10 Most Disturbing American Horror Story Episodes

When it comes to the unsettling, this series does it best. Do you have what it takes?

American Horror Story Smouldering Children
FX

With a name like American Horror Story, no one goes into this series expecting a barrel of laughs. Instead, we are greeted with some of the bloodiest, freakiest, and most twisted scenes ever put to the small screen.

This cultural icon of a horror series, created by Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuk, explores a vast array of different time-periods and sub-genres from season to season. Consequently, viewers are spoiled for choice when it comes to the gruesome and disturbing. Want to watch a family be psychologically tortured by ghosts in a murder house? You got it. The violent spree of a mass-murdering clown more your speed? Lucky you, because they have that too.

American Horror Story prides itself on those hard-to-watch moments that send hearts racing and hairs raising. As such, many episodes feature such unsettling content, that you would not be blamed for admitting defeat and popping on your favourite episode of Peppa Pig to decompress.

If you don’t have the stomach for experiencing these episodes first-hand, or are just in for a casual stroll down repressed-memory lane, read on and learn of the ten most disturbing episodes in all of American Horror Story history.

10. “Welcome To Briarcliff” – Season 2, Episode 1

Bloody Face American Horror Story
FX

How does a series begin to pick up the pieces after such a shocking first season? If your answer was “with Maroon 5’s Adam Levine,” then you’re correct… unfortunately. In all seriousness, the first episode of American Horror Story’s second season packs a serious punch with some truly awful displays of horror, straight off the bat.

At the beginning of the episode, we meet Leo (Levine) and Teresa, a pair of newly-weds who, for whatever godforsaken reason, have decided to spend their honeymoon in the wreckage of Briarcliff Asylum. Things take a sharp turn for the worse when Leo promptly gets his arm ripped off by an unseen creature.

Flashing back to 1964, we meet Kit Walker, on whom tragedy befalls almost immediately. Aliens abduct Kit's wife, causing him to get committed to Briarcliff; police suspect Kit to be the infamous ‘Bloody Face Killer’ after finding his wife's body cut to pieces. But wait! As if that wasn’t enough, we also meet Lana Winters, a reporter who had come to Briarcliff to investigate. Horror soon strikes in the asylum when Lana blacks out, waking up to find herself strapped to a prison bed.

Needless to say, this episode crams in a tonne of unsettling nightmarish moments to set a phenomenally abysmal tone for the rest of the season.


9. “Piggy Piggy” – Season 1, Episode 6

Tate Shootings American Horror Story
FX

Those familiar with the sublime first season of American Horror Story would recognize this episode and understand its place on this list immediately. Episode six, dubbed ‘Piggy piggy’, features a hard-hitting flashback which reveals fan-favourite character Tate Langdon as the perpetrator of a school shooting.

Before we delve into that, it would be remiss to not mention the supplementing storyline of this episode, and that for which it is named. One of Ben’s new patients (played perfectly by Modern Family’s Eric Stonestreet) tells the urban legend of the ‘Piggyman’. Part-Candyman, part-Saw, this fictional legend revolves around a ghost-butcher who dons a pig mask and kills his victims when they say his name in a bathroom mirror. Creepy stuff.

Of course, the real horror comes from our journey into Tate’s past. To put it lightly, this scene is hard to watch, largely due to the fact that what happens is already revealed to us in the previous episode. We are forced to watch a group of innocent high-schoolers pray for their lives, knowing very well that they are about to be murdered. The real punch to the gut, however, lies in the revelation that the charismatic young character of Tate could have done this. Consequently, he soon pays with his life, when a SWAT team swarms his house and shoots him dead.


8. “Test Of Strength” – Season 4, Episode 7

Ma Petite Death American Horror Story Freak Show
FX

From a season titled ‘Freakshow’, you can expect your fair share of strange and disturbing content, but one episode, in particular, takes the freaky cake. Honourable mentions to episodes one and four, for their off-putting depictions of clown murder and snuff films respectively.

Season Four, Episode Seven of American Horror Story features an especially shocking act of inhumanity, not from any supposed ‘freaks’, but from a regular man who fears them. A young woman named Penny, who has taken a liking to the freaks and plans to abscond with them, comes home to retrieve her things. Upon arriving, she is greeted by her father who does the rational thing and forcibly tattoos her entire face and splits her tongue. On second thought, he might have gone a tad too far with that one.

That’s not all, as this episode also features strongman Dell Toledo commit a truly heinous act towards one of his fellow freaks. Grappling with the loss of his secret boyfriend, and tempted by an offer to earn a great sum of money, Toledo attempts to murder one of the freak citizens. After failing his first attempt, and getting beaten to a pulp, Toledo turns his attention to an easier target – Ma Petite. Watching Toledo snap the neck of this helpless tiny woman is agonizing, and not an image that will swiftly leave you.


7. “Unholy Night” – Season 2, Episode 8

American Horror Story Santa Leigh Emerson
FX

Episode Eight of American Horror Story Season Two boasts the answer to a perverse question that no child would ever want to ask – what if Santa was a murderer and a rapist? That alone should be all the explanation you need to watch (or rather avoid) this episode.

The opening of Unholy Night introduces Leigh Emerson, a deranged serial killer with a penchant for dressing up like Santa Claus. We witness the depth of his sadism in a flashback which sees him slaughter a young girl’s parents. In the present (pun fully intended), we find Emerson locked in solitary confinement at Briarcliff. When the holidays roll around, a very possessed-by-the-devil Sister Mary Eunice decides to give Emerson a “chance at redemption.” What results is an orderly getting their face sliced open with a rather sharp Christmas ornament.

At the end of the episode, tensions heighten when Emerson locks himself in a room with Sister Jude. Watching the unhinged Santa Claus taunt Jude as though she’s a “present” he’s going to “open” will make you think twice about sitting on Santa’s lap this year. If this Santa Claus is coming to town, “you better watch out.”


6. “Return To Murder House” – Season 8, Episode 6

American Horror Story Apocalypse Constance Langdon
FX

Who can forget the spectacularly horrid finale of American Horror Story Season One? Few shows have the gumption it takes to kill off almost every character from the season like some quasi-soap-opera bloodbath, but for AHS it’s a pretty standard affair. Who, then, would suspect that a whopping seven seasons later the show would revisit that carnage?

American Horror Story Season Eight’s return to the sadistic setting of Season One boasts ghosts, murder, and a generous helping of Satanists. Seeking to uncover the mystery that surrounds the malicious Michael Langdon, witch and warlock Madison Montgomery and Behold Chablis make good on this episode’s title and return to the murder house in which Michael was born. Once there, the pair engage with the spirits of the house and learn of Michael’s gruesome history.

Squeamish viewers beware because Return to Murder House boasts a myriad of flashbacks which act as a highlight reel of Michael’s most violent kills. Not only does he kill an innocent nanny and priest, but he also murders two newcomers to the house and permanently expels their ghosts. The cherry on top of the evil sundae, however, is his mutilation of the poor ghost of the Black Dahlia. Michael is the Antichrist after all, so what else would you expect?


5. “Halloween Part 1” – Season 1, Episode 4

American Horror Story Frankenstein Baby
FX

Back to Season One for what is perhaps one of the outright scariest episodes of American Horror Story. Placed relatively early in the season, Halloween Part 1 utilises the mystery that the murder house is still shrouded in to great effect. As an audience, at this point we know very little about the spectral inhabitants of the house, and this episode sheds some light on them, much to our disgust.

Firstly, we are shown the backstory of Chad and Patrick, former owners of the Murder House; we witness a horrible fate befall them at the hands of the sinister Rubber Man. Chad and Patrick's deaths are unsightly, and without going into too much grisly detail, an iron poker is forcefully inserted in a supremely uncomfortable place.

Next, we have the crowning jewel of horrifying basement-dwelling ghost babies: Thaddeus. In another flashback, young-Tate heads down to the Murder House’s basement, and what transpires is one of TV’s most spine-chilling moments. As Tate stares into the shadows, a gnarled, demented face slowly reveals itself – the hideous visage of Thaddeus. Good luck getting that image out of your mind any time soon.


4. “Holes” – Season 7, Episode 5

American Horror Story Cult Clown
FX

From an episode which gets its name from a certain kind of phobia, you bet that we are going to see some truly disturbing stuff. Separated from her wife and child, series protagonist Ally contends with her mounting anxieties in a home that has been ‘marked’ by a cult of killer clowns. The most horrifying moment from this episode stems from this cult’s attack on the home of a local newsman named Bob.

People nowadays will do anything for likes, but few go as far as the series antagonist, Kai. In a bid to spread a message of fear to the general public, Kai and his cult dress up as clowns and torture Bob on camera. Their attack is interrupted, however, when Bob reveals that he has a gimp strung up in his attic. Sure enough, the cult finds a man suspended by hooks through his skin in the newsman’s attic. Kai instructs his followers to attack both Bob and his gimp, stabbing them to death in an all-too-real film sequence.

The American Horror Story creators really wanted to double-down on Kai’s psychopathy, it would seem, because later in the same episode we discover his parents' fate. After a nasty murder-suicide, Kai discovered his parents' bodies, and rather than calling the police or doing any other rational thing, he mummifies them. Kids these days.


3. “Checking In” – Season 5, Episode 1

American Horror Story Addiction Demon
FX

Season Five of American Horror Story ushered in a slew of new cast-members, and with them, a whole new kind of horror for the series. This premiere episode launches viewers into the deep end with reckless abandon – murder, vampires, and some less-than-desirable sexual encounters.

Detective John Lowe investigates a series of cold-blooded murders in the City of Angels – this is the vehicle upon which Season Five’s journey rests. The murders that Lowe investigates are cruel and perverted, involving a couple who had been tortured whilst having an affair, and a pair of brothers who had been disembowelled. Although, believe it or not, these aren’t the freakiest moments of the episode.

At this season’s titular Hotel Cortez, one heroin-addict gets more than he bargained when he rents a room to shoot-up. The addict is attacked by a fleshy “Addiction Demon”, who proceeds to savagely rape him with a drill-bit dildo. This scene is sickening and should genuinely be avoided if you’d rather live your life free of that unpleasant picture.


2. “Smouldering Children” – Season 1, Episode 10

American Horror Story Violet Death
FX

“Gee whiz, another Season One entry?” Correct, and this one’s a doozy. In this episode, you get one hell of a slap-in-the-face twist that’ll have you convinced you’re watching a Shyamalan flick. Before we indulge in that, however, this episode also provides a little more insight into the events that led to Tate’s death.

If you are like most people, for the first nine episodes of Murder House you were probably wondering how the character Larry got his signature Two-Face aesthetic. In episode ten, that question is answered when we see Tate, high on cocaine and crystal meth, venture to Larry’s office with gasoline and a grudge – watching the poor man scream and burn is decidedly bleak.

Now for the twist. Later in this episode, we watch an increasingly frantic Tate attempt to convince Violet to commit suicide. Though not too unusual by itself for one of his character, Tate’s behaviour is suspicious. We soon discover the reasoning behind it, however, when Violet stumbles upon her own corpse. Four episodes prior, Violet had attempted suicide, but appeared to have been saved by Tate. He reveals that she had, in fact, succeeded in her attempt; he had hidden her body, now rotting and swarmed with flies, to spare her the knowledge of her fate.


1. “The Coat Hanger” – Season 2, Episode 9

American Horror Story Asylum Oliver Thredson
FX

One episode and one episode only can take the crown for the most horrifically gut-wrenching viewing in the entirety of American Horror Story history. For that winner, none could argue that we must turn to Season Two, Episode Nine.

Though there is one moment in particular that rockets this episode to the top of this list, it is also worth mention Monsignor Howard’s shocking crucifixion. At the end of the episode, Howard attempts to baptize Leigh Emerson (that psycho Santa), though it doesn’t exactly work out as he planned. Emerson overpowers Howard, holding him underwater, then nailing him to a crucifix in the asylum’s chapel.

This act, though heinous, is dwarfed in comparison to an earlier one in the same episode – Lana’s attempted abortion. After being raped by Dr. Thredson, Lana is informed by Sister Mary Eunice that she has become pregnant. Suddenly the title of the episode takes on a pitch-black meaning – we watch as Lana attempts a coat hanger abortion. Saying the scene is painful to watch is an understatement, and to make matters worse, we later learn that it didn’t even work. If you endeavour to watch this scene, do so with caution, as it is not for the faint of heart.


Contributor
Contributor

Dan is a writer and actor originally from South Australia who now lives in a constant state of anxiety... and Los Angeles. Whether writing about movies, watching movies, or binging the Great British Bake-off, Dan approaches any endeavour with a steely resolve which is rivalled only by his ability to lie about his strengths. For professional inquiries, call Melissa Cropley - Dan's mum; she wishes he would call more often and you'd really be doing him a favour.