10 TV Shows To Fill That Doctor Who Shaped Void

If not Who, then what?

Life can be separated into two periods. When Doctor Who is running and when it€™s not. Between seasons it€™s as if there is only half a weekend. Saturday evenings mock you with their lack of Who-ness and the enforced abstinence seems to never end. There are two ways to deal with this, endure or look for a substitute. The genuine article may be off air while the cast and crew work on the next season, but that doesn€™t mean you can€™t watch another show in the mean time. Choose wisely and you€™ll soon be back highlighting the TV guide, ranting online and hiding behind the sofa. Doctor Who is the best but there is still good stuff to watch. Some people even prefer other shows to Who. Inconceivable? Perhaps, but there you go. It takes all sorts. We are living in a golden age of television horror, sci-fi and fantasy. There are also some quality thrillers and dramas for those with less speculative tastes. Some you can watch with the kids while others cater for the mature audience only. There are shows that are good for laughs and some that will bring a tear to the eye. Action galore and mind bending plots, you should find enough to tide you over until Doctor Who season 9 hits the screens. There€™s no mad man in a box but you can€™t have everything. Here's our countdown of 10 TV shows that will help you fill that Doctor Who shaped void. You can thank us later!


10. The Walking Dead

How exactly does a show following the struggles of a small band of Zombie apocalypse survivors, in anyway, fit into a Doctor Who shaped void? Fair question. One of the appeals of Doctor Who is its scares and chills. It€™s a horror series for children that sometimes manages to terrify its adult fans as well. With The Walking Dead, grownups can relive those nail-chewing moments. This is not family viewing so don€™t sit your four-year-old on your lap to watch it, not unless you want a traumatised child or to raise a serial killer. Another similarity between The Walking Dead and Doctor Who is its lively online fan community. One favourite debate is over the sexuality of Daryl, with passionate advocates on both sides. The creator of the series also had to recently deny another fan theory that had gathered momentum, namely that the lead character Rick was in a coma and dreaming the whole series. Said showrunner then followed up by joking that Rick was actually crazy and the show was documenting his delusions. Showrunners never lie, eh Mr Moffat? So The Walking Dead gives you grown up scares and an online fan community to throw yourself into. In short, if you're after a replacement for family viewing with a few giggles along the way, look elsewhere.

9. Game Of Thrones

Well this juggernaut had to be mentioned sooner or later, didn€™t it? True, Game of Thrones would only fit into a Doctor Who shaped hole with the aid of a hacksaw and a lump hammer, but don't dismiss it just yet. Do you think the Doctor is a bit of a goody-two-shoes? Do you wish they€™d take the blink-and-you€™ll-miss-it smut of NuWho and turn it up to 11? Do you like Doctor Who but really miss Torchwood? Give Game of Thrones a punt. Doctor Who is more fantasy than sci-fi so it€™s not such a leap. Doctor Who has Classic fans and Nu fans. Game of Thrones has fans of the books and fans of the show. Pick a side and join in the comfortably familiar sneering, sniping arguments. Or you can sit back and enjoy both sides making fools of themselves. Whatever rings your bell. Like The Walking Dead, this is a show that that can make you cry out as you watch yet another favourite character bite the dust. Whether it€™s by headsman€™s axe, poison, a quarrel in the guts or a knife across the throat, no one is safe. Fans have a list of characters they say George R. R. Martin wouldn€™t dare to kill, but it€™s getting shorter all the time. €œHe wouldn€™t dare kill XYZ€ is now more of a desperate plea than a confident prediction. Epic in every way, this show will pull you in and spit you back out. Oh, and it's got dragons.

8. Arrow

Arrow is based on DC€™s Green Arrow, a costumed vigilante cast from the Batman mould. No super powers as such, but rich, fit as a butcher€™s dog, and just a little bit nuts. And the similarities with Doctor Who are strong, if you think about it. A lonely man with a passion for justice, riven by guilt for the crimes he has committed in the name of sanity. He has blood on his hands but bends over backwards to defeat his enemies without killing them. He doesn€™t use guns (often) and wears an elaborate costume. He keeps his real name secret from the world and relies on loyal friends who would lay down their lives for him. He keeps kissing his girl companions. Differences? Well, the Doctor did match Robin Hood in an archery contest but only because he used a remote controlled arrow. The Doctor also lives in the TARDIS rather than beneath a night club. Need more reasons to watch Arrow? Well, John Barrowman is a cast regular as an enemy/mentor of The Arrow (it€™s complicated). He isn€™t Captain Jack but he's an assassin known as the Magician. If that doesn€™t do it, then how about rare appearances by Alex Kingston? Her character Dinah Lance is as alike to River Song as Rory Williams is to Jack Bauer. Proof if needed that the lady can act.

7. Sherlock

There's a vocal group of Whovians who don€™t like Steven Moffat. There's also a larger and quieter group who think he€™s pretty good. The same could be said of Mark Gatiss though the debate is on a more modest and restrained level. If only they would collaborate to make some other show in between seasons of Doctor Who. Oh wait... they do. Sherlock! The concept is simple enough. What if Sherlock Holmes, plus his friends and foes, had been born 120 years later and were active today? This Holmes€™ cases are inspired by original Conan Doyle stories but events veer wildly from the originals. Mr Moffat plays his usual mind-bending tricks with intricate plots and flashback reveals. There€™s plenty of humour for viewers, both for those with no knowledge of Conan Doyle and for veteran Holmes fans alike. If you like Moffat and Gatiss then this is for you. Kids can watch but expect most of it to go over their heads. Sometimes this show tries to be too clever. The reason Sherlock isn€™t higher on this list is that episodes are as rare as hen€™s teeth. Each series is only 3 episodes long and they come two years apart. Don€™t burn yourself out lads, will you? Come to think of it, more time spent on Sherlock means less Doctor Who. As you were, Moffatt and Gatiss. As you were.

6. The Flash

The Flash is stable mate to Arrow and launched with some help from its elder via crossover episodes. Again it€™s based on a DC hero but The Flash is genuinely super-powered, he is the Fastest Man Alive. This does make him sound like a one-trick-pony but his speed extrapolates into other powers such as quick healing, time travel and the ability to drink everyone else under the table. The tone of The Flash is lighter and less edgy than Arrow. Technically he€™s still a vigilante, but he works for the police in his Barry Allen persona, and with them as the Flash. He€™s an old-school hero which is a refreshing change these days. The bad guys are not killed but secured in an underground super-prison (just 'cause!) and The Flash always tries to do the right thing. None of your brooding, guilt-ridden lone wolf here. If the Arrow is like the Doctor after the Time War, then the Flash is like the Doctor before it. He€™s even rubbish with women. Though it's light and fluffy in comparison to most shows on this list, not every series needs to turn your stomach, stretch your mind or challenge your moral certainty. Lots of action, a hero with a strong moral compass and colourful villains, this is a show you can watch with the young. That€™s why The Flash beats Arrow in this particular list.

5. The 100

The 100 channels The Hunger Games to bring us some YA, post-apocalyptic, sc-fi action drama. This series has its critics, but what show doesn€™t? The cast is ridiculously handsome but there€™s a feasible scientific explanation for that. The Sky People are all descended from astronauts so benefit from a prime gene pool. The Grounders are all survivors of nuclear radiation so only the healthiest survive and they€™ve mutated perfect teeth. The Mountain People never see the sun so they avoid premature aging and erm, well... The 100 is hardly the first show to rely on a good looking cast. If you want ugly, drop in at the local games store. For all its beauty, The 100 doesn€™t shy away from brutal action, bloody scenes and moral quandaries. With multiple factions, divided loyalties and inter-generational struggles, The 100 has more political storylines than the Battlestar Galactica reboot. If you want black and white factions then look elsewhere, this is a tale of choosing between the lesser of numerous evils. Learning a lesson from Game of Thrones, few of the cast is unkillable. Most deaths are telegraphed but that just adds to the tension. Not a show for the youngest, but if you have pre-teens and up then this should keep the family€™s attention until the Doctor returns.

4. Elementary

This is a good illustration that you can take the exact same idea and come up with two very different interpretations. Elementary is another series following the adventures of a contemporary Holmes and Watson. The key differences are that it is US set and made, Watson is a woman, and each series has 8 times as many episodes as the UK version. Elementary is a more traditional police procedural and will appeal to those who have an aversion to Moffat and Gatiss. Some of the plots need to be taken with a pinch of credibility salt but they are clever, and true to the Conan Doyle foundations. In Elementary, Holmes is a drug addict and his recovery is a major theme throughout the series. How Who is Elementary, then? Well, the influence of the literary Holmes on the character of the Doctor has been often commented upon. Sherlock is a man so brilliant that he struggles to build healthy relationships with normal people, and battles with boredom between cases. Again, he has a passion for justice and a select group of disciples. Jonny Lee Miller's Holmes is like a younger, sexier Twelfth Doctor. There is one more think link to the Whoniverse. Inspector Lestrade makes occasional appearances and is played by Sean Pertwee, the son of Jon Pertwee. That€™s a royal stamp of approval if ever there was one.

3. Gotham

What€™s this? Another DC television show? Is this because they are currently kicking Marvel€™s backside in the television arena? Maybe it€™s because the Doctor seems more of a natural fit in the DC universe than with Marvel? Discuss. James Gordon, destined to become Commissioner Gordon, is a true everyman hero. He could look the other way, go along with the corruption and build himself a safe and comfortable life... but of course he doesn€™t. He chooses to make a stand instead, upset the apple cart and put his life on the line in the name of justice. In the darkest moments it looks as if he€™s alone, but his example draws more to the cause and the tide starts to turn. You think that the Doctor would like James Gordon. This Gotham€™s Bruce Wayne is still a lad, being taught how to stick up himself by a familiar face. It€™s Sean Pertwee again, but this time as a series regular and playing the coolest Alfred to date. The son of the third Doctor is Batman€™s butler. Nice. If Gotham€™s €˜good€™ guys can€™t fill the yawning gap in your life where the Doctor usually resides, then watch it for the most colourful villains on telly. First amongst them is the magnificent Penguin. This chap is still to grow into his full plumage, but he has enough malice, madness and brilliance to bear comparison to the Doctor's arch enemy, the Master. What more could you possibly want?

2. Atlantis

Since the BBC brought back Doctor Who and scared itself to death with its unexpected success, Aunty Beeb has been trying to pull off the same trick. It came close with Merlin but fell short with Robin Hood. It's next attempt was Atlantis. Intended for the same Saturday evening slot and audience, Atlantis is a good Doctor Who substitute. It€™s got a handsome heroic lead with two comical sidekicks, who get reluctantly pulled into good old-fashioned good versus evil romps. Greek mythology is a rich source material for a family adventure show. Season 1 was family friendly with monsters of the week, foreboding prophecies and at least two budding romances. The writing was on the wall for poor old Medusa and Hercules, but Jason and Ariadne looked to have a chance. Season 2 got a bit darker (do any shows get lighter?) with more blade work and butchery, but still nothing too violent for the little ones. Good family fun. However, there's a catch. Season 2, which will soon return after the near compulsory mid-season break, will be the last. The Beeb is going to allow Atlantis to sink beneath the waves. This is a shame as the series could have run for a long time, capably filling the Saturday tea-time family slot while Doctor Who was between seasons. However, this show's early demise allows you to rant about the BBC's contempt for the fans, and write angry letters to the director demanding its reinstatement. It's like 1989 all over again.

1. Buffy The Vampire Slayer

Yes, this series did finish in 2003, but Buffy is the closest show in theme, format and style to NuWho there is. The reason that Buffy will fill that Doctor Who shaped void so well is because NuWho was basically cut from a Buffy shaped template. The influence of Buffy on NuWho has been publicly acknowledged by Russell T Davies and Steven Moffat, with Moffat stating that Buffy was the blueprint for the revised show. "I don't think the fact that we're in the post-Star Wars era is an issue, but matching Buffy is. Doctor Who was never a space drama anyway, it was about horror: dark shadows and creepy monsters lurking just around the corner." In fact, Buffy and NuWho are so alike that if you love one you€™re almost guaranteed to like the other. Humour, action, chills, companions, a lonely god-like central figure and, of course, lots and lots of monsters to boot. f you€™re a Buffy novice then buy some old boxsets or series link it on the many channels that continue to air it. Do yourself a favour and watch it in order, from €œWelcome to the Hellmouth€ to €œChosen€. If you€™re a Slayer veteran, well it€™s been 18 years (Hells Bells!) since the show first started so it€™s high time to reacquaint yourself with the best supernatural drama series ever. You never know, you might forget about Doctor Who altogether. What did you think of this list? Are there any other TV shows that would fill that Doctor Who shaped void? Leave your recommendations in the comments section below!

Contributor
Contributor

Older than some and taller than most. Grey of eye and white of beard. Stephen's book 'Hiding', about a boy who meets a goblin in a local wood, is available to download from the usual places. Think of it as a scavenger hunt.