10 Star Trek Episodes That Actors Regret
These are the Star Trek episodes that made the actors look for the undo button.
It's fairly well known that not every episode of Star Trek is universally loved, but even some of the true stinkers have their fans. It's part of the appeal, after all, because there's no way you can tune your tele-box into a fantastical voyage every week without being open to the odd slice of dumb fun. As a result, some of Trek's worst episodes are actually the most fun.
But the episodes that stand out as truly woeful tend to do so for very good reasons. While what's depicted on screen might not be that bad, the events that went on behind the scenes have earned them reputations between the cast and the fans as thoroughly regrettable experiences.
There are usually examples from each series in the franchise, though Discovery, Picard, and Lower Decks are (so far) spared the pain of this list. Who knows what's going to come out in the wash once they're all off the air though...
For now, grab the popcorn and the tea, and let's find out which episodes really rubbed the stars up the wrong way
10. Profit And Lace - Armin Shimerman
Profit And Lace is the sixth season episode of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine that sees Quark undergo gender reassignment surgery. Directed by Alexander Siddig, the story began life as a serious exploration of the son coming to understand his mother. However, during production on the episode, the producers pushed for a funnier tone.
The result is a badly presented parody of cross-dressing and gender dysphoria, which was antithetical to the initial pitch. Armin Shimerman expressed regret at the way the episode ended up, citing the heart attack scene in particular.
When they first filmed it, he and Cecily Adams, who played Ishka, did it straight. They fight, they cuss each other out and then Ishka collapses because of her heart. Quark then goes into panic mode. As presented in the episode, it is a sillier escalation that robs the scene of any tension. This scene is analogous to the episode as a whole. Shimerman regretted it, Alexander Siddig regretted it and Ira Stephen Behr would come to regard it as the episode that killed the chance for any future Ferengi-centric stories going forward.
9. Extinction - LeVar Burton
This is technically a cheat as LeVar Burton didn't appear in front of the camera. Rather, he appeared behind it, directing the episode. In the years that have passed, he has openly stated that he was ashamed of being associated with this chapter of Enterprise.
The plot follows a vaguely similar structure to Burton's own episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation, Identity Crisis. In both installments, members of the crew are infected with a virus that regresses them to become something other than human. The thing about Extinction however is just how ridiculous everything comes across as.
The episode arrived in Enterprise's third season when the show was generally beginning to pick up speed thanks to the Xindi Arc. There is a message in the episode about ethnic cleansing and genocide, yet this is lost in the bafflingly awful execution of the storyline. To be very fair, Scott Bakula and Linda Park give it their all as they act the part of the infected, yet that really is the nicest thing that can be said about it.
8. These Are The Voyages - Most Of The Main Cast
The final episode of Star Trek: Enterprise depicted the crew that audiences had been following for four years as holograms with Riker interacting with them throughout the episode. It was designed by Brannon Braga as a valentine to Star Trek in general and was panned by critics and cast alike. In the years that passed, Braga began to apologise profusely for it.
He believed that the episode was a narcissistic attempt to make a tribute to all of Trek but failed. He said that in all of the time on Enterprise, this episode was the only one that caused Scott Bakula to get pissed off at him. Jolene Blalock described it as simply awful, while guest star Jonathan Frakes bluntly said that it stinks.
Although some of the featured actors, such as Dominic Keating, John Billingsley and Marina Siritis took a softer approach, it is fair to say that as the last episode of the show overall, it was a misjudged endeavour. Many of the crew consider the preceding episodes, Terra Firma and Demons, to be the actual finale to Enterprise. Oh and that entire scene with Trip? Dream sequence. Prove us wrong.
7. Spock's Brain - Leonard Nimoy
While the episode is a milestone in the franchise's history for just how bad it is, Spock's Brain is also firmly in the 'so bad it's good' camp. The episode was made with the slashed production budgets that the third season received, serving almost as an insult to the fans who campaigned to keep the show on the air.
Leonard Nimoy is of course front and centre in this instalment and related in his autobiography that he felt embarrassed for almost the entire shoot. Though it was a feeling that would come back several times in the third season, Spock's Brain bore the brunt of the criticism here. It is not simply that it is a bad episode, though that is without question.
The episode seems dumb. Vulcan physiology allows them to exist without a brain for 24 hours, which is a pretty marvellous attribute for any species. Yet, it had never been mentioned before and would never be mentioned again. So clearly, it was made up on the fly. The story does give McCoy a few chances to have a bit of fun that really is stretching things. Nimoy's review may just have been the kindest thing to be written about Spock's Brain in its entire history.
6. The Last Outpost - Armin Shimerman
The Ferengi were supposed to be the big villains of Star Trek: The Next Generation in its first season, eventually rising to the same infamy as the Romulans and the Klingons. While they certainly became infamous, it wasn't for the reasons the writers intended and for that, Armin Shimerman again makes an appearance on this list.
He was one of the very first members of this race to appear on-screen and considering he would go on to define what it meant to be a Ferengi, he feels responsible for the early failure with them.
The Last Outpost depicts them as something akin to jackals on speed, barking and hissing and generally being a nuisance. Shimerman had an impossible task - make this character description intimidating. Even the blue energy pulsating whips that they used weren't enough to make the audience take them seriously.
Taking on the role of Quark in Deep Space Nine was Shimerman's attempt to course correct the damage that had been done to the Ferengi overall, giving the character everything he had to make sure that no one would ever think of those hyped-up idiots from The Last Outpost again.
5. Assignment: Earth - Terri Garr
Terri Garr appeared in the final episode of Star Trek's second season, Assignment: Earth. The story had been created to serve as a backdoor pilot to a spin-off series. This proposed series would follow Gary Seven and his exploits, yet it never took off.
This episode credits Gene Roddenberry as 'Producer' rather than 'Executive Producer' and he was incredibly hands-on in this instalment. Though this was ostensibly to ensure it was the best that it could be, to ensure it got a series order, it involved him getting in everyone's way.
Garr was particularly annoyed with him as he continually insisted that her skirt be shortened to make it more revealing. Not only did this upset the actress but the costume designer William Ware Theiss quickly lost patience with Roddenberry as well. It all combined to make the set a dismal place to be.
In the years since the episode's release, Terri Garr refuses to talk about Star Trek at all. She is incredibly derisive of her experiences, balancing never talking about it with making sure any interviewer knows how little her opinion of it is.
4. Move Along Home - Avery Brooks
Move Along Home has become a running joke in the Star Trek fan community for its silly themes and that song. Once those lyrics get into your head, there's usually no chance at salvation. However, that's not the part that makes Avery Brooks cringe in this episode.
He said before that despite the silly tone, he could excuse the song and the basic plot. For him, the dealbreaker was making the main cast play a game of hopscotch through a corridor on their way to escape.
Deep Space Nine was still in its first season, with this episode being in the first half of the episodes. Similar to the issues that faced The Naked Now in The Next Generation, the audience hadn't the time to get to know the crew before they were being asked to see them in this ridiculous situation.
To be fair, while the episode still contains moments that are akin to having one's teeth drilled, it has aged, with the aid of nostalgia, a little better than many of the other entries on this list. Just don't ask Brooks to dance to the tune of Allamaraine any time soon!
3. The Killing Game - Robert Beltran
The Killing Game was the two-part episode from Star Trek: Voyager's fourth season that saw the ship overrun by the Hirogen. The crew were forced to enact holographic simulations of brutal conflicts from history, again and again, all for the enjoyment of the hunters. Naturally, World War II quickly caught the Hirogens' eyes and a recreation of a French town in the grips of NAZI oppression appeared.
Robert Beltran hated the episodes, believing first that they were offensive to German fans of the show. The NAZIs were an easy villain to portray yet every single German character was portrayed as evil, with no attempt to show any double agents or spies.
Leading on from this, he felt that the episodes were not well written. Writer and producer Joe Menosky acknowledged that it had been a long-gestating idea that changed forms several times, though the idea of putting the crew in a WWII scenario was one of his first pitches to the series. Despite Beltran's feelings on the episode, its success in being aired on a single night led to the creation of Dark Frontier, which was always intended to be a TV movie.
2. Up The Long Ladder - Colm Meaney
Filming this episode was not an easy task for Colm Meaney. Up The Long Ladder was a second season entry in Star Trek: The Next Generation and to say that it misfires on almost every front doesn't do it justice. The depiction of Irish characters goes way beyond stereotype here, instead opting for an openly racist and degrading option.
Meaney was far from the starring role that he would receive on Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, serving instead as a day player still. This meant that speaking up and opining about the direction the episode was taking really wasn't much of an option at the time. He was 'none too pleased' on set, something he has not elaborated on in the years since. He was however in a better position when If Wishes Were Horses came along, which originally featured a storyline focused on his Irishness in a condescending manner. This was swiftly changed.
The episode was panned. It's no Code of Honor, yet arguably Shades of Grey is a stronger entry! It also received hate mail, though it had nothing to do with the racism. Instead, the line in which Riker states he has the right to control his own body became a target for the right-to-life movement in the US, resulting in screenwriter Melinda M. Snodgrass getting a lot of hate mail.
1. Code Of Honor - Everyone
Code of Honor is the infamous early episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation that is frequently voted one of the worst episodes of the entire franchise. Jonathan Frakes and Brent Spiner have both gone on the record with how much they hate the episode, citing it as a "racist piece of sh*t".
Rod Roddenberry feels that the episode isn't quite as bad as the reception would have people believe, yet it's the depiction of every member of the Ligonians that crushes any argument against the inherent racism on show. Although they are on the one hand technologically advanced enough to have contact with the Federation, they are backward enough as a society that a rigid gender-stereotype exists.
Katharyn Powers wrote the script and would later write the script for Emancipation, an episode of Stargate SG-1 that follows almost exactly the same plot. Both episodes were widely panned by the cast and crews as well. Actor Garrett Wang, although he didn't appear in this episode, cites watching this as the reason he got the role of Harry Kim on Star Trek: Voyager. After viewing Code of Honor, he was no longer too nervous to audition!