10 TV Characters Killed In Desperate Attempts To Boost Ratings

Nothing like the brutal death of a beloved character to keep audiences happy!

Brian Death Family Guy
Fox

Television is unique in the world of entertainment, mainly because it doesn't necessarily set out with an end goal or final date immediately in mind. Whereas a film needs everything condensed in the time it takes someone to devour some popcorn, a TV show can basically go on for as long as a studio wants it to.

Whilst this can obviously have some great benefits for fans who get to binge through hours upon hours of their favourite shows, for a writer it can pose some significant challenges. Keeping interests peaked is the aim of the game with television, and ultimately stands as the thing that will decide whether a show is on air or not after all.

Sadly, it's pretty clear that the more episodes of something are made, the harder it becomes to think of genuinely original and exciting storylines that keep pulling in decent viewership and reception ratings.

One way to overcome this slump in ratings is by throwing in some wild and desperate deaths to some high-profile names. Shows like Game of Thrones and Breaking Bad have shown the true power of a shocking TV death, however, it's safe to say that maybe that isn't the case for these other examples of characters being killed just to give the ratings a quick injection.

10. Glenn - The Walking Dead

Glenn Rhee Death The Walking Dead
AMC

The Walking Dead is one of those shows that seems to have fallen into that horrible trope of killing off a beloved character every time the ratings threaten to dip a bit too low. Special mentions go to Carl and Rick Grimes for their respective deaths (or "death" in the case of the latter), however Glenn's death at the very start of season seven was where the ratings influence really became the most apparent.

It's probably fair to say that some people were already growing tired of The Walking Dead by the time season six rolled around, with most agreeing that the show had never matched the heights of its debut season. It was still the most valuable show on AMC however, and the channel attempted to drum up the hype for its seventh season with the cliffhanger over which one the main group Negan was going to kill.

The unfortunate recipient was fan favourite Glenn Rhee, one of the few characters to have survived since the debut series. The death was almost unsettlingly bloody, and Glenn's selection was so random that it was pretty clear the show was just trying desperately to keep itself relevant by that point.


9. Will Gardner - The Good Wife

The Good Wife Josh Charles
CBS

Ever the charismatic ladies' man, Will Gardner was one of the most important characters in The Good Wife's first five seasons, with actor Josh Charles even being nominated for a Golden Globe for bringing this business hotshot to life.

It was always a franchise that had received warm enough reviews, however there was a noticeable drop in quality between seasons three and four, with some fans claiming that the show just didn't have the same pull as it once had. In order to raise the stakes, the show runners decided to have Will shot in the courtroom and establish a 'Whodunnit' storyline over who his killer was.

The results in the ratings were pretty striking too. According to IMDB, episodes fifteen and sixteen of season five (the episode of Will's death and the one immediately following it) hold a 9.4 and a 9.2 rating against the 8.2 and 8.4 on the episodes before it, showing off just how desperate the clamour was to know what had happened to this intriguing character.

However, this shock can only jolt a show for so long and the loss of arguably the most interesting male character led to a serious decline once Will's death was resolved. By the time season seven rolled around, the show had dropped to its worst-ever viewership tally and, with the absence of the complex and engrossing plotlines that come from characters like Will, the show was shelved in 2016.


8. Derek - Grey's Anatomy

Derek Shepherd Grey's Anatomy
ABC

Fans of Grey's Anatomy are certainly no stranger to an on-screen death. Plenty of fan favourite characters have bit the dust in some truly shocking and memorable ways, however few of them had the punch with both audiences and critics alike as Derek's in season eleven.

Portrayed wonderfully by Patrick Dempsey ever since the debut of the show in 2005, McDreamy had become part of the walls of the Grey Sloan Memorial Hospital and undergone his fair share of dramatic storylines over that course, most notably with his longtime partner, Meredith.

His death actually came about following the supposed happy conclusion to this relationship, with Meredith and Derek finally giving what the fans what they wanted and reconciling. Viewership figures for the show however were on the downward spiral at the same time, dropping from nearly twelve million in the US for season nine to just over nine for season ten, which spelled bad news for Derek.

After his reconciliation, Derek was involved in a shocking car crash that led to the doctor being put on a life support machine after being declared brain dead. It was undoubtedly one of, if not the, most shocking and solemn moments in the show's history at that point, however the show still hasn't managed to hit over ten million views since Derek's departure and has actually seen a fairly sharp decline since season fourteen.


7. Maude Flanders - The Simpsons

The Simpsons Maude Flanders death
20th Television

Maude Flanders had been one of the ever-presents in The Simpsons for nearly a decade by the time her end came about. Maggie Roswell had given the character her instantly recognisable voice for every episode, but off-camera issues were beginning to make the showrunners wonder whether it was feasible keeping Ned's wife around for much longer.

Roswell was growing tired of having to fly around the country to record her lines for the show and, when her request for a raise was turned down by Fox, it was clear that her time on the show had come to an end. However, this departure just so happened to be coinciding with some pretty noticeable dips in the ratings for the show and the writers decided to break the mould and actually kill off the character for good.

Maude Flanders was killed in the season eleven episode Alone Again, Natura-Diddily after a huge bundle of T-Shirts were accidentally fired at her. Though the episode was one of the more higher-rated entries into the season, The Simpsons has increasingly become known as a show in decline, with every season released being compared unfavourably to what came immediately before it, and unable to tell that it's probably time to stop now.


6. Astrid Peth - Doctor Who (New Run)

Doctor Who Astrid Peth Death
BBC

Doctor Who had a legendary status when it was rebooted in 2005, but more than lived up to that reputation with the first two seasons starring Billie Piper, Christopher Eccleston and then David Tennant.

The characters became so familiar they were almost like an extended family, the stories were exciting and quirky and the show only seemed to go from strength to strength for its first couple years back on the air. Billie Piper's departure in 2006 however marked an end to the high point for many fans.

However when that series came to an end, and Martha Jones proved she was no Rose Tyler, the show decided to go completely crazy to try and find a way of winning back the ratings. A futuristic Titanic spaceship and sinister Angel-robots made up that year's Christmas special, with Kylie Minogue jumping on board as would-be companion, Astrid Peth.

Most New Who fans probably hadn't seen Adric's demise at the end of the Fifth Doctor's Earthshock adventure, meaning that Astrid's sacrifice at the end of the Voyage Of The Damned episode was the first permanent human death they had ever seen in the show.

Sadly, the show continued to struggle to unite its fanbase in the way it had done before following the special and its choices of storylines, actors, companions and tones remain as divisive today as they ever have been.


5. The Sixth Doctor - Doctor Who (Original Run)

Sixth Doctor Colin Baker
BBC Studios

Despite the fact that he was a mega fan of the show, had appeared as a side character in one of the Fifth Doctor's stories and had plans of surpassing the legendary Tom Baker for the show's longest run as the Doctor, things never really got going for Colin Baker's Sixth Doctor.

By the time he picked up the TARDIS keys, it was clear that the show was increasingly struggling to justify itself. Budgets were increasingly slim and stories felt increasingly low quality, but the biggest crime was undoubtedly the decision to make Baker's Doctor one of the most unlikeable in the history of television.

A character who, at the start of his tenure at least, was arrogant, short-tempered, angry and even violent towards some of his friends, this one decision essentially put the nails in the coffin for the original run of the legendary series. In fact, the concerns from the BBC grew so big that they attempted to pull the show twice during Baker's two seasons as the Doctor.

In one final, desperate, attempt to save the show and its ratings, the show runners hastily fired Baker, brought in Sylvester McCoy and wrote in a regeneration story inbetween seasons. Baker, who became the show's shortest-lived Doctor at the time, wasn't even present for his death scene and the show would be cancelled just three years later in 1989.


4. Jerome Valeska - Gotham

Jerome Valeska Gotham
Fox

When Gotham first hit screens in 2014, the one character Batman fans were waiting to see was the Clown Prince of Crime himself, the Joker. Because of legal reasons, the show couldn't actually create a character and name them 'Joker' however, which led to the creation of the Valeska Twins, Jerome and Jeremiah.

Both of these characters turned into some seriously creepy villains for Bruce, Gordon and co. to deal with and both take some inspiration from classic Joker tropes of old. Jerome had his turn in the spotlight first and, whilst his portrayal as a Joker-wannabe was generally pretty well received, it didn't stop the show from slowly starting to slump in the ratings.

Luckily, the show had a twin on hand and could afford to kill off Jerome as a sort of freebie.

Jerome Valeska bows out in the episode eighteen of season four and whilst the episode and series got some favourable reviews upon release, the show continued its downward trend of critical reception and viewership figures. Eventually, these continually declining viewership numbers led to Fox declaring that the following season would be the final for the show.


3. Tara Maclay - Buffy The Vampire Slayer

Tara And Willow Buffy
Mutant Enemy

First appearing in Sunnydale in 1999 during season four of Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Amber Benson's Tara Maclay overcame some pretty nasty resistance from fans to become one of the first instances of a lesbian couple regularly appearing on prime time US television, as well as establishing herself as one of the most wholesome and likeable characters on the entire show.

Constantly the voice of reason and a symbol of overcoming one's own reservations, her magical skills and relationship with Willow made her increasingly popular as her character continued to grow and develop.

However, consensus amongst critics were beginning to note that the same couldn't be said for a lot of the other characters on the show by that point, especially Willow, which was contributing to the show's slow slip down the ratings.

Tara was killed by a stray bullet near the end of the sixth season, triggering a vengeful rampage from Willow that the series had never really experimented with before. One of only a handful characters from the show to have never been resurrected, Tara's death was as controversial with the fans as it was absolutely gut-wrenching to watch.

Sadly however the show was already in a spiral it couldn't get out of, and the seventh season for the show proved to be the worst received, least viewed and final one to date in the main run.


2. Russell 'Stringer' Bell - The Wire

The Wire Stringer Bell
HBO

Before he emerged as the James Bond that everyone wants, Idris Elba was Russell 'Stringer' Bell in The Wire, a drug kingpin who stands out from most of his fellow traffickers on the show thanks to his educated background and approach to gang culture.

Elba shines throughout his portrayal and Stringer is undoubtedly one of the most complex and intriguing characters in the show, however The Wire is notorious for how it was never received as well as it should have been at the time, and these middling ratings ended up contributing to Stringer being killed off in season three.

Though Stringer's demise was shocking enough to help the series carry on solidly throughout the fourth season, it was clear that interest in keeping the series was beginning to decline. The ratings at the time weren't booming in the way HBO had hoped, and the final series for the show was forced to water itself down from thirteen episodes in season four to just ten in season five.

Viewership for season five was the lowest the franchise had seen, only surpassing one million views four times out of the ten episodes at the time, perhaps showing that the decision to take out such a strong performer in Elba and a brilliant character in Stringer was not necessarily the right one.


1. Brian - Family Guy

Family Guy Brian Death
20th Century Fox

Easily the most infamous of any controversial TV death, the level of attention and outcry Brian's death got following the season twelve Family Guy episode 'Life of Brian' was unlike anything seen before. This cartoon canine's death came about from a rogue hit-and-run courtesy of a reckless driver, after Stewie decided that he was going to stop travelling back in time to change the course of past events.

The episode not only brought with it huge waves of opposition from fans, criticism directed at everyone from the production staff to Seth MacFarlane, but it also helped to create one of the largest Change.org petition ever with 120,000 signatories in just a couple of days.

Unlike other TV shows in this list, Family Guy wasn't necessarily on the way out when The Life of Brian aired, but the whole controversy certainly turned out to be one of the best moves the show could have ever made in breathing in new interest from its fanbase.

Viewership rose from 5.2 million average viewers at the start of the series to 6.37 for the episode immediately after The Life of Brian and it was the highest rated episode of season twelve. However, if the show's more recent stodgy numbers are anything to go by, fans could be in store for more resurrection storylines courtesy of Seth and co.


Watch Next


Quiz: How Well Do You REALLY Know Family Guy?

Family Guy Beer
Fox

1. What Is The Name Of The Beer Served In Quahog?

Contributor
Contributor

Horror fan, gamer, all round subpar content creator. Strongly believes that Toad is the real hero of the Mario universe, and that we've probably had enough Batman origin stories.