10 Doctor Who Villains Who Actually Won

The Time Lord Victorious doesn't always come out on top.

Doctor Who Amy's Choice Toby Jones as the Dream Lord
BBC Studios

Despite being completely insane, quite rude in places, and a bit inept at times, the Doctor almost always gets the job done when it comes to fighting bad guys.

The Time Lord wouldn't be nearly as revered in their own universe (or as popular in ours) if they didn't have a decent hit ratio when stopping evildoers. However, nobody bats a thousand, and the Doctor is no exception.

Over the years, the time traveller has suffered some pretty harsh defeats, those very rare occasions where the bad guys actually come away with a victory.

Now, "victory" doesn't necessarily mean that everyone dies and the universe is over. It doesn't have to be a big thing - not being late to work is a victory when you've got a hangover - just as long as the villain's goals have been met.

With that in mind, let's take a look at those Doctor Who opponents who actually got one over on the Gallifreyan, from dreamy tricksters, to little blobs of fat. Yeah, that second one was definitely a strange day at the office.

10. The Cybermen (The Age Of Steel)

Doctor Who Rise Of The Cybermen
BBC Studios

The Cybermen have been a thorn in the Doctor's side since the early days of the show. In fact, they were the reason he undertook his first regeneration.

The Doctor must've been thrilled to see the back of them after the classic series, but this joy was short-lived when they turned up in an alternate universe.

The brainchild of mad scientist John Lumic, these new Cybermen are metal shells created to house an inhibited human brain. They're sleek, shiny, and deadly, plus they have neat little handles on their heads so you can take them anywhere you like.

While the second half of this two-parter ends with the Doctor defeating Lumic and freeing London from Cyber-control, there's still the small matter of the rest of the world.

Lumic's plan to upgrade the human race wasn't just taking place in the English capital - he had conversion factories across the globe.

The fact that the Cybermen returned at all could be seen as a victory, as they always find a way to escape their would-be-doom. Them conquering the entire world was just the robotic cherry on the emotionless cake.


9. Skaldak (Cold War)

Doctor Who Cold War Skaldak
BBC Studios

After beginning the episode frozen in ice, Grand Marshal Skaldak gets thawed out on a submarine at the height of the Cold War. And yeah, that's not good.

From here, it's up to the Eleventh Doctor, Clara, that guy from Titanic, and Ser Davos from Game of Thrones to prevent Skaldak from firing the ship's missiles and starting World War III.

The reason why this scaly fella is so upset is because the humans on board attacked him for no good reason. He's got no agenda against the Earth itself - he's just after a bit of revenge. So, when his people come to rescue him, he leaves without setting off the missiles, even though he could've done so easily.

The Doctor and co. were powerless to stop Skaldak after he hacked into the submarine's weapons systems. If the Ice Warrior rescue ship had turned up just a few minutes later, then the whole world would've been toast.

In other words, Skaldak won. It was only via his mercy that the Doctor lived to finish out Series 7.


8. The Flood (The Waters Of Mars)

The Waters of Mars The Flood Doctor Who
BBC Studios

An episode that put millions of children off showering for good, The Waters of Mars is one of those rare stories where the villain is actually predestined to win.

While the Doctor is visiting Bowie Base One on Mars - a genius little joke, by the way - he discovers that its crew is slowly being infected by a waterborne parasite called the Flood.

One of the greatest one-off villains ever, the Flood turns its victims into zombie-like creatures with cracked skin around their mouths. Also, they constantly spew water, which is as scary as it is gross.

Though this horrific enemy is seemingly vanquished when the base is blown up, the damage had already been done by that point.

Most of the crew members - engineer Margaret Cain, tech-head Roman Groom, and no-nonsense deputy Ed Gold - have already been converted by the Flood, with Captain Adelaide Brooke taking her own life in order to maintain this fixed point in time.

This event cannot be changed no matter how hard the Doctor tries. The base must always be destroyed, its people must always perish, and the Flood must always win.


7. The Adiposian First Family (Partners In Crime)

Doctor Who Partners In Crime Adipose Ship
BBC Studios

The first episode of Series 4 permanently paired Donna Noble with the man who rescued/ruined her wedding day.

Donna and the Doctor join forces to investigate Adipose, a diet pill manufacturer with a dark secret. Instead of headaches or blurry vision, the side effects of this medication involve users' fat being turned into tiny, blubbery aliens.

These Adipose children are being born on Earth because their species' original nursery planet was stolen by the Daleks. As a result, the Adiposian first family employed a space nanny called Matron Cofelia, to find them a new breeding ground.

Of course she chose Earth. They always choose Earth.

While the good guys manage to stop full conversions of the people who took the pills, several thousand Adipose children were created. Their parents come to pick them up, killing Cofelia to cover their tracks.

So while Cofelia doesn't get away with her crimes, the Adiposian First Family ends up getting what they want: they have a batch of new younglings with nothing to tie them to their illegal breeding scheme.

A good day to be a little white blob.


6. The Vashta Nerada (Forest Of The Dead)

Doctor Who the Vashta Nerada
BBC Studios

To give the Vashta Nerada credit, they only ended up in the planet-sized library after their forests were harvested to make books. To take that credit away from them, they're terrifying, flesh-eating nasties that hide in shadows and are completely relentless.

This is why the Doctor is forced to reason with them rather than actually defeat them. When confronted by the living darkness, the Doctor cuts them a deal - they give him one day to free the people trapped inside the library's data core, and then the library is theirs.

Of course, Ten succeeds in that plan. Well actually, River Song is the one who saves the day, but if we talk about her death scene then we'll just cry. All the people in the Library are saved, and then they leave, surrendering the complex to its new inhabitants.

The Vashta Nerada got exactly what they wanted, and then some. Not only did they find a new forest, but they also got some tasty snacks as a bonus!


5. The Dream Lord (Amy's Choice)

Doctor Who Amy's Choice the Dream Lord Toby Jones
BBC Studios

The Dream Lord, as played by the fantastic Toby Jones (who is also the voice of Dobby - try watching Harry Potter after making that link) traps the Doctor, Amy, and Rory in two separate realities: one where the Ponds live in domestic bliss, and the other where they are travelling in the TARDIS.

He tasks our heroes with finding out which reality is real, and which is fake. In the end, it turns out that both worlds were a lie, and the gang manages to escape the Dream Lord's clutches.

The Dream Lord was actually the result of a really bad trip after some psychic pollen got into the TARDIS. Sure, "psychic pollen". Is that what they're calling it these days? Despite not being real, the existence of the Dream Lord rocks the Doctor to his core, as he has just witnessed what his dark side can do.

It's hard to establish what the Dream Lord's exact goal was, but he definitely seemed like he was out to expose the Doctor's flaws, so in that case, mission accomplished.


4. The Weeping Angels (The Angels Take Manhattan)

Doctor Who Weeping Angel The Angels Take Manhattan
BBC Studios

While the Vashta Nerada were simply looking for a home, the Weeping Angels are just nasty little so-and-sos through and through.

These stony sods feed off people's time energy, sending their victims back to the past to live out their days in confusion and isolation. See? What a bunch of meanies.

They do this to poor old Rory Pond in Series 7's The Angels Take Manhattan. They originally send him back to 1938, but the Doctor, Amy, and River Song all manage to rescue him by causing a paradox that wipes the Angels out.

Or so they thought.

While standing in a graveyard, Rory spots a tombstone with his name on it. Before he has a chance to say "Ruh-roh", he is touched by a surviving Angel and is displaced once again.

Due to the paradox, the TARDIS cannot return to the time where Rory is trapped. Faced with a life without her beloved, Amy touches the Angel too, and joins her hubby in the past.

It's an incredibly sad exit for the Ponds, that's made even worse when you realise that the Angels actually got what they desired.


3. The Master (The Sound Of Drums)

Doctor Who The Sound of Drums
BBC Studios

If a tree falls in the forest and nobody hears it, does it still make a sound?

Equally, if the Master successfully takes over the Earth but nobody remembers it, does it count as a victory?

This is what happened when John Simm's version of the charismatic loony was voted Prime Minister of the UK, under the guise of Harold Saxon. Using his army of Toclafane, the Master becomes ruler of the entire Earth, and slaughters its population for sick sport.

The Master is in charge of the planet for an entire year before Martha Jones enacts a plan to remove him from power. This results in time being reversed to the point before he took over, undoing all the death and destruction he had caused.

Technically then, he didn't actually win, because he ended up dying at the end of the series. However, he was the most powerful being on Earth for a full 12 months, enjoying unlimited power and control in that time.

Also, the Doctor, Martha, her family, Captain Jack, and the millions of people who watched the episode all know it happened, so it still counts as a victory.


2. Madame Kovarian (A Good Man Goes To War)

Doctor Who Madame Kovarian
BBC Studios

Not just called "Eyepatch Lady" as some people thought, Madame Kovarian enjoys an unprecedented victory when she actually manages to fool the Doctor - which doesn't happen very often at all.

In a plot involving a kidnapped Amy Pond, some Headless Monks, and good old Danny Boy from Victory of the Daleks, it momentarily looks like #TeamDoctor has come out on top. There's a fierce battle which sees brave Strax get killed and stupid Dorium Maldovar get his stupid head cut off, but other than that, everything seems fine and dandy.

But unfortunately, Eyepatch Lady has the last laugh when she reveals that the child they have in their possession - the child that was the entire point of this mission - is a fake.

The child in question is of course Melody Pond, aka River Song. River is subsequently taken by Kovarian and the Silence, who raise her to kill the Doctor before he can reach Trenzalore.

So not only did Kovarian embarrass the Doctor, but she also gave the show one of its best recurring characters. That's a double win!


1. The Daleks (Genesis Of The Daleks)

Doctor Who Davros Genesis of the Daleks
BBC Studios

Of course it's the Daleks. It's always the Daleks.

These killer dustbins always find a way to come back to life, even when they've been shot, blown up, or wiped from existence entirely. However, they very nearly never existed at all.

Back when Tom Baker had his jelly baby-covered hands on the TARDIS key, the Doctor was sent on a mission to destroy the Daleks before they are even created.

This leads to the Time Lord's first-ever encounter with Davros, who looks a little more rubbery than modern fans might be used to.

Ultimately, the Doctor cannot commit genocide, so he lets the creator complete his work and unleash the hateful race of monsters into the universe.

When it comes to victories, they don't come much bigger than this in Doctor Who. If the Daleks had never existed, the entire landscape of the show would be completely different.

The Doctor undoubtedly did the moral thing, but imagine how many lives would've been saved if these abhorrent creatures were erased from history. The Tenth Doctor's Baywatch-style run towards Rose Tyler in Series 4 would've ended with a hug rather than a regeneration lost, for example.

Ah, what could've been.


Watch Next


Doctor Who: The Ultimate Daleks Quiz

Nyder Doctor WHo
BBC

1. Who Were The Kaleds At War With When They Became The Daleks?

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jacob Simmons has a great many passions, including rock music, giving acclaimed films three-and-a-half stars, watching random clips from The Simpsons on YouTube at 3am, and writing about himself in the third person.