10 TV Characters Viewers Completely Changed Their Mind About

Who'd have thought they'd end up like that?

Television is an underrated and difficult medium. Each season allows time for a full story arc to develop and conclude in a calendar year (offering closure to the viewer), while a show's continuation over multiple seasons allows characters themselves a similar opportunity to grow. With proper character development, actions viewers would see as out of character in Season 2 may seem par for the course in Season 7. Consequently, show runners are saddled with a Herculean task - they must maintain enough of the character viewers initially fell in love with to satiate the audience, while pushing to develop them to prevent the character from feeling stagnant. It is a delicate balancing act to perform. For instance, over five seasons Breaking Bad transformed a mild-mannered family man and high school science teacher into a crystal-meth producing kingpin, responsible for killing dozens and ruining the lives of countless others. The show's ability to have this progression feel natural to viewers (or as natural as the previous sentence could feel) is one of the reasons it is considered by many to be the greatest show of all time. Conversely, each of Dexter's eight seasons offered diminishing returns, as the character's choices and motivations became muddled and confusing. So to honour the idea of change, here are 10 characters viewers changed their mind about. SPOILERS throughout for the uninitiated.

10. Carol Peletier - The Walking Dead

Few characters experience the drastic change Carol has on The Walking Dead. Introduced to audiences as a meek mother of Sophia and battered wife to the despicable Ed, Carol rarely registers with the audience as a character. In fact, much of the first two seasons find Carol relegated to the background. Completely inert, her inaction and helplessness defined her existence to viewers for almost half of the show. It takes the death of Ed and Sophia in Seasons 1 and 2, respectively, for Peletier to shed her persona and become something new. The Carol we see after the time jump between Seasons 2 and 3 is a different woman. Self-assured, capable, and deadly, Carol has become a leader, a trusted voice and a contributor to the group. Her increased confidence and belief that hard decisions must be made (and that she is the woman to make them) led to her to shocking acts in Season 4, decisions that left viewers divided. Was Carol too far gone? That was certainly up for debate. Yet regardless of which side viewers came down on, they could recognise these were the actions of a new woman, a woman no longer relegated to the sidelines or disregarded. A woman that now defines her existence by action, and not cowering just out of shot.

9. Gaius Baltar - Battlestar Galactica

It is entirely possible Battlestar Galactica's Gaius Baltar experienced a severe case of whiplash in his journey from heel to hero. At different points in the show, Baltar was considered a traitor to the human race, saviour of the human race, an incompetent and corrupt politician, and Christ-like leader of a revolutionary movement. The show's writers continually dumped a metric ton of character development and regression on Baltar over four seasons and a miniseries. And he somehow survived each advancement and retraction, all with his patented arrogance and flair. In fact, Baltar's transformation on the show comes late in the series. Only after he lets go of his incredible arrogance and understands his predestined role in the BSG world does he truly change. Gaius is not the ultimate demise of the human race, and he is not the revered saviour of the new colonies - he is simply a cog in the machine and a piece of the story in something set to be repeated throughout history.

8. Boyd Crowder - Justified

In many cases, the evolution of a character is simply the result of an actor€™s talents. Initially slated to die at the end of the pilot episode of Justified, audiences have instead found themselves transfixed by Walton Goggins' portrayal of Bowd Crowder over five seasons of the show. In interviews, Goggins admits he was hesitant to take the role of the racist hillbilly who blows up a black church with a rocket launcher. He only agreed when producers allowed him to tweak the character, and play up the schemer in Boyd. The decision to keep the charismatic Goggins on board allowed Boyd to become the most interesting character of the series. Boyd's near death experience in the pilot leads to a spiritual awakening, and watching Crowder consistently struggle with the man he is and the man he wants to be is fascinating, and often heartbreaking. And while Crowder does eventually give in to his fate and return to a life of crime, he is now well-read, well-spoken, and well-versed in the art of manipulation, as well as often being the most intelligent man in the room.

7. Rachel Green - Friends

To be fair, the (almost) Mrs. Barry Farber, DDS is introduced to viewers as an already-reforming gold digger. While certainly still possessing vapid and shallow tendencies, Green's abandoning of her engagement to the dentist (because she was more attracted to a gravy boat than her fiancé) in the pilot set off a chain reaction of events. After her disappearing bride act, she moves in with Monica, is cut off financially by her family, and begins working as a waitress at Central Perk. Leaving Barry at the altar was the catalyst for her core reinvention. The Rachel Green we meet in the pilot is a far cry from the woman she will become, and by the end of the show's 10 seasons, Rachel is a mother, and more importantly, a self-made woman who worked her way through the ranks of the fashion world under her own steam.

6. Bill Compton - True Blood

Anything is possible in the wild world of True Blood. The pseudo-soap opera is a fun, pulpy rollercoaster that constantly threatens to fly off the rails, and character motivations seem to change weekly. Nobody embodies this trend more than Bill Compton. Introduced in the pilot episode as a Vampire Romeo to Sookie Stackhouse's Juliet, Bill is a kind-hearted southern gentleman who long ago decided to "mainstream". Bill respects life, both human and vampire, and quickly becomes a sort of Vampire ambassador for the small town of Bon Temps, LA. But over six seasons, he mutates into a vicious, audacious monster. His turn as King of Louisiana is marred by betrayal and bloodshed, and a convoluted storyline involving Vampire Biblical text and militaristic machinations sees Bill gain increased powers. He achieves a near God-like state from drinking an ancient vial of blood of Lilith, the Vampire God, meaning that his turnaround involves more than simply an identity crisis - his core beliefs and values fundamentally change, which is certainly heavy stuff for a tawdry drama. In Season 6, the creators' decision to have Bill cede those powers and return to a more compassionate form brought the character full circle, and seem to be building to a complete redemption arc in the series' upcoming final season. But in the eyes of many viewers the damage was done, and Bill will always be a monster.

5. Andy Dwyer - Parks and Recreation

The cast of Parks and Recreation could rightfully comprise this entire list. The characters viewers have grown to love for their warmth and positivity bare little resemblance to their Season 1 counterparts, whose introduction to audiences is little more than a screechy, unfunny Office knockoff. The most egregious offender, though, is Andy Dwyer. A poor man's Jack Black, Dwyer spends much of Season One as a buffoonish, boorish jerk. Insensitive to his girlfriend's wants or needs, he's pretty much a hollow caricature of a character. His breakup with Ann was a catalyst for change, and the character developed a vulnerability and softness that viewers began to respond to. However, following this plotline the show struggled to find ways to incorporate the talented Chris Pratt into the world of small government. It wasn't until the show paired him off with April that the Andy Dwyer audiences love took form. The show found a way to utilise Pratt's natural charisma, and the hilarious, big-hearted Dwyer viewers fell in love with arrived.

4. William 'Spike' Pratt - Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Fan favuorite William "Spike" Pratt was introduced to audiences as a widely-feared and brutal killer. His nickname was derived from his favorite torture weapon of choice, the railroad spike. He had killed two previous slayers before arriving in Sunnydale. In fact, the only vampire more feared that Spike was Angelus, so needless to say, a redemptive arc for Pratt seemed unlikely. But while Spike certainly accumulated an impressive body count during the early years of the show, his status over seven seasons changed completely. Beginning as Sunnydale's resident bad boy, by the series finale he had transformed into a self-sacrificing servant to the cause, earning kudos and shedloads of love from the audience. In fact, viewers later discovered that Pratt's other nickname "William the Bloody" came not from his merciless nature, but was in fact a derisive commentary on his "bloody awful" poetry. It was an important lesson to fans of the show. Disregard your parents' advice, because bad boys can change, and all it takes is true love*. *Note: That is definitely not all it takes.

3. Dennis "Cutty" Wise - The Wire

Few characters on the critically-acclaimed HBO show The Wire experience significant personal growth. In fact, a macro point of the show seems to be people are who they are. It has always been like this, and it always will be. One of the few exceptions that proves the rule is Dennis Wise, or "Cutty". Viewers are first introduced to Cutty as he is released from prison after a 14 year sentence. His reputation as a killer, and a company man, is rewarded with an opportunity to resume his previous life of crime. But when Cutty has the chance to retaliate against a man who robbed him, he finds himself unable to pull the trigger. He decides to take low paying landscape work and invest his time and efforts into the community. Watching Cutty transform from a brutal killer to surrogate father and boxing coach for neighbourhood kids allows viewers a respite from the heavier story lines. It is a small breath of fresh air for viewers before they delve back into the darkness.

2. Rickety Cricket - It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia

Has a man of the cloth ever fallen this far? Nicknamed for the huge leg braces worn during adolescence, Matthew "Rickety Cricket" Mara is introduced to audiences as a kind and pious priest, confounded by the request of his former high school tormentors to bless a water spot in The Gang's bar. And over the next nine seasons, Rickety Cricket becomes a reoccuring victim of manipulation and humiliation befitting the show's aesthetic. A short list of the tragedies that befall Mara: he quits the priesthood, becomes homeless, becomes addicted to cocaine, has his legs broken by the mob, is hunted by Dennis and Mac for a very specific humiliation, has part of his throat slashed in a wresting match, and is stabbed in the arm with a hatchet. And that's the abbreviated version. All of this may sound more horrifying than humorous, but It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia somehow finds the comedy in tragedy, allowing the viewers to laugh at this mountain of misfortune without losing sleep.

1. Theon Greyjoy / Reek - Game of Thrones (TV Version)

For all intents and purposes, Theon Greyjoy is no more. In his stead, we find Reek, the castrated, near-mute servant and shell-shocked torture victim of Roose Bolton's bastard Ramsay Snow. Greyjoy certainly was no saint, but for television audiences unfamiliar with the character's novelised fate, seeing how far he had fallen packed a devastating blow. Introduced to viewers as arrogant and impulsive, but ultimately good, Theon's reactionary nature and violent tendencies begin to overshadow his friendship and alliance with Robb Stark. As his arrogant need for recognition and belonging increase, so do his sins. He betrays his best friend, ties himself to his estranged father and begins his descent into complete and utter tool-dom. His bungled taking of Winterfell and the staged "murder" of the remaining Stark boys seal his fate. His outnumbered men, having no respect for their leader and simply wanting to go home, betray him and turn him over to Ramsay Snow. They're flayed in short order, but that's no consolation to the Ironborn heir. The torture he suffers at the hands of Snow in immeasurable, and all sense of his former hubris and humanity are stripped away. He is at this point little more than a de-clawed, defeated pet. And as such, Ramsay renames his new pet Reek, after the stench now attached to the former "Prince of Winterfell". It's one hell of a descent from the cocky, strutting Theon of before. This is certainly not a comprehensive list, though. What are other characters audiences changed their mind about? Let us know in the comments below.

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

He writes half-baked novels and twitter fiction. He makes short films for contests. He plays mostly unheard music. He painted something once, and it was... okay. A lover of all things pop culture, a master of none, Stephen nevertheless will continue his pursuit to become a modern-day renaissance man. And post it all at stephenstories.com