10 Doctor Who Moments That Make NO SENSE

Some of the biggest head-scratchers from the world of Doctor Who.

Doctor Who The Christmas Invasion the Doctor's hand Captain Jack Harkness
BBC Studios

The thing that sets Doctor Who apart from almost every other sci-fi show is that its writing is consistently great. You don't make it to 60 years on telly without doing something right!

Writers on the show take enormous care to craft likeable characters and amazing worlds, with stories that are big and exciting, but grounded enough to maintain audience investment.

Yes indeed, a lot of work goes into writing for Doctor Who – which is why it's highly annoying when stuff like this happens.

Plot holes, inconsistencies, and silly moments affect every TV show, but in this case there are literally hundreds of them – and these are some of the biggest ones from the modern series.

Character inconsistencies, technology not quite adding up, and huge coincidences are the order of the day here. Some of them won't affect your viewing of the episode too much, but others will make you wonder how you ever overlooked them.

Sorry in advance.

10. Graham Randomly Shows Up In A Volcano

The Power Of The Doctor Graham Ace
BBC Studios

Despite an extended runtime, The Power of the Doctor was bursting at the seams. It had a lot to cram in, including a cameo from everyone's favourite gameshow-hosting companion.

Bradley Walsh returned to the fray as Graham, leading a support group for ex-companions at the episode's end. Before this, he saved the day by helping Ace defeat the Daleks, who were trying to set off numerous volcanoes all at once.

Told you it was a busy episode.

But hang on just a jiffy – how the hell did Graham get here? How does he just show up inside a volcano?

Last we checked, there are no public footpaths into the centre of boiling hot pits of doom. And Graham hardly has the resources or athleticism of a James Bond superspy. And how did he even know which volcano to visit? It won't shock you to learn that there are quite a few of them dotted around the Earth.

It's one of those things you're just meant to accept, but it still keeps us awake at night thinking about it.


9. Destroying The Cybermen With LOVE

Doctor Who Closing Time Matt Smith the Doctor Alfie Stormageddon
BBC Studios

Before he inexplicably became one of the most hated men on Earth, James Corden made two appearances in Doctor Who as loveable lad Craig Owens.

In The Lodger, the Eleventh Doctor helps Craig come to terms with his love for best friend Sophie. When he pays him a second visit in Closing Time, Craig and Sophie have a baby called Alfie – or "Stormageddon: Dark Lord of All" to his mates.

The Doctor, Craig, and Stormzy discover that a group of Cybermen are hiding in a nearby shopping centre – because even robots can't resist a bargain. They end up capturing Craig and begin converting him, when he hears Alfie's cries.

They wouldn't, would they? Oh yes they would.

Doctor Who Closing Time
BBC Studios

Craig uses the power of love to overcome the conversion, saving himself and eventually leading to the Cybermens' destruction. Really? The power of love? That's the most cliched, hackneyed ending imaginable! What are they gonna do next week, the Doctor fakes his own death?!

We probably should've seen this coming, considering that "love saves the day" was also the solution in The Lodger. But to do this to the Cybermen was criminal.


8. They Throw Rocks Now?

Doctor Who Blink
BBC Studios

Blink is one of those episodes that will always have a place in the hearts of Whovians, which makes it all the more difficult to accept that there's a really weird detail right at the start of it.

Sally Sparrow first gets a sense that her life is about to take a strange turn when she reads a message scrawled on the wall of Wester Drumlins: "DUCK NOW!"

Moments later, a rock flies in through the window, narrowly avoiding her head.

According to writer Steven Moffat, a nearby Weeping Angel threw the rock so it could make Sally an easier target, which was perhaps the first clue that he didn't understand the abilities of his own monster.

Doctor Who Blink Weeping Angel
BBC Studios

We've never seen another Angel attempt anything like this, so what made this one such a wimp? Angels move at lightning speeds – even the weaker ones in Blink, as we see at the end of the episode – so why do they need to incapacitate their victims? Surely that's the whole point of their ability.

Sorry Stevey boy, but you're not off the hook with this one.


7. Legend Of The Sea Devils, Just Generally

Doctor Who Legend of the Sea Devils
BBC Studios

Ah, Legend of the Sea Devils. What a mess.

Jodie Whittaker's second-to-last outing as the Doctor is not only the least-watched NuWho episode ever, but it was also roundly smashed by fans and critics. The production of the episode was extremely rushed (something even showrunner Chris Chibnall has admitted), and oh boy can you tell.

At one point the TARDIS, with the Doctor and Yaz onboard, gets eaten by a giant sea monster. A few minutes pass and we spend some time with Pirate Dan, and when we cut back to the Doctor and Yaz, they're somehow... inside the Sea Devils' base?

What?

Doctor Who Legend of the Sea Devils
BBC Studios

It's not clear where they are or how they got there. Is the Sea Devil base inside the monster? Or has it transported them somewhere else? And where's the monster now?!

There are many small disconnects like this one throughout the episode, and it makes the whole thing a rather confusing, frustrating experience to watch.


6. Captain Jack Goes Handhunting

Doctor Who The Christmas Invasion hand
BBC Studios

In David Tennant's first proper outing as the Tenth Doctor, he engages in a swordfight with the Sycorax leader, which costs him one of his hands. Thankfully, he's able to grow a new "fightin' hand!" in its place, which is rather good at throwing satsumas.

That severed limb would serve as a critical plot point later down the line, as Ten is able to use it to stave off regeneration, leading to the creation of the Metacrisis Doctor.

Before that however, he's reunited with his lost appendage thanks to Captain Jack Harkness, who gives it to him in the Series 3 finale.

Doctor Who Utopia hand
BBC Studios

Question is... how the hell did Jack get it?

Sure, Jack works for Torchwood, and can use some wizzy-wozzy super-duper Doctor detector. But he still would've needed to track it down very quickly after it was lost in order to preserve it so well.

The bigger sticking point is the fact that the hand fell over London (directly into the Eastenders title sequence, by the looks of it), while Jack is based in Cardiff – a good 150 miles away.


5. The Doctor's Cue Cards

Doctor Who Under The Lake Cue Cards
BBC Studios

Under the Lake is the first part of the first two-parter from Series 9, in which the Twelfth Doctor and Clara have to deal with a bunch of murderous ghosts aboard an underwater mining facility.

It's all very interesting and spooky and science-fiction-y, but none of that is why it's on the list. That reason is something far more simple.

When the Doctor confronts the crew of the facility early in the story and realises he's been a tad insensitive by expressing amazement at their dead friend coming back as a ghost, Clara reminds him of the cards in his pocket – a selection of stock phrases to help him deal with various situations.

This gets a cheap laugh when the Doctor reads out the painfully generic statement written on one card, but everything else about this moment is seriously flawed.

The Doctor might be an alien, but he's not an idiot. He's dealt with plenty of complicated emotional matters without needing a script, so what makes this one so different?

It's also difficult to believe that the Doctor and Clara sat down one night for some arts and crafts to put these cards together. Clearly the writers liked the gag, but put little thought into whether or not it made sense.


4. Slowest. Walk. EVER!

Doctor Who The Church on Ruby Road Ruby's mother
BBC Studios

Ncuti Gatwa kicked off his tenure in the 2023 Christmas special The Church on Ruby Road, and good grief, was it something else. In a good way! He did a whole musical number, for crying out loud.

The special also introduced new companion Ruby Sunday, and set up her backstory as a foundling abandoned on Christmas Eve. Fifteen ends up travelling back to that day in order to save baby Ruby from becoming goblin food, which is where this odd moment takes place.

When the Doctor arrives, Ruby's mother is already walking away from the church, far down the road (above). He then Hot Fuzzes the Goblin King, rescues Ruby, touches back down on the ground, and runs back to the TARDIS – all of which takes several minutes – and the mother is still in the exact same place she was when he first arrived!

Doctor Who The Church on Ruby Road Ruby's mother STILL WALKING AWAY
BBC Studios

Come on now. There's taking your time, and then there's really taking your time. Is she actually three kids in a trench coat? Was she wearing really heavy shoes? 

Maybe we'll find out that there were some timey-wimey shenanigans going on here (like the jacket-less Matt Smith in Flesh and Stone). Or maybe it was done for dramatic effect, so the Doctor could stare at her walking away. Either way, it takes you out of the moment, and makes little sense to boot.


3. Why Do The Daleks Have A SPIN Button?

Doctor Who Journey's End Dalek spin button
BBC Studios

At the end of the Series 4 finale, just when everything looks bleak for the Tenth Doctor and his army of friends/human weapons, Donna Noble ascends!

The power of the DoctorDonna kicks in, giving her genius intellect and allowing her to set in motion the destruction of the Dalek fleet.

She disables their weapons, disarms the reality bomb – sorry, "THE REALITY BOMB!!" – and... makes them do doughnuts? Ok then.

Donna twists a little button on the control desk and makes all of the Daleks spin around. Then she makes them go the other way, because you would, wouldn't you.

Doctor Who Journey's End Daleks spinning
BBC Studios

This is funny and all, and cuts through the bleakness of the previous moment. But it raises a whole bunch of questions – chief among them, why the Daleks would have a spin function in the first place. Not to mention a host of other switches and levers that make them completely useless.

Maybe RTD wanted to see spinning Daleks, and you know what... that's fair.


2. Quite Possibly The Worst Soldiers In Existence

Doctor Who The Zygon Invasion soldier
BBC Studios

Series 9's The Zygon Invasion/The Zygon Inversion is remembered for Peter Capaldi's incredible speech at the end of the second episode, and rightly so.

However, the rest of the story isn't quite so strong. It's good, don't get us wrong. It's solid. It's just that you're probably better off booting up the speech on YouTube rather than sitting through the whole 90 minutes.

One highly questionable moment occurs when a group of soldiers approach a Zygon-infested church. Knowing full well that the Zygons are capable of shape-shifting, the soldiers are reminded just before the mission begins that, "You know what they're capable of. Do not fall victim to it."

In other words, when the Zygons inevitably take the form of someone you love in order to trick you, ignore it.

So guess what happens next?

Almost immediately, the lead soldier is duped when a Zygon emerges from the church posing as his mother. And despite every single piece of evidence pointing to the fact that they're being lured to their deaths, the entire group of soldiers lower their weapons, enter the church, and are murdered.

Doctor Who The Zygon Invasion
BBC Studios

Well gee, if only someone had warned them!

It's utterly ridiculous that a trained group of soldiers would fall for such a simple ruse. Without a doubt one of the most contrived moments in recent Doctor Who history.


1. Bye Bye Boatswain

Doctor Who Curse Of The Black Spot
BBC Studios

Remember this guy from Series 6's The Curse of the Black Spot? You probably don't, and there's a very good reason for that.

The Eleventh Doctor and the Ponds end up on a pirate ship where the crew are being haunted by a Siren, which comes for anyone who sustains even the slightest of injuries.

Heading up the buccaneers is Captain Henry Avery, played by Hugh Bonneville. His fellow sea dogs include a character known simply as the Boatswain, portrayed by Lee Ross.

This guy is just sort of there to begin with, until he gets wounded about halfway through. And then, he just vanishes. Into thin air.

If you think we're exaggerating, we're not – the Boatswain literally disappears from the story and only emerges at the very end, reunited with his crew. It's never explained what happened to him, or where he went.

Doctor Who The Curse of the Black Spot
BBC Studios

Apparently, there was a whole subplot filmed about this character that was cut during editing, creating a significant continuity error in the final episode.

Shall we start taking bets on Big Finish plugging the gap with a series of audio adventures? "The Boatswain Adventures." It'd fly off the shelves!


Watch Next


In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jacob Simmons has a great many passions, including rock music, giving acclaimed films three-and-a-half stars, watching random clips from The Simpsons on YouTube at 3am, and writing about himself in the third person.