10 Unanswered Doctor Who Mysteries

So, like, what happened to Jenny?

THE DOCTOR S DAUGHTER
BBC

It is quite an astonishing feat that a show that nearly failed to get past the pilot stage has managed to stick around for more than half a century. Yes, the show had a decent hiatus, but both classic and modern series have made it to or past a dozen series, making it the one of the longest running serial in the history of Television, and consistently the strongest.

With a show that has explored so many events, characters and locations throughout time and space, there have been quite a few mysteries pop up that have remained unsolved. Be it the whereabouts of certain companions or a key plot arc that remains without a definitive conclusion, certain Who story threads remain frustratingly without answers.

While there can be a fine line between unsolved mystery and plot hole, this list aims to explore those questions that potentially have an answer. Many entries on this list are likely to be addressed in future seasons, while others look set to remain frustratingly out of reach. Then there are those questions we hope never get answered, the fun of theorising and sense of mystery proving to be one of the show's enduring traits.

So get ready to bunker down and revisit all those boxsets of seasons past, as we look at some of the unsolved mysteries from Doctor Who.

10. Who Was Orson Pink?

Doctor Who Listen Orson
BBC

A pivotal plot point in the 8th series of modern Who was the growing romance between Clara Oswald and fellow teacher Danny Pink. There was a genuine chemistry between the two, but they never appeared to exit the dating stage, and there was no inference that they had 'consummated' the relationship.

However it was strongly inferred in the 8th season episode Listen that the two eventually 'hooked up' and produced a child. In a delightfully nuts moment in this episode, Clara is approached by a man in a spacesuit while she is on a date with Danny, with the man inside the helmet looking remarkably like her date.

The man is revealed to be Orson Pink, who infers in a later conversation that Clara is 'family', the revelation appearing to insinuate that Orson is Clara and Danny's grandchild. At the very least Orson appears to definitely be in Danny's bloodlines as both characters are portrayed by the same actor, Samuel Johnson.

This idea of Danny and Clara having a family is undone however when Danny dies in the penultimate episode, Dark Water. While there was the possibility that Clara may have fallen pregnant to Danny before his death, this theory was obliterated when Ms Oswald herself died in the next season.

So if Orson wasn't Danny and Clara's grandchild, who exactly was he? Did the deaths of Danny Pink and Clara undo his existence? Was this just a plot hole or a mystery to be untangled? Sadly, we will probably never know.


9. How Did The Master Survive?

The Master The Timeless Children
BBC

This mystery is one that can be asked of The Master on several occasions throughout the modern series, but never as much as in recent times. The iconic Who villain first returned during Russell T Davies era as show runner, with a sound explanation at hand as to how he returned in the first place, and again when he was 'resurrected' for the End of Time story.

But the mystery of how The Master has survived since then has been much harder to track. While Missy, the Female form of the Master, was seen to have regenerated after she ironically killed her prior self, it is still a mystery as to how John Simm's Doctor escaped Gallifrey. Was he frozen in a single moment of time with his fellow Timelords? Was it he who broke the Timelords free?

The return of The Master in the most recent season poses even more questions. Sacha Dhawan's reveal as the Doctor's old nemesis came as a mighty big shock, especially considering the apparent permanent death of 'Missy' at the end of the 10th season.

The answer to the mystery of the villain's reappearance may come with the reveal of where Dhawan's Master fits into the show's timeline. The use of miniaturising technology was very much the ammunition of classic era Masters, as was the idea of taking the form or body of someone he had killed.

One feels that we will receive answers for this mystery, with this writer hoping Dhawan's Master predates Delgado's original interpretation.


8. When Did The Doctor Tell River His Name?

Doctor Who The Husbands of River Song
BBC Studios

Within the wonderfully timey whimey adventures featuring the Doctor and River Song, it was revealed on several occasions that Ms Song knew the Doctor's real name. On the last occasion that she saw the Doctor in person in an effort to get him to trust her, River whispered his name in his ear, and it was evident from the Timelord's reaction that it was correct.

A second time when the name was spoken was during the epic finale of Series 7, when the companions of Matt Smith's Doctor were saved when River whispered his name to open his tomb. Again, we couldn't hear what the name was, but it was definitely correct considering the Doctor's tomb was opened.

None of this however pinpoints the exact moment the Doctor told her his name, or why he did. David Tennant's Doctor stated that there was 'only one moment he could', and while we assumed this was his wedding day, it was never definitively stated that this was the case. Matt Smith's Doctor stated to River that he had 'just told her his name' on their 'wedding day', but this was revealed to be a ruse

There are many theories as to when the Doctor revealed his name to his lover, but at the time of his death would be one that makes the most sense. Why the Doctor's name holds such importance, well that's for another entry...


7. What Is The Doctor’s Name?

Matt Smith Doctor Who
BBC

Labelling our favourite character's name as 'Doctor Who' has been a bugbear of many a Whovian throughout the years. It's not his name, it's the name of the show damn it! Or so we think. The credits for the first four seasons labelled him as Doctor Who and Missy cheekily stated this as his name during the penultimate episode of Series 10, World Enough and Time.

The question as to what his name is continues to rage, and one can only hope that Moffatt was pulling our leg with Missy's 'revelation'. The mystery of the Doctor's true name became an integral plot point within Matt Smith's story arc, with the idea of his name holding significant power almost making his title seem like a potential universe crushing threat.

The question of the Doctor's name became less of a focus in Capaldi and Whittaker's time as the Timelord, but recent revelations re the Timeless Child has thrown a new light on the question. Was the name that seemingly holds so much power given to him by the Timelords? Or was it his/her birth name given to The Doctor on their planet of origin? Perhaps the Doctor doesn't even remember it fully.

Show runner Chris Chibnall seems to be answering a number of old mysteries, so it will be interesting to see if and how he addresses this question. One hopes the answer isn't simply 'the timeless child', as that would be a severe let down.


6. Who Was The Mystery Woman In The End Of Time?

Doctor Who mother
BBC

Now this is a mystery that had looked to have been solved, but is now very much up for review. During Tennant's final stint as the Doctor during The End of Time, a mysterious female figure continued to appear before his companion Wilfred. While it was never revealed on screen exactly who this lady was, the theory that she was in fact The Doctor's mother was revealed by show runner Russell T Davies to be true.

However this is another mystery that has been reignited since the stunning reveal in Season 12 that the Doctor was not originally of Gallifreyan origin, but seemingly of another universe. The 'Doctor's Mother' appeared alongside the Timelords during her one appearance, which seems to infer that she is a version Tecteun.

For those who missed The Timeless Children episode, Tecteun was revealed to have found the Doctor as an orphan child, before taking over in a 'Motherly role'. Unfortunately she was more like Norman Bates' mother persona from Psycho, experimenting on the doctor and making him/her endure a number of deaths and regenerations.

This theory however has its flaws, most notably that Tennant's Doctor clearly remembered the lady's face in the brief moment he saw her. With recent revelations, it's even possible the person is The Doctor herself, seeing her face triggering memories from Tennant's Doctor of a past incarnation long thought lost. The internet may just explode if this was in fact the case.


5. What Happened To Jenny?

Doctor Who The Doctor's Daughter Jenny
BBC Studios

The character of Jenny was the 'child' of The Doctor who was 'created' from the Doctor's DNA in the episode titled The Doctor's Daughter. Appearing in the 6th episode of David Tennant's final full season, Jenny was created as a young female soldier as part of a war between humans and native species The Hath.

The extremely innovative and exciting plot point that is Jenny strangely hasn't been addressed since this episode, leaving many pondering where she is now. The Doctor had assumed she died, having not seeing her eventual regeneration and blast off into space for further adventures.

So where could Jenny be? You would think the young lady would be keen to track down her father, although it is a very big universe, so she could have just failed to do so yet. Adding to the mystery is Jenny's ability to regenerate, meaning the Doctor may have met her without knowing it. Why Jenny would withhold her identity would need to be explained, but her ability to change her appearance opens up a range of possibilities.

The other possibility is that Jenny can't fully regenerate, with the ability to use some regenerative energy without the ability to take a new form. Georgia Tennant(formely Moffett) has recently returned to the role of Jenny as part of the Big Finish audio plays, so having her return to tie up this story arc would be great to see and could allow for an emotional reunion.


4. Did The Doctor Have His Own Family?

Doctor Who Fear Her
BBC

This mystery ties into others we will look at later in our list, with several plot points making this idea all the more feasible. The mystery of if The Doctor ever had a wife and children arises from the fact that his first ever companion, Susan, was apparently his granddaughter.

While calling Susan his granddaughter could be explained away as her being adopted rather than a blood relative, a comment from The Doctor during series 2 of the modern series gave this idea extra legs. In the episode titled Fear Her, David Tennant's Doctor casually states to his then companion Rose that he was a father once, a quick little aside that was never acknowledged after.

If it is in fact the case that the Doctor did have children, then the big question becomes who the mother is and when did this happen. River Song seems the most logical option, although how the baby would fit into her already convoluted timeline is enough to make your head spin.

There is also the possibility that Jenny had a child that the Doctor then brought up, but how the Doctor's daughter would have got back to early Gallifrey would be another mystery in itself. The most likely story is that the Doctor fell in love with a Gallifreyan lady and had a family on his home planet, which he lost in the Time War.

Or then again, maybe the Doctor was in female form and had the child himself. Now that would be a twist!


3. What Happened To Susan And Is She A Timelord?

Doctor Who Susan
BBC

Directly linked to the question of The Doctor possibly having a family and children of his own, comes the question regarding his granddaughter and first companion, Susan. Taken on its merits, it would be fair to assume that Susan would in fact be a Timelord herself, having grown up on Gallifrey alongside the Doctor.

This is another mystery that has come back to life with the Timeless Child revelations, and make us ponder exactly who, and where Susan may be. The question of her being a Timelord relates directly to her parentage, with the possibility that she is a 'hybrid' of sorts a very interesting prospect indeed. This also opens up the option of Susan being the prophesised Hybrid that would bring destruction upon Gallifrey and the Timelords, however unlikely.

Susan became the first companion in Who history to leave the TARDIS when she was left behind on Earth with her new love David. The Doctor bizarrely never tried to make contact after this moment, although comments made by Doctors of the NuWho era infer that she may have died during the Time Wars.

There is the possibility that Susan has regenerated on a number of occasions and had no affinity to the Timelords at all. Or maybe the Matrix wasn't telling the whole truth, and it was in fact Susan who was the Timeless Child, with the Doctor realising this and helping her escape. The possibilities are endless.


2. Why Did The Doctor Run Away?

Doctor Who Clara Oswald First Doctor Gallifrey TARDIS Jenna Coleman William Hartnell
BBC

The oldest question of them all and one that all show runners have hinted at without ever giving a definitive answer, the grand old mystery of why the Doctor ran away from Gallifrey remains the show's biggest unanswered question. There have been a few tongue in cheek comments from various incarnations of The Doctor, including one from Tennant's Doctor stating that he was one of the ones who 'ran away', but a concrete explanation has never occurred.

One suspects and fears that current show runner Chris Chibnall is going to try and come up with a definitive answer, which would really be a shame. Recent revelations open up a number of possibilities, not all great, most notably that the Doctor found out some information in relation to him being The Timeless Child and fled because of this.

The query in regards this theory is just how much the Doctor remembers or knows information about The Timeless Child revelation and why they can't remember now. The fact that a 'prior' incarnation of The Doctor as played by Jo Martin had also chosen to flee to Earth makes a link between the two events highly likely.

Some non Timeless Child related theories as to why The Doctor made a hasty exit include Susan's life coming under threat, revelations of the upcoming Time War or The Doctor quite simply being bored of the constrictive life on Gallifrey. Given a choice, most fans would likely choose the last option.


1. How Was Gallifrey Unfrozen?

Doctor Who Gallifrey
BBC Studios

There are many mysteries related to the Doctor's home planet that have yet to be answered, including the manner in which the Master managed to destroy Gallifrey. While the planet was apparently destroyed by the Doctor in his efforts to end the Time War, we see the Doctor in fact save his home planet at the end of the 50th anniversary special, 'freezing it in a single moment'.

The planet however was revealed to be 'unfrozen' when the Master, who had apparently been sucked into Gallifrey when attacking head Timelord Rassilon, reappeared in female form. Under the new pseudonym of Missy, she revealed Gallifrey's location to the Doctor, although this initially appeared to be a lie.

The location of Gallifrey remained unclear until the Doctor broke out of a trap set for him by the Timelords in Heaven Sent. Capaldi's Doctor broke out of the trap and found himself on his home planet, with his people alive and well and very much 'unfrozen'.

Surprisingly there was no explanation of how the planet broke from its stagnant state, a mystery that could easily have been solved in a quick one liner. Show runner at the time Steven Moffatt stated that he had no intention of answering every mystery, and with the planet now destroyed it seems like it may remain unsolved.

One can only speculate that The Master had some involvement in the whole affair, although it is also a possibility that a future Doctor has yet to complete the task of unfreezing the planet.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

While he likes to know himself as the 'thunder from down under', Luke is actually just a big dork who loves all things sport, film, James Bond, Doctor Who and Karaoke. With all the suave and sophistication of any Aussie half way through a slab, Luke will critique every minute detail of films and shows from all eras- unless it's 1990's Simpsons episodes, because they're just perfect