10 Scariest Supernatural Episodes Ever Made
In its 15-year run Supernatural has given us some of the most terrifying moments on television.
Sometimes it's easy to forget that Supernatural is a horror show. Over the years, the series has found itself moving more into plot-focused seasonal arcs about the war between Heaven and Hell. While cool and all, that has arguably shifted the series from the realm of horror and into a completely different territory.
Even if it may not resemble much of the the cult horror hit it started as, over its 15-year run there have still been many spine-tingling episodes to be found. Supernatural has pulled from every corner of the the genre, and even crafted some of its own original ghost and ghouls that go bump in the night. In fact, the early adventures of the Winchester brothers contain more genuine nightmare fuel than you can shake a stick at.
J-horror inspired ghost girls, killer clowns, and spirits of serial killers past, Sam and Dean have seen and hunted it all.
So turn on the lights because it's time to take a walk down memory lane with a look back at the scariest episodes of Supernatural.
10. No Rest For The Wicked (Season 3, Episode 16)
Within the first three seasons of the series, viewers got to see both protagonists die. It's a trend that has grown into a staple of the show.
In the Season 3 finale, Dean's day of reckoning is almost here and the boys are left with one final chance to save his soul from an eternity in Hell. Things don't go as planned however, and everyone's favorite monster hunting bad boy ends up a bloody mess.
'No Rest For The Wicked' is painful to see play out. Fans came to love both brothers over the course of three seasons. Having to watch one of them get savagely brutalized while the other is rendered powerless to do anything is just plain heart-wrenching. The Hell Hounds tear Dean apart like he's made of paper as Lilith gleefully immobilizes Sam, cementing them both as two of Supernatural's most ferocious enemies.
While Dean dies several times through the series, the difference between this death and those later is the inevitability of it all. It's this idea of fighting tooth and nail until the bitter end, but still changing nothing that is so horrifying to think about.
Few episodes in the series come close to delivering a harder emotional gut punch.
9. Party On, Garth (Season 7, Episode 18)
This is an example of an episode after the original ending point at Season 5 that manages to deliver some genuinely solid scares.
The Winchesters are called upon by Garth to assist in a hunt that has him stumped. Turns out there is, as Dean puts it, a 'Japanese booze monster' on the loose gutting people like fish.
While in this episode the spirit is a shōjō, it is more visually reminiscent of an onryō featured in such horror classics as Ringu and Ju-On. This dark haired spectre draped in white is always an unnerving sight to behold. Something about the pure malevolence radiating off of it combined with the iconic look never fails to terrify.
The part about only being able to fight it when wasted adds an extra layer of fear as well. How can anyone fight a vicious, unrelenting enemy when they can barely even walk in a straight line? If it weren't for Bobby's spirit giving them a helping hand, the brothers might have been dealing with more than they could handle.
Equal parts scary and fun, 'Party On, Garth' makes for a truly underrated episode of Supernatural.
8. Something Wicked This Way Comes (Season 1, Episode 18)
Everyone had that feeling as a kid of there being something outside their window wanting in. Children have overactive imaginations that can conjure up endless horrors and 'Something Wicked This Way Comes' asks one simple question: what if it wasn't just your imagination?
While digging into a case where children are mysteriously falling into comas, Dean realizes that the monster responsible is the same one that almost killed Sam when he was a younger.
The creature is known as a Shtriga. An old, decrepit Albanian witch with a taste for the life-force of kids. During the day, it's disguised as the same doctor entrusted with caring for the comatose children. That has to be some degree of malpractice.
A Shtriga can only be killed is when it's feeding. This leaves Sam and Dean no other choice than to use the brother of one of its victims as bait. Basically, this kid had to trust two strangers to save him from a near unkillable witch-monster before it drained the life from him. A gamble that fortunately pays off.
As the brothers point out, this kid's life is changed forever. Now he knows that monsters really do exist, and could be skulking right around the next corner. That's a lot to put on anybody, much less a child.
7. Wendigo (Season 1, Episode 2)
Camping, a chance to disconnect and be at one with nature. Just you, maybe some buddies, and the open wilderness. What could possibly go wrong? Well for starters, everything.
Following in their father's footsteps, the brothers find themselves helping out with a missing persons case in the great outdoors. The deeper they get in the woods, the more the realize that they're the ones being hunted this time.
In the world of Supernatural, when a person enjoys eating human flesh a little too much they turn into a Wendigo. Unlike many of the monsters in the series, the Wendigo is scary because of its brain rather than its monstrous appearance. (though that also helps).
It uses its intelligence to get its prey to do exactly what it wants. Not just that, but it can mimic human voices in order to better set traps for unsuspecting victims. Once caught, the victim can expect to be tied up and hung in a dark cave until dinner time.
The phrase "kill it with fire" has never been more relevant.
6. Everybody Loves A Clown (Season 2, Episode 2)
Why anybody finds clowns to be amusing is one of the great mysteries of the universe. There has never been anything wholesome about them.
The boys go undercover at a carnival to investigate a string of gruesome murders. Unfortunately for Sam, the culprit is revealed to be a childhood fear of his in the form of a shape-shifting clown creature.
To paraphrase cinema's greatest Nazi-fighting archaeologist: clowns, why'd it have to be clowns? On top of being a near indestructible killing-machine, this thing can also turn invisible. It's like the Predator, only without the dreadlocks and way less cool. Much like a vampire however, it can't just walk into a house without being invited in. Which would be a real obstacle if it weren't for how gullible children can be.
The part of this episode that sticks out is the moment where its face morphs into a twisted smile before disappearing. It goes from one to one hundred on the creep meter within mere seconds. Thanks for that Supernatural. Who needs sleep anyway?
5. The Kids Are Alright (Season 3, Episode 2)
'The Kids Are Alright' takes the term "little monsters" to a whole new level.
In the episode, Dean uses a Final Destination-esque buzz-saw death as an excuse to rekindle and old flame. However it isn't too long before the boys discover that the children in this once quiet suburb are being replaced by parent murdering devils.
The design of the changeling is one that nightmares are made of. Most of the time, they look like normal children, but a glimpse in a mirror reveals their true form, involving decaying flesh and way too many teeth. Imagine having a kid who is secretly a literal spawn from Hell plotting your bloody demise. Birth control, brought to you by Supernatural.
What this episode nails is the idea that suburbia might not be the calm paradise it's made out to be. Darkness could be brewing right next door without anyone suspecting a thing until it's too late.
Changelings, fun for the whole family!
4. No Exit (Season 2, Episode 6)
What's worse than being captured by a serial killer? Being captured by the ghost of America's first serial killer, of course!
Sam, Dean, and fan favorite Jo are on the hunt for a spirit haunting an apartment complex. As a surprise to the three hunters, it turns out that said spirit is the one of the notorious serial killers, H.H. Holmes.
A sizable chunk of 'No Exit' takes place in dark, dirty, confined places. Claustrophobic doesn't even come close to covering it. Yet, neither those tight spaces nor the maniac lurking within them are the creepiest parts of this episode. That award goes to all the ectoplasm.
When one hears the word "ectoplasm" they probably think of the comically gross green stuff from Ghostbusters. Supernatural takes a much more different approach. Rather than being fun and icky, it's more like visually repulsive on every level. Plus, the sound it makes could almost be described as crunchy. That's right, crunchy.
This is also one of the few episodes where the thing being hunted doesn't bite the dust. Instead, Holmes meets his fate locked away in a concrete prison. Talk about time-out.
3. Croatoan (Season 2, Episode 9)
Ever wonder what happened to the lost colony of Roanoke? Well Supernatural has an answer for you.
After Sam has a psychic vision of Dean dusting an innocent man, the two head to a small town in search of answers. Things get messy once they find out they've step foot into ground zero for a demonic blood plague.
Not only is this one of the scariest episodes of the series, but it's also one of the best. 'Croatoan' feels like a mix between The Thing and Invasion of the Body Snatchers. Most of the episode takes place inside a clinic where the few survivors have held up together. Any one of them could be infected, making the tension here so thick you could cut it with a knife.
Demon blood monsters aside, this is also one of the first times viewers get to see Dean go dark. His willingness to almost murder a possibly innocent man is something that feels so out of character for him that it's scary in itself.
Nail-biting tension and excellent character work makes this an episode for the ages.
2. Family Remains (Season 4, Episode 11)
Often times it's said that human beings are the scariest monster of them all. 'Family Remains' agrees with that statement to a terrifying degree.
To distract himself from thinking about his time in Hell, Dean has been dragging Sammy along on one case after another. This eventually leads them to a supposedly empty haunted house where things are not at all what they seem.
A paranormal haunting is a more comforting thought than what's going on here. Instead of ghosts, the house has two squatters in the form of a duo of feral incest siblings. These two terrifying twins disable any means of escape, cut off the power, and steal the boys' weapons stash. This was clearly not their first rodeo.
The thing that makes this episode so unsettling is its two creepy surprises. Surprise number one is the first feral incest child, while surprise number two is her equally sickening brother. That's two too many feral incest children.
It'd be a mistake not to mention the night vision sequence as well, which really only seems to exist to make things feel even more nerve-wracking. Mission accomplished.
1. Bloody Mary (Season 1, Episode 5)
It's hard for horror TV to effectively pace scares in such a small span of time. 'Bloody Mary' does not have that problem. This episode is straight up terrifying.
In the ep, a man comes down with a nasty case of melting eyeballs. Apparently, the urban legend of Bloody Mary is more fact than fiction forcing the boys to put a stop to her before more bodies drop.
There are a lot of things that give this episode the number one spot. From the moody lighting to eyes violently leaking blood like a broken faucet, the scares here are plentiful. Though what really solidifies 'Bloody Mary' as the series scariest episode is the ending. The sped up image of Mary crawling out of the broken mirror and melting into a dissolving blood pile is not one you're not likely to forget anytime soon.
Don't go messing around with urban legends kids. It never works out for anyone in the end.
Watch Next
Quiz: How Well Do You REALLY Know Supernatural?