10 Oddly Wholesome South Park Moments

A deep dive into South Park's sensitive side.

LePetitTourette Cartman South Park
Comedy Central

South Park is a popular and enduring TV show, which has acted as a satirical pop-culture time capsule since 1997. Its creators Trey Parker and Matt Stone target society indiscriminately. This is a key reason they skirt much criticism when delving into controversial and contentious topics. The other is the writing talent that gives life to South Park.

The show has both amused and angered every section of society, often provoking both emotions in the space of a single episode. There are many diverse and visceral opinions on the long-running animated comedy, ranging from cultlike worship to words more succinctly expressed by spitting on the ground. Few would include the adjective “wholesome”.

However, Trey and Matt have crafted colourful yet relatable characters, who you can’t help but empathise with after all these years. Feel-good and oddly moral occurrences in the characters' adventures still surprise viewers. Though they use it sparingly, South Park can pierce its viewer’s souls, no matter how tainted, and play at their heartstrings, blending sincere emotion in between a scatological joke and some searing celebrity satire.

10. Satan Counsels Stan Through Addiction

South Park S04e11c06 Abandon All Hope 16x9
Comedy Central

Freemium Isn't Free (Season 18, Episode 6)

As Jimmy pushes the Terrance and Phillip freemium game on the kids of South Park, nobody embraces it as much as Stan. He quickly becomes addicted to the “free” game and spends hundreds of his parent’s hard-earned dollars on the app.

Randy, oblivious to his own relationship with alcohol, identifies that Stan has the same “demons” as his gambling addict grandfather. Despite Randy’s efforts, it is “The Prince of Hell” who talks Stan through his turmoil.

Satan takes a scientific approach explaining the role of dopamine problems in humans who have “access to all the s**t they want”. He reassures Stan that there’s nothing “spiritually wrong” with him. Satan mocks the addict counsellor staple that those who are addicted are filling a hole in themselves with the diatribe; “well, who’s not filling a f**king hole, right?”

Though Satan claims he is motivated by a drive to preserve nuanced temptation, and uses Stan’s body to combat the Canadian Devil, it is a wholesome moment seeing the evil deity and ex-lover of Saddam Hussein show a soft side.


9. Mr. Connors Becomes A WWE Superstar

WTF South Park
South Park Studios

W.T.F. (Season 13, Episode 10)

After attending a live WWE show, the Boys promptly join their school’s wrestling programme. However, they soon sour on it, dismissing the amateur wrestling presented by Mr. Connors as “gay”. The former students establish the Wrestling Takedown Federation, which quickly pulls in an audience with the town’s redneck population.

The popularity of W.T.F.’s brand of wrestling causes Principle Victoria to cancel the school’s wrestling program citing its “adult subject matter”. Connors is jobless. Upon learning that WWE’s chairman Vince McMahon is attending a W.T.F. show, Connor’s plots his revenge.

After a failed attempt to kill McMahon with a rocket launcher, Connors storms the ring ready to rant. The crowd are initially hostile to Connors explaining “real wrestling”. However, they are swayed when he reveals the Boys “took his job”. This courts support with the redneck crowd. McMahon dubs the monologue “one of the finest wrestling performances” he’s ever seen. He signs Connors to a WWE contract, and dismisses the Boys as “decent” but lacking Connor’s “raw wrestling talent”.

In a colourful and fantastical episode, the triumph of the underdog is a satisfying conclusion, even if he does sell out his brand of “wrasslin”.


8. Lemmiwinks Is Crowned "The Gerbil King"

Lemmiwinks Gerbil King
Comedy Central

The Death Camp of Tolerance (Season 6, Episode 14)

In chasing a pricey lawsuit, Mr. Garrison tries to force South Park Elementary to fire him for reasons relating to his sexuality. He enlists Mr. Slave to help push the expression of their relationship beyond taste and appropriateness. The exhibitionist display cumulates in Mr. Garrison putting class gerbil Lemmiwinks up Mr. Slave’s anus. With the parents terrified of appearing bigoted, it is the class who face punishment. As the children endure a Schindler's List parody in Tolerance Camp, Lemmiwink’s has his own journey.

Despite its gross location and oddball characters, Lemmiwink’s quest follows the traditional “Hero’s Journey”. Set to a descriptive folk ballad, the gerbil navigates his way through Mr. Slave’s digestive system. He is guided by spirits of animals who have perished inside (the Frog King, Sparrow Prince, and Catatafish).

Unlike the ecosystem of spirit animals inside Mr. Slave, Lemmiwinks survives. Outside the body, he is reunited with his guides. The Sparrow King reveals that thanks to Lemmiwinks the animal spirits are free. As a reward he is crowned ‘The Gerbil King’. After traversing through grotesque visceral terrains, it is contenting to see the crazy critters at peace.


7. Slash Magically Rebuilds The Orphanage

South Park Slash Orphanage
Comedy Central

Crack Baby Athletic Association (Season 15, Episode 5)

In an episode with one of the darkest premises, a feel-good ending certainly helps.

After TV guilt trips Kyle into volunteering with crack babies, he is suspicious to discover Cartman already registered. Kyle uses minimal private eye skills to discover that Cartman is the commissioner of the Crack Baby Athletic Association.

Viewers are accustomed to Kyle as the moral centre of most situations, a role he initially occupies. However, he is wooed by the money and perks. He remedies his guilt by securing a deal to build an orphanage with a percentage of the profits.

As the sport takes off, Clyde and Craig attempt to book Guns 'N’ Roses guitarist Slash for a halftime show. However, they inadvertently discover he is not real and has a mythos similar to Santa.

When EA Sports screw over the boys, Kyle laments that the crack babies have suffered the greatest loss. His spirits soar when he stumbles on the exact orphanage he envisioned. In the corner of the reception sits Slash’s hat and guitar. Maybe ‘Vünter Slauche’ is real after all…


6. Mr. Adler Moves On

Mr Adler South Park
Comedy Central

Tweek vs. Craig (Season 3, Episode 5)

While the rest of the school obsess over the titular fight, shop teacher Mr. Adler comes to terms with the death of his fiancée. He initially recalls happy memories of a live-action woman (assistant writer Pam Brady). However, her death soon plays out ruining his reminiscence. His fiancée died while piloting a skywriter, which exploded and crashed, leaving her to drown in the ocean. The juxtaposition of clips from her life and death is vaguely unnerving.

Mr. Adler composes his suicide note, tragically addressed “to whom it may concern”. He says farewell to the cruel animated world and lays down on a table saw. The fight bursts into the shop class, interrupting his plan. However, Kenny is maimed when a machine flings him into a box of rusty nails.

As he dies in Mr. Adler’s arms, Kenny’s face becomes a screen through which the dead fiancée communicates. Mr. Adler finally gets his chance to say goodbye, however, she points out it is not the goodbye that matters but the time they spent together. The scene packs a significant punch for a B-plot centred on the love life of a background character.


5. Kip Gets Stan’s Facebook Friends

South Park You Have 0 Friends
Comedy Central

You Have 0 Friends (Season 14, episode 4)

As Facebook takes over South Park, Kyle takes pity on social outcast Kip Drordy, who after being on the platform for six months is yet to have a single friend. Kip’s ecstatic emotion immediately invokes sympathy. However, Kyle faces trial by social media as his friend stock plummets.

Kip’s parents are overjoyed when they find out their son has a friend. They fail to realise how there is little semblance between a Facebook friend and a real one. Rather than newsfeed browsing and likes, the Drordys believe Kip and his new friend Kyle are “really getting to know each other” at Kyle’s family farm. In reality, Kip is satisfied by the click of a button.

Kyle, unable to endure being an outcast, unfriends Kip. He plummets into an even worse depression than prior to Kyle’s friendship. Despite the root of the episode’s humour being how serious people take Facebook, it is genuinely moving when Kip sees Kyle vanish from his Friends.

Salvation comes in the form of Stan, who after being literally sucked into Facebook, defeats his sentient profile, and transfers his 845,323 friends to Kip.


4. Nurse Gollum Just Wants To Be Treated Like Everybody Else

South Park Nurse Gollum
Comedy Central

Conjoined Fetus Lady (Season 2, Episode 5)

Nurse Gollum was one of the most visually striking characters of the early seasons. Even bright pink hair couldn’t distract from the dead foetus conjoined to the left side of her head.

After Sheila Broflovski hears the Boys discussing their shared disgust at the nurse’s condition, she reprimands them and attempts to educate them about Conjoined Twin Myslexia. Her crusade leads to the town of South Park holding a “Conjoined Twin Myslexia Awareness Week”, despite Nurse Gollum’s discomfort and polite protests that she’s “a pretty happy person”.

Among the embarrassments she endures are being the only “brave soul” in the week’s opening parade, and official celebration hats that mimic her condition.

Nurse Gollum uses the week’s concluding speech to empower herself. She berates the town that the last thing she wanted was to be singled out, let alone have a weeklong focus on her handicap. She concludes: “I just want to be ridiculed, shouted at, and made fun of, like all the rest of you do to each other”. Shared humour is a potent form of inclusion.


3. Cartman’s U-Turn

South Park The Pandemic Special
Comedy Central

The Pandemic Special (Season 24, Episode 1)

The extended episode featured some of the raw and pressing issues of the global pandemic, taking swipes at issues such as Trump’s response to Covid-19, police brutality, and declining mental health.

Stan has the most subdued reaction to the pandemic, focusing his energy on kids like Butters, who aren’t as strong as him. When the students are forced to lockdown inside the school, Butters has a meltdown about the repeated delays to his Birthday Build-A-Bear trip.

Following a mass breakout, the Boys get Butters to Build-A-Bear. When armed police close in, Randy is forced to give up the pangolin containing his semen (the believed cure for the virus) to stop them firing on the Boys.

To preserve his “new normal”, Cartman seizes the pangolin and holds it above the Build-A-Bear do-over shredder. Stan comes forward and emotionally admits that it hasn’t been about Butters. He tearfully reveals; “I did all this because I just want my life back... I just want my life back”. Without word, Cartman hands the pangolin over to a scientist and leaves.

However, Cartman’s most selfless act is undone when President Garrison destroys the creature with a flamethrower.


2. South Park Accepts Homosexual Pets

South Park Big Gay Al
Comedy Central

Big Gay Al's Big Gay Boat Ride (Season 1, Episode 4)

When Stan’s dog Sparky (barking provided by George Clooney) exhibits notable gay tendencies at the school bus stop, his owner is humiliated. Stan seeks advice from the flamboyant, but at this point still closeted, Mr. Garrison who rants that "gay people are evil" and refers to them as displaying “Nazi-esque patterns of violent behaviour”.

As a result of more terrible advice from the adults of South Park, Stan drives Sparky away with wishes for a “butch dog”. Seeing his error, Stan shuns his responsibility as South Park Elementary’s star quarterback and locates Sparky at Big Gay Al’s Big Gay Animal Sanctuary. Big Gay Al uses his gay menagerie and Big Gay Boat Ride tour to educate.

Stan returns and leads the team to an “almost” victory. When called upon to give a speech, he uses his moment to highlight that it’s “okay to be gay”. It is “part of nature and a beautiful thing”.

The simple speech was, during the episode’s original airing, rather radical. South Park often hits home using the Boys, and their simpler understanding of their world, to make sense of complex, adult issues.


1. Stan Doesn't Get It

South Park With Apologies to Jesse Jackson
Comedy Central

With Apologies to Jesse Jackson (Season 11, Episode 1)

In one of South Park’s most forthright explorations of racism, Randy Marsh destroys his reputation on a television game show. When answering the conundrum pictured above, Randy blurts out a racial slur rather than “naggers”.

While Randy ironically experiences discrimination as “The N-word Guy”, Stan battles guilt by association. As Token is the only African American who Stan has a relationship with (by this point Chef had been exposed as a paedophile and brutally slain), he goes out of his way to preserve their friendship. Stan’s attempts are tone-deaf. He states his dad isn’t racist, “just stupid”, and that it is “no big deal”. Token is rightly offended at Stan’s attempt to quickly dismiss the incident as petty.

Stan alienates Token further when he mistakenly believes the situation is “cool now” as Randy had apologised to Jesse Jackson. Also, he equates the struggles of African Americans and Little People.

However, in the episode's closing moments, Stan has the epiphany that he “doesn’t get it”, that he’ll never understand how a black person feels when somebody uses the N-word. The episode is a powerful piece of character development that touches the show’s predominantly white audience.


In this post: 
South Park
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

An English Lit. MA Grad trying to validate my student debt by writing literary fiction and alternative non-fiction.