10 Most Memorable Talent Show Judges

Talent shows are consistently the most viewed productions on television today. Whether you are an avid fan or would rather put pins in your eyes, chances are you have heard of a few of these judging personalities. Part of the generic formula of talent shows include the phone voting and the back story of the contestants in the show. But in recent years, those celebrities who sit on the judging panel are more so a draw card for viewers than ever before. Some people tune into X Factor for that suspense building moment when the doors open with Nicole and Sharon revealing what frock they're rocking. Some might watch Strictly online and skip to the judges comments and scores, because that is where the real fire and excitement is. Well, except for Bruce's one-liners of course! So with all of this in mind here are my top 10 most memorable talent show judges ever.

10. Paula Abdul

Paula Abdul is a serial talent show judge, having appeared on American Idol, Got To Dance, X Factor USA and also had a small guest stint on X Factor UK. She is an accomplished dancer and singer, having famously appeared in a music video with a singing animated cat. But, Paula was also one of the first to realise the career potential of appearing on a national television show twice week. Joining American Idol when it debuted in 2002, Paula became an iconic part of American pop culture and equally a driving force in the success of the show. In addition, it elevated her from a forgotten 1980s pop star to once again a household name right across America and in fact the world. Paula will never be remembered as the most eloquent judge or the most knowledgeable. She is undeniably caring and brought necessary heart to Idol...but she also displayed some questionable behaviour while on the show. She is absolutely cooky and was often accused of appearing drunk and/or high while filming for Idol. It became a running joke for media pundits especially during the live shows, when Paula would either shine or fumble completely. Just check this video out below when she becomes totally tangled: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wUJMP2S9SMk Paula will continue her judging career in 2014 by joining the panel of So You Think You Can Dance Australia, allowing another nation of fans to enjoy her obscure behaviour. She has the credentials for every role she has taken thus far, it's just shame people will recall her shortcomings before her career experiences.

9. Mary Murphy

Viewers outside of the US might be unfamiliar with this fire cracker of a judge, but you should definitely enjoy just a fraction of Mary Murphy's history. She appears on the US version of So You Think You Can Dance and is a ballroom dancer and choreographer - putting her in good stead for her role on SYTYCD. Like every good judge, Mary fills the kind maternal archetype. She sits between two male counterparts and offers a far more gentle way of delivering feedback to dancers on the show. But so many female judges fill this role around the world right? What makes her so special? Well Mary has cracked the personality gimmick trick wide-open and has mastered a unique way to stand out in the crowded talent show world. Her signature? Well she is known for screaming incredibly loud and enthusiastically at contestants when she is impressed with a dance. One of her more dominant go-to's is when she refers to the dancers as hot tamales. But when a contestant performs an outstanding number, Mary takes things to a new level and declares they are on the "hot tamale train" - much to Nigel Lythgoes disapproval. It is high energy and over the top that lifts a live studio audience and also motivates other contestants to achieve the same. She has been on every season so far except one and looks set to hold her seat for years to come. Watch Mary listen for the 'train' below: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=grDZzM1-LF8

8. Bruno Tonioli

Bruno Tonioli (above, far right) is known and loved in the UK and America for his infectious personality on the panels of Strictly Come Dancing & Dancing With The Stars. He is one of the most outrageous personalities on television today and will continue to do so - appearing on 3 seasons a year. Bruno's aura can definitely be linked to his Italian roots, but his career highs have all been in the dance world internationally. He has worked professionally as a choreographer for MEGA stars like Sir Elton John, Tina Turner and Freddie Mercury among others. Look closely and you'll see Bruno working it in Elton's "I'm Still Standing" music video. So when the BBC created Strictly Come Dancing for it's flagship channel and launched the show overseas soon after, Bruno was perfect. He had the relative experience which made him a top choice, but what they got was truly lasting entertainment. He is the most animated, energetic and unpredictable judge that I've ever seen. It is rare to see him actually sat at his desk, instead preferring to throw around his body in complete euphoria when delivering critique. He is often told off for giving long winded feedback by the hosts, but that adds the fun of the show. Poor Len Goodman, his co-judge on both shows, is often caught in the middle of Bruno's crazy moments - find out for yourself below: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xmFfGPylKYo

7. Tyra Banks

Tyra Banks is one incredibly successful self made woman. Forget the fact that she's a stunning model, she's also built a business empire for herself that stretches to every corner of the globe. A big part of this has been her instrumental involvement in the Top Model franchise, where she has been the head judge for an unbelievable 20 seasons. Tyra works twice as hard on her own show, because she not only judges but also hosts as well. The beauty of this show compared to others, is that it is prerecorded. Yes, I know that auditions on other talent shows are recorded too - but with Top Model there is added flexibility to re-record a segment or delivery of a line if need be. This has allowed Tyra to cultivate a dramatic persona on the show that captures her modelling expertise, but also allows her to blow off steam as well. Trust me, she brings out cray cray Tyra when she needs too. Tyra is part of the Top Model series...as in she owns a portion of every adaptation in every country. So not only is she raking it in, she has an internationally respected mogul name too. She's a boss lady that is truly a professional. Unless you take the piss out of the modelling profession or her TV show - then you'll get ANGRY Tyra. Watch below to see for yourself. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=53sOpQQWOOA

6. Jason Gardiner

Jason Gardiner is the Mr Nasty in the rink, having dished out numerous controversial comments during his time with "Dancing On Ice". The show is basically Strictly meets ice skating, but has been a strong part of ITV's early year line-up since 2006. Producers were looking to fill the judging slot that is taken by Craig Revel Horwood on Strictly - a mean but overall entertaining personality. Jason gives the harsh criticism and often scores celebrities far below his fellow panelists, which has made him shine on the show. However, some of his comments have been construed as properly offensive to contestants, that has made him a talent show judge that many love to hate. One infamous moment was when Jason described contestant Sharron Davies as 'like faecal matter that won't flush'. He received a lot of negative feedback but continued to pursue his on screen persona. He undeniably crosses the line in the ice and not everyone takes it well. Remember when Denise Welch's hubby ran onto set to give Jason a piece of mind live on air? Classic. But it isn't just the contestants that Jason take on, it is his fellow judges too. His feud with Karen Barber, on again off again judge and sometime head coach, is well documented. It's just part of the reason that he has made it this far up the list. Just check out the shade he throws her in a clip below: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Byk0jHxwf8

5. Nicole Scherzinger

Nicole Scherzinger is a true grafter, fiercely ambitious and is a heavily under-appreciated vocalist. But most British viewers will know her from the X Factor, where she brings some much needed American flair to the panel. Nicole's career started on the American version of Popstars, but she rose to prominence as the lead singer of the Pussycat Dolls. You know, don't cha wish your girlfriend was hot like . She first dipped her toe into the X Factor UK pond in 2010 when she covered for Dannii Minogue and Cheryl Cole at bootcamp. She had a noticeably subdued judging style that oozed professionalism and showcased her nurturing side - something that was carried over when she appeared on the US version. Her time on the American edition was marred by a controversial choice to send a bottom two elimination decision to deadlock, which resulted in 13 year old Rachel Crow being sent home. Scherzinger took the brunt of the blame for causing Crow's on air distress and she certainly wasn't welcomed into the hearts of viewers. Simon Cowell axed her at the end of season 1. But when Nicole was selected to become a full time judge in 2012 in Britain, no one could have expected the refreshingly hilarious catch phrases that Scherzy came out with. Nicole brought brand new life to the panel and the nation marvelled at her schamazing jajazzles. 2 words honey, win-ning. Her future on the panel is unknown, but she will always be remembered as a gorgeous eccentric made for live television. Check out her best bits below: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XwbSZbq_0N4

4. Louis Walsh

It wouldn't be the X Factor without Louis Walsh sitting on the end of the panel. He's as familiar as home cooking and essentially part of the furniture. In his ten years on the show he has won it once in 2005, but brought so many memorable moments he just couldn't not be included in this list. Louis was first on UK screens when he sat on the panel of Popstars The Rivals, that witnessed the formation of Girls Aloud way back in 2002. A personal relationship with Simon Cowell saw him join the X Factor UK panel in 2004, a position that he has held ever since. Louis was always a punching bag for Simon in the early days and had a great rapport with Sharon Osbourne throughout. However in his later years, Louis became known for putting through so called 'novelty' acts to the live shows. Gary Barlow and Kelly Rowland HATED this behaviour and sadly, we never got to see Goldie Chung make it to the live shows. He is after all responsible for Jedward, Wagner and Kitty Brucknel - all remembered for everything BUT their vocal performance. But of course, Louis loved the controversy and the fact these acts gained press coverage and votes over other contestants, was the icing on the cake. His catch phrases are well known and painfully overused, but the audience love him for it (me included). There are only so many times you Louis can say "You remind me of a young & "You're the next big boy band". Still...Saturday night with out Louis Walsh would be a sad, sad place. Relive some of his best moments below: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ewckpubYzHI

3. Nicki Minaj/Mariah Carey

A judging panel can either have harmony and mutual respect or be as a frosty as the relationship between Madonna and Lady Gaga. American Idol season 12 was pretty much like the latter, when a feud erupted between Nicki Minaj and Mariah Carey. The pair replaced Jennifer Lopez when she took time off to go on a tour. The season was star studded but immediately you could cut the tension with a knife. Mariah obviously didn't take too kindly to having another woman on the panel and that was clear even from the promos. Idol is more American than apple pie and having two divas tear each other apart was completely unappealing to family viewers and the ratings reflected that. Nicki and Mariah being put together on the same show is like throwing a cat amongst the pigeons. There is so much diva energy between them that it easily boils over. Mariah is the veteran in the industry, winning over music fans with an incredible range and fantastic hooks in her tracks. Nicki is young and fresh, killing it with her guest spots and non-conforming fashion. The spats on the panel were rooted in this divide. Mariah has commented that she was under the impression she would be the only female on the panel on the show. Nicki was invading her moment and Mariah was just defending her territory, in her eyes anyway. I feel that Nicki gave better feedback overall during that season, but as sparring partners they will be remembered for their colourful hate-hate relationship on screen. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F4TfvfQ2trU

2. Cheryl Cole

She has been named the nation's sweetheart, has had two number albums and won the X Factor twice. Cheryl Cole owes her solo career to her time on the X Factor and that is unquestionable. She paved the way for other band members to use a judging position to throttle them into the big league. We're looking at you Tulisa. Cheryl was part of the UK's biggest girl band, Girls Aloud for ten years. She was not the strongest singer, but had a the most fiery personality and unmatched dance ability in the group. This caught the eye of Simon Cowell and in 2008 she took a seat on the X Factor UK panel that changed her life forever. Immediately Cheryl struck a chord with the audience. She was unbelievably relatable, exudes compassion and was gorgeous to look at and listen to. Her critique was coming from someone who has been a contestant herself, which gave a unique perspective to the talent show world. She rocked some brilliant fashion choices during the live shows and her on air working relationship with Simon Cowell was unforgettable. Cheryl will also be remembered as a career savvy woman, who took herself from a girl-bander, to a solo artist with number 1 singles an albums. That Fight For This Love performance was iconic, as was the outfit. But I feel like Cheryl will always be known for her the special touch she had with contestants. It was very personal - the wiping away of tears, the endless hugs and as this video below shows, even lending a helping hand during auditions. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZsqWn3OIahI

1. Simon Cowell

Simon Cowell is the undisputed leader of the talent show world and is unequivocally the most memorable judge television has ever seen. Simon has been a judge on Pop Idol, American Idol, World Idol, Britain's Got Talent, X Factor UK and X Factor USA. That is a pretty impressive CV, especially when he has producer credits on three of those shows as well. Simon was the first villain on modern day talent shows. His straight talking and no nonsense approach as well as an inability to let contestants down easy, was a hit with viewers. Of course he is equally despised by those who feel he has saturated the music industry with manufactured pop. But the amount of number 1's and platinum records he has amassed over the years speak for themselves. In the beginning years of his judging career he was simply a face to deliver harsh comments. But in recent years he has become a mellowed character that is more respected, than hated. Contestants used to tear him apart in the early days, dismissing him as being rude and unreasonable. He has had water thrown him, had grandmothers telling him off and of course been egged on live television as well. Nowadays, his opinion is the only one that truly matters to contestants. They recognise his influence in the pop industry and his keen eye for creating hits. He is the father of talent shows and isn't afraid of giving truthful advice, even if it is directed to an act he is personally mentoring. With X Factor and Got Talent just renewed for another three years on ITV, we won't be seeing the last of Simon Cowell just yet. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vCb0jQOCobw

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Sometime law student with a passion for writing & a love for British pop. English blood with Aussie upbringing. An avid Tweeter and you can find me @JonoGibson