10 Tragically Romantic Doctor Who Episodes

Hoping for a romantic evening with the Doctor? Best prepare for tears instead...

Doctor Who Amy Rory The Girl Who Waited
BBC

Let’s be honest, Doctor Who is not the most romantic show. Yes, there’s the beauty of the universe, but sooner or later we all know that the Doctor will be trouble and that candle-lit dinner is going to be interrupted by Daleks, Yetis, or the Master. It’s pretty inevitable.

The show itself hasn’t really included romantic relationships until recently, anyway. A companion getting married usually meant the end of their adventures in the classic series, and the Doctor himself never had a serious love interest. Modern Doctor Who changed all that, allowing both the Timelord and his companions to have more substantial relationships. Unfortunately, a lot of these relationships, especially where the Doctor is concerned, end tragically - that’s the problem with dating during an invasion.

Nevertheless, with Valentine’s Day in mind, we wanted to give you some romantic Who moments, sad or not.

So, snuggle up on the sofa, grab a box of tissues and check out this list, in no particular order, of ten tragically romantic episodes. Be warned there are spoilers ahead!

10. Daleks In Manhattan/Evolution Of The Daleks

Laszlo and Tallulah daleks in manhattan
BBC

This story set in 1930s New York, sees the feisty singer Tallulah and the loyal stagehand Laszlo join forces with the Doctor and Martha to stop the Daleks.

A well-established couple that is very much in love, Laszlo and Tallulah get on great together. Lazlo is even inviting Tallulah to meet his mother. Unfortunately, when the pair part backstage so Tallulah can go perform her song, Laszlo is kidnapped by the Daleks pig slaves. Despite this awful turn of events, the now partly pig Laszlo continues to visit and leave flowers for his girl, while Tallulah, sure that he isn’t the sort of guy to just run off, still holds out hope for him returning.

She is correct of course, and thanks to the Doctor, the two meet up again in the sewers. Tallulah is saddened by what has happened to her boyfriend, but ultimately his transformation doesn’t change anything between them.

The pair manage to survive their adventure with the Daleks, and by the episode’s end, the couple are still together, with Laszlo finding refuge with the homeless in Central Park - proving that becoming part pig is the least a couple has to worry about in the Doctor Who universe.


9. Blink

Doctor Who Blink Weeping Angels
BBC Studios

The story that famously introduced the Weeping Angels in the world, also introduced Sally Sparrow to Larry Nightingale.

While the pair had met before, their adventure with the Doctor and the angels is what really brings them closer together, as they decode the Timelord’s messages and find his TARDIS. It is obvious to anyone that a romance is blossoming between them as they deal with these strange circumstances. Unfortunately, this new love comes at a cost, as it’s not only the Doctor who connects them.

Larry’s sister, Cathy, becomes a victim of the angels when she goes exploring an abandoned house with Sally. By the time Sally receives a letter from Cathy, via her grandson, she has already died.

It is mainly this tragedy, you could argue, that draws Larry and Sally together. After all, who else is going to know, let alone understand, how it feels to have someone you care about thrown back in time? It is a bittersweet fact that loss, as well as love, can draw us together.


8. The Pilot

Doctor Who The Pilot Heather Bill
BBC

The first outing for Bill Potts and the Twelfth Doctor sees Bill being chased by a type of alien engine oil, when it takes over the body of fellow student Heather.

Unlike the other entries on this list, this episode features a thwarted crush, rather than an actual coupling. While it is apparent that Bill has the hots for Heather, the two girls have very little chance to really connect before the poor girl is possessed by an alien. Nonetheless, it’s the beginnings of this connection that end up driving the alien force. It now follows Bill everywhere, throughout time and space, determined to keep a promise made by Heather - to not go without her. It is only by telling her to go that Bill frees herself from it. The moment is still tragic though, not only for the potential love Bill loses, but because she is actually tempted to go see the universe with Heather, even doubting her choice for a second, in the Doctor’s study.

Luckily, everything ends pretty happily, as the Doctor offers to take her travelling instead, hinting that they will find Heather again one day.


7. The Girl in the Fireplace

The Girl In The Fireplace 346
BBC

This episode from the second season sees the Tenth Doctor meeting Madame De Pompadour, or Reinette, after he discovers time-windows into her life on a spaceship.

He meets her first as a young girl, but when he returns to find an adult Reinette, the French noblewoman quickly takes a liking to the Timelord. The Doctor seems to fall for her too with each meeting. They especially bond when he has to shift through her memories, and clever woman she is, she is able to see his mind too. Reinette realises the Doctor feels lonely, and insists he come dance with her at the ball.

Eventually the Doctor stops the horde of clockwork robots by literally riding in on a white horse to save her, but ends up trapping himself in the past in the process. Luckily, he is able to get back to the spaceship. However, this is where the tragedy comes. There is a time difference between Reinette and the spaceship, with hours on the ship translating into weeks, months and years. So, when the Doctor returns, time has passed and she has died - leaving only with a letter asking that he come back soon.


6. Voyage of the Damned

Doctor Who Astrid Peth Voyage of the Damned
BBC Studios

This Christmas special sees the Doctor meet up with Astrid, a waitress who works on a star ship called the Titanic.

There are some charming moments between the Doctor and Astrid in this episode. He comes to her defence after a rude passenger tells her off, and then manages to sneak her to Earth on shore leave. So, it’s not surprising that Astrid starts to become fond of the Doctor, flirting a little and eventually asking to come travelling with him – to which he happily agrees. As usual though, things go wrong, as the ship is struck by meteors. The Doctor, Astrid, and a small band of the passengers survive the smash, but then have to stop the ship from crashing into Earth. It’s a dangerous task, and most of the group die, including Astrid, when she goes to save the Doctor.

Most sad of all is a scene where, for a moment, the Doctor thinks he can bring her back through her teleport bracelet. There isn’t enough power however, and so instead he simply kisses her goodbye and then lets her atoms float off into space, so she can travel as she wished.


5. Demons Of Punjab

Doctor Who Demons of the Punjab
BBC

This episode sees the Doctor doing something rather risky – going back into a companion’s history – as she takes Yaz to see her grandmother Umbreen when she was young. When they end up at Umbreen’s home in the Punjab in 1947, it is revealed that the man her grandmother is about to marry isn’t her grandfather, a man called Prem.

Unlike some of the other episodes on this list, the romance in Demons of the Punjab really is the heart of the story. It also personalises the historical events and creates big emotional and personal stakes for Yaz. As an audience you can sense the tragedy coming, as you realise something has either gone wrong with time, or something awful is going to happen to Prem – and of course it does, he gets shot.

This story really does have a different emotional impact. It is a story of two normal people in love, who are ripped apart by the real political events, rather than the fictional monsters. The episode is far more grounded, and more like a historical drama in this sense, but that’s what makes it so good.


4. Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead

Doctor Who Silence In The Library River Song David Tennant Alex Kingston
BBC Studios

This is a double whammy for the TARDIS team, as both Donna and the Doctor end the episode having lost someone important to them.

Donna, having been saved by the library system, ends up in a virtual world where she is introduced to a sweet man called Lee, who has a stammer. The two get together, marry, and even have children. It’s your typical, lovely romance that ends with a happy family life, but of course Donna soon realises it’s all virtual reality – or so she thinks. When she is returned to reality Donna is unable to find her husband in the crowd, and merely assumes he was made up, like her children. However, the audience sees that he is real, and in a cruel twist of fate, his stutter prevents him from calling to Donna before she leaves.

The Doctor, meanwhile, has just had to witness the death of River Song, who has hinted that she is someone very important to him. The scene takes on more potency when re-watched now, since the entire backstory of River has been revealed and we all know that she is, in fact, his wife. All in all, it's a very sad ending.


3. The Husbands of River Song

Doctor Who The Husbands of River Song
BBC Studios

The poor Doctor, thanks to time-travel has to say goodbye to his wife twice, once at the library and again here, when he sees her for the last time before she dies. It’s confusing.

This episode is a fun romp, as River does not recognise the Doctor with his new face. She assumes she has met all of his incarnations, and even has the wallet photos to prove it! So, Twelve is stuck running around after her, hoping she’ll catch on; whilst also watching her snog other guys and pretend to be the wife of an evil king so she can steal a diamond off him. While this might not sound romantic, the banter and chemistry between them is excellent. The scene where River realises who the Doctor is, after declaring that he wouldn’t care enough to be there in danger with her, is marvellous. That’s when the Doctor gets to say ‘hello sweetie’ for a change.

The date the Doctor takes her on, with the sparkling lights and singing towers is gorgeous, and comes with a final twist. This might be the last night the Doctor spends with River, but it will be a night that lasts twenty-four years.


2. The Girl Who Waited

Doctor Who Amy Rory The Girl Who Waited
BBC

Amy and Rory were a fantastic couple, the best probably on the show, but wow they went through some bumpy times in the TARDIS! Perhaps none more so in this episode where due to a time difference, Amy is accidentally abandoned for thirty-six years.

This episode demonstrates how genuine and strong the bond is between Rory and Amy. Rory doesn’t care that Amy is old when he sees her again, only that ‘we didn’t grow old together’, and it’s Amy’s love for him that persuades her to change her future and rewrite time. There’s a great scene where the past Amy speaks to her future self, and they talk about how a person’s personality can make them beautiful. They agree that Rory is the most beautiful person they know.

Of course, there is a caveat. Old Amy wants to go with them in the TARDIS. The Doctor lies and says yes to this, only to shut her out of the TARDIS. When Rory protests, the Doctor tells him to choose one to save. Fortunately, old Amy makes the choice, and tells Rory not to open the door. It’s a real emotional test for the couple, and a truly heart-breaking moment.


1. The Family Of Blood

Ten Joan Redfern Human Nature
BBC

This two-parter was based on the Virgin book of the same name, and sees the Doctor turn himself human to hide from a family of aliens intent on using him to help extend their lifespans.

This romance is one of the best on show. There is enough time for it to develop and allow the audience to become invested, without it feeling rushed or slow; even with everything else going on in the plot. Meanwhile, the Doctor as John is able to express his love and affectation far more openly than he does as a Timelord. In fact, you could say the relationship is more human in nature, excuse the pun, compared to the Doctor’s other couplings.

This makes sense, since after all, John Smith is not really the Doctor. He is an alternate human version of the Timelord – which, is of course where the great tragedy lies. The Doctor has to return to stop the monsters, but that in effect means John Smith must be wiped away. This creates a truly difficult moral dilemma, and it is painful to see John and Joan sacrifice their love, and John’s life, for the Doctor.


In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

A freelance writer and Doctor Who fan.