watched a future human-trampoline explode into tiny chunks, letting her internal organs splatter across the ships floor? No. Did it seem like a children's show when Jack Harkness continually made sexual remarks while he was on screen? Of course not. But the show also featured a plastic Mickey Smith running around, and Vinvocci, a race that resembled vibrantly colored cacti. Doctor Who has been intended as a family programme since its revival and it has always found a balance between child and adult. Hence why, in the Russell T Davies era, there were both Torchwood and The Sarah Jane Adventures simultaneously, so that either types of fan could enjoy more of the Doctor Who mythos without having to sit through older episodes that many of them find archaic. But recently the scales have been tipped in the favour of the younger viewers. The Sontarans have been reduced to mere comedic relief, children storm the TARDIS interior with alarming regularity and Robin Hood and Santa Claus are a part of the programme's universe (Santa less so). Simply put, it needs to be dialed back a bit.

1. The Sonic Screwdriver

The subject of many heated debates within the fandom is the recently popularised sonic screwdriver. In the Classic era it was a rarely used device, and even more rarely needed. Of course, as mentioned previously, episodes are shorter these days, and the sonic screwdriver allows a way for the narrative to move forward without wasting much time. But in many situations the sonic is just used as a multi-tool that does anything without it being mentioned beforehand. Sure, it doesn't work on wood, but it's a rare occasion where the Doctor actually reaches this issue. The sonic is handy for storytelling but generally resolves conflict far too lazily. A way to change this in the future is to have Peter Capaldi's Doctor lose his sonic, either in a battle or by simple personal error. Have him then approach the wardrobe of his TARDIS and pick out an older screwdriver, like the one from the Eccleston/Tennant era (the Doctor admitted to having multiples), thus allowing him to still use the sonic in a good capacity, but less often since it was revealed that that particular sonic used a numbering system (as mentioned in The Doctor Dances) that the Doctor could very well not remember anymore. Therefore, the sonic could be limited in ability but slowly he'll begin to memorise the numbers again, thus allowing it to become more useful over time. So there you are ladies, gentlemen and variations thereupon. Ten issues with Doctor Who, as well as solutions for each. What do you think? Do you agree or disagree? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor

This article was written by a Guest author. If you would like to become a regular contributor on WhatCulture, please submit an application.