10 TV Shows That Switched Main Characters

A series finale may not be the only time you say goodbye to beloved characters.

Homeland TV Show
Showtime

A television show can have as original and interesting a concept as it wants, but what keeps the viewers coming back, and what will always be remembered, is the characters.

In writing classes, you are told that television viewership retention is the lowest in any creative medium. Where films and video games often have the opening twenty minutes to convince the audience to carry on with it, television scripts are given just the opening five minutes to really grab the attention of the audience before they are likely to turn off.

A strong lead character can make all the difference in that respect.

Whether it is their personality or an immediate action, a great protagonist will invite a viewer to become attached to them, but will also allow them to live in that fictional world vicariously. Seeing Rick Grimes explore an apocalyptic wasteland for the first time allows the audience to journey through the world of The Walking Dead right alongside him.

Television with multiple seasons can be huge commitments though. Many television shows, whether thanks to decisions in the writer's room, real-world controversies or the actor simply growing tired of playing the same role year after year, are forced into the most drastic change any series can undertake: passing the position of lead onto a different character. Sometimes it works, but sometimes, it's as much of a gamble as you'd think.

Beware major spoilers ahead.

10. The Walking Dead

Rick Daryl The Walking Dead
Gene Page/AMC

Adapted from Robert Kirkman's 2004 comic book series of the same name, The Walking Dead was always Rick Grimes' story. Yes, the show had to compensate for an ever-growing cast and so Rick would be entirely missing in episodes that explored other subplots, but Rick has still featured in the second most episodes of the entire show.

After awaking from his coma and finding his family at the Atalanta camp in season 1, Rick quickly became the leader of their group, and this stayed in place the entire way through the show. Although they would enter other communities with existing hierarchies, it was Rick that all would eventually turn to keep them alive and safe.

Andrew Lincoln's performance is undoubtedly incredible, portraying Rick's joys and despairs and quickly creating a character that all TWD fans loved. Real-world responsibilities caught up with Lincoln, and his duties to his young family outweighed his ambitions with The Walking Dead.

Initially wishing to be killed off in season 8, Lincoln was convinced to stick around to give the character a proper send-off. He agreed and was last seen being choppered away to parts unknown in S09E05, and the baton for the lead role was passed on to co-star Daryl Dixon (played by Norman Reedus).


9. Narcos

Narcos Pablo Escobar
Netflix

In one of Netflix's earliest original series, Narcos follows Colombian druglord as he murdered his way to the top of South America's cocaine trade. Season 1 begins in the late '70s, when Escobar first began manufacturing the drug, which quickly garnered the attention of both the Colombian military and the USA's Drug Enforcement Administration.

Hunted by DEA Agent Steve Murphy, Escobar expands his business and even begins exporting cocaine to Miami before his capture and imprisonment, with season 1 ending with his escape from captivity.

The series goes on to depict just how much of a frightening presence Pablo Escobar truly became in Colombia - soldiers even refused to arrest him after his escape - as Escobar ascends to a strange godhood in his hometown of Medellin. Escobar began pumping money into the community, creating new housing and football fields and was even alleged to have funded some children's football teams.

Raking in an exorbitant $70 million a day, Pablo Escobar's time was limited. He was eventually tracked down and killed by the Colombian military and the DEA, and season 3 of Narcos would go on to show the DEA's war against an entirely different cartel.

The show is now set to reboot entirely, being dubbed Narcos: Mexico, just going to show that some main character switches spell the end.


8. Game Of Thrones

Game Of Thrones Ned Stark Hand Of The King
HBO

Whether it be Jon's travels North of the Wall, Dani's journey through Essos or the in-fighting of the Lannisters in King's Landing, the television adaptation of George R.R. Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire novels features a stellar ensemble cast.

It is reasonable to say, however, that season 1 painted the main character out to be Ned Stark, patriarch of the Stark family.

Played by Sean Bean, Ned Stark is the warden of the North, residing in Winterfell when he is approached by his old friend, King Robert Baratheon, about becoming the new Hand of the King. Ned begrudgingly accepts, departing for the capital with his daughters, Sansa and Arya, leaving behind his wife and the rest of his children.

Ned becomes a central element to all of the misdeeds and corruption that the Lannister family has to offer. Ned discovers the truth about Queen Cersie and her brother, Jaime, and threatens to expose them. It is this key event that is the catalyst for much of the story of Game of Thrones. It is also the event that leads to his death.

Viewers were shocked to witness Ned Stark's execution in the penultimate episode of the first season, and the mantle of 'lead character' was henceforth to be shared amongst the cast.


7. Homeland

Homeland Season 3
Showtime

When Homeland first aired, there was no individual lead character. Instead, the show had two key main antagonists: Carrie Matheson (Claire Danes) and Nicholas Brody (Damian Lewis). The early plot has Matheson, a CIA officer, tasked with uncovering a potential double-agent that is plotting a terrorist attack in the heart of America. Brody, a Marine that had just been retrieved from the captivity of Al-Qaeda, is her prime suspect.

Her suspicion of him turns out to be correct: Brody had planned to assassinate the Vice President by detonating a suicide vest but faltered after a conversation with his daughter.

Brody adapts to living in the United States once more, but after a terrorist attack is carried out on Langley - the headquarters of the CIA - the blame is pinned on the former Marine, and Matheson must work to prove his innocence. After completing a dangerous assignment for the CIA - the assassination of Iranian Intelligence Chief, Danesh Akbari, so that the CIA may replace him with one of their own assets - Brody is captured and publicly executed by the Iran military.

Homeland creator Alex Gansa claimed that Brody was always going to be killed off, but they became sure that Homeland would survive the death of one of its two leading characters due to the strength of Carrie Matheson's premise.


6. The Hogan Family

Valerie's Family
NBC

This is a prime example as to why making the name of the main character be the same as the name of the show - also known as an eponymous character - might not always be a wise decision. The Hogan Family had originally been named Valerie and revolved around Valerie Hogan (to be known as VH in this entry to avoid confusion).

The sitcom had always been based around the Hogan's, a standard family dealing with the day-to-day life of raising a family and juggling a career. The show was a critical success, and the viewership quickly spiked after a move to a prime-time slot on Monday nights. Actress Valerie Harper (playing Valerie, just to add to the confusion), whose husband Tony Cacciotti worked on the show as a producer, assumed greater creative control over the show, and in the period between seasons 2 and 3, the duo approached the NBC about a pay bump.

What followed was a well-documented, messy legal fight between Harper/Cacciotti and the NBC. This constant back-and-forth ultimately led to Harper's termination from the show, with her character being killed off off-screen. The show was subsequently re-branded twice with the emphasis being on the remnants of her family. It would carry on for a further 4 seasons before abysmal ratings led to its cancellation.


5. The Office (US)

Michael Scott The Office
NBC

What is regarded as one of the most beloved television shows of recent history (and the superior to its British counterpart), The Office (US) is based in the Dunder Mifflin Paper Company, with Michael Scott (played by Steve Carell) as the branch manager.

The show certainly makes the most of its diverse and entertaining cast, with some viewers tuning in solely for certain characters or subplots (i.e. the 'will-they-won't-they' between Jim and Pam) and Michael certainly earned a large following all of his own. The Office did superbly in keeping its core cast together for its entire nine-season tenure, with starring characters such as Dwight, Jim, Pam, and Stanley being constant features. Carell's, Michael Scott, however, would call it quits at the end of season 7.

There was no malice in Carell's departure from the show: he has stated previously that he always intended to see out his original contract, and his character was written out as having been offered a new job in a different state.

The Office would continue for another couple of seasons, opting against replacing Michael with a new branch manager and instead relying on the pre-established cast. Seasons 8 and 9 saw a significant drop in ratings and viewership, showing that despite its stellar ensemble cast, Michael Scott was the heart of The Office.


4. Vikings

ragnar rollo bjorn vikings
History

Delving into Norse legends we find Ragnar Lothbrok, King of Denmark and Sweden, raider of England and France, and the lead protagonist of the History Channel's historical drama 'Vikings'.

Vikings depicts Ragnar Lothbrok's rise to power in 9th Century Scandinavia. Having organised raids to the West against the wishes of Earl of Haraldson, who sees no reason the cease their raids in the Eastern Baltic, Ragnar takes a crew of volunteers and lands on the shores of England, where they immediately sack a monastery.

Ragnar combats all adversaries both in foreign lands they are invading and in the hierarchy of his own people, eventually becoming King of Kattegat. After losing a battle in Paris, Ragnar disappears for a decade, leaving his family and kingdom to fend for themselves.

After returning to England once again, Ragnar is taken captive by King Ecbert and handed over to King Aella, who intends to torture Ragnar and convert him to Christianity. Ragnar refuses and is subsequently killed when Aella has him thrown into a pit of poisonous snakes.

Vikings continued with new emphasis being placed on the warring between his ex-wife, Lagertha, and his surviving children, Bjorn, Ubbe, Hvitserk, and Ivar. Partway through season 6 at the time of writing, Vikings has continued to see stellar ratings and retained a high viewership.


3. House Of Cards

10 Claire Frank Underwood
whatculture

If you've kept up with recent industry news at all then you had to have expected this to pop up.

In Netflix's first-ever original release on their streaming service, we have House of Cards, the story of an ambitious congressman, Frank Underwood (played by Kevin Spacey), as he divulges in the dirty underbelly of politics to gain an advantage on his opposition. Manipulation, blackmail, murder: nothing is off-limits as Frank Underwood aspires to become President.

By the end of the second season, Frank has been sworn in as President, but he must keep all of his shady business under wraps if he has any chance of staying in the White House and out of prison. Frank, alongside his wife, Claire, endorse shady international deals, become embroiled in terrorist plots, have political adversaries and other opponents assassinated (or do the killing themselves) and even declare war to keep themselves in power.

Following the real-world allegations of sexual misconduct levelled against Kevin Spacey, the production of season six was suspended and Spacey was fired from the show. Season six begins one hundred days into now lead character Claire Underwood's term as President, with Frank having been killed off-screen.

Season six would be the final season of the show, although whether this is because of Spacey's misconduct or the low ratings is up in the air.


2. Two And A Half Men

Charlie Harper
CBS

Much loved sitcom Two and a Half Men first aired in 2003 and would go on for twelve seasons. Initially hollowing Charlie Harper (played by Charlie Sheen), a very wealthy jingle writer living the high life in Malibu, and his more unfortunate brother, Alan, who is forced to move in with Charlie following his divorce.

The duo's hijinks would bring a tear to your eye and laughter to your side, supported by a terrific cast of recurring characters and guest appearances. All good things must come to an end though.

Charlie Sheen has long been a figure of notoriety in Hollywood, and this notoriety caught up to him. During the filming of season eight, Sheen entered a drug rehabilitation facility three times in the space of a year, leading show-runners to eventually give up on the iconic actor and terminate his contract before season nine. Sheen made many public appearances slating those in charge as well as some of the cast and even entered a legal battle with Warner Bros.

Charlie Harper was killed in an accident off-screen, and so wealthy benefactor Walden Schmidt (played by Ashton Kutcher would purchase the house and continue to allow Alan to live with there to maintain as much continuity as possible. It didn't matter though, as viewership and ratings plummeted.


1. Misfits

Misfits Gif
Tumblr

Where in other entries I have focused on the standout member of an ensemble cast, for this entry I will be looking at the entire original main cast.

Based on the strange superpowers people gained after a freak lightning strike, Misfits focuses on a group of young delinquents performing community service. The five developing powers including telepathy, rewinding time, invisibility, invincibility, and making people uncontrollably horny. No, seriously.

In the aftermath of these new abilities, Kelly kills their probation officer, Tony, in self-defence after he had been driven mad by his own power. In their attempts at covering up his death, Simon accidentally kills Tony's replacement, Sally. The group decides that from that point forward, the group must keep their powers concealed.

Interactions throughout the opening seasons largely consist of issues with other super-powered people. As of season four, Alisha has died in their current reality, Simon has travelled back in time, Kelly has moved to Africa and Nathan has been put in prison for attempting to defraud a casino, leaving Curtis as the only remaining character.

The cast is replaced with a new group of troubled youths serving their own community service. Partway through season four, however, Curtis too would be killed off, and season five would conclude the series with the cast introduced just one season prior.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Homeland
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lover of all things zombie. Secretly wishing for the apocalypse, but only on easy difficulty. Top of the world leaderboards for a couple of songs on Pro Drums on Rock Band 4. Can name every world flag. Currently doing my MA in Creative Writing in an attempt to do something with my life.