10 Saddest TV Character Exits That Made You Cry

Be warned, getting through this list is going to be hard... that's what she said.

Who doesn't love a good cry? While movies are often known as the tear jerkers in entertainment, when TV makes you cry, it makes you cry hard. Fans invest years of their lives into TV shows, watching the characters grow and develop. Watching them fail, watching them succeed. Laughing with them and laughing at them. That's why it's so difficult when they leave. Often, seeing a member of your favourite cast depart can feel like losing a member of the family.

TV show exits can bring a tear to the eye for a whole range of reasons. Sometimes it’s because the beloved character will be so badly missed, and other times it’s because of the utter devastation they leave behind. In the interests of variety, there’s some deaths, some finales, some Irish goodbyes and some that made you sad for all the right reasons, just to keep you on your toes.

Fair warning, while some of these moments might have an almost sweet, nostaligic feel to them, others are going to hurt like a gut-punch. This is like watching an old home movie of your faithful dog being put to sleep, after all. Make sure you have a Kleenex ready.

10. Jill Tracy - Scrubs

Scrubs Jill Tracy
NBC

This is the kind of layered emotional impact that Scrubs was so great at.

Jill was a recurring character, slightly annoying in her fun and quirky ways. Like most characters of that ilk, a lot of her best work came either bouncing off JD's enthusiasm or enraging Dr Cox. Prior to her final appearance, she was a known suicide risk, so when she's brought in with no clear cause of death, they assume this attempt was successful and Cox uses her organs on several of his patients. However, they soon find out she in fact died of rabies, as do all but one of the transplant recipients.

Cox is devastated but in a touching reversal of their peer/mentor relationship, JD reassures him it was the right thing to do. Those patients needed organs quickly. If Cox hadn't operated, they'd have died anyway. Then things get really bad.

Cox's final patient, a man who 'could've waited a month for a kidney' dies as well. After resuscitation fails, Cox has a meltdown, destroying everything in the room and slipping into alcoholism. Jill's death plays the tear jerking long game as we see the strong, proud Dr Cox crumble into nothing over and over again.


9. Wanda Pierce - BoJack Horseman

Wanda and Bojack
Netflix

BoJack Horseman has always been supremely well written, especially from season two onwards. Importantly the jokes land, but the character development is on a level unheard of for an animated show too. Wanda's departure is an exemplar of this, delivering two absolutely golden lines.

Their relationship is under pressure because of Diane living in the BoJack household but also because of BoJack's depression and general lack of enthusiasm for anything. Wanda, being a relative newcomer, chalks these up to Diane's influence, though regular viewers know better.

BoJack then delivers a perfect commentary on the situation; 'You didn't know me. Then you fell in love with me. And now you know me.' This searing summation of the dating world when everyone is playing their own little role is powerful, and shows BoJack vulnerable, seeing himself as damaged, worthless. This exit isn't sad because of Wanda necessarily; characters like Vincent Adultman left and were much bigger fan favourites. She doesn't leave a void when she goes, she reveals the void that was in BoJack all along.

She gives as good as she gets too, departing on 'when you look at someone through rose-coloured glasses, all the red flags just look like flags'.


8. Troy Barnes - Community

Community Troy Abed
NBC

Actor Donald Glover's stock as Childish Gambino was on the rise, and he had started to outgrow the cult sitcom. The show itself made no attempt to hide Troy's leaving; his last episode is a game of 'the floor is lava' to say goodbye.

So far, so Community. The school had shut down on multiple occasions before, for huge paintball battles parodying (amongst other things) Star Wars and Mad Max. But there's something lurking under the surface. The game is organised by Abed, Troy's best friend. In fact, they seem to be each others' only friends. Abed has fairly severe Aspergers, while Troy is a childish jock who intentionally injured himself because he knew he didn't have what it took to go pro. The two need each other.

As the game goes on, Abed becomes more competitive and less stable. Eventually, it's revealed that Abed has convinced himself the floor really is lava. He's so desperate for Troy to stay - and his mental health so threatened by his only friend leaving - he's determined to keep playing forever. Troy is able to talk him around and the pair share a wholesome goodbye as Troy sails away... from the parking lot.


7. Sun-Hwa Kwon & Jin-Soo Kwon - Lost

Lost Sun Jin
ABC

Fans didn't quite know what to make of Sun and Jin at first, not that anything was ever straightforward in Lost. A Korean married couple, we only saw Sun's personality initially, with Jin's lack of English relegating him to the background. Ironically, American actor Daniel Dae-Kim spoke English perfectly, relearning Korean for the role.

Because of this initial roadblock, they were all the more charming as their prominence in the show grew. Jin's sense of humour developed with his English, building an unexpected bond with cocksure conman Sawyer. Having given Jin the nickname 'Chewie' because of his silence, Sawyer seemed to enjoying being the Han Solo.

One thing that was never in doubt was the love Sun and Jin shared, and that's what makes their exit all the more tragic. Trapped as the room slowly fills with water, Sun begs Jin to leave and save himself. He promises to get her out of there, but it's no use. As they realise all hope is lost, Jin still refuses to go. He'll never leave the love of his life again. The pair kiss as the water rises, with the episode ending on a heart-wrenching shot of their lifeless hands drifting apart.


6. Fox Mulder - The X-Files

The X-Files Mulder Abduction
Fox

This Season 7 finale was written as a soft ending in case the show was not renewed, though you'd never know it from the quality. The show did return for two more seasons, but Mulder was only an intermittent character from then on. This exit, originally written as his total farewell, was the most fitting departure he could have received.

Having built up such a strong bond with partner Scully through their equally deadpan dynamic, Mulder is a character held fondly in the hearts of many sci-fi fans. Though there had always been tangents to uncover the mysteries of various monsters of the week, the main plot of The X Files was Mulder's investigation into the alien abduction of his sister. Along the way, he slowly unravelled government conspiracies around extraterrestrials, but never seemed to find the core of the truth that was out there.

In his exit, we seem him step willingly into the beam of a UFO to be carried off into the universe. Despite the fairly abject reality, this exit always had that happy-sad feel to it. Had the series ended then and there, you were left with the sense that somewhere out there, Mulder got his answers.


5. Lou - The Fresh Prince Of Bel Air

Will and Uncle Phil Fresh Prince
NBC

The Fresh Prince of Bel Air had some fantastic ‘very special’ episodes in its six-year run, but this could be the best of the lot. This is the moment Will Smith really became an actor.

Lou is Will’s deadbeat dad, and no one is sorry to see him go. That’s not where the sadness comes from. Lou is ready to skip town without saying goodbye, but Will walks in just in time. Bags slung over his shoulders enthusiastically, Will puts up a decent front as he learns the trip they had planned together is off. He keeps his composure, even managing to deliver an ice cold ‘Lou,’ instead of ‘dad,’ as his father exits.

Once he’s gone, that facade quickly crumbles. Showcasing incredible range, Will is cocky, vulnerable and angry all at once as he lists all the ways he’s been better off without Lou anyway. His performance was so emotional, Karen Parsons (who plays Hilary) can be heard crying off screen.

As Will screams ‘to hell with him!’ the rage disappears entirely, leaving Will, Uncle Phil and the audience on the brink of tears. Then, as he delivers the final, heartbreaking line ‘how come he don’t want me, man?’, everyone is pushed over the brink.


4. Mona Simpson - The Simpsons

Homer Simpson Sky
20th Century Fox

The Simpsons has always had some emotional moments sprinkled in with the comedy, but Mona's exit could be the most poignant of their 30 season run.

She's returned several times, even reappearing in flashbacks after her passing, but that first cut is always the deepest. Homer gets the heartstrings warmed up early as he suggests to Marge the reason Mona left when he was a boy is because he was 'a horrible son and no mother would want him'. It turns out though, that Mona had been on the run from the law and had not forgotten Homer for a second.

Unfortunately, this reunion is short lived as her felonious, if well intentioned, past catches up with her. The eye waterfall factor here is not the sadness; Mona has done well enough on the run all these years and Homer has a happy and fulfilling life in Springfield. Instead, it's how tender this moment is, and the wonderful imagery as the credits roll. Mona tells Homer 'you'll always be a part of me' before stepping on the bus with a trademark Simpson 'Do'h!'.

From there, Homer sits and watches the sun set and the stars come out as his mother drives away.


3. Hodor - Game Of Thrones

Hodor Game Of Thrones
HBO

For a show so splattered with death in every episode, this one definitely hit fans the hardest. For weeks, you couldn't even ask one of them to 'hold the door' without them curling up on the floor in a blubbering mess of tears.

While not a star like Jon or Daenerys, most fans secretly thought Hodor had a considerable amount of plot armour on. George RR Martin was heartless, but not so heartless to kill this gentle giant, surely? Besides, it was glaringly obvious that Bran was somehow crucial to the plot and Hodor was his only protection.

What we didn't realise was that he'd been Bran's protection for longer than anyone knew. Hodor's mindless mantra was never just a buffoon raving. Rather, he knew he had one monumentally important thing to do in his life; Hold the door.

Like all noble deaths, Hodor's sacrifice saved the lives of others, with Bran and Meera escaping. The hardest thing to take was the knowledge that deep down, Hodor always knew it was going to end this way and carried on regardless, for the good of his friends.

Along with Hodor, Bran's dog Summer perished holding the door too, signifying that finally, winter was coming.


2. Michael Scott - The Office

The Office Michael Leaves
NBC

Oof, now this is a hard one... that's what she said.

Michael Scott was the epitome of what elevated the American version of The Office above the British one. While Ricky Gervais was excellent as David Brent, the whole schtick was that he was god-awful as a boss. Michael may not have been the World's Best Boss as his coffee cup claimed, but he genuinely loved his employees. Even if he did try a little hard to be loved in return.

It wasn't just his exit that tugged at the heartstrings either. His sprinkler-soaked proposal to Holly was endearingly goofy, and so fitting for them as a couple. Arguably his finest moment though was Pam's art show. With Oscar the only one to show up (and make some sneering comments to boot), Pam is devastated. As she solemnly packs her things, Michael rushes in. He heaps genuine praise on her, so proud that she chose to paint Dunder Mifflin.

It's fitting then, that Pam rushes in just in time as Michael leaves. In a subtle homage to Lost In Translation, we see them exchange words. But as Michael has already taken off his mic, we never hear what he says to her.


1. The Tenth - Doctor Who

Doctor Who The End of Time David Tennant
BBC Studios

Everyone has their favourites, but David Tennant's role as The Tenth Doctor is widely recognised as one of the best. Not just of the modern revival either, but of all time.

It's no surprise then, that fans were so sad to see him go. He'd already delivered an emotional wallop when he left Rose on that beach, but his own exit topped that and then some. We're used to the Doctor regenerating, but not like this.

Tenth's final few episodes see him and the series take a darker turn. He goes rogue, meddling with the timeline in ways he knows he shouldn't. Not only is he not going down without a fight, he's not going down. He won't regenerate. He refuses.

He can have his wish too. He's beaten the Master, it's all over. Then Wilf knocks four times. Bernard Cribbins' loveable granddad even tells The Doctor to just leave, and he so badly wants to. He could do so much more. But what kind of a doctor leaves a man to die?

In saving Wilf, he dooms himself and staggers towards his TARDIS as an operatic score rings out. Then he leaves us on that haunting line... 'I don't want to go'.

Which TV character exits made you cry? Let us know down in the comments.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Lost
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Self appointed queen of the SJWs. Find me on Twitter @FiveTacey (The 5 looks like an S. Do you get it? Do you get my joke about the 5?)