10 Most Re-Watchable Star Trek Episodes

These are the Star Trek episodes to play on repeat.

In A Mirror Darkly Star Trek
CBS

Long before Star Trek came to streaming services, DVDs and VHS tapes were often worn out as people watched episodes again and again. Trying to narrow down the almost 800 episodes of Star Trek into ten most rewatchable is a beautifully impossible task - let's get this out there at the outset of this list!

This list in particular highlights almost every iteration of the franchise, so it will clearly be immediately dated the moment it is published. However, that is the true beauty of Star Trek. Depending on the day, preferences change, episodes rise and fall in the fandom's estimations and people will still sit there and hit play on some of these again.

It could be fair to say that some episodes have almost become cliché in how popular they have become. With almost thirty years passed since the end of Star Trek: The Next Generation (not to mention the almost fifty years passed since the end of The Original Series!), so many episodes have reached nearly iconic status (with some episodes reaching over that lip) and everyone has their favourites. Think of this as the first of many, many lists of rewatchable Star Trek episodes.

10. Balance Of Terror

Star Trek The Balance of Terror
Paramount

This episode was one of Star Trek's earliest examples of truly brilliant writing. The classic episode introduces one of the franchise's longest running antagonists - the Romulans. They are so iconic, in fact, that they continue to pop up as villains a full fifty years later on! And it all began here, with Mark Lenard's outstanding performance as the Romulan Commander.

There are so many moments that stand out in this episode. The beautiful design of the Romulan Bird-of-Prey makes its debut, along with the re-used Vulcan design for the Romulan people. The reaction of the bridge crew to the image of, what they believe, is a Vulcan man ordering the attack on their ship is a heart-stopping moment - followed by wise words from Captain Kirk.

Leave you bigotry in your quarters. There's no place for it on the bridge.

Everything about the episode works. It is effectively a submarine battle in space, with the Romulan cloaking device giving them a distinct advantage in the battle. However, the Enterprise is the more powerful ship, leaving the two in something of a stalemate for much of the run time. Mark Lenard sells every moment of his portrayal of the Romulan Commander, showing himself to be one of the most honourable representatives of his race, while also being a brilliant military tactician.

Absolutely essential viewing for any fan, while also being thoroughly enjoyable on multiple watches.


9. Year Of Hell

Star Trek Voyager Year of Hell
CBS Media Ventures

Star Trek Voyager's fourth season was where the show truly found its feet, going from a fairly good Star Trek spin off to an absolutely excellent series on its own merit. The two-part epic, Year of Hell, displayed a truly frightening and engaging 'What If?' scenario, with Voyager being repeatedly battered day in, day out for an entire year - all while Janeway and the crew try to keep it together.

So much about the story works. All of the acting, including guest star Kurtwood Smith as the coldly diabolical Annorax, is top notch. However, the real star is Kate Mulgrew, through and through.

She anchors the episodes with her steely determination to keep the ship afloat, while trying to ensure the safety of the crew. Already as tough as nails, that toughness turns to armour to rival anything as she defeats the odds again and again.

This was reportedly a direction that could have lasted an entire season and while that may have been truly gripping for the fans to enjoy, this two-part story is a fantastic taste of just how dark Voyager's time in the Delta Quadrant could have been. It is, in a way, a spiritual prequel to Equinox. Janeway is pushed, almost to the breaking point, again and again - but she never gives in.

Truly excellent storytelling.


8. Trials And Tribble-ations

Star Trek Deep Space Nine
CBS

In this love letter to the classic series, the crew of the USS Defiant find themselves hurled back in time to track down an assassin and... really, the plot isn't the important one in this episode! This was made to commemorate the thirtieth (ha, we were all so young!) anniversary of the franchise and it is an absolute smash from star to finish.

There are so many bits to love. The new crew in the old uniforms. Chief O'Brien bamboozled by the old designs. Bashir thinking he's destined to become his own grandfather. But, most importantly, the way they all turn to look at Worf, waiting on an explanation for the room full of 'Klingons' that surround them.

The episode is farce and tribute all in one, with everyone getting in on the fun. Even the usually straight-laced Captain Sisko can't resist, working his way up to meeting Captain Kirk in a piece of truly impressive camera trickery at the episode's close.

This may be Star Trek lite - there are no consequences, no battles (apart from the brawl in the canteen) and, other than re-introducing an ecological menace to the 24th century, this is very much a bottle show. But, in the true spirit of Star Trek, it is upbeat and positive, it keeps everything firmly rooted in science fiction - and it shows that sometimes, the '60s aesthetic can work in the modern era!


7. In A Mirror, Darkly

Star Trek Enterprise In A Mirror Darkly
CBS

Star Trek Enterprise's fourth season is a truly strong season of Star Trek. Enterprise has the unfortunate 'honour' of being the first cancelled live action series since the Original Series and, thoroughly unfairly, this stain has tainted many opinions of the show. However, In A Mirror, Darkly was a fantastic experiment in storytelling in Star Trek - something that could easily win over new fans.

This was the first live action Star Trek episode set entirely in the mirror universe. Archer, T'Pol and the rest live under the banner of the Terran Empire, with all of the usual fun and menace that comes along with that. However, in a brilliant twist, they discovery the USS Defiant (no, not that one), lost in The Tholian Web, and use it to begin conquering their enemies.

The episode is a LOT of fun! The classic era designs look both strange and brilliant against the more industrial backdrop of the Enterprise era ships. The Defiant is also, in a fun twist, a much more advanced vessel than anything it encounters - even with all the Matt Jefferies designs (and pop-up eye pieces) surrounding the crew.

In a way, the episodes are completely devoid of any lasting consequences (unless Hoshi and Georgiou have some connection, who is to say?), meaning that there is very little preamble needed to jump in and enjoy. An absolute hoot from start to finish, this will have you questioning whether or not you believe in Terran or Vulcan dominance!


6. Nepenthe

Star Trek Picard
CBS

Let's be straight here: not everyone loved Star Trek: Picard. There are several reasons why. Nepenthe, however, is not one of those reasons.

Although STP was most definitely not Season 8 of The Next Generation, this episode came the closest to serving as a sequel featuring the bridge crew. The return of Jonathan Frakes and Marina Sirtis was an absolute delight to watch, with both of them delivering fantastic performances. Sirtis, in fact, delivers what is arguably a career best, taking Jean Luc to task when the need arises.

Kendra is everything one would hope that a Riker-Troi child would be, while the heartbreak of losing Thad feels as fresh to the audience as anything. This is a family that you do not want to see anything bad happen to.

But overall, the episode is light and fun, with everyone clearly comfortable around each other and enjoying the change up in the dynamic. Jean Luc is no longer their captain - which only serves to deepen their connections as friends. Will as a forest baking man, with pizzas topped with bunnicorns, served with the odd glass of red - heaven.

The scene around the dinner table is as close to a classic, Next Generation conference room scene as Star Trek: Picard has yet delivered, with all three settling, if even for a short time, into their old personas.

That closing scene, with Jean Luc and Will sitting on the dock, is as perfect a scene between these two old friends as we have ever seen. Beautiful.


5. Such Sweet Sorrow

Star Trek Discovery Such Sweet Sorrow
CBS Media Ventures

The close of Star Trek: Discovery's second season went out with many very, very literal bangs. There is a lot to unpack in these episodes, but it is safe to say that, so far, these are two of the best episodes that Star Trek: Discovery has delivered.

The return of Po.

Seeing both the Enterprise and Discovery side by side.

Seeing two fleets target each other.

The arrival of the Klingons.

Spock and Burnham's final scene together.

The episodes pack a true emotional punch, along with all of the explosions along the way. It is the close of not just a great season, but the first era of Star Trek: Discovery. In a beautiful tribute to the wormhole scene in Star Trek: The Motion Picture, the Discovery warps off into the future with Burnham taking the lead in the red angel suit. The music soars and Captain Pike bids his friends farewell as they go.

The fact that the episode closes on the Enterprise's refit and return to Earth is a clever choice by the writers, hooking the audience so that they must return for the third season (although odds are, if you're still watching by the end of the second season, you're coming back for the third regardless!). It also gives a bit of a coda to Spock's story, while also teasing us with what Star Trek: Strange New Worlds is going to look like.

Brilliant viewing all together!


4. ...All Good Things

Star Trek The Next Generation All Good Things
CBS Media Ventures

This is a decision that changes depending on which number of rewatch we complete, but All Good Things is very possibly the greatest finale of all Star Trek series to date. (What You Leave Behind is snapping at its heels). The time travelling, Q focusing, Yar returning, Riker greying episode is simply fantastic, with no dull moments along the way.

It is pure Star Trek in the telling. The great climax of the episode, while yes it features explosions and action, is more about the realisation of humanity's possibilities and potential, rather than anything giant OMG moments. As Q tells Picard in the courtroom, it was the moment of understanding the paradox in which Q saw that there was more to humanity.

Everyone involved delivers their A game in this episode but the star of the piece is Patrick Stewart. He has to carry the burden of time-hopping, while keeping the various crews either up to date or in the dark. There are shades of season one Picard in how he deals with his contemporary crew, only adding to the fun of the episode overall.

Seeing multiple copies of the Enterprise-D was also a stand out moment, with the inventive and badass three-nacelled version (subsequently named in various media as the Dreadnought class) creating pure excitment.

While it was sad that the show had to end, they did it in the best way possible.


3. In The Pale Moonlight

Star Trek Deep Space Nine In The Pale Moonlight
CBS Media Ventures

Some people often complain about how dark Star Trek has become with Discovery and Picard. There is merit to this: the optimism of early Star Trek has been somewhat thin on the ground in the more recent series. However, there is a little show that set the mould for these two shows and that is Star Trek: Deep Space Nine.

More specifically, there is In The Pale Moonlight.

This is a budget saving, tight bottle episode. It also ranks as one of the greatest episodes of the entire franchise. Avery Brooks ABSOLUTELY delivers a home run here, dictating his secret captain's log - all while facing the camera and breaking the fourth wall, something Star Trek never does (and hasn't repeated since.)

This episode is dark. It's heavy. It shows what the weight of waging a war does to the good guys, breaking them down and pushing them into acts they might never have considered in 'normal times'. The episode also features the impossible-not-to-love Garak in one of his most significant appearances in the series, playing the smiling assistant to Sisko's reluctant architect.

They make a frighteningly good team, succeeding in the most daring mission that the captain has embarked on in his career. He may have commanded troops into battle - but conning an Empire into joining the war on the side of the Angels? This was a new high, or low, for Sisko.

In The Pale Moonlight is a stand out episode of the franchise, deserving a spot in any top 10 list that comes along.


2. Endgame

Star Trek Voyager Endgame
CBS

While Endgame is not the best finale of them all, it has one of the best re-watch values of them. This is not a criticism - it is very hard to beat the highs of All Good Things and What You Leave Behind - and if anything it speaks to the fact that Endgame is one of the most fun finales of the bunch!

Voyager covered in armour!

Transphasic Torpedoes!

Alice Krige as the Borg Queen!

It was a triumphant ending to the series, with a cathartic (if a little brief) return to Earth by the crew. Watching Voyager escape from a Borg Sphere by destroying it from the inside out was, without a doubt, cool!

Yet there is heart in the episode as well. Seven of Nine, despite being somewhat shoehorned into a relationship with Chakotay, shines, while Harry Kim FINALLY makes captain, even if it is in a timeline that now never existed (honestly, when will that man ever catch a break?)

But, the episode belongs to Kate Mulgrew again, playing both captain and admiral Janeway in several scenes together. The fact that it all comes together so seamlessly is simply a wonderful aspect to the episode.

Star Trek: Voyager was a wonderful series overall, which may have suffered a little from comparison's to The Next Generation, yet has completely established itself as a solid and essential piece of Star Trek history, with a wonderful finale.


1. Yesterday's Enterprise

Star Trek The Next Generation Yesterdays Enterprise
CBS

This is quite simply one of the best episodes of Star Trek, hands down. The reason behind this is not just the fact that everyone involved brings their best to the show, but it also widens the Star Trek lore with the arrival of the Enterprise-C, it gives a proper send-off for Tasha Yar, it brings several timelines together and it also goes one step further to offering a 'there but for the grace of God' version of Federation-Klingon relations.

The episode is, technically (and literally, with the lighting choices) a dark one, yet it never truly feels oppressive. David Carson directed this installment and he would return for both Emissary and Star Trek: Generations off the back of this, with his signature look all over both.

The Ambassador class ship is another beauty. It is fun to note that Carson directed the first appearances of both the Enterprises C and B, in reverse order!

Everything works here. The crew is great, the stakes are sufficiently high, reason still wins out in a time of war and the family feels complete. Denise Crosby shines as Tasha, getting enough to do to give the character the closure that she deserved back in the first season.

While there are nearly 800 episodes of Star Trek at this point, when it comes to which one this writer will watch on repeat?

Let's make sure history never forgets the name... Enterprise.


In this post: 
Star Trek
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Seán is the host and head writer/presenter for TrekCulture, as well as a writer/presenter on WhoCulture and WhatCulture Horror. He has authored two novels, dozens of short stories, and hundreds of articles for WhatCulture. He holds a Master of Arts in Creative Writing from University College Dublin. As part of his work with TrekCulture, Seán has been invited to participate in collaborations with Roddenberry Entertainment, as well as contributing to several Star Trek community projects. An avid fan of Star Trek, Doctor Who, and the horror genre at large, Seán's expertise has helped develop these channels to the successes they are today. As host of the Ups & Downs series on TrekCulture, Seán has become internationally recognised for his positive yet critically informed approach to reviewing every episode of modern Star Trek, ensuring he is one of the go-to voices in the Trek community. Favourite Quote to describe himself: "I'm serious about what I do, just not always about the way that I do it"