10 Most Underrated Actresses Currently Working In Television

These ladies deserve more love.

Orphan Black Helena
BBC America

Although the Golden Age of Television is still in full swing, it would appear that not everyone is earning their deserved reputations for constantly knocking it out of the park on their respective shows. Then again, with such an abundance of outstanding programming, it makes sense that some performances simply get lost in the shuffle.

Still, it's unfortunate that some of the greatest actresses currently giving some of the most dynamic and all-around brilliant performances inside that little box of yours remain unknown or unappreciated. 

But even in TV shows that seem to have the entire world's attention, some actresses just don't get the recognition they deserve, despite the fact that they give consistently excellent performances

In this list you'll find 10 incredibly solid reasons why we shouldn't rely on ratings and awards to determine which actresses currently working on television deserve more of your attention.

10. Lauren Graham (Gilmore Girls: Seasons)

Lauren Graham Lorelai Gilmore Girls
Warner Bros Television

Her role as the mom we all wish we had on Gilmore Girls is enough to justify her place on this list, but she also brought her pitch-perfect quirky-but-not-annoying-in-that-Zooey-Deschanel-way brand of humor/mothering to the stunningly under-appreciated Parenthood. 

Just because Lauren Graham is known for her levity, that doesn't mean she can't get serious when she needs to. In fact, it's this more dramatic side of her talent that doesn't get recognized enough. 

Whether she's arguing with one of her fictional daughters or defending herself against a fictional boyfriend's tirade, Graham has one of the most natural deliveries of anyone currently working in the industry. Particularly in her portrayal of Lorelai Gilmore, it would be easy to have such rapid-fire, intricately-worded monologues come off a bit too forced, especially when the emphasis isn't on delivering a punchline. But Graham makes it seem effortless and, most of all, genuine.

Whether or not the short order of new Gilmore Girls episodes for Netflix expands into another full season later on, we should all be happy to have the coolest fictional mom on the planet back in our lives, however briefly.


9. Stephanie Beatriz (Brooklyn Nine-Nine)

Rosa Diaz Brooklyn Nine Nine
Fox

It's hard to stand out in a cast of looney tunes that makes up the bulk of Brooklyn Nine-Nine. In fact, it would be completely understandable if Stephanie Beatriz faded into the background entirely, leaving all of the comedic heavy-lifting to Andy Samberg, Joe Lo Truglio, and Chelsea Peretti. But not only does Beatriz hold her own as Officer Rosa Diaz, she frequently grabs the spotlight without having to try all that hard.

Oddly enough, her character's standoffish, no-nonsense demeanor allows her to have some really terrific, interesting chemistry with all of her fictional coworkers. Somehow that stony-faced aloofness makes Diaz the ideal foil for pretty much the entire police department.

Beatriz nails the kickass, confident, emotionally stunted portrayal as if she's been practicing for the role her whole life. Yet, behind the scenes, Beatriz couldn't be further away from the cold renegade she plays in the Nine-Nine. 

It's likely the soft, sweet, sincere core of the actress that allows her character's inner affability to shine through, while giving Beatriz the chance to really flex her acting chops. And boy are those muscles huge.


8. Jamie Clayton (Sense8)

Jamie Clayton Nomi Sense8
Netflix

Even in a cast that's absolutely littered with fresh, young talent, Jamie Clayton finds a way to stand head-and-shoulders above the rest with a perceptive, shaded performance as Nomi Marks, a transgender political blogger and hacker extraordinaire. 

Clayton herself is transgender, which made it easy for the actress to sink into her onscreen relationship with Freema Agyeman. It's refreshing to see a trans woman portrayed without an excessive amount of baggage or grandstanding.

And honestly, that's the least interesting part of her depiction. It's the way Clayton effortlessly plays up Nomi's soft vulnerability in the face of a traumatic medical diagnosis - without devolving into self-pity - while still finding a way to exude compassion for everyone around her. 

Clayton is one of the show's anchors, and her dominant performance hopefully means we'll be seeing her name in the Emmy nominations one of these years.


7. Hannah Simone (New Girl)

Cece New Girl
Fox

In looking at the trajectories of every character from New Girl, Cece and Winston have both skyrocketed into prominence since the show first debuted. And indeed, it's the infrequent, should-be classic "Cece and Winston mess-arounds" that are the most pleasing of all the loft dynamics (outside of the Nick and Schmidt flashbacks, anyways).

And much of the credit for the Cece's ascendence into one of the principal members of the cast - and legitimate member of the loft -  goes to Hannah Simone, who is able to deftly balance big, weird comedy with a grounded sense of her character's backstory and maturation.

In the first season of New Girl, it would have been all too easy to write Simone off as just another pretty face. But it wasn't long before she was dominating her scenes alongside the also underrated Max Greenfield, and eventually the two of them blossomed into one of the most endearing onscreen couples in recent sitcom history.

Simone's star is pointed straight upwards, and even though her inclusion as "one of the gang" took a bit longer than it probably should have, there's likely no one who's sad to see her get more screen time.


6. Melissa McBride (The Walking Dead)

Carol The Walking Dead
AMC

It takes equal amounts of gumption and heart to play a character as potentially polarizing as Carol on The Walking Dead. Sure, she's gotten to be a fan favorite in recent seasons, but it was very touch-and-go there for a long while. 

Remember how much you sympathized with her in Season 1? How much you desperately wanted her to punch her husband right in the throat? And remember how much you hated her in Season 2, when she constantly blamed everyone else for her daughter going missing? And then in Season 3 you rooted for her again? But then Season 4 rolled around and you kind of hated her again? 

And so it was, back and forth, from season to season or even episode to episode, our love-hate relationship with Carol growing more passionate and connected as time went on.

That was the work of the incredibly talented, chameleon-like abilities of Mellisa McBride, who plays the subtle humanity of Carol so well that you can practically hear her inner monologue in most episodes. Because of that, she can add and remove just enough layers of her personality to adapt to whatever the storyline might be that week, while maintaining an actual character arc, which so many of the others on Walking Dead seem to be lacking.


5. Mindy Kaling (The Mindy Project)

Mindy Kaling
NBC Universal

There might be an urge by some to classify Mindy Kaling as overrated, given the significant amount of press she earned following the debut of her show The Mindy Project. But now that the project has made the jump from a major network to its spot as a Hulu exclusive, it seems like the world is primed to forget about Mindy.

And that, ladies and gentlemen, would be a massive shame. Let's forget about her as a feminine role model for a moment. And disregard the fact that she's one of the few Indian women on television in a principal role. And set aside the fact that she made the "impossible" leap from a secondary role on The Office to being the star of her own, uniquely-voiced TV show with her name in the title. 

Mindy is just...so f--king funny.

It's great that she's all those other things to people, but above all else, she's simply too funny to ignore. She has the ability to wring a laugh from any situation, and can get away with saying things very few others would be able to do without coming off as giant d*cks, just because her delivery is that perfect blend of sweet naïveté and robust narcissism.


4. Lizzy Caplan (Masters Of Sex)

lizzy caplan masters of sex
Showtime

Lizzy Caplan is a perpetual scene stealer in whichever show she happens to be cast in, regardless of the genre or size of the role. Of course, she tends to favor characters that reflect her real life wry, sardonic wit, a style she first displayed for a wider audience as outcast Janis Ian in Mean Girls.

Caplan made her first TV appearance as Jason Segal's goody two shoes girlfriend on the Paul Feig/Judd Apatow-helmed cult classic Freaks and Geeks. From there she's deftly weaved herself into the fabric of several other shows, whether it be as a principal player in yet another criminally overlooked comedy, Party Down, or in smaller, recurring roles on popular fare like New Girl, The League, and True Blood.

She's currently finding her groove as the increasingly overwhelmed researcher of human sexuality, Virginia Johnson, on Showtime's Masters of Sex. And as is the case with literally everything else the actress has done, Caplan manages to stand out in just about every scene she's in. (Then again, it would be hard for a beautiful woman who repeatedly bares her breasts not to stand out, especially opposite Michael Sheen.)

Despite her increased productivity over the last few years, it seems Caplan is still relegated to another "that girl" in the public eye.


3. Emmy Rossum (Shameless)

Emmy Rossum Fiona Shameless
Showtime

One of the most underrated jobs an actor can have is that of the straight man. And in a dramedy as frequently outrageous and darkly comic as Shameless, that job must become ten times harder by default. Enter the even-keeled, plain-spoken, lucid gem that is Emmy Rossum.

Now, it wouldn't be surprising (or unwarranted) if you read the above description and instantly thought "that's the most boring way you could ever possibly present an actor, what's so great about that?" But her character isn't boring. She's the show's heavy.

Sure, William H. Macy steals the spotlight with his, ahem, "eccentricities,"  but it's Rossum who's the real lifeblood. She's the one constantly setting up the jokes for everyone else, and also devours the most soul-crushing scenes when things turn more serious. (Remember that scene in the court when Fiona attempts to become her siblings' legal guardian? Oof.)

Rossum is to Shameless what Jason Bateman is to Arrested Development. (Or literally anything else he's done since.) Her timing is precise, her sly wit undervalued, and her ability to straddle the line of the show's seriocomic universe is unmatched in modern television.


2. Tatiana Maslany (Orphan Black)

Tatiana Maslany
BBC America

In the long and storied tradition of actors playing multiple roles on a project, it's rare for each one of those performances to come off nuanced, unique, and natural. More often than not, the actor seems to be playing slightly different variations of themselves, rather than investing in whole new portrayals.

Especially on television, when these characters have to be stretched across multiple seasons, with numerous personalities showing up in every episode, it would be lunacy to expect one person to pull each one off so effectively.

And yet, Tatiana Maslany makes it look so damn easy. She never goes for the broad characterization. She doesn't simply slap on a different, hackneyed accent and style her hair differently. She sinks into each one of her eleven roles with an appreciation for their personal backgrounds and respect for the audience.

Think about the last actor you saw taking on multiple roles in something. Actually, scratch that, just think of Eddie Murphy. Remember all those movies he played a whole bunch of characters in? Remember how awful those movies were because he relied entirely on makeup and fat suits and cheesy verbal tics to get the job done? Maslany is literally the exact opposite of that.


1. Paget Brewster (Criminal Minds, Another Period, Grandfathered, Adventure Time)

Paget Brewster
Fox

If you're looking for an actress who excels at both quality and quantity of television performances, look no further than Paget Brewster.

Since first appearing as Joey's girlfriend on Friends in 1997, Brewster has been all over the radar. She's rarely been without work in TV land, and that work has rarely been anything but stellar. Her versatility makes her a strong utility player in ensemble casts, finding a way to break through her relatively mundane surroundings in procedurals like Criminal Minds and Law & Order: SVU, while also being unafraid to get real weird with it on Community and Andy Richter Controls the Universe.

When people talk about actresses having that certain, special quality, they're talking about Brewster. (Or they're using it as an idiom to talk about an actress' breasts.)

She has instant chemistry with just about everyone she shares a screen with, a fact that was brought to light in a big way when Brewster started pulling quadruple duty in 2015, bouncing back and forth between shows like a school district's superintendent traveling between schools to ensure everything is running well.

Agree with these picks? Which actresses would you say are underrated? Let us know in the comments. 


Contributor

Jacob is a part-time contributor for WhatCulture, specializing in music, movies, and really, really dumb humor.