10 Least Interesting Romances In Otherwise Great TV Shows
Oh yeah, remember when Troy and Britta dated?
Are there any shows that completely lack examples of forced romance? Especially among long running sitcoms, it's surprisingly hard to think of too many. When a series has been on for years, too often the writers feel the need to pair up every single character together, as there apparently can't be any group of friends that don't date one another.
Of course, it's not like romance is inherently a bad thing in TV shows, but the best couples in television history were set up slowly and naturally over time. Jim and Pam, Ross and Rachel, and Leslie and Ben were all relationships that the series built up over the course of many seasons so that viewers were rooting for them by the end.
But writers don't always have that much patience, and far too often characters will get together for seemingly no reason other than that the script tells them to. In all 10 of these cases, a relationship occurs just because two people are attractive adults that share the same physical space, not because it's been made clear that something is drawing them together.
With that in mind, let's take a look at the 10 least interesting romances in great TV shows.
10. Andy And Erin (The Office)
The writers of The Office ran into a huge problem after Jim and Pam finally got together. Their romance was the heart of the series, and having them start dating in Season 4 was a good decision in terms of not stretching the storyline out, but where does the show go from there?
Jim and Pam became increasingly less interesting as time went on and they evolved from the flirty young kids into the boring married couple, so the writers tried to launch a new relationship: Andy and Erin. Erin was introduced as the new secretary in Season 5, and it soon became clear that Andy had feelings for her, another classic story of a salesman falling in love with the receptionist.
Except these two were just not nearly as interesting as Jim and Pam, as much as the writers attempted to force them down viewers' throats. They tried their best with Andy's grand romantic gestures for Erin, like driving all the way down to Florida for her or trying (and failing) to get her an amazing Christmas gift. But eventually, after all that effort, the writers apparently just gave up, and so the series ends with Andy becoming more and more of a douche and Erin suddenly getting with the new salesman. Romance of the century, huh?
9. Troy And Britta (Community)
Remember when Troy and Britta dated? If you’ve forgotten, it’s hard to blame you, as this was a relationship introduced and then quickly abandoned because it was just profoundly uninteresting from start to finish.
Community for the most part was always able to avoid the forced sitcom romances. There was the main love triangle between Jeff, Britta and Annie, but other than that, the writers never felt the need to pair the entire study group together. When the characters dated, their partners were usually people from outside the group.
And then this happened: in early Season 4, Britta and Troy started going out for some reason. It’s not that they were an obviously terrible couple, but they just didn’t have much in the way of chemistry, and little to no effort was put into making the audience care about them. It felt like one of those romances that only existed because these were both attractive people who are on the same show, not because they have anything at all in common.
Troy and Britta officially began their relationship in Season 4 Episode 1, and they were broken up by Episode 11 in a really bizarre episode where Troy pretends to have swapped bodies with Abed. The fact that they once dated is almost never referenced again, so this is yet another victim of the “gas leak” season.
8. Ann and Tom (Parks And Recreation)
Parks and Recreation almost always handled relationships in the absolute perfect way. The show started out a little rocky with boring romances between Andy and Ann and Leslie and Mark, but it quickly moved on to the much more interesting pairings of Leslie and Ben and Andy and April, two of the best sitcom couples of all time.
Both of these relationships developed naturally throughout the series, especially with April and Andy. That felt like a romance that the writers just stumbled into and slowly discovered worked, much like a real life relationship. It wasn’t the show forcing a romance out of nothing.
But then there was this pointless relationship between Tom and Ann in the middle of the show that went nowhere at all. Many of the Parks department people did end up pairing off together as in your typical sitcom, but most of the couples at least felt earned. Not this one. It was forced, boring, and the two had absolutely no chemistry.
One could argue that this was kind of the point, and eventually a lot of humor was mined out of Tom's repeated and failed attempts at wooing Ann, but it just because tiring after a while. Thank goodness the writers quickly realized that and let this one go.
7. Jake And Amy (Brooklyn Nine-Nine)
Brooklyn Nine-Nine is definitely one of the funniest sitcoms on television right now, and for the most part it’s able to avoid the standard sitcom tropes to just deliver non-stop laughs. So that’s why it’s so frustrating that far too many episodes are centered around yet another will they/won’t they relationship that has been done a million times before far more effectively.
The Jake and Amy story is every sitcom romance ever, with the writers constantly teasing that they could be together but then it doesn’t happen over and over. Jake likes Amy, but she’s in a relationship! Now Amy likes Jake, but uh oh, now he’s dating someone! It’s another Jim and Pam situation, but in this case the writers have not really proven that Jake and Amy are even a particularly interesting pair. They’re two attractive people of the opposite sex who work together, and that's supposed to be enough.
Usually Brooklyn Nine-Nine doesn’t get bogged down with romance, and it actually did something really interesting with Gina and Boyle in Season 2 which strayed from the typical sitcom mold. But Jake and Amy are such a trite pairing that leads to some incredibly tedious scenes throughout the series, and it really feels like something that’s beneath these incredibly talented writers.
6. Sayid And Shannon (Lost)
There are a bunch of truly incredible and affecting romances throughout Lost: Charlie and Claire, Desmond and Penny, Jack and Kate, and Jin and Sun to name a few. Shannon and Sayid does not measure up to those.
The two were introduced as a couple towards the end of the first season, becoming close when Sayid asks Shannon to help translate some of Rousseau’s writing, as all great romances start. They’re especially bonded together after Boone’s death when Shannon turns to Sayid for support.
They aren’t a horribly mismatched couple, and they do have a few sweet moments together. But while most romances in the show felt like the writers were taking their time with them, like the beautiful Charlie and Claire relationship which slowly percolates over the course of several seasons, this one is just far too rushed, especially considering Sayid was dedicating his entire life to tracking down Nadia, the love of his life, just a few weeks prior.
Particularly jarring for a lot of fans was the fact that during the series finale, Sayid ended up with Shannon in the afterlife rather than Nadia. This girl he spent a few weeks with on the island was more important to him than the woman he loved more than anything and searched for for years?
5. Hannibal And Alana (Hannibal)
Alana Bloom is an excellent character on Hannibal, a smart and interesting colleague to Will who becomes something of a love interest for him. So that’s why it was so bizarre when in Season 2, she suddenly and randomly falls for Hannibal and begins dating him out of basically nowhere.
Their relationship is apparently sparked partially by Alana feeling betrayed by Will, moving to Hannibal for emotional support. Will is locked up and tries to have Hannibal killed, so Alana feels betrayed and ends up in a relationship with Hannibal as a reaction to that. On paper that kind of makes sense, but in the show it seems to come totally out of left field, and this truly interesting character for the rest of the season basically just lies in Hannibal’s bed every episode.
It also becomes incredibly frustrating how obvious it is that Hannibal is manipulating Alana but how she somehow can’t see it even though she's a pretty smart person. Though that frustration is arguably how the audience is intended to react, it just comes across as far too sudden of a shift and definitely could have been built up more effectively.
4. Larry And Polly (Orange Is The New Black)
When it was announced that Larry and Polly wouldn’t be in Season 3 of Orange Is The New Black, fans everywhere let out a sigh of a relief. That’s how boring this plot line was.
At the beginning of Season 1, Piper has to leave her fiancé Larry when she’s sent to prison. The series spends a decent amount of time with him throughout the first season, and it makes some degree of sense to follow up on how he’s reacting to Piper being gone for so long.
But the more time Piper spends in jail, the less relevant Larry is, especially as Piper herself becomes less of the main character as the series progresses. But they already hired Jason Biggs, so in Season 2, the writers figured they had to give him something to do. His storyline involves him breaking up with Piper and dating her best friend Polly. Ugh.
It's really poorly set up and the two are terrible together, but even if they weren't, this plot just feels like such a profound waste of time. The audience at this point is completely invested in Litchfield and all of the characters in it, so cutting away to this awful, boring romance between two horrible people just makes any sane person want to skip right ahead to the next scene.
3. Jim And Maggie (The Newsroom)
A lot of elements of The Newsroom felt like Aaron Sorkin consciously attempting to recreate The West Wing's success, and Jim and Maggie were like the poor man's Josh and Donna. While that relationship was sweet and endearing, Jim and Maggie’s only made both characters more annoying.
Part of this is probably due The Newsroom only getting 25 episodes total compared to The West Wing’s 156, so Sorkin simply didn’t have the time to allow this romance to naturally develop over the course of many episodes.
But even from the beginning, Sorkin never really convinced viewers that these two would be a good couple, and it becomes increasingly unclear why you should be rooting for them. Maggie is constantly screwing up and Jim is constantly saving her in the most smug way possible like he’s her knight in shining armor, and that becomes really tiresome. It’s another will they/won’t they built upon childish arguments, misunderstandings, hiding things from one another, and comically poor timing.
In the end, Maggie moves away because of a job that she apparently wouldn't have gotten without Jim, so once again her career is entirely reliant on how amazing and gallant he is, and the two begin a long distance relationship that you have no reason to think will be any good for either of them.
2. Mrs. Krabappel And Ned Flanders (The Simpsons)
If you stopped watching The Simpsons years ago like most sane people, you missed out on this pretty dumb romance which happened for seemingly no reason other than the writers got bored.
In the season finale of Season 22, Edna Krabappel is suspended after she slaps Bart. She’s leaving the building via a ladder which collapses, but luckily Ned Flanders happens to be there and he saves her. They immediately start dating. Ned finds out about Edna’s dating history and gets upset, but then Edna is upset with Ned because he was upset, and it’s a whole bunch of dumb back and forth for the whole episode.
But while most relationships like this would just be a one episode deal, the writers actually decided to let viewers vote on whether they wanted Ned and Edna to remain a couple. Yes, in the last scene of the episode, Homer and Marge break the fourth wall and tell fans to go online and vote. Because apparently some people want to watch the world burn, the results came out in favor of the two remaining a couple, and they were married until Edna’s death in Season 25.
It was a pretty badly set up relationship, and having viewers actually decide the fate of it was one of the clearest examples of the show having completely run out of steam.
1. Ted And Robin (How I Met Your Mother)
Here’s a bizarre example where the couple that turned out to be the crux of the entire show was one that fans were actively rooting against.
How I Met Your Mother begins in a really refreshing way by setting up a relationship between Ted and Robin, and then assuring viewers that they don't end up together. This won't be your typical story of a guy seeing the love of his life from across a crowded bar and then chasing after her for years.
Except the series turned out to be exactly that. Ted and Robin date in Season 2 before realizing they’re fundamentally different people and not right for each other. They break up, and then Ted spends the rest of eternity trying to get back with Robin and refusing to move on. Every episode that once again revolved around Ted trying to get Robin back just prompted a collective sigh among the audience.
But that would be okay if this was a story about a guy who has to get over a girl who isn’t right for him (Robin) in order to move on to the girl that is right for him (Tracy). Except no, in the final episode, it turns out that everything with the mother was just a waste of time until Ted could go crawling back to this decade old, failed relationship.