10 Underrated TV Shows You Need To Start Watching

Give these shows a chance before they're cancelled.

Copenhagen Cowboy
Netflix

As TV viewers, we have so much damn choice at our fingertips nowadays - you've got no chance of ever watching everything you want to, and so it's simply natural that some great shows end up falling by the wayside.

"Underrated" is certainly a strange word that means many different things to many different people, but most will at least agree that it defines a TV show that's been underestimated, under-praised, and simply under-seen by audiences at large.

Due to so-so reviews, a lack of marketing presence, or the simple absence of online discourse, these shows have all fallen under the radar to an extent - or at least, far below the esteem they should be held in.

Whether rebounding from a rough start or simply continuing to quietly put out quality content, these shows absolutely deserve to get their flowers and be celebrated by audiences at large.

If you sleep on these shows now and get into them later after they've been cancelled, you'll sadly only have yourself to blame. These 10 shows could certainly use your help, and you're only missing out by giving them a pass...

10. Party Down

Party Down Adam Scott Jennifer Garner
Starz

Cult classic comedy series don't get much more cult than Party Down, the legendary sitcom co-created by Paul Rudd which stars Adam Scott as a failed actor who returns to work for the titular catering company.

Party Down debuted in 2009 and aired for two seasons before being cancelled, because despite strong reviews ratings were incredibly low - a common problem with shows airing on Starz.

After years of failed attempts to get a film or revival series off the ground, in 2021 a six-episode third season was finally announced, as brought back almost the entire ensemble cast, save for Lizzy Caplan due to scheduling conflicts.

Party Down's third season recently finished airing amid rave reviews, and though fan response has been near-universally positive, its ratings have again been disappointingly lackluster.

It is, in the most literal sense of the word, underrated.

This certainly makes the prospect of a fourth season decidedly less likely, despite the principal cast members all expressing their eagerness to return. Short of the show enjoying a major uptick in viewership on streaming in the months to come, Starz will likely give it the chop for a second time.


9. Rabbit Hole

Rabbit Hole Kiefer Sutherland
Paramount+

Kiefer Sutherland's new thriller series Rabbit Hole may have been marketed as yet another identikit espionage joint created in the mould of his career-defining hit 24, but don't let that fool you - this is some seriously fun television.

Look past its generically glossy production values and Rabbit Hole is far from the formulaic, self-serious slop you might well be expecting.

This is a show far more aware of its own absurdity than you'd reasonably anticipate, gleefully indulging in wildly over-the-top plot twists with a sure wink at the audience.

Just when you think you know what's going on, the show flips the table over and completely changes things.

It's tremendous fun waiting to see what daft twist the writers will serve up episode after episode, aided by the electric chemistry between the ensemble cast, especially Sutherland and his on-screen father, Charles Dance.

Sure, it lacks the zeitgeist appeal of 24, but remains a textbook example of a show that knows precisely what it is and delivers accordingly - across a tightly-paced eight-episode season no less.

Reviews have been solid albeit not great, but if you're craving a certified Dad Show that also isn't completely braindead and patronising, Rabbit Hole is one of the year's most purely entertaining series to date.


8. From

From Harold Perinneau
Epix

Epix's new sci-fi horror series From debuted last February to broad acclaim, and though the presence of lead actor Harold Perrineau in a mysterious slow-burn sci-fi story invites obvious comparisons to Lost - not to mention Lost producers Jack Bender and Jeff Pinkner being involved - From is very much its own fascinating beast.

While the first season certainly had its missteps, the combination of great acting - especially from Perrineau - and an enticing central enigma involving a town which traps anyone who enters it, ensured it scratched that Lost itch alright.

It remains to be seen whether or not From can avoid Lost's mistakes pertaining to "mystery box" storytelling, but season one absolutely left fans eager for the second, which just recently premiered.

Yet From is currently struggling to break out of its small-but-dedicated fandom and become a wider hit, perhaps in part because it launched on a relatively niche TV network. All the same, those in the market for a transfixing episodic mystery-thriller need look no further.


7. Shrinking

Shrinking Harrison Ford Jason Segel
Apple TV+

If you saw the trailer for Shrinking and assumed that it was another superficially feel-good sitcom in the vein of Ted Lasso, you'd basically be right - in fact, it was co-created by Ted Lasso's own Bill Lawrence.

But its generic, unchallenging sitcom sheen belies the fact that it also boasts one of the finest performances of Harrison Ford's career, and that alone makes it entirely worth watching.

Ford appears in the series as Dr. Paul Rhoades, a therapist afflicted by the early stages of Parkinson's disease, and while Ford absolutely leans into the grumpy persona he's honed on talk shows and press appearances for years, he also peels back the layers to reveal Rhoades' vulnerability and humanity.

Ford hasn't seemed this happy to be doing actual acting in many years, and it's pretty much dead certain that he'll end up nominated for a Best Supporting Actor Emmy as a result - if not win the award outright.

This isn't to discount the solid work being done by Jason Segel, Jessica Williams, and the rest of the ensemble cast, but Ford is the anchor holding everything firm in even the series' schmaltziest, most sentimental moments.


6. Tokyo Vice

Tokyo Vice Ansel Elgort Ken Watanabe
HBO Max

Michael Mann's crime thriller series Tokyo Vice was released last spring to solid reviews, and despite the maelstrom of controversy still surrounding lead actor Ansel Elgort, it performed well enough for HBO to greenlight a second season, which is currently shooting and likely to wrap by mid-year.

As much as yet another crime drama about a white guy protagonist infiltrating the corridors of a Japanese crime syndicate might make your eyes roll, Tokyo Vice is an uncommonly gripping serial, elevated by its meticulous attention-to-detail, entertaining cast of characters, and sharp performances across the board.

Even with its renewal, Tokyo Vice's first season quickly came and went without making much of a dent in the mainstream discourse, despite rocking a unique flavour compared to just about every other crime series on TV right now.

It's the best thing Mann's been involved with for years, and has serious potential to grow into itself if it runs for multiple additional seasons.


5. Chucky

Chucky Season 2
Syfy

There are certainly those who heard about Chucky living on as a Syfy TV series and immediately dismissed it as a desperation move, that the Child's Play franchise had lost its theatrical value and was now eking out a meagre existence on a third-rate TV network (no offense, Syfy).

Yet as anyone who's seen more than an episode or two of the show will attest, Chucky has delivered some of the greatest material in the slasher franchise's history.

Aided by the active involvement of Child's Play creator Don Mancini, Chucky debuted to solid reviews, yet has struggled to grow its viewership over the course of its two seasons to date.

By the end of the recently concluded second season, the linear TV ratings had declined significantly compared to the first season, enough that fans feared it wouldn't be renewed for a third.

But alas, Syfy indeed greenlit season three, yet unless the ratings pick up, it's fairly probable that the upcoming season will be Chucky's last.

Considering how creatively and ambitiously the show has engaged with the series' lore, it'd be a damn shame if Mancici's vision was cut short prematurely. If you care at all about the Child's Play franchise, you need to do your part and tune in.


4. Severance

Severance Adam Scott
Apple TV+

Even though Apple's ingenious sci-fi thriller series Severance was one of last year's most acclaimed shows, the near-universal praise bafflingly failed to translate into much awards success at all.

Despite being nominated for a stonking fourteen Emmys at last year's ceremony, Severance walked away with just two, for Main Title Design and Original Dramatic Score, while failing to win anything for its astonishing writing, directing, or acting, all of which was certainly Emmy-worthy.

Needless to say, many will be hoping that its upcoming second season will receive a far more charitable treatment from Emmy voters.

Meanwhile in terms of viewing figures, Severance's popularity (or possible lack thereof) remains a mystery, due to Apple failing to report any meaningful data whatsoever.

Hell, even the series' executive producer and director, Ben Stiller, said that Apple withheld precise numbers from him, ensuring that even he doesn't know exactly how many people are watching the show.

Case in point, you absolutely need to watch Severance if you're not already - it deserves to be more than a critical fave that gets cancelled because its viewing figures don't justify its obviously high cost of production.


3. Copenhagen Cowboy

Copenhagen Cowboy
Netflix

Nicolas Winding Refn's new crime-noir series Copenhagen Cowboy was quietly released on Netflix at the start of the year with a minimal marketing push, and just like Refn's previous Amazon series Too Old to Die Young, it received wildly polarising reviews due to its glacial pacing and surreal style.

Yet for fans of Refn, Copenhagen Cowboy was sublime - another gloriously neon-splashed, Lynchian nightmare which dared to challenge and at times infuriate audiences rather than simply deliver comfortable, undemanding streaming Content you can digest while doing your laundry.

Unsurprisingly, the show failed to break into Netflix's Top 10 most-watched TV series even on release week, and outside of the fandom's fervent discussions, Copenhagen Cowboy more-or-less fell straight into the abyss.

Though Refn has stated that he hopes to make a second season and already has a story treatment written, it's looking tremendously unlikely without the show being suddenly discovered by the masses and propelled to greater viewership.

While the famously trigger-happy Netflix hasn't officially cancelled the series yet, they're most likely viewing it as a one-off mini-series and so don't feel especially compelled to announce that it won't be coming back.

We can hope for season two, but without a surge in demand it's far more probable that Refn's next series will need to be shopped to yet another streamer.


2. The Afterparty

The Afterparty
Apple TV+

The success of Knives Out has shepherded in a new era of murder-mystery stories, and one of the best to come down the pike in recent times is The Afterparty.

A comedic whodunnit yarn created by the great Christopher Miller (21 Jump Street, The Lego Movie, Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse), The Afterparty was broadly well received upon release in early 2022, for its enticing mystery, creative episodic storytelling, and killer ensemble cast.

Yet it's also a show which simply failed to stir up much of a conversation, and with Apple again being cagey about viewing figures, it's impossible to know how well the first season performed.

Well enough for a second season at least, which releases this July, but a show this cleverly written and brilliantly acted deserves to be far more of a breakout phenomenon - indeed, on the level of the Knives Out movies. Instead, its subreddit is only sparsely populated.

Apple TV+ is fundamentally still a growing streaming service, which doesn't help any of their shows grab an easy foothold with the mainstream, but if you sleep on The Afterparty you're absolutely missing out.


1. For All Mankind

For All Mankind Joel Kinnaman
Apple TV+

The ultimate expression of Apple TV+'s opaque approach to viewership and "success" is surely For All Mankind - a frankly brilliant sci-fi drama series which depicts an alt-history version of the space race after the Soviet Union beats the U.S. to the Moon.

Though the first season had its critical dissenters, praise for the second and third seasons has been near-universal, commending the excellent ensemble cast and thrillingly epic sense of adventure.

Independent analytics at least suggested that the show toppled Ted Lasso from the top of Apple's most-watched series last year.

Yet despite the unrelenting acclaim for the show's third season in particular, the series has failed to attract much awards attention at all, save for a single crafts Emmy nomination.

Though early comparisons to Mad Men perhaps didn't get the show off on the right foot with audiences, For All Mankind has done what all great shows do - it's grown with each passing season.

It feels like barely a week goes by without an outlet running an article dubbing it the most underrated or overlooked TV show on the air right now, which really says it all.


In this post: 
chucky
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.