10 Greatest TV Pilot Episodes of All Time

It is funny the power a TV pilot can have on the audience. I have watched many shows all the way through to the end based on the strength of a pilot alone. In fact, when researching for this list, it surprised me to find that most of my favorite all time television series' pilots were actually not all that wonderful. To any one out there who has read any of my other posts, my love of Whedon and Buffy the Vampire Slayer is quite apparent, and one of these days I will try to stop talking about it, but even I was surprised to find that Buffy doesn't make it onto this list. In fact, though I loved all of Whedon's shows, only one makes it here. Some amazing shows have pretty weak pilot episodes. Joss Whedon's Dollhouse wasn't all that terrific, I wasn't completely hooked at first even with shows such as Homeland, Dexter, The Walking Dead and The Newsroom... these pilots were alright, but it took me at least a couple more episodes until I got more into the groove of the shows. The following pilots hooked me pretty much immediately, and though with a couple of these examples the shows didn't turn out to be all that great, the pilots will at least live on in our memories forever, especially considering the lack of any amazing new show pilot from this years new fall shows... Click "next" below to start the list...

10. American Horror Story "Pilot"

I bet most of you have never watched this show, and I will admit that this pilot just made it onto the list, however watching this was a breath of fresh, macabre air. The pilot hooked me immediately and made me want to see so much more, even though I found the later half of the season somewhat uneven, rushed, and not all that inventive, but I love the show and I will watch season 2 because there really is nothing of this genre currently on TV. This was, along with Homeland, my favorite new show of last year. The episode focuses on the Harmon family made up of the somewhat veteran actors Dylan McDermott, Connie Briton and their daughter, the fantastic newcomer Taissa Farmiga who move to Los Angeles after Connie's characters husband played by Dylan McDermott has an affair with a younger woman. Little do they know however that the house they are moving into is known by the neighbors as the "Murder House" and every resident (almost) who has lived in the house for the last 100 years or so has been killed in gruesome ways as the house is haunted by every person who ever died in its walls (and there are a lot). This episode starts off in the past as we are presented immediately with the central character on the show, the house itself, and witness it do its work on two young twin boys. Though I don't get scared easily at all, and this series didn't scare me in the slightest, it is so much more than a show for horror fans, and adds a lot of variety and surrealism to an otherwise samey line up of shows on TV. There is nothing else like this on TV, and the pilot shows enough promise and excitement to keep you hooked through the ups and downs of the rest of the episodes.

9. Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip "Pilot"

Despite being somewhat of a fan of Aaron Sorkin, he does seem to somewhat struggle with writing for TV. Don't get me wrong, he is better than most people, but there is always something a little off about most of his shows with perhaps the exception of The West Wing. Studio 60 was only one season long, and the entire show was watchable and kind of good, but it was never better than in its pilot, and this is why it is included here. The pilot was immediately engaging and allowed us into a world rarely seen on a television show; backstage on a live sketch show which was pretty much the fictional version of Saturday Night Live. The show took a lot of slack for not really being very funny, and having sketches performed on the fictional show that were just not very funny. I agree that the sketches weren't at all good, and the show wasn't much funnier either, but if you have seen Saturday Night Live recently (or ever) most of the sketches on that show are shocking at best (with the occasional stand out) so at least it was realistic. Regardless of this, the pilot drew me in, and was enough to make me watch the entire season, although I didn't enjoy an episode as much since. Some say it is like 30 Rock but worse, and that probably ended up being true, but if you just watch the pilot to Studio 60, you'd think otherwise (plus, 30 Rocks pilot isn't very good). This was Matthew Perry's best role on TV since friends, and arguably his best dramatic role of all time, and the supporting cast were extremely likable in the beginning... Amanda Peet has never been better and nor has Sarah Paulson as the lovable, modern Christian actress. The entire pilot is pretty much a homage to Sidney Lumet's "Network", opening with a similar rant by the great Judd Hirsch on everything that is wrong with modern television. The episode also won Emmy's and other prestigious awards. It's a shame the rest of the show never lived up to this promise.

8. Desperate Housewives "Pilot"

For all those that are at this point thinking this list is going to be full of rubbish TV shows, wait, I promise it gets a lot better. I actually watched every episode of this show, and the reason for this is because the show had a truly stellar first (and arguably second) season. However, in retrospect, the show started to dramatically go down hill from the end of season 2, until it was pretty appalling by its finish. If I wasn't a completest I would have probably given up around season 5, but there were a few good episodes past this season and a lot of funny lines. Plus, if I am being completely honest, I do really like the four leading ladies on the show, and they were always better than the material they were given. Regardless of what the show became, the pilot was probably the shows greatest episode, and boy did it hook you in. Opening with a Stepford Wife-ish looking woman committing suicide in what you'd think was a pretty average suburban neighborhood, and ends with four women finding out that the woman was blackmailed for keeping a dark secret by someone likely in the street, finding a note that read "I know what you did. It makes me sick. I'm going to tell". Perhaps a pretty easy way to hook in an audience, but the pay off of this secret is actually pretty darn good, as is the rest of the first season. If you never watched the show because you either thought it was too "made-for-middle aged women" or you were just more into your dark dramas, this show could actually get surprisingly dark at times, and the first season is one of the greatest murder mystery type stories ever told on television. Plus, this episode was universally loved by critics, and won three Emmy awards and a Directors Guild of America award... so at least at first it was a pretty good show.

7. Fringe "Pilot"

I know a few people who really weren't all that impressed with this pilot and never watched the show because of it, but I am certainly not one of those people. Critics also had mixed reviews- some found it lackluster while others found it to be extraordinarily well made. I think it was action/ sci-fi television at its best. I am not a huge fan of J J Abrams (who co-created this series and co-wrote this episode) for reasons that I won't go into on here in all that much detail- let's just say he doesn't end his shows all that well, or for that matter his films- but credit where credits due... this man knows who to make a fantastic pilot episode. He features not only once more on this list but twice. The almost feature length Fringe pilot (80 minutes of epic) starts off irresistibly with a chemical release on an airplane that strangely turns everyones flesh to crystal and just gets weirder from then in. The episode features strange scientific experiments (kind of the whole point of the show), explosions and main character deaths. It promises to be the new X-Files and pretty much delivers on this promise for a good couple of seasons before the show- like most of J J Abrams shows start to become too weird for their own good. In fact, the show has had so many story changes (fake Olivia used to be pregnant... now she isn't) and many alternative futures that I can hardly remember all that much detail because there really is so much going on. The one thing I do remember through all the mess (not necessarily bad mess mind you) is that Fringes pilot was almost as exciting as a feature length film and just the right amount of weird to keep me entertained, especially considering that I am a huge fan of weird, as perfectly demonstrated by my love of the next pilot episode on this list...


6. Twin Peaks "Northwest Passage"

Twin Peaks was a brilliant TV show that I strongly recommend you watch all of if you have yet to do so. I have to admit, I am not at all a fan of David Lynch's movies, but this show was almost perfection for me. The episode, which is another feature length pilot, introduces us to the surreal small town of Twin Peaks... how surreal the town is is not explored in too great a detail in the pilot, but from the weird characters and eerie music, we get a good enough vibe early on. The episode opens when the body of the most people teenage girl in the entire town is found dead on a riverbank wrapped in plastic, and the following episode pretty much explores every important town members reaction to this horrific murder. Murder or death is an extremely common thing to include in a pilot- in fact, I can't think of that many shows that don't start with one of these two things (only 2 shows on this list do not) but Twin Peaks does this better than all the others. If you are looking for a really great murder mystery/weird surreal horror, you wont find a better example than this. The pilot also introduces us to one of the most iconic characters in all of television history, and one of my all time favorite, FBI Agent Dale Cooper played by Kyle MacLachlan in his best role yet. FBI Agent Dale Cooper was exploring weird supernatural events a good three years before Mulder and Scully were. If you were too young to watch this show in its original run then get the box set like me (or get Netflix) and prepare to be weirded out in the best way imaginable. Like I said previously, I do not get scared easily by films or television, but I can honestly say I have never, ever, ever, been more frightened by anything on TV or Film than I was whilst watching this show. In fact, even typing this sentence whilst remembering the shows terrifying moments is creeping me out just a little. For any one who has seen the show, is there a scarier moment ever than when Bob creepily climbs over the couch and slowly walks towards the camera grinning? I don't think so.

5. Firefly "Serenity"

Here it is, Joss Whedon's one and only inclusion on this list, in an episode he directed and wrote himself, which was also feature length. Not to be mistaken by the actual feature film released some years later with the same title as this pilot episode... they are entirely different stories, although both fantastic pieces of entertainment. Shockingly, Fox (who should never ever be fully forgiven for what they did to this wonderful show) found this episode to be too weak as a TV pilot and instead aired the episode after before this one, only airing this episode after the series had finished on TV. I think the executives at Fox simply didn't understand the genius and potential appeal this show had, and never gave it a chance to succeed. I for one, despite being a Whedon fan since I watched my very first Buffy the Vampire Slayer episode at about age 9, didn't watch this wonderful show until I was 18 (2008, 6 years after it aired). Despite hearing great things about the series, I was unsure I would actually enjoy it, and was actually pretty worried I would find it terrible like I do with a lot of TV series' set in a spaceship in space (I won't say which shows because I don't want to anger anyone but know it is pretty much everyone other than this). Luckily, this first episode was ridiculously good, and I could breathe easy... Joss Whedon was even more of a genius than I thought. For those that don't know, the show features a group of rebel survivors who lost in the Battle of Serenity Valley during the Unification War (this is set way in the future) who now make a living for themselves as space cowboys as they fly around space in their Firefly-class spaceship named Serenity, taking jobs which involve petty crimes. They pick up a mysterious, mentally damaged young woman named River who has many secrets which only make the lives of the crew members more difficult than they ever were. But seriously, if you haven't seen this show, go watch it... it is only 14 episodes long and it's pretty much better than anything else on TV at the moment.


4. Breaking Bad "Pilot"

Breaking Bad is probably (probably) my favorite show currently on TV and definitely one of my all time favorite shows, and the pilot episode was incredible. The reason this isn't higher on this list, despite arguably being the best show on this list is that whilst the pilot was thrilling, it isn't Breaking Bads greatest episode, and at this point we didn't really know Walter White all that well. The show is interesting because Walter is such a complex character, and the more complex he gets, the better the show gets. Season 1 was probably the weakest in its run, with every season after just getting better and better. Season 1, despite being the worst season, is still one of the greatest television series of all time. Breaking Bad's Pilot chews threw so much story in so little time. You forget how much really happens in this episode and how quickly, though convincingly Walter Whites character changes in such a short amount of time. In this pilot, Walter goes from being a 50 year old chemistry teacher who is living the definition of a mundane life to meth cook who kills a guy. All this in just the first episode... it is extraordinary that the writers managed to make such a sudden character transformation seem so seamless as this. The episode begins with Walter driving his RV with his assistant Jesse with him, through the desert, with two apparently dead bodies in the back of his van. At first the audience (at least I did) thinks that this must be a scene from the end of Season 1, but in fact this crazy cool scene happens again before the episodes end. It is impossible not to watch this episode and not be immediately hooked from then on. Truly edge of your seat drama with a great deal of thrilling action thrown in for good measure. This is a must watch. One of the greatest episodes in TV history.

3. Glee "Pilot"

I love this series OK. I wish I would stop having to apologize for this fact. It really is a lot better than it gets credit for being. I bet a lot of Breaking Bad fans are pissed that this episode beats Breaking Bad's but hear me out... Breaking Bad is a drama, and though the show has a fantastic concept, it is fairly conventional. It is very common to start an episode with a slight flashfoward, and many pilot episodes like I mentioned earlier include murder or death of some kind. Including a death or a murder to hook your audience in can be very exciting, but it is also arguably lazy and obvious, and not all that difficult to think of. Glee however doesn't use a death as a starting point, so gets props for that. It also isn't a drama, so has a more difficult task in hooking an audience. It isn't broody or dark, and in this current generation, dark is almost automatically considered better than anything else. And finally it is a musical, so is completely unique to all TV shows (well, at that point anyway) on air. Not conventional in the slightest in this respect. Unarguably, it had a much more difficult task than Breaking Bad, and considering in was on Fox and not Cable, it really needed the viewers or it would have been canceled immediately. Critically, this episode was a phenomenal success, more than anyone could have ever imagined. This was the biggest hit TV show of that year, and certainly the most talked about new show on the air at that time. The pilot episode is considered one of Glee's best episodes ever and is even pretty much loved by people who hate Glee and went off the show after Season 1. In fact, I bet most of you have seen this episode, right? Anyway, the pilot episode was nominated that year for two Emmy awards, pretty much the only two awards one episode could be nominated for... writing and directing- and Ryan Murphy, the shows creator won the award for directing for this episode. The shows first season also won Best Comedy Series at the Golden Globes (also winning again the next year).

2. Lost "Pilot"

First of all know that I used to be a massive fan of Lost. In fact, up until Season 4 I considered it my second favorite show of all time, and up until the end I would have probably included it in my top 10 shows of all time. Now I despise it... I wouldn't recommend it to anyone and I am actually still angry with what the writers got away with. They promised us answers to their ridiculous mysteries from the beginning then when they actually couldn't think of any, they told us that is was all about the characters and that we shouldn't be watching a sci-fi series for plot, when in fact that is kind of the whole point of the science fiction genre. Anyway, despite all this, Lost's pilot was epic, and it was because of the strength of this pilot that I watched every episode after this, despite the dramatic lack of quality in seasons 4, 5 and 6. Had this show ended strongly, perhaps this pilot would have taken the top spot, but because the show failed to give any real answers to Lost's many many dangling plot-lines, this kind of makes everything that happen in the pilot seem somewhat irrelevant, and had I known then how the series was going to end, I would have turned off the television before getting hooked into the ridiculousness of the show. Still, J J Abrams is the master at hooking in an audience, and is the master at creating a great TV pilot episode- there is no one greater at it on TV, and he directed and co-wrote this thrilling example. Opening the show with a devastating plane crash that brutally kills many people within the first couple of minutes is pure genius, and then confusing the hell out of people from then on by showing an island full of mysteries including the weirdest thing of all, an angry polar bear, just added to this greatness. I know a lot of people were put off of this episode because of that polar bear, and from then in gave up on the show ( I wish I was one of you) but I had faith (stupid faith) that there would be a really, really good explanation for all of this (there wasn't). I remember watching the show and not really knowing what to expect. I had no idea before I started that the island was going to be "supernatural" and thought it was simply about a group of survivors stuck on an island similar to the movie Castaway. Though in retrospect I wish it had been more simple, the weird surprises the show had up it's sleeve in every episode felt like pure television gold at the time. J J Abrams also won the Emmy for directing this episode, and he certainly deserved to win.

1. Alias "Truth Be Told"

This feels right to me being placed at number one. I came to this show pretty late, getting all the box sets about 3 years ago. I was at first unsure whether or not I'd like the show but I can honestly say I have never been more entertained by a pilot episode in my life. It was actually shockingly good- exactly what i wanted from a television series at the time. Edge of your seat, jaw dropping action with a phenomenal cast and truly intriguing concept and set up. This is Alias's best episode ever and Alias had many great ones. Though I will admit the series, like all of Abrams' get worse and worse from season 2 onwards (in fact, like most TV shows in general), and the shows mythology (again like all of Abrams') kind of makes absolutely no sense, I find it to be an overall more exciting TV series than Lost, and it certainly makes more sense. J J Abrams wrote and directed this 70 minute episode which shows Sydney Bristow (played by Jennifer Garner in her best role ever) finding out that the intelligence agency she is working for, SD-6, is actually not part of the CIA like she has been told it is, and is actually an illegal, ruthless and murderous organization, after SD-6 brutally kill her fiancee. She also finds out her father, who also works for SD-6 is a mole within the company, working for the CIA. Sydney, shocked and devastated by this information and by the loss of her fiancee, is recruited by the CIA to also work undercover for them within this dangerous organization. Sounds great and it really really really is great. This single episode is one of the most thrilling things I have ever watched in my life, and when I think of great TV pilots, this one is always the first one that comes to mind. How about you? Have I missed your favorite TV pilot from this list? Are any of my choices unbelievably stupid? Sound off in the comments section below... I really am interested to hear your suggestions, if only to give me more things to watch...

In this post: 
Lost
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

I am a recent Screenwriting for Film and Television graduate from the UK. I am an unashamed geek who loves everything Marvel, and anything Joss Whedon has ever touched (except for maybe Alien Resurrection and Titan A.E). My current favorite TV shows are Breaking Bad, Family Guy, House of Cards, Game of Thrones, American Horror Story, Homeland and Glee. I look forward to debating things with all of you in the future. (As of January 2013 I have had over 1 million views since joining WhatCulture in September 2012. You can reach me at danieljamesbowen@hotmail.co.uk)