10 Ways Clara Could Leave Doctor Who

10 ways the Impossible Girl could leave our screens...

This article will contain spoilers from the episode guide recently published in the Radio Times. As well as sporadic bursts of new information from the BBC, just before the start of Series 8 the standard tabloid rumours about Doctor Who started cropping up. When it comes to Doctor Who, the easiest rumour to print is that either a Doctor or a Companion is leaving. And since suggesting that Peter Capaldi is already jumping ship would be stupid even for the Daily Mirror, they instead put out a story that Jenna Coleman will leave during this year€™s Christmas Special. Since the tabloids are notoriously bad with Doctor Who rumours and often just make stuff up (like suggesting that Billie Piper was in the running to play the Eleventh Doctor), it€™s best to take this €˜news€™ with an entire ocean€™s worth of salt. But there also might be something in it. Jenna Coleman may have only done thirteen episodes so far but Series 8 and the Christmas Special will take her total up to twenty-three (a not inconsiderable amount for a New Who Companion), and it is coming up to two years since her debut in Asylum Of The Daleks. So it may very well be the case that Clara and the Doctor will be parting ways soon. Particularly since, in an interview on ITV€™s This Morning, Coleman did nothing to quash the rumours and said that she enjoyed the speculation. So in case the tabloids have got it right for once and Jenna Coleman will be moving on, we€™ve come up with 10 ways Clara could leave the Doctor...


10. She Can't Get Over The Regeneration

It looks like this one will be put to bed one way or the other by the end of Series 8 but for now, it remains an open possibility. Despite Clara€™s angry rebuff to Vastra€™s accusations of her being shallow, and her acceptance of the Twelfth Doctor at the end of Deep Breath, the question remains of whether or not Clara can get over the Doctor€™s Regeneration. Because it€™s not just a case of the Doctor no longer being her €œdashing young gentleman friend€, it€™s a fundamental change in almost everything about him. While the watchword for Regeneration is €œSame man, different face€, the Doctor€™s new personality is a radical departure from what Clara was used to. The physically affectionate manchild she knew has been replaced by a much sterner and more abrasive figure. Which is likely to be something she will struggle to adjust to. In the end it may turn out that the vast change in personality is too much for her to deal with. Though using this as a reason for Clara€™s departure would doing the character something of a disservice. Particularly since she has personally met four different Doctors by this point.

9. Settling Down

The Doctor€™s female Companions leaving him to settle down (often with a love interest) has been a recurring theme ever since Susan€™s departure in 1964€™s The Dalek Invasion Of Earth and most recently seen with Rose and the Metacrisis Doctor in Journey€™s End (2008). As part of the ongoing drive to give Clara more characterisation of her own, she is being given a love interest this series in the form of Danny Pink (Samuel Anderson); a colleague of hers and the older brother of her troublesome student Courtney. It may be a case of putting two and two together and getting an outdated reason for the departure of a Companion, but the introduction of Danny and the rumours of Jenna Coleman€™s departure coming so close together would seem to imply that the two are linked. Danny being the catalyst for Clara deciding to stop bumming around the universe while trying to hold down a full time job would be an interesting character arc and tie into Series 8€™s theme of the consequences of living the Doctor€™s life. Though this reason for a companion€™s departure has rarely been seen since the 1970s and would probably conflict with Doctor Who€™s portrayal of Clara (as well as Companions in general) as a strong and independent woman. Which makes it a less likely possibility.

8. The Doctor Leaves Her

Whatever his faults may be, one of the Doctor€™s highest priorities is always the safety of his companions; to the point of sending them away against their will when facing great danger like in Logopolis (1981) and The Parting Of The Ways (2005). And we€™ve already seen shades of this before in The Time Of The Doctor (2013) when the Doctor sends Clara away from Trenzalore twice to protect her from the siege. Using this for Clara€™s final departure would be an interesting spin on it since it has never been done permanently and would open up a lot of doors both for character moments, and for the Doctor facing a danger so cataclysmic that he leaves Clara behind permanently. Though it would be a bit repetitive and at the same time, the Doctor has only tried to send his Companions away when going into a situation he thinks is unwinnable. So how it could work for a situation that the Doctor will obviously survive is questionable.

7. Becoming An Enemy

BBCBBC This was touched upon in Asylum of The Daleks with the reveal that Oswin had been converted into a Dalek, but the Doctor€™s companion being his enemy is another rarely used concept that could have the potential to be a very strong ending for Clara. Although Clara€™s been shown to have the willpower to overcome mind control before, depending on the enemy and manner of control, there€™s nothing to say that she can€™t end up being completely controlled. Especially since the Cybermen are returning in the Series 8 finale and very few characters have been shown to overcome Cyber-control. Clara struggling to overcome Cyber-conversion and either sacrificing herself or getting the Doctor to kill her as an act of mercy (à la Kamelion in 1984€™s Planet Of Fire) would be an absolutely heartbreaking ending for her. Not to mention a welcome change of pace to the endings of previous New Who companions which are always bittersweet at their very worst.

6. A New Home And Purpose

This one was easily the most common method of departure for Companions in Classic Who. At the end of their last a story, a Companion would realise that they felt at home in the location of their latest adventure, and possibly find a purpose there such as the Fifth Doctor€™s Companion Nyssa remaining on leper colony Terminus to help heal the sick. Clara€™s history as a nanny and career as a teacher firmly establishes her as having a caring nature and loving children. Which definitely opens the door for her to leave the Doctor and start a new life caring for others like Nyssa, or some other purpose that she can turn her talents to. However, it has been the practice of New Who to establish companions with much more prominent home lives and families than in Classic Who. Particularly in the case of Clara who only travels with the Doctor occasionally while working full time, and having a family and a boyfriend. Although it€™s not out of the question, Clara would be giving up a lot to stay in another time and place permanently.

5. Forced Separation

This has been pretty much the go-to method of writing out a Companion since Doomsday (2006). Rose, Donna, and Amy and Rory have all been separated from the Doctor with no hope of seeing him again. It€™s an easy way of creating a dramatic exit without going too far for a programme largely aimed at children, and would make to sense to go with a tried and true ending. If it ain€™t broke, don€™t fix it. Plus it would allow Jenna Coleman to make a comeback further down the line if she wanted to. Conversely, another forced separation is unlikely because it has been done far too recently. It€™s certainly a plot device that works and is broad enough to have a lot of variation, but it€™s time to give it a rest for a few Companions. Steven Moffat is intelligent enough to realise this and not add another one to the tally so quickly.

4. Death

This one€™s a nice and simple way of removing a Companion from the equation. Particularly if the actor in question doesn€™t want to come back. Not counting Adelaide€™s suicide in The Waters Of Mars (2009), Doctor Who has featured no direct and permanent companion deaths since Adric in 1982€™s Earthshock; one of the most shocking moments in 1980s Who. It€™s a fate used so sparingly used that it would have a massive impact and help to cement the darker tone that Series 8 is trying to establish. Particularly as Clara is a very likeable character and is set to develop significantly over the course of Series 8, making her potential death even more of a blow to fans of her. However, this was sort of done with the Ponds (though offscreen and decades after their last appearance), and would most likely bring the Doctor back to his depressed state that we saw in the Snowmen (2012). So it€™s unlikely that Moffat will go down the same route with Clara. And she€™s been killed off twice already so how effective a third death would be is questionable.

3. It's Stopped Being Fun

A departure method that we haven€™t seen for a while is going down the (disappointingly rushed) route of the Fifth Doctor€™s companion Tegan. After a particularly bloody battle with the Daleks (in a story with a higher body count than Terminator), Tegan tells the Doctor that she€™s had enough and that€™s time for her to leave because travelling with him has stopped being fun. And there€™s no real reason that this couldn€™t work for Clara. She's not an Ace or a Leela; the kind of steely action girl that can take a lot of the grimmer moments of life with the Doctor in her stride. And despite having had a hard life with the death of her mother at a young age, she isn€™t really hardened enough to cope with the consequences of life with the Doctor for a long time. It would be an all too human and in-character development for her to leave the Doctor after having enough of the danger and constant death that comes from that lifestyle. There€™s only so much that a person can stand before they have to call it quits not only for their own personal safety but for their emotional wellbeing as well. And Steven Moffat has said that Series 8 will be exploring the consequences of living a life like the Doctor€™s. Which certainly gives some weight to the possibility of Clara deciding to leave for this reason.

2. The Doctor Is Too Ruthless

This one certainly seems likely since (as Steven Moffat€™s episode guide in the Radio Times revealed), it is going to happen temporarily. The events of Mummy On The Orient Express (Episode 8) will see the Doctor doing something so ruthless that Clara calls it quits but they will be reunited in Flatline (Episode 9) for the rest of Series 8. This is certainly a concept that has potential and is only used very occasionally, having only cropped up in The Massacre Of St Bartholomew€™s Eve (1965) and The Waters Of Mars. Also, a ruthless act is so broad that it could be used in a huge number of ways; meaning that Steven Moffat would have a lot of different ideas that could be explored as well as choosing one tailored to Clara. An act that another companion may have been able to look past but that Clara finds so utterly repugnant that she can€™t be with the Doctor any more. Though on the other hand, since this concept is already going to be used in Series 8, it€™s simultaneously unlikely that we€™ll be seeing it again at Christmas. Especially for something as momentous as a Companion€™s departure.

1. Saving The Doctor

Although the mystery surrounding Clara has now been solved and will be left aside to give her the chance to grow as a character in her own right, on some level she will always be the Impossible Girl. Which is why it would make sense for her final fate to tie into this in some way. The Name Of The Doctor (2013) established that there were millions of Claras in millions of times and places; all running to save the Doctor. From his very beginnings on Gallifrey to his battle against the Great Intelligence on Trenzalore. But what about after that? Although the timeline with the Doctor€™s grave was aborted; as the Doctor, Clara, and the Great Intelligence are time travellers, it still happened for them. And despite its suicide, it€™s always possible the Great Intelligence to make a comeback since it is pure information You can€™t kill information just like you can€™t kill an idea. A final battle with the Great Intelligence would be a nice bookend to Clara€™s time with the Doctor; saving the Doctor from it at both the start and finish of her time with him, and fulfilling the same destiny as the millions of other Claras out there. How do you think Clara could leave? Would you be sorry to see her go? Let us know in the comments section below...

Contributor
Contributor

JG Moore is a writer and filmmaker from the south of England. He also works as an editor and VFX artist, and has a BA in Media Production from the University Of Winchester.