10 Great TV Cliffhangers (With Awful Pay-Offs)
The Walking Dead, The Sopranos and Arrow all left us hanging.
Few things in life are harder than wrapping up a story in an interesting way while also keeping the viewer hooked for any potential follow-up. Whether it's a movie, a video game, a book or a TV series, there are many ways to stumble right at the finish line. Honing in on TV, in some ways creators might have realistically already crossed the finish line, only to then fall flat on their faces when the next season of a series rolls around.
Not only does it hurt when these things happen, but it's even worse knowing that the cliffhanger that came before was so incredibly good that you couldn't stop thinking about it for days, weeks or even months. You'd expect the resolution to be on par or even better than what came before, but that is not always the case.
Sometimes series do you dirtier than a pig rolling through the mud when it's hot outside. Sometimes the resolution is just plain awful and it leaves you in a state of uncontrollable rage. Not because they were just that bad, but because these cliffhangers failed you on a personal level.
Be aware, full spoilers for these episodes follow.
10. The Walking Dead - "Start To Finish"
We're starting this list off right with one of the downright worst episodes in the history of The Walking Dead, but not in the way you might expect. The Season Six mid-season finale of The Walking Dead, Start to Finish, is an exciting hour of television leaving us excited to return to the show when it comes back in the spring. Unfortunately, Start to Finish can be credited as the episode that started the worst batch of episodes from the entire show.
Of course, we didn't know this at the time. When the episode aired it was quite fine by leaving us with some tantalizing promises. With Alexandria flooded with walkers, Rick and Carl (along with Jessie and her kids) have to make their way across a sea of the undead while covered in zombie guts. Jessie's youngest son, Sam, is mortified, however, and starts to call out for his mom at the worst time possible.
It's an exciting cliffhanger, especially if you count the post-credit scenes that introduce Negan and the Saviors to the TV universe. Looking back, the pay-off wasn't worth it at all. Negan and his goons are responsible for the worst story arc in the show due to the plot being stretched out way too thin. It's not surprising many people stopped watching, and frankly, we can't blame them.
9. 24 - "Day 2: 7:00 A.m. - 8:00 A.m."
The staple of a great cliffhanger is leaving people wanting more as soon as possible. The second season of 24 managed to accomplish just that with an outstanding finale in an otherwise disappointing season. In the final stretch of episodes, the writers managed to redeem most of the first half thanks to some great action and lots of tension. The finale is probably the season's crowning achievement.
Fans of 24 were ravenous after the Season Two finale, which saw President David Palmer collapse due to being poisoned by Mandy. The closing minutes of that second year were the talk of the town for an entire summer, with everyone wanting to know if President Palmer, a beloved character on the show, would survive. Fast forward a few months, and Palmer comes back in the Season Three premiere just fine.
The show jumped three years forward in time as if nothing happened. Although the show made reverence to Palmer's poisoning, viewers didn't get to see any of the drama. Instead, they needed to quickly adjust to the new setting and story: a story in which the heroic Jack Bauer all of a sudden had a heroin addiction.
8. Lost - "Exodus"
At one point, Lost was the biggest thing on TV. Over its first season, the series became a phenomenon thanks to its complex characters, mysteries, and draw-dropping action. People couldn't wait to get to the water cooler just to talk about what happened in the most recent episode. This was especially the case for the first season finale, as it left our heroes with many great cliffhangers.
Walt got taken by the Others, while Locke finally made some progress with the hatch. For an entire summer, people were talking about what could be in the hatch and who might have taken Walt. Unfortunately, the pay-off to both of these questions wasn't great.
Michael became, rightfully so, obsessed with getting his son back, and made many stupid decisions in the process. It's clearly understandable he wants to save his son, but at every turn Michael makes the worst choice imaginable. The hatch, meanwhile, became an interesting part of the lore of the series, but is also responsible for many meandering episodes. Pushing that button was fine for a few episodes, but an entire season was just way too much.
7. The Sopranos - "Made In America"
Technically it might be cheating to include this one, but the series finale of The Sopranos is for sure one of the greatest TV cliffhangers of all time. Incidentally, it also has one of the worst pay-offs ever. The reason? There simply is no pay-off.
All fans got after watching close to 90 episodes was a cut to black at the worst time imaginable. It's quite stunning that The Sopranos even got away with this. Imagine if Breaking Bad would end three episodes earlier than it did? People would riot in the streets.
No one will ever truly know if Tony and his family made it out alive of the diner after the bell rang as someone entered. Tony looked up, almost as if he recognized who came in, but watchers will never know who that person was. It's both brilliant and infuriating at the same time.
Did The Sopranos get a happy ending, or is that diner overflowing with blood? No one knows, and while that might be an amazing twist, it's also an awful pay-off that we'll never get an answer to.
6. True Detective - "Night Finds You"
Everyone remembers the outstanding first season of True Detective, so when the second season rolled around, people were excited. A new story with a brand new cast was a tantalizing prospect. The first episode wasn't fantastic, but there was no real reason to worry. Then the second episode delivered shock and awe with a fantastic cliffhanger as Colin Farrell's character Velcoro took not one, but two shotgun rounds to the chest.
People wondered if the writers really just killed off one of the main faces of Season Two in the second episode. It was a bold move and yet also worrisome. Velcoro had been, up to that point, the most complex character of True Detective's second season. Would they really kill off their ace in the hole? The answer is no.
One week later, it was revealed that Velcoro got shot with rubber-pelleted riot control rounds. Instead of raising the stakes, True Detective lost many of its fans right then and there. The fake-out left many upset and unwilling to stick around for the rest of the season.
5. Money Heist - "Whoever Keeps Trying It, Gets It"
Faking out your audience is never a good thing, yet many shows get away with it anyway. La Casa De Papel (also known as Money Heist) is guilty for this sin as well, particularly with the mid-season finale of its first season. The ninth episode of this Spanish hit series delivers on all fronts thanks to some great storytelling and fantastic action.
The Professor and his band of bank robbers are starting to break under the pressure as the police are closing in. Arturo, one of the hostages, manages to break out some of his co-workers. In the process, he fatally wounds Oslo, marking him as the first one of the group to die. However, this isn't were the episode ends.
This all comes to ahead with Raquel finding the villa where the bank robbers planned the entire robbery. Fast forward one episode, and viewers get the reveal that the villa has been part of the plan all along. It's a good twist for some, while it lessens the tension for others. If you make it look like The Professor is unbeatable, you can't expect people to believe things might go sideways.
4. Arrow - "Lian Yu"
Arrow has had many ups and downs over its eight-season run. One of the highest highs came with the excellent Season Five finale. Adrian Chase and Oliver's conflict reaches its boiling point in the best way imaginable. The Emerald Archer is forced to take his entire crew (including past enemies) to Lian Yu, the godforsaken island he escaped from five years prior, to face Chase and save his son William.
In the end, Chase beats Oliver by shooting himself. Committing suicide caused Lian Yu to blow up while Oliver's friends (and William's mother) were still on the island. The episode ends with Oliver and his son watching in horror as the fate of many remained up in the air. For an entire summer, people speculated who would survive the carnage.
When all was said and done, the explosion didn't amount to anything substantial. Every main character on the show seemed to be wearing plot armor thicker than that of Jon Snow after he got murdered. The only impactful death was William's mother dying, and that was only to make sure the show could start a new storyline with Green Arrow being a full-time father. Overall, it was just really dissapointing.
3. Game Of Thrones - "Mother's Mercy"
While Game of Thrones' fifth season isn't one of the series' finer seasons, there is no denying the finale made fans remember what made the show so fantastic. Plot twists are par for the course in Game of Thrones, so when Jon Snow gets brutally murdered by his sworn brothers (including that little bastard Ollie!) it came as quite a surprise.
Although many people theorized that Jon would come back in one way or another, there was no certainty to this. Jump forward to Season Six, and Game of Thrones eventually brought Jon back to life, with fans happy to see him return.
Looking back now that the show is done, many agree that Jon got the raw end of the deal by being exiled for saving the Seven Kingdoms and becoming a Wildling. Why would you bring such a beloved character back if this is where you're going to end his story? It's still baffling that's the way Jon's story ends, while stone-faced Bran gets to sit on the uncomfortable chair of swords.
2. The Walking Dead - "Last Day On Earth"
Yep, that's right. The Walking Dead gets the (dis)honor of making this list twice thanks to that godawful Negan storyline.
As the show dragged on some of its worst writing to date for more than two seasons, it's being quite generous to only give the show two spots on this list. The worst offender comes with Last Day on Earth, the season six finale. It's the episode where Jeffrey Dean Morgan is officially introduced as Negan.
Negan makes a spectacular entrance by capturing Rick and his gang in a torturous game of cat and mouse. Morgan's character soon shows everyone who's boss, and to top it all he decides to bash in someone's brain. It made for a spectacular season finale, even though many were pissed off by the fact that the show explicitly decided to keep viewers hanging, as no one got to see who took a bat to the head.
In the end, the showrunners got what they wanted as people showed up in record numbers to watch the Season Seven premiere. However, when the bloody premiere was over, so were many fans.
People showed up to see who got killed, and as soon as they saw, they'd seen enough and quit the show. Over the course of the Saviors arc, many more would similarly drop off due to the story being stretched out way too much.
1. How I Met Your Mother - "Something New"
After 184 episodes fans of How I Met Your Mother, fans finally got the reveal they'd been waiting eight years for, as the mother was officially revealed at the very end of Something New, the season eight finale.
Fans were left with the tantalizing prospect that Ted would finally meet the mother of his children at Barney and Robin's wedding. Naturally, people were excited to see how they'd meet.
What fans didn't expect was a ninth season that stretches out a single weekend over the course of 24 episodes. In the end, the final season was disappointing overall, although a few standout episodes do rank among the best of the series.
Unfortunately, the finale, for many, isn't one of them, as it controversially killed off the Mother so that Ted could get back together with Robin.
How could they possibly kill off the character the show had been working towards introducing for eight years? Outrage followed, and an alternative ending was made to redeem the godawful original ending. It's undoubtedly the worst cliffhanger pay-off in TV history.