10 TV Shows Which Didn't Get Better With Age
Retroactively ruined.
When your favourite show gets cancelled, it can be soul destroying. When it goes out on top with a great ending, it feels like TV time well spent. When it sticks around too long and disgraces itself over and over again, it's just plain infuriating.
If there's one thing the world's biggest shows nearly always have in common, it's a top notch Season 1. The first instalment sets the stage for the rest of the show, mounting a high bar fans will come back to see exceeded next year. While fandoms sprout like weeds, sharks start getting jumped.
Budgetary restraints, cast members leaving too soon, new (worse) writers taking over. Any number of reasons can prompt a series to slide off a cliff. Before you know it, the once praised show becomes a joke, even the good stuff is dismissed and history treats it appallingly (or forgets it completely).
You get millions of cranky viewers realising they spent literal days of their lives watching a show they now hate, wishing they could go back and do something else with all that lost time.
Not everything can age gracefully...
10. How I Met Your Mother
Sometimes you can have too much of a good thing. Season 9 of How I Met Your Mother was one such example. Set over Barney and Robin's wedding weekend, the season provided little laughs or anything at all beyond padding out the stars' bank balances. Storylines were repetitive, jokes were flat and character development moved backwards.
We're given little time to know Tracey Mosby, the all important mother referred to in the title. Before you know it, you're watching her death and Ted is stumbling his way back to Robin. A bizarre 180 for both characters, it appeared the writers' suddenly wanted Ted and Robin to have a Ross and Rachel dynamic. Undoing nine long years of story telling in one go, the series insulted viewers and its own premise with a cheap last minute twist.
Reappraisals of the series in the years since have often proved negative. Its finale turns up in most worst series finales lists out there, and criticism has been aimed at its writing, characters and catchphrase-laden humour. One can't help but feel its fans (and viewers in general) would remember it more fondly had it not proven such a letdown at its last haul.
9. Community
The inventive cult favourite grew a solid fanbase thanks to its sharp dialogue, clever one-liners and array of pop cultural references. While these were all great traits, a noticeable downturn into madcap humour and an over reliance on referential humour gradually sunk the show's quality.
Community suffered a severe setback when creator Dan Harmon was fired. Season 4 and all of its gas leak glory had fans complaining about a shark jump. Episodes relied much too heavily on gimmickry, short changing the characterisations and developments that had initially won so many viewers over. When it was announced that Harmon would be returning, many hoped that Season 4 was simply an aberration we could all move on from.
While Season 5 was indeed an improvement on its predecessor, it was not quite up to par with the show's highly acclaimed early days. With various departures and sagging ratings, NBC pulled the plug on the series.
For a brief spell, it seemed the show mantra of six seasons and a movie would live on when it was renewed for one season by Yahoo. Four years later, though, and the long discussed movie is yet to appear, leaving the series on a rather disappointing note.
8. Sons Of Anarchy
The ludicrous but entertaining biker series got off to a solid start with two seasons of all-American biker madness. Charlie Hunnam's charismatic portrayal of Jax Teller lead the show nicely. Ron Perlman's also in it, that alone gives the series a gold star. Riding around biker clubs, strip joints and bars of California, the show hooked viewers with ease.
It was the trip to Ireland in Season 3 that started this show's march to stupidity. Episodes overflowed with idiotic, often offensive stereotypes of Irish culture and some of the worst accents ever put to screen. Cringe-inducingly inane, the Irish episodes succeeded only in making everyone involved look utterly ridiculous.
Beyond that, the series begins to focus less on biker culture and more on violent, depressing soap opera. Never the pinnacle of realism, the plot lines grew too implausible to enjoy.
Jax developed a borderline supernatural capacity for convincing anyone to do anything in later seasons. All the same, he needed a child to spell out that his mum knocked his wife off, making him look like a fool in the final season. Throw in episodes that last way beyond their welcome, and you had a series that went out with a whimper.
7. The Walking Dead
The ratings juggernaut gradually declined from decent (if slightly repetitive) storytelling to revolving around which character will die this week. Needless to say, this formula does not create must-see TV, a fact reflected in the series' declining popularity in recent years.
The firing of initial showrunner Frank Darabont was the first sign of trouble ahead. The abysmal handling of Andrea in Season 3 was the next one. Devoid of the personality traits that had made her a favourite in the source material, the character was eliminated in a terribly handled death scene.
Fans often cite the prison flu plot line of Season 4 as another key moment in the show's quality drop. The flu itself almost exclusively targeted the secondary characters Rick took in at the end of Season 3, making their initial inclusion rather pointless. Plots would often start and then be dropped without warning, while other, duller subplots would eat up too much of a season.
By Season 6, episodes become so poorly constructed that the show's thrill factor is null and void. Worse than being bad, The Walking Dead became boring, the biggest sin a series can ever commit.
6. Prison Break
A sad example of a show outliving its whole point, Prison Break's hot start went cold soon after the titular escape occurred. A structural engineer gets himself incarcerated at the same prison as his brother to rescue him from that ever-dreaded death sentence. Cool stuff. The show delivered the goods with a high intensity, often crazy first season.
Season 2 maintained the series' acclaim with a wild, fugitive chase storyline. Sadly, beyond that it goes horribly downhill with a variety of contrived, unnecessary plot devices to keep the show alive. The Sona prison of Season 3 had entertainment value, but was a definite step down from its predecessors. Worse still was it being cut short due to the 2007-2008 writers' strike, an event that decimated almost every US show on the air at the time.
The show's foolhardy move into government conspiracy plots saw a nosedive in the quality department that the series never recovered from. By the time the Season 5 revival arrived in 2017, much of the fandom had died out and the often ridiculous plot failed to set the world on fire again. A journey into the bland and the inconceivable ruined this once tightly wound thriller - a great shame given its exceptional beginnings.
5. Happy Days
The original (and all too literal) jumping of the shark.
A charming, if rather predictable, sitcom centred on the life of teenager Richie Cunningham and his family, the series was ultimately consumed by the Fonz.
Mr Cool in a leather jacket, Fonzie captured fans and critics alike for some time, gradually conquering more and more show time. Fonzie's hostile takeover saw him move into the Cunninghams' home, share top billing with Ron Howard and ultimately replace him entirely as the series' lead.
In the wake of Jaws' colossal box office success, the series decided to do a comical homage featuring their new protagonist. Fonzie goes water skiing (sporting his trademark leather jacket the whole time) and jumps over some stock footage of a shark relaxing in a pool.
Bizarre, cheesy and just plain preposterous, it signalled a downward spiral the series remained on for the rest of its run. It was so terrible that the world of bad TV ever since has been compared to this game changing pile of stink.
From mild-mannered coming of age sitcom to permanent punchline, Happy Days is a good lesson in why you shouldn't stray too far from the original premise.
4. Heroes
Season 1 of Heroes is a tremendous piece of entertainment. Thirteen years on and its acting, writing, effects, pacing and atmosphere remain a masterclass in how to make great TV. Full of mystery, it ended on a high note with the main characters coming together for an epic showdown at Kirby Plaza and that was that.
The series never so much as breathed in this direction of quality again. Many blame the writers' strike at the time of Season 2 for its lowered entertainment value. While a valid point (the season is half as long due to the strike halting production), the cold hard fact is the storytelling had gone downhill from the first episode back.
An unnecessary time jump and the decision to nerf the overpowered Peter, Sylar and Hiro characters in different ways cut the show's thrill factor in half. By Season 3, retcons were being thrown at the wall to no avail. Storylines meandering, once likeable characters becoming obnoxious, and the existence of way too many cast members all contributed to a once thrilling product becoming nigh unwatchable. The series would slump its way to a Season 4 cancellation.
2015's Heroes Reborn did little to restore the show's moment in the sun, with many fans confused as to whether it was a direct continuation or a complete reboot.
3. True Blood
Released at the height of the late noughties vampire craze, True Blood provided a much needed adults-only tonic to those unimpressed by Twilight. Instead of well mannered, abstinent, 'vegetarian' vamps, True Blood saw complex, often sinister characters locked in a gory, over-sexed Deep South thriller.
Debuting to huge interest, the series sported a curious, metaphorical plot concerning themes such as racism and sexual identity. It was all so good (albeit rather ridiculous) for those first two seasons that what came after is just head-in-your-hands horrible.
For one thing, True Blood refused to knock off most characters until the end, leading to an absurdly bloated cast all vying for relevance. Characters' arcs would often change at the drop of a hat, a grim sign of minimal long term planning in the creative room.
By Season 7, the series had become such an illogical mess that one was left wondering why they'd even watched it in the first place. The cherry atop this good show gone bad cake was the final episode, one of the worst in the history of anything. Unsatisfying and in no way fitting to the storylines that preceded it, it was as if the writers had grown to hate both the series and its fans.
2. Game Of Thrones
The biggest show of the 2010s went down in flames worse than King's Landing.
There is a direct correlation between the series' downturn and the loss of source material. For nine long, painful years, George R.R. Martin has delayed in completing The Winds Of Winter, leaving the now widely loathed show runners without his considerably better written novels to work off.
The series saw a loss of everything that made it good in the first place: the political intrigue, complex character arcs, plot twists, surprise deaths, sharp dialogue and ability to not have Starbucks cups in shot were all gone.
Instead, we were given a plot with more holes than a moon made of Swiss cheese. Tyrion lost his wits, Jon Snow lost everything beyond the ability to say "You are my queen" and Daenerys suddenly went mad and became the series' big bad. It was all so frustratingly, incomprehensibly bad and out of nowhere that the last two seasons feel more like a big budget spoof than an actual continuation.
Runners D.B. Weiss and David Benioff have since thrown out wonderfully terrible explanations for their shoddy work including Benioff's "Themes are for eight-grade book reports" comment. Their lack of passion for putting out a worthwhile product to the end let down the fans, cast and crew in one miserable swoop.
1. Dexter
Two words: Scott Buck.
With Season 6, Mr Buck took creative control of this initially awesome series about a vigilante serial killer and pulled pork sandwich enthusiast in Miami. After five seasons of thrills, spills and kills, the series took a deep end nose dive. Centred around an abysmal Bible obsessed serial killer played unconvincingly by Colin Hanks, the show became a cringe-worthy bore overnight.
Things continued to get worse from there with non-existent character development, boring subplots, unnecessary retcons and the absolute dirt worst final episode in TV history. The suspenseful, darkly funny series that captured audience's imaginations was dead and buried long before that inconceivable last scene infuriated millions.
Despite having written for modern classic series such as Six Feet Under and Rome, Buck's work as a showrunner is amongst the lowest of the low. Since torpedoing Dexter, he's moved on to do Iron Fist for Netflix and Inhumans for ABC, two widely panned debacles from Marvel.
Michael C. Hall himself acknowledged the disappointment of the show's ending in an interview with the Daily Beast: "The way that show ended gave no sense of closure for people and a lot of questions unanswered."
From must see TV to monumental disappointment, Dexter serves as a lesson in the importance of ending a show before it outstays its welcome.
Watch Next
Prison Break Quiz: Michael Scofield - True Or False?