10 Worst Doctor Who Performances Ever

The (not so) good, the bad and the damn right awful.

The history of Doctor Who has been littered with a plethora of superbly written characters who were cast and performed beautifully by their actors. David Tennant was majestic; Matt Smith danced his way between crazy, compassionate and genius; Clara was brought to life through the warmth and strength displayed by Jenna Coleman and John Simm gave The Master a whole new level of depth as a villain. Ecclestone tried desperately to conceal his pain and Tom Baker truly wrestled with his morality. Tony Curran's Van Gogh was a masterpiece and Jessica Hynes complimented the Doctor perfectly as Joan Redfern. In spite of these performance highs, the show has had some absolute clangers over the years too. Some performances were just a little average, and some took the show to whole new lows that relegated even the most positive of Whovians to huffing and grunting at the TV.

10. Richard Briers (Chief Caretaker) - Paradise Towers

Richard Briers has been through the ringer for his performance as the Chief Caretaker, which was a rare blip in an otherwise successful acting career. Before his death in 2013 he had been active in the entertainment industry for over 50 years and the tributes that flowed in after his passing were a testament to the quality he had managed. That doesn't mean that he was infallible though, and from the moment he was possessed by the evil spirit of Kroagnon his performance completely fell apart. It was a shame because up until that point he had been fine. But with the possession came a terrible awkwardness and stiffness that, when coupled with the Hitleresque costume and Basil Fawlty moustache, meant that what began as another solid Richard Briers performance turned into a perfect storm of rubbish-ness. It was as though Briers couldn't conjure up any kind of ideas of how to play the character and, in a cold sweat, bumbled through his lines hoping that nobody would notice his discomfort.

9. Noel Clarke (Mickey) - Boom Town

Okay, so there were a lot of performances to choose from for Mickey. Maybe it was the childlike nature of the character or maybe it was a lack of any real scripted relationship between Mickey and Rose, but the character was easily one of the worst consistently in the show's history. Pretty much all male companions have been woefully weak and soppy, often appearing as more of a straggler than companion. For Mickey this made him feel like a puppy sulking when its master is out of the room and then cloying for attention when she comes back. It's true that he does toughen up in the later series, having spent a significant amount of time in an alternate universe, but that still leaves plenty of performances where Noel Clarke unconvincingly played the poor puppy and failed to come across as believable at all. Possibly the worst of these performances can be found in Boom Town. Chemistry was an alien concept in this episode. At no point was it believable that the pair had ever had any kind of relationship, let alone intimacy, and the script seemed to be delivered more like an improv session than a tied together performance. Nothing he says is backed up with any real emotion and comes across as being unbelievable and insincere, leading you to like his character even less. At least the writers, and Noel, had the opportunity to redeem his character in later episodes. Unlike some.

8. Abisola Agbaje (Chloe) - Fear Her

If ever there was a reason for a writer to feel guilty, it would be when criticising a child actor. What would make it worse is if a really famous TV series had a long history of hiring bad child actors to play bad child characters but said writer still chose to single out one particular child actor. Well, that is what is going to happen now. Because Abisola Agbaje is on the list of the worst ever Doctor Who performances. Cue the rush of guilt. In general her performance was as bad as many other kids, but during the intense sinister moments where she was supposed to be haunting and scary all we got was an unconvincing arm fold, and absolutely nothing else. And then, when the alien possessing her starts to speak through her, we get whispering. It's hard to tell if the intent was to be sinister, or show a weak youthful alien, or maybe even just a plain abstract, but the only thing they did get was a young actress left looking out of her depth. On a much brighter note: "Night Terrors" was a far better take on the 'child whose thoughts become a dystopic reality' and is really worth another watch.

7. Graham Crowden (Soldeed) - The Horns Of Nimon

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eRUqJSCOyZ4 The Horns of Nimon was a Greek mythology imitation and one of the most over-the-top stories in the show's history. The whole episode was filled with silliness that actually got in the way of some nice ideas. The Nimon life cycle that included arriving on planets after long migrations as 'godlike' entities and setting up power networks for further travelling is a very nice concept, but it was completely under utilised and a quality episode lost. That wasn't the worst thing about the episode though.; the above video was. Graham Crowden surely thought he was in a pantomime version of Shakespeare's Twelfth Night as Sir Andrew Aguecheek. David Brent is probably the only character who you could feel less comfortable watching, but at least Ricky Gervais wrote him to be that way. For anyone who likes to associate with a character and enjoy the subtle skill of an actor then Soldeed is certainly not for you.

6. Kylie Minogue (Astrid Peth) - Voyage Of The Damned

Kylie Minogue has the face for TV but her acting ability just isn't as good as the hype would suggest. Astrid Peth is a great character in the Voyage of the Damned. She is a semi love interest cum companion for the Doctor, she is broken having lost her purpose for life and finally, having begun to find a passion for exploration with the Doctor, she is killed in what was a rubbish first death scene that was followed by a much better death scene. Kylie actually pulls off the character with some wonderful close up shots of her pouting and giving Tennant the wounded puppy eyes. But that's as far as her acting talents reach. There is a serious lack of convincing dialogue or chemistry and where it does appear is a result of clever editing, shot framing and the emotional machine that is David Tennant carrying them both. For most people that would be acceptable, but for a show-stopping, A-list celebrity it just doesn't cut the mustard and as a result La Minogue goes down as one of the most disappointing performances on the show.

5. Peter Kay (Abzorbaloff) - Love and Monsters

Much like the 'childish' problem faced with early Mickey, Peter Kay fell into the same 'nothingy' trap. The Abzorbaloff was a monster designed by nine-year-old William Grantham of Colchester, for a 'Design a Doctor Who Monster' competition held by Blue Peter and appeared in the episode "Love & Monsters". Peter Kay, as the Abzorbaloff obviously, is a creature that absorbs other living beings into his body with a simple touch. In doing so, the Abzorbaloff makes his victims part of himself, adding their memories and knowledge to his own while slowly killing them. The potential for this villain is brilliant. Instead of a complex, multiple personality character with depth and layers we saw Peter Kay playing the role of Peter Kay in a fancy costume, sticking his tongue out a lot. It is easily one of the laziest performances ever seen.

4. Jeanna Crowley (Vena) - Timelash

If you rearrange the letters of Timelash, they rather pertinently make up the word 'Lame Sh*t', which pretty well sums up how the vast majority of fans regard this particular episode. Vena, played by Jeanna Crowley, is one of the reasons why. Trying to articulate the depths of just how low this performance went is a tough ask, but this excerpt by John Bensalhia cannot be beaten.
Crowley glides her way through the story with the expression of a woman who's just been thwacked on the head with a frying pan. Worse still, she reads her lines with all the emotion of an ironing board. €œHe's dangling on the edge of oblivion!€ is a bad enough line, but in Crowley's hands, it's made doubly worse in that she shows no concern whatsoever.
Bad episode. Bad character. Truly terrible acting.

3. Roy Skelton (Kroton) - The Krotons

One of the most undersold qualities of Doctor Who is the monster voices. From the unmistakable ring modulated Daleks to the whispering snake-like Ice Warriors, the show has always had a penchant for making use of the villains' voice. With the exception of two Krotons that is. One apparently originated from Birmingham and the other is a weird mix of Brummie and South African. This meant that €œThe Dynatrope will expire in 30 minutes€ actually sounded like €œThee Dwey-nat-raope weell expoyar een therteee meeneets€. And rather than menacing people with cries of €˜Exterminate€™ they threaten people with €œYou weeel be deespersed my son€. What is most disappointing is that one of the voice artists is Roy Skelton, a good voice actor. That means that playing the characters with those voices was a conscious choice rather than some poor soul who happened to hail from the wastes of Birmingham. And it is that conscious decision that makes the Kroton one of the worst performances in Doctor Who history.

2. Catherine Tate (Donna) - The Runaway Bride

Catherine Tate€™s opening performance as Donna isn't too dissimilar to listening to someone scratching their nails down a blackboard. Yes, she does eventually become a well rounded and very likeable character who develops lots of chemistry and depth with the Doctor, but her introduction was painful. The good news is that Catherine Tate doesn't come across as wooden or trying too hard to play a character that just doesn't work. The bad news is that she is on absolutely top form when it comes to the over-the-top, loud mouthed, decibel shattering, Essex annunciating character that she has become famous for elsewhere. Thank goodness she dials it down a notch and the writers actually brought in some character development and quieter scenes for Donna to take part in later.

1. Rick James (Cotton) - The Mutants

'Bungled', 'Uneven' and 'Convoluted' are just a few of the words used in major reviews of The Mutants episode, and Rick James could probably be held accountable for all of them on the merit of his performance alone. Every single scene that Cotton appears in is undermined by a man who looks like he had never taken an acting lesson in his life. His woodenness and apparent inability to deliver his lines with any degree of conviction make the episode feel more like a primary school nativity - minus the proud parent blinkers. Everything feels forced and contrived, and unfortunately, it felt like he was in A LOT of scenes. Congratulations Rick James, you have earned the title of worst ever performance on Doctor Who. Who has been judged too harshly and who hasn't been judged harshly enough and deserves a spot instead?

Contributor
Contributor

I have been described as a sportsman with the brain of an athlete and the body of a scientist. Since it was established that playing wouldn't work out for me I have taken to writing.