10 Times The Doctor Wasn't Very 'Doctory'

Like everyone the Doctor can be flawed, and on these occasions, is a little out of the ordinary.

Human Nature Poster
bbc

Like many protagonists, the Doctor – over the last fifty-seven years – has defined themselves by rules and limits. Adopting, where possible, the Time Lord philosophy of non-interference, as well as his own moral codes of helping those in need and avoiding doing harm to others. The Doctor, usually, is simply a traveller in time and space, just “passing through”.

Even after at least fifteen incarnations, there has always been a great deal of similar qualities passed down throughout the years. Granted every Doctor brings something new to the table, but inside, they’re still the same individual through and through.

But sometimes, the Doctor isn’t very ‘Doctory’, doing something which seems slightly out of character, and without reason. This could include moments such as the Time Lord Victorious moments in The Waters of Mars, however, there is justification for these actions, as well as realisation from the Doctor that he’s gone too far.

But sometimes these out of character moments come with very little reasoning or are just unjustifiable, with the Doctor showing very understanding in their actions.

Whilst these moments don’t necessarily ruin the show - if anything some enhance their episodes - they’re still very out of character for our titular Time Lord.

11. Honourable Mention: The Girl Who Waited - Tricking Old Amy

Old Amy Pond The Girl Who Waited
BBC Studios

Our honourable mention is kind of justifiable. In Series 6, the Girl Who Waited, once Rory has saved the younger Amy in the Two Streams Facility, the Eleventh Doctor refuses the older version of Amy entry to the TARDIS. This leaves this version of the Doctor’s best friend to simply cease to exist.

Whilst abandoning his friend like this doesn’t seem very ‘Doctory’, there are two ways to justify this.

One, for the sake of the Web of Time, two versions of Amy couldn’t exist this way. Which leads to the second point, where saving the original Amy technically ceases the older version to exist, and therefore she was never there to exist.

So, whilst this goes against the Doctor’s usual attitude of saving those he can, in this instance, he had no other choice.


10. The Twin Dilemma - Strangling Peri

Doctor Who Colin Baker The Twin Dilemma strangle Peri
BBC Studios

The Sixth Doctor doesn’t get off to the best of starts, with this incarnation suffering from the worst case of post-regeneration trauma we’d seen at the time. But the tip of the iceberg has to be turning on his companion Peri and strangling her to the ground, until she manages to stop him with his own reflection.

Whilst fans of the Sixth Doctor can justify this with the fact the Doctor is suffering from post-regeneration, this action is certainly out of character.

Over the course of her time in the TARDIS, Peri supports the Sixth Doctor and takes care of him, but to see her suffer like this maybe wasn’t the best creative choice. Although, it does get across the message that this Doctor is a lot different to his predecessor.


9. An Unearthly Child - Attempting To Kill A Caveman

Doctor Who An Unearthly Child
BBC Studios

When the TARDIS first leaves Totters Lane, the Doctor, Susan, Ian and Barbra, find themselves in the distant past, in 100,000 BC. On this first adventure, the original TARDIS team find themselves separated from the ship and held captive by cavemen.

In the third episode of the serial, whilst formulating an escape, the Doctor picks up a stone and goes for caveman Za but is stopped in the act by Ian. In this moment, the Doctor claims he was going to make the caveman draw a map, with the stone, back to the TARDIS. However, his gesture showed otherwise.

Whilst this episode is from the show’s earliest days, and the Doctor is yet to mellow due to the presence of his companions, this action of threatening to bludgeon a caveman’s head with a stone is a little too intense for what we know of the Doctor.


8. Hell Bent - Saving Clara

Doctor Who hell bent the doctor shoots a general
BBC

One of the largest impacts upon the character of the Doctor is the death and loss of his companions. In the series, we’ve seen the deaths of Katarina, Sara Kingdom and Adric, as well as slightly cheated deaths such as Amy, Rory, Clara and Bill.

But it is the death of Clara that is of interest to this entry. In Face the Raven, Clara makes the mistake of taking the mark from Rigsy, the careless action that results in her death.

This is until, two episodes later, in Hell Bent, where the Doctor tricks the Time Lords into extracting Clara from her death, to share her knowledge of the hybrid.

Once Clara is on Gallifrey, the Twelfth Doctor ‘fatally’ shoots the General and escapes with his recently deceased companion. This action prolongs Clara’s life, and long story short, the episode ends with the Doctor forgetting Clara and her travelling in a diner TARDIS with Ashildr.

Whilst it's already been said that the Doctor will do anything for companions, this was maybe a step too far. As Clara herself says, she was already “gone”, and this should have been something the Doctor mourned and accepted.

Instead he risks the web of time by extracting his companion and also ‘kills’ the current incarnation of the General. Whilst his compassion for Clara is admirable, to shoot the General in order for him to regenerate and brushes his actions off as resulting in Time Lord “man-flu”, seems very careless of the Doctor.

But this isn’t the last of the Twelfth Doctor and Clara on this list…


7. Kill The Moon - Abandoning Clara

Doctor Who Kill The Moon Angry Clara
bbc

Series 8’s Kill the Moon, is a divisive episode to say the least. A trip taking Clara and her student Courtney to the moon is interrupted when they discover that something is happening to it which is having a negative effect on the Earth below.

Coming to the climax of the episode, and the Doctor realising there is a choice to be made, he decides that he cannot make this one, and that it should be left to the decision of the humans. So, he leaves Clara and her student and flies off in the TARDIS. Bit of a dick move…

Once the decision is made, the Doctor returns and takes them back to Earth to witness the decision they’ve made, where the moon is revealed to be the egg of some space creature (but let's just leave that there).

Upon returning to the TARDIS, Clara kicks off at the Doctor for “clearing off”, saying she doesn’t want to see him again, which is one of Clara’s most understandable actions.

Although, the Doctor’s intentions maybe to show that he can’t make every decision, the way he goes about it, isn’t very ‘Doctory’. Always saying he helps where he’s needed, why in this difficult moment abandon his companion? We've seen companions be head strong plenty of times, but that's on there terms, not a moment thrust upon them by the Doctor as a sort of test.


6. Earthshock - Ignoring Adric

Doctor Who Adric death Earthshock
BBC Studios

Now, with this occasion, it isn’t exactly the Fifth Doctor ignoring Adric that is the not very ‘Doctory’ moment, but the result of this. Throughout the show, the Doctor is often shown not listening to his Companions, such as in the Beast Below, but in the end, this always has a harmless result. Not with Adric…

Adric, at the time, was the Doctor’s longest serving companion of the current team, but at the start of the episode this is seemingly coming to a close with Adric wishing to return home to E-Space.

By the end of the serial, Adric and the Doctor are split up, and just as Adric is about to escape the Cybermen with the crew of the cargo ship in an escape pod, he goes back in order to try and stop the Cybermen’s plot, resulting in his death.

From the start of the episode, Adric is trying to get the Doctor to take him home, however, the Doctor simply brushes off the idea and refuses to take him back to E-Space. This leads to Adric being killed in the same story, as he tries to prove his ability.

If the Doctor had accepted his friend’s decision, Adric wouldn’t have died stopping the Cybermen.


5. The Seeds Of Doom - Twisting Scorby's Neck

Doctor Who
BBC

Over the course of the show, the Doctor has come into conflict with many henchmen. Whether he stops them with his own buffoonery, or the use of his Venusian Akido, it’s not something you can criticise the Doctor for as he needs to be able to defend himself.

But in The Seeds Of Doom, the Doctor takes this a bit further. When being chased by Harrison Chase’s goons, the Doctor is confronted by his main henchmen, Scorby, who after a scuffle, the Doctor simply twists the villain’s neck…

Now, Scorby does get up from this incident, so the Doctor didn’t actually snap his neck, but on-screen you literally see our hero twist the man’s neck to incapacitate him.

This isn’t the Doctor’s only moment of violence in this serial, though, as earlier on in a quarry, the Doctor, after a confrontation with a deadly chauffeur, simply punches the man out whilst he’s on the ground.


4. Day Of The Daleks - Shooting Ogrons

Day of the Daleks Doctor Who
BBC Studios

“I never carry weapons”, the Fourth Doctor says in the Face of Evil. However, on several occasions that’s not exactly true. The Talons of Weng Chieng and the End of Time are both examples where the Doctor carries a weapon, for whatever reason.

But, never as carelessly as in Day of the Daleks, where the Third Doctor gets his hands on one.

When escaping pursuing Ogrons, the Third Doctor picks up a laser gun and disintegrates several of them.

Whether this makes the situation better or worse, Ogrons are ape-like humanoids of limited intelligence, nearly mindless servants of whichever race hires them. But does that make it any better that the Doctor simply picks up a weapon and takes out a bunch of them rather than some other alternative?

Since then the Doctor has very rarely used guns, and whenever he has, it hasn’t been to straight up kill anyone. The Doctor’s stance on not using guns makes for interesting narrative decisions in the show, as the Doctor simply cannot kill enemies to get out of a situation. Sadly, not the case in Day of the Daleks.


3. The Runaway Bride - Drowning The Racnoss Children

The Runaway Bride Doctor Who
BBC Studios

The Racnoss were an ancient race from the Dark Times of the universe, where they were one of many enemies of the Time Lords. The survivors of their war fled in a ship which the Earth formed around. In 2007, the Empress of the Racnoss discovers these survivors and starts a plot to awake her young.

However, as usually in Doctor Who, she is beaten by the Doctor. But in an unusually dark turn of events, when the Empress doesn’t take the Doctor’s ultimatum, he does something kind of unexpected. The Doctor floods the tunnel down to the centre of the Earth with water from the Thames and drowns all the Racnoss young…

Whilst the Empress escapes, however not for long, we’re led to believe this is the last of the Racnoss. The Empress flees to her ship, not long before being destroyed under orders from Harold Saxon.

Therefore, it isn't hard to argue that the Doctor has a serious hand in committing genocide, by wiping out the species young. Not something we’d usually see or expect from the Doctor, especially when the Racnoss young were effectively helpless.


2. The Curse Of Fenric - Using Ace As A Pawn

Doctor And Ace
BBC

When looking back, Sylvester McCoy’s Seventh Doctor is the first incarnation which could truly be considered dark. Although his debut Season 24 is generally very light-hearted, this era of the show takes a darker turn over the next two seasons.

The Seventh Doctor becomes the great schemer, with the scheming and willing to do things other incarnations maybe wouldn’t have done.

And in these schemes his greatest pawn was usually his companion Ace. On several occasions, including Ghost Light and the Curse of Fenric, as well as plenty of Big Finish audios, Ace is manipulated by the Doctor in order to achieve his plans.

Ace’s journey in the TARDIS was all due to a time storm caused by Fenric, to use her in their battle, something the Doctor knew but neglected to tell her, allowing the plot to move on as a part of a complex game.

A feature prominent throughout Doctor Who is that part of the Doctor’s strength comes from his friends, and this is all the truer for Ace, but not in the usual meaning. The Doctor’s companions are those closest to him and he’ll do anything to keep them safe. Sadly Ace is quite often put in harms way so that the Seventh Doctor can right wrongs in the universe.

No companion has been taken advantage of as much as the Doctor used Ace.


1. The Family Of Blood - Fates Worse Than Death

Doctor Who The Family Of Blood David Tennant
BBC Studios

“Never cruel or cowardly” is one of the moral codes the Doctor says he stands by. However, the fate he bestows upon the Family of Bloody is rather cruel…

When the Doctor defeats the Family of Blood, Son of Mine says that he now realised why the Doctor, who fought gods and monsters, had fled from them: “it was a kindness”.

After everything they had done, the Doctor shows his wrath and deals punishment upon them, a separate one for each member of the Family. They desired immortality; the Doctor would grant this wish.

Father of Mine is bound in unbreakable chains forged at the heart of a dwarf star. Mother of Mine is sent into the event horizon of a collapsing galaxy, where she is imprisoned forever. Sister of Mine is trapped in every mirror in existence, where, once a year, the Doctor visits. Finally, Son of Mine is suspended in time and dressed as a scarecrow to watch over the fields of England.

At the end of all these fates, death maybe would have been kinder on them. This was the time the Doctor showed that he could be cruel, and that sometimes you shouldn’t cross the Last of the Time Lords.


Watch Next


Doctor Who Quiz: Which Doctor Said It? - Obscure Quotes

BBC

1. “Oh, Please, Don’t Call Me Human. Just Doctor Will Do Very Nicely, Thank You.”

Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a simple man, trying to make my way in the universe