10 More TV Storylines Actors REFUSED To Do

These actors knew better than the people writing the show - or so they thought.

It's Always Sunny
FX

The whirlwind pace of TV production means that there often isn't much time for actors to experiment creatively, and that more of than not, they need to just stick to the script and get things in the can.

But sometimes a scene or storyline is objectionable enough, for one reason or another, that they just flat-out refuse to perform it, forcing the creatives to go back to the drawing board and retool the scene to their liking.

As a sequel to our recent article on the very subject, here are another 10 actors who vetoed stories, scenes, and single moments from some of the biggest TV shows of all time.

Perhaps they felt the storyline was inconsistent with the character they've spent many years playing, they simply weren't interested in performing what was written, or they had a moral objection - whether justified or not - to what was being asked of them.

Whatever the reason, these actors all told the writers to get back in a room and start redrafting, in turn coming up with something which the star found more palatable...

10. Stringer Bell Rests In P*ss - The Wire

The Wire Stringer Bell Idris Elba
HBO

Idris Elba gave a phenomenal performance as enterprising gangster Stringer Bell in The Wire, so fans were gutted to see him go when he was shot dead by Brother Mouzone (Michael Potts) and Omar Little (Michael K. Williams) in the late season three episode "Middle Ground."

But the show's creator David Simon originally had a more... involved death scene planned for String, where after being shot and killed, Omar would urinate on Bell's corpse as the final humiliation.

In a 2019 interview with The Hollywood Reporter, Elba revealed his reaction to this planned story beat: "I told [Simon] it was absolute tragedy, that it was sensational, and that it wasn't going to happen."

With Elba flat-out refusing to play a pissed-on dead body, Simon and the episode's writer, George Pelecanos, ultimately decided to rewrite the scene to remove Omar's final insult.

On one hand it certainly would've been consistent with Omar's characterisation, but on the other, you can appreciate why Elba felt it was a little much.


9. Cooper Dates Audrey - Twin Peaks

Twin Peaks Cooper Audrey
ABC

Anyone with a pair of working eyeballs could pick up on the serious sexual tension between Agent Dale Cooper (Kyle MacLachlan) and 18-year-old Audrey Horne (Sherilyn Fenn) throughout Twin Peaks, and indeed, David Lynch ultimately planned for this to bloom into a full-on romance.

But MacLachlan, who is six years older than Fenn, objected to the subplot, feeling that it would be inappropriate and out of character for Cooper, an FBI agent, to be dating a high-schooler.

Curiously, however, Fenn claims that the real reason for MacLachlan's refusal was due to his then-partner Lara Flynn Boyle, who played Donna Hayward on the show, being jealous of Fenn's prominence on the series.

Either way, the Coop-Audrey love story was resultingly axed, with Heather Graham's Annie being brought in as a new romantic interest for Coop - who, ironically, was a whole five years younger than Hayward, albeit not playing a high-schooler at least.


8. Tara Returns From The Dead - Buffy The Vampire Slayer

Buffy Tara Family
Mutant Enemy Productions

In Buffy the Vampire Slayer's season six episode "Seeing Red," fan favourite character Tara (Amber Benson) was shot and killed by Warren (Adam Busch), and as much as Joss Whedon just loves killing off his most cherished characters, in this case he initially planned for her to return.

Fans were furious with Whedon for killing Tara off - and, seemingly unintentionally, furthering the tired "Bury Your Gays" trope - enough that they demanded he finagle a supernatural means for Tara to return from the dead.

According to actress Amber Benson herself, Whedon realised that he had "made a mistake, that he had been short-sighted," and so indeed resolved to bring Tara back.

However, Benson ultimately decided against coming back for two reasons - scheduling and her lack of trust in Whedon doing the resurrection arc justice. She said in the book Into Every Generation a Slayer Is Born: How Buffy Staked Our Hearts:

"But I didn't want to come back. He really wanted me to come back and we just couldn't come to an agreement on it. And most of that was my schedule... I just didn't feel super trusting of the situation... And I felt like people had already been really hurt by this. And I'm not the writer. I can't decide what's going to happen to this character. I don't have the reins. And so between the schedule, and not really having a hundred percent trust in what was going to happen and some other things, it just didn't work out."

7. The Unnecessary Appendectomy - M*A*S*H

Mash BJ
CBS

Sometimes an actor will refuse to perform a storyline when they firmly believe in their bones that it's inconsistent with the character they've been playing for years, as was the case with M*A*S*H star Mike Farrell, who played B.J. Hunnicutt throughout the series.

The season seven episode "Preventative Medicine" revolves around a reckless Lieutenant Colonel whose battalion has sustained more casualties than any other.

Originally, it was scripted for Hawkeye (Alan Alda) and B.J. to conspire to perform an unnecessary appendectomy on the Colonel in order to keep him on the bench and save the lives of his men.

However, Farrell felt that it would've been out of character for B.J. to participate in such a plan that so flagrantly disregarded medical ethics.

Though the show's writers cited a real-life example where just such an incident occurred, Farrell dug his heels in, insisting that he knew B.J. as a character and was sure he'd never agree to such a morally dicey procedure.

And so, the episode was rewritten to have B.J. firmly protest Hawkeye's unnecessary surgery and refuse to help him.

Furthermore, the episode ends with wounded soldiers flooding their tent regardless, to which B.J. tells Hawkeye, "You treated a symptom - the disease goes merrily on."


6. The Season 3 Flash-Forward - Riverdale

Riverdale Season 3
The CW

Riverdale's third season ends with a flash-forward showing Archie (KJ Apa), Betty (Lili Reinhart), and Veronica (Camila Mendes) out in the woods covered in blood, as they shed their clothes and burn Jughead's (Cole Sprouse) beanie while agreeing to go their separate ways in order to avoid being caught.

Fans were primarily left wondering what happened to Jughead and why he wasn't in the scene, that perhaps the beanie-burning moment was meant to imply his death.

As it turned out, this was simply a result of actor Cole Sprouse refusing to strip off and shoot the scene in the cold.

At San Diego Comic-Con 2019, Sprouse's co-stars revealed that Jughead was indeed scripted to be a living, breathing part of the group, but when he refused to film it, the writers simply changed the scene to imply something untoward might've happened to him.

In co-star Apa's own words, "The only reason why that [scene] happened is 'cause Cole was cold that night."


5. Greg's Hair Turns Bright Orange - The Brady Bunch

The Brady Bunch
NBC

The Brady Bunch's season six finale, "The Hair-Brained Scheme," would ultimately turn out to be the series' last ever episode when ABC opted not to renew the legendary sitcom for season seven.

That proved rather unfortunate for actor Robert Reed, who portrayed family patriarch Mike Brady and vocally objected to the content of what would unknowingly be the series finale.

In the episode, Mike's son Greg's (Barry Williams) hair turns bright orange when he uses a non-FDA-approved bottle of hair tonic, but Reed felt the storyline was "stupid" enough that he refused to appear in it, writing memos to the show's staff and studio Paramount telling them as much.

As a result, series creator Sherwood Schwartz had Mike Brady conspicuously written out of the episode, with it being rather limply explained that he's out of town.

Hilariously, though, Reed was actually on set when the episode was being filmed regardless. According to co-star Williams, he "[hung] around the set while the episode was being shot, grumbling about its idiocy." Amazing.


4. Reese & Carter's Romance - Person Of Interest

Person of Interest Reese Carter
CBS

Since sci-fi crime drama series Person of Interest ended in 2016, various cast and crew members have spoken out about lead actor Jim Caviezel's chaotic presence on set, with Caviezel using his power as the show's star to impart his fringe political beliefs on the very series itself.

Caviezel's conservative tendencies extended to him refusing plans for his character, John Reese, to embark on a romance with Detective Joss Carter (Taraji P. Henson).

Though the pair do kiss once, Caviezel ultimately put the kibosh on any further plans due to his own belief that interracial relationships were wrong. This apparently offended Henson enough - as it should have - that she decided to quit the show to pursue other opportunities.

As such, Carter was abruptly killed off mid-way through the series' third season, and let's be honest, Henson's career hardly suffered from her departure.

Caviezel, though, continues to be radioactive in Hollywood circles due to his vocal right-wing fundamentalist beliefs, which have evidently only intensified in the years since the show ended.


3. Sulu Gets A Katana - Star Trek: The Original Series

Star Trek Sulu
CBS

Even if you've never seen a single episode of Star Trek: The Original Series, there's a good chance you've seen the iconic image of a shirtless Sulu (George Takei) brandishing a sword and running around the Enterprise like a member of The Three Musketeers.

This scene occurs in the series' fourth-ever episode, "The Naked Time," where an inhibition-lowering infection spreads throughout the ship, in turn prompting Sulu to fancy himself a swashbuckler.

However, the episode was originally written to have Sulu using a katana instead, but George Takei refused to film the sequence with such a culturally stereotypical prop, instead opting for a sword. He said:

"Originally they wanted to put a katana sword in ­Sulu’s hands... It was technically consistent with my ancestry but, as a boy, I had never played samurai. I played Robin Hood! My parents had taken me to see Errol Flynn in The Adventures of Robin Hood and it swept me away. I had my mother make me a Robin Hood outfit, and my backyard became Sherwood Forest."

2. Frank Goes To Jail - It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia

It's Always Sunny Frank Reynolds
FX

It's honestly tough to picture the It's Always Sunny gang turning down any proposed storyline, because they seem basically game for anything, but there was one "planned" episode which impressively went too far for the great Danny DeVito.

In a 2022 interview with IndieWire, DeVito revealed that, earlier in the show's run, stars Rob McElhenney, Glenn Howerton, and Charlie Day sent him a script where his character Frank Reynolds goes to jail for trying to pick up a hooker and is repeatedly raped by the prison's various cliques, including the cops themselves.

DeVito was immediately startled by this storyline and called up his lawyer to turn it down, but as he soon learned, he was actually being bamboozled:

"Then I got to the end of the script. And the last guy that nailed me leans in. Well, Frank is now laying on the ground, [his] face is on the ground. He's been f**ked by every… And the guy leans down and he says, 'April fools, bitch.' And I realised it was April 1st. They wrote this script in order to break my balls... I called them up. They were all on the call, laughing their asses off. And then we went and did some other crazy show."

1. Eric Or Tami Has An Affair - Friday Night Lights

Friday Night Lights
NBC

One of Friday Night Lights' dramatic pillars was the firm relationship between high school football coach Eric Taylor (Kyle Chandler) and his wife Tami (Connie Britton), enough that actors Chandler and Britton made a pact during the show's tenure: they'd never agree to do an infidelity storyline.

Speaking on Entertainment Weekly's Binge podcast back in 2017, Britton said:

"We were like, 'We're never letting the writers have us have an affair. If they try to do it, we're not going to do it.' And we told them so."

This is a rare instance of actors pre-empting the creative process entirely and heading it off at the pass, by flat-out telling the writers not to get any funny ideas before they even do.

Given that having one of the Taylors cheat would've likely been a disaster for the series, it's tough to argue with their perspective in the slightest.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.