10 Scariest Supernatural Episodes Ever Made

1. Bloody Mary (Season 1, Episode 5)

supernatural changelings
The CW

It's hard for horror TV to effectively pace scares in such a small span of time. 'Bloody Mary' does not have that problem. This episode is straight up terrifying.

In the ep, a man comes down with a nasty case of melting eyeballs. Apparently, the urban legend of Bloody Mary is more fact than fiction forcing the boys to put a stop to her before more bodies drop.

There are a lot of things that give this episode the number one spot. From the moody lighting to eyes violently leaking blood like a broken faucet, the scares here are plentiful. Though what really solidifies 'Bloody Mary' as the series scariest episode is the ending. The sped up image of Mary crawling out of the broken mirror and melting into a dissolving blood pile is not one you're not likely to forget anytime soon.

Don't go messing around with urban legends kids. It never works out for anyone in the end.

Watch Next


Quiz: How Well Do You REALLY Know Supernatural?

Supernatural Quiz
The CW

1. What Is Crowley's Human Name?

Contributor
Contributor

Part-time writer, full-time Kurt Russell enthusiast.