I have made absolutely no secret of my love for this TV show in my previous posts (check them out if you already haven't) but even as a massive "Gleek" (I guess, though I hate the word) I don't love anything unconditionally, and I am more than happy to critique this show all day long. That said, I do love the show a great deal more than I hate it (I don't hate it at all) ... though if you do hate this show, this list will only add fuel to your burning fire of hatred. I am also not the type of person who would ever argue that Glee musical covers have the power to ruin the originals. I believe any one who thinks a cover of a great song can actually ruin that song is a little strange, and any one who doesn't watch Glee because they believe Glee ruins songs are too insecure and too protective of their precious precious music. You wouldn't refuse to go to a Karaoke bar because you didn't want to hear people "ruin" your favorite songs, and it is the same with watching Glee. Glee isn't trying to replace great bands and artists and most, if not all of the time, Glee covers are done out of respect for the artist and band. Added to this the fact that Glee covers really good bands that most Top 40 teenagers will never have heard of, and after they cover a band it is often the original song they cover that charts higher on iTunes than the Glee cover itself. Plus, if you claim to love music you really shouldn't be able to deny not only the talent of most of the cast members- honestly, Lea Michele and Amber Riley in particular have almost unmatchable amazing voices you should be in awe of... but you also shouldn't be able to deny that on many many occasions Glee covers are actually arranged fairly well and sound pretty great. This however is not that list. Because, although I like Glee covers 70 percent of the time, the other 30 percent not so much. This is my Top 10 list of the covers I loathed. Press "Next" to start with the 10th worst Glee cover...
10. Ben: Micheal Jackson
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ISPT6XI1ibU Though this is widely considered Micheal Jacksons worst song I honestly don't mind the original version. Still, as a fan of MJ's music, this is still one of his worst and the Glee club do nothing to change its status. My two favorite singers in the Glee universe personally are Lea Michele and Chris Colfer (Rachel and Kurt) and when they sing together I love their voices even more, but really- what the hell were the writers thinking here. Not only is this songs just tonally out of place in the MJ tribute episode, but it is perhaps the cheesiest thing you will ever watch. If this was all I had seen of the show there is absolutely no way I'd be a fan- luckily however this is one of the worst examples. It isn't that the song is sang badly at all, but it certainly isn't improved... and why the hell are they all singing creepily to Blaine in an eye patch. This is creepy for so many levels and Finn looks uncomfortable throughout this whole song. If I were the actors I would have struggled not to laugh through this entire number. And for the life of me I can't understand why they didn't change the word from "Ben" to "Blaine"... it fits perfectly and they really missed a trick here.
9. Baby One More Time: Britney Spears
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eDjmMAdyQmc This song is from one of the worst episodes Glee have ever made but unfortunately one of the most watched. This episode, the second episode of Season 2- the first Britney Spears episode- was really just 40 minutes of Glee copying Britney's music videos. Again, it is difficult to ever criticize Lea Michele's technically breathtaking voice, but this is probably the worst she has ever sounded and her voice sounds super effected as if she is putting on an American accent. Unfortunately for Lea Michele also, she doesn't look all that good in this video... but then again maybe you disagree. I think Lea Michele is very often stunningly pretty, in fact I would even go as far to say I think she is one of the most attractive people on television, but this performance looks forced, desperate and really, what was the whole point of this. She looks like a bratty, spoilt self absorbed teenage girl here and the music number is really offering nothing new to the song, and is pretty much copying the original music video scene by scene. There is zero creative merit in this whole number and I find it difficult to believe that Ryan Murphy wasn't regretting this decision half way through the filming. If it was funny it probably wouldn't be all that dreadful- but it isn't. In fact, I really don't know what this is.
8. One Bourbon, One Scotch, One Beer: Amos Milburn
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6AySEI7iCds If there is one thing I can not stand about Glee it is when they try to make Will Schuester cool. I'm sorry Will, but you were not cool when you rapped along to Kanye's Gold-digger in the second episode of Glee ever, and you are no more cool now. If anything, the simple fact that you asked Finn to be your best man at your wedding in Season 3 means you are the exact opposite of cool. This isn't to say I hate the character- I genuinely think he has a good voice and is criminally underused, but just accept the fact that no one who watches the show thinks you are cool and nor have they ever thought you were. Who was asking for the Glee characters Beaste and Will to sing a drunken duet of a truly horrible to each other in Season 2 of Glee? Absolutely no one is who. This whole performance seems to be more about trying to make the adults in the show (although all of the teenagers are adults in real life too) happy and giving them something to do... but please don't bore the audience just because you have run out of ideas for your older cast members. This whole performance was a waste of 3 minutes which Glee could have easily been using to wow us with something great, instead of bore us so much that we'd need one bourbon, one scotch and one beer just to make it to the end of this number.
7. Physical: Olivia Newton John
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xa5xlzSVzjI Another example of Glee reenacting a musical number for no real reason what so ever. This performance however, and this episodes entire storyline is unforgivably embarrassing. Olivia Newton John sees Sue Sylvester dancing to Physical on YouTube so invites her to redo the music video with her and release the song together. I know a lot of Glee is ridiculous and obviously removed from reality but this is really pushing it too far, and the only reason for this storyline was so Glee could involve Olivia Newton John as a ratings boost. Also, though this isn't a criticism of this performance, but when Sue and Olivia Newton John meet up at the end of season 1 for a second time to judge Regionals they act as if they never new each other and they hate each other although Sue apparently was a big fan and Olivia liked her enough to want to release a single with her. The only reason this performance isn't higher up on this list is because as a cover of an older song it is hardly that much worse than the original, simply because it is basically exactly the same as the original- Olivia Newton John is the lead singer in both. Also, this is clearly supposed to be a joke- and although I didn't find it at all funny, at least Glee weren't trying to make something good here (at least I hope).
6. Candles: Hey Monday
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g2Bfs9tkOxw The episode in which Kurt and Blaine sing Hey Monday's song Candles to one another is a very big episode in the two characters relationship. Just minutes before this number Kurt and Blaine had kissed for the first time, and this episode marked the turning point where Kurt and Blaine became Klaine. After this historic moment between the two, fans needed a duet that would be as epic and triumphant as the moment a few minutes prior was. This was not that performance. Never ever ever has Kurt sounded worse, and although Kurt and Blaine's voices generally gel well together (see "Perfect" or "Don't Speak") here the two voices do not get along at all. Like I said previously, I really like Kurt's singing voice, but to all those people that think he sounds like a cat being strangled if you are referring to this particular song you are absolutely right and I can't, nor do I want to defend this number. What a complete and utter buzz kill this really was. The worst thing about all of this however is that since the beginning of the show we have been waiting for Kurt to get a solo, or a significant moment in one of New Directions competition episodes. Here he finally gets a solo on stage and it is utter garbage. There was no way the Warblers were going to win after this and everyone knew it. Not even close. Unfortunately for poor Kurt, he never did get a significant moment in a competition performance again although he is certainly one of the most gifted performers of the Glee cast (see "Not The Boy Next Door" for a show stopper).
5. Jolene: Dolly Parton
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jDcbMyL6g7M The inclusion of this at number five is more out of disappointment than anything else. FYI, the music attached is not the performance I am referring to- but simply what could have been. The great and powerful Dolly Parton classic was given to Coach Bieste in Season 3's worst episode (I Kissed A Girl) in a terribly forgettable and wasted moment that was rushed over. It wasn't horrendous, but it was nothing special and it was mostly forgettable. No one is going to be telling people after they watch this episode that they must check out Coach Bieste's performance. The reason this is included at number 5 (although with out this reason it would still have been included somewhere on this list) is because Samuel Larsen- joint winner of the Glee Project season 1 and now New Directions member Joe Hart sang this song to perfection on the reality program. Honestly, this is probably the greatest cover of this song I have ever heard and I may even like it better than the original. This cover needed to be on Glee, and now it is very unlikely that it ever will because of Coach Bieste's pointless and very random rendition of the show. I have nothing against her as a character, and actually like her duet with Puck of Taylor Swifts "Mean" but don't give great songs to people who can't sing... especially when people who can sing like Samuel Larsen would have probably loved the chance to do his cover on the program. A wasted opportunity here.
4. A Little Less Conversation: Elvis Presley
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j89JnZ-9mLc This strange Spanish twist on this classic Elvis song has no musical merit whatsoever. You may think that because I have included a few Will Schuester songs on this list that I really hate the guy but this is simply not true, and he has some really good covers in Season 1. But from season 2 onwards the writers haven't known what to do with Glee and they haven't really given him any good songs to sing (apart from his duet "You and I" with Idina Menzel in Season 3) either. This song, and the whole performance of it was an embarrassment and difficult to sit through. In all fairness to the show, this performance was supposed to be somewhat bad, and Santana even calls him out on this fact, but that doesn't make the performance any better (maybe just a little more forgivable though). Matthew Morrison who plays Will is a very talented Broadway star with killer pipes. This song, or at least the songs arrangement doesn't suit his voice and doesn't allow him to show off the talent he has. Considering this was one of only a few times Will got a chance to sing in Season 3 it is an utter disappointment to the very few Will fans the show still has. It is a shame, considering that Will was the main character in the pilot and kind of a big deal in Season 1 that his character has almost been completely forgotten in Season 3 and 4... however if they simply can't think of any thing good to do with him or any good song for him to sing they really should just get rid of him completely.
3. Jump: Van Halen
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DvgVSOv-wT8&& No! No! No! No! No! Some things I wish I could unwatch and this is one of them. This performance here makes it very difficult for me to defend this show against its critics, but honestly, it truly is one of the greatest TV shows on television at the moment. You just have to pretend this musical performance never ever happened. This is perhaps the only Glee cover where I could accept someone saying it actually ruined the original version. Though I have never been a fan of the original song by Rock band Van Halen, Glee managed to turn a rock classic into a number that would have even had been cut from the High School Musical films for being too cheesy. Just look at the Glee cast in this number... look at their faces... too much cheese to even bare. How they managed to get through this performance without either throwing up with embarrassment or killing themselves laughing is a mystery- and for this they deserves all the awards (I wish someone would give Lea Michele a legitimate award already, I really really do). This episode from the much loved believe it or not first half of season 1 was the first episode of Glee I ever watched, and because of this number and this song (plus the Lily Allen song in the same episode) I didn't watch another episode for almost an entire year after this because I hated it so much. Thankfully, when I convinced myself to give some other episodes a try I really really was blown away. Just start with the pilot and when this episode comes around bare in mind that the episode which follows this one is one of Glee's all time best with it's all time greatest solo performance that features on the top spot of my all time greatest Glee moments.
2. Ohio: Wonderful Town
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8vAIzilTl-I This is for sure the most bored I have ever been with any Glee musical number. It went on for far too long and I really just wanted it to stop. Why wouldn't it stop? Maybe had I been older or even American I would have appreciated Carol Burnett's appearance in Glee far more than I did- but honestly, until Glee I had zero idea who she was and Glee didn't exactly get me all that enthusiastic about knowing anything more about her. A few days back I wrote an article naming Glee's worst and best guest stars. Unfortunately I completely forgot Carol Burnett but had I remembered she would have certainly featured highly on the worst side of that list. By season 2 most of us still just about liked Sue but she was still somewhat of a pointless character- I am pretty sure no one cared about meeting her mother though, especially considering we hadn't even met Rachel's dads at this point. Still this performance is completely unenthusiastic and lackluster although in all fairness so is the original. Why the Glee writers thought this song would be perfect for the show (other than the fact that the show is set in Ohio) is beyond me. The largest demographic for the show is teenagers and I am pretty sure no one has downloaded this song onto their ipods. If you have I'd actually like to know? I promise I won't laugh.
1. Barbra Streisand: Duck Sauce
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lzbH48lpCGM It's almost ironic that a song named after someone who has had a huge influence over the TV program Glee, would also be the worst musical number the show has ever done. Some of you may argue that this doesn't count because the Glee cast are not singing on this track, however this number still takes up about 5 minutes of an episode and is frankly an utter embarrassment. Coming in the middle of one of Glee's all time longest and greatest episodes, "Born This Way" (the episode where I first really fell in love with Santana and where Kurt moves back to McKinley from Dalton) this musical number sticks out like a sore thumb. This episode has mostly wonderful performances... a great duet between Rachel and Quinn, a wonderful Broadway tune from Kurt and a Warbler rendition of Keane's Somewhere Only We Know (one of my all time favorite bands). But then, stuck out of place in the middle of all this greatness is a musical number set in the middle of a shopping mall which Kurt apparently planned for Rachel so that she wouldn't get a nose job. Since when did Kurt (who by the way doesn't really have that many friends) have the power to convince lots and lots of random people we have never seen before to participate in an elaborate dance routine in the middle of a shopping mall. When ever I watch this episode (yes, I have seen it a couple of times) I like to skip over this scene- my eyes almost roll out of their sockets if I do not. That said, it is probably a lot to do with the fact that I truly hate this song. It seems a lot of people love it though and it was even nominated for a Grammy Award... why? To cleanse your pallet after these abysmal 10 Glee covers and to prove that Glee can be good (honestly) I leave you with this... One of Glee's finest musical medleys to date. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oDF8CozU5_E
I am a recent Screenwriting for Film and Television graduate from the UK.
I am an unashamed geek who loves everything Marvel, and anything Joss Whedon has ever touched (except for maybe Alien Resurrection and Titan A.E).
My current favorite TV shows are Breaking Bad, Family Guy, House of Cards, Game of Thrones, American Horror Story, Homeland and Glee. I look forward to debating things with all of you in the future.
(As of January 2013 I have had over 1 million views since joining WhatCulture in September 2012. You can reach me at danieljamesbowen@hotmail.co.uk)