10 Worst CGI Moments In Star Trek
Decades of experience doesn't always make for expertise...
Star Trek has forever been about pushing boundaries in both storytelling and the technology that is on show. Many of today's technological advances can be traced back to what was seen in the Original Series and the Next Generation. Many of the finest shots in the franchise were filmed on a shoestring budget. One only has to watch some of the stunning fly-by shots of the Enterprise D, thanks to Industrial Light and Magic, to know that when Star Trek did it right, it really did it right.
However, the nature of Science Fiction is that sometimes there is a need to show something that doesn't exist. Early science fiction and indeed early Star Trek often relied on physical models to make the imaginary into reality. Thankfully, today we have excellent CGI imagery that can make photo realistic animals and depict gigantic star ships going head to head among swarms of fighters. Truly, there are moments of beauty that can be created in the comfort of a digital lab.
This list is not about those moments. This list is about the other moments. This list is about the moments that made the animators work harder to ensure that they wouldn't come again.
These are the worst moments of CGI in Star Trek.
10. Star Trek II The Wrath Of Khan - The Genesis Wave
Starting with one of the oldies, this is an example of a bad scene from an otherwise fantastic movie. It is widely accepted that Star Trek II The Wrath of Khan is one of, if not the, best Star Trek films and so aiming criticism against it feels almost sacrilegious. However, fair is fair - the animation in this scene is awful.
While the argument can be made that this is slightly unfair as the film was released in 1982, one has to consider the absolutely phenomenal CGI work that was on display in Star Trek The Motion Picture. When compared together, the depiction of the Genesis wave seems to come from an entirely different franchise. It is an example of attempting to run before the filmmakers could walk and unfortunately, while it is certainly iconic and was reused for Star Trek IV The Voyage Home, it is not a good reflection on the ability of the franchise to deliver the beautiful visuals it would come to be known by.
However, it must also be said that while this scene sticks out like a sore thumb, the model work in the Wrath of Khan elevates the film back up. The entire sequence in the Mutara Nebula is a classic example of why real studio models were used right up until Star Trek Voyager. They may have been more cumbersome but they delivered a beautiful punch.
9. Star Trek Voyager - In The Flesh
Species 8472 were the largest scale, entirely digital race that were created for Star Trek Voyager and so singling them out may come across as slightly harsh. However, this particular scene lands on this list because it is a disappointing entry to Species 8472's canon.
The big reveal in sickbay during the episode was designed to be a shocking moment. The Doctor administers his treatment that will reverse the DNA sequencing and both he and Janeway show shock and fear. However, the thing they fear is neither shocking nor frightening.
For their first appearance in the show, 8472 was shrouded mostly in darkness and when the ships began to attack, it was an entirely CGI scene. This scene however shows the digital creature superimposed on the sickbay set, with two defined actors only serving to highlight the soft, CGI edge in the foreground. With the limitations of television budgeting available, it is entirely forgivable to attempt this as, the alternative (guy in a suit) would have looked equally ridiculous.
It is somewhat fair to say though that the members of 8472 who are played by human actors in this episode serve a far better purpose for the plot than the CGI puppet in sickbay and the more time that is spent with them raises the overall quality of the episode.
8. Star Trek V - The Final Frontier - Overall Effects
The Final Frontier has its problems. It was beset with production issues from the off, not least because of the rushed production schedule and the untried director. However, for the purpose of this list, its biggest drawback was the fact that Industrial Light and Magic, who had provided the effects on all three previous films were working on Indiana Jones and The Last Crusade. That meant that they were unavailable to cover the effects and it really shows.
There are many issues. The studio model of the Enterprise was the same one that had been produced by ILM for the Motion Picture, but had been damaged and had to be repainted, adding to the time delays. Shatner insisted on watching all pre-vis for the effects, adding large amounts of time to change anything he didn't like. The ending sequence, originally planned to feature fire breathing rock men, was replaced with a blob of light that would chase Kirk when the results of the actor in the rubber suit looked as ridiculous as it sounds.
Many of the effects on the film were either reused from the Voyage Home (the shot in Spacedock), filmed on set or rear projected, which was a cheaper way of producing CGI shots.
The end result was, despite the best of intentions going in, Star Trek V looked cheap. However, one massive positive that the film has, while nothing to do with the effects, was the glorious return of Jerry Goldsmith to score the film, bringing back the Star Trek march from the Motion Picture.
7. Star Trek Voyager - Macrocosm
The macrovirus encountered by Voyager had the potential to be a terrifying enemy to defeat. Instead, the soft focus, balloony looking creatures just serve to add to the hilarity of the overall episode.
There are several issues with this season three entry. There are gaps in logic (how did Voyager get access to those new phaser rifles?) and enormous gaps in quality. While the idea of Janeway taking on the Ripley role itself could make for a great episode of Star Trek, the fact that she is fighting these creatures completely deflates any sense of menace or drama from the scenario.
What's even more frustrating about these designs is that Star Trek Voyager had already shown some fairly impressive CGI work. Many scenes in the first season stand out - the entire Grendel sequence from Heroes and Demons springs to mind, and many of the scenes with the Doctor are also far superior.
While these creatures are not as bad as some of the other entries on this list, they do stand out as an awkward page in Voyager's history. An ill conceived idea from the beginning, the entire scenario is best forgotten. Just keep calm and think of the lovely CGI work on Discovery and Picard.
6. Star Trek Enterprise - Stigma
This is an example of scenery, which is often far easier to render than close up shots of alien races. This cityscape appeared in the Star Trek universe after the beautiful display of the cityscape of Romulus for Star Trek Nemesis.
There is little argument to be had here. The people in the shot are so clearly of Sims quality that it is a wonder why they were even included to begin with. These are far away shots and technically they should be better than the close up issues on display with the two Xindi races or even the Macrovirus from Voyager.
But what seems to be on display is a rush job, put into a scene with the hope of revisiting it at a later stage. Perhaps the production team never got the chance to do this but, honestly, cutting this shot from the episode entirely would probably only serve to improve the scene as a whole!
5. Star Trek Insurrection - Admiral Dougherty's Death
This entry appears here not just for the obvious visual issue on display but also for the fact that this film should have delivered more.
Following on the heels of the fantastic Star Trek First Contact, Insurrection was a hotly anticipated sequel. The tone opted for a more upbeat and hopeful message, which was a bit jarring after the pitch blackness of the Borg plot. That aside, it is the first film in the franchise to rely entirely on CGI and it largely succeeds in delivering. The shots of the Enterprise E are beautiful and the Son'a fleet is terrifically rendered. The first CGI flaws start to show in the shuttle battle between Data, Worf and Picard but these are forgivable.
The Son'a skin stretching technology is less forgivable. When demonstrated on F. Murray Abraham's Ru'afo, the make-up in place takes some of the edge off of the CGI. The mask he wears is already stretched and pulled apart, so the CGI 'help' doesn't make much of an impact. However, when the full intact face of Anthony Zerbe's Admiral Dougherty is thrown down on the machine, the issues explode on the screen.
It is roughly five seconds long and it robs the scene of any dramatic impact. This old man had just received a beating, which was very uncomfortable to watch. The horror of his impending murder is looming and then, deflating everything, his face is stretched like putty. An unfortunate end to what should have been a tense and upsetting scene.
4. Star Trek Voyager - Basics
Suffering many of the same issues that the other Voyager entries on this list faced, the Hanonian Land Eel was meant to be a terrifying creature of dread. It had the honour of being the first entirely CGI creature created for Star Trek Voyager and while it was ambitious, it is a victim of that ambition.
The first shot of the Eel, shown in this image, has it wrapped up and waiting. It looks like a matte painting. Until it moves. Another example of the CGI clashing horribly with the real actors in the scene, it is an example of hope being dampened by reality, which probably sounds extremely cruel!
Something positive to be said about this though was that it was the initial attempts like this that pushed the CGI artists further, allowing for a greater display of imagery in later seasons.
This would be the precursor to other non-humanoid creatures like the Macrovirus and Species 8472 and without this rubbery old Eel, Star Trek may not have had the bravery to push forward into the CGI achievements it would later display.
3. Star Trek Enterprise - Xindi Aquatic
Enterprise season three pushed boundaries and it is responsible for the rise in the show's overall quality. The inclusion of the five separate races of the Xindi was a fantastic idea, demonstrating the differences in evolution of a race in ways that hadn't been touched on before.
The Primates, Reptilian and Arboreal races all look excellent and the make-up for each, varying in layers and intensity, are a triumph. The latter two races however, while certainly ambitious, let the side down for everyone.
The Xindi Aquatic race, exactly what it sounds like, was a water dwelling element of the Xindi council. There is very little to say other than they just look so out of place among most of the rest of the characters that it begs the question why the production team had to include them. This criticism does not extend to their ships, which are stunning, but just to the race themselves.
They are perhaps let down most by the now common theme of having to interact with real actors and scenes. The CGI of the early '00s just had not advanced far enough to make this look convincing and they come off as a projected cartoon on otherwise solid sets. However, they are only the second worst of the Xindi races in this respect...
2. Star Trek Enterprise - Xindi Insectoid
The Xindi Insectoid race were billed as fearsome and hot headed when in actuality, they were not at all threatening. They inevitably call to mind the similarly woeful Geonosians of Star Wars Episode II Attack of the Clones. They are, like the Aquatics, entirely rendered through CGI but the budget really does show whenever they are on the screen.
They are shown most often alongside the Reptilian race and it only serves to do an injustice to both. The Reptilians are supposed to be fearsome and deadly - which they most certainly are, when alone, thanks to a combination of acting and fantastic make-up. There is no strong acting to reconcile the dreadful CGI display for the Xindi Insectoids here. Showing them in the room with the rest and having the other actors react so seriously to them is unintentionally hilarious - and that is with a healthy dose of suspending disbelief as well.
As previously stated, if there is a positive to take away from this, it is that the limitations that were shown here gave rise to the need for a greater budget and greater degree of technology when attempting this. Comparing the Insectoids to the Tardigrade from Discovery, for example, one would be forgiven for not knowing these two creatures came from the same franchise at all.
So, its tenuous, but possibly the Insectoids are to thank for the improvements in the future shows? Maybe?
1. Star Trek Enterprise - The Gorn
The absolute winner of worst CGI goes to the very same creature that would probably win any list for worst make up and costuming as well!
The final season of Enterprise has many of the best episodes on show. Two such episodes are the wonderful In A Mirror, Darkly. They are set entirely in the mirror universe and they are a lot of fun, watching the crew play out the evil versions of themselves, along with boarding a '60s accurate version of the USS Defiant. There is even a Tholian in the episode which looks quite good all things considered.
When the Gorn enters the fray however, you simply just have to see the funny side. The episode was created for comedy and it completely delivers. Archer versus the CGI Gorn has about the same level of threat as Kirk versus the rubber Gorn. Give it enough time and this scene may go down in infamy as well. It. Is. Hilarious. It's like watching of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles try to fight, had that turtle been animated while drunk.
This may seem like a scathing criticism but in all actuality, it completely adds to the hilarity of the episode. It's meant to be funny. It's meant to be tongue in cheek. Maybe one day, the Gorn will appear in either Discovery or Picard where they might be presented as a more formidable race but for now, thanks to this wonderful CGI offering, they remain the funniest and cuddliest warrior race in the Star Trek canon.