11 Best 11th Doctor Episodes

The 11 best episodes from one of the best Doctor Who eras of all time!

Eleventh Doctor Matt Smith Doctor Who Series 5
BBC Studios

For many whovians out there, the best Doctor Who era is without question the 11th, starring Matt Smith as the adventuring Time Lord. And it isn't hard to see why, since it's the one many fans most likely started with.

Sure, you could argue that the fandom for the Doctor Who reboot had been steadily building ever since David Tennant took over, but the 11th era coincided with the advent of social media - particularly the "fandom" culture of sites like Tumblr and Reddit - making for a perfect storm of word of mouth spread that resulted in the hype train moving at turbo speeds and never really stopping.

If you ever watched Sherlock or the new Dracula and wondered why Steven Moffat gets so much slack, this era of Britain's most famous sci-fi show is why. But what episodes solidified that? Sure, this Doctor Who era focused quite a bit on long running narratives and mysteries, but it always remembered to have great standalone episodes in between all that. And we're gonna be looking at the best of the bunch. A lot of great episodes had to be left out to make room, leaving none but these as the definitive 11 episodes of one of the best Doctor Who eras of all time.

11. The Lodger

Doctor Who The Lodger James Corden Craig Owens
BBC Studios

"The Doctor in a lodger sitcom", the jokes just write themselves.

When the TARDIS gets stuck in a mysterious time loop, sending it hurtling through the time vortex and taking Amy with it, The Doctor has to investigate alone. But he needs a place to stay in the meantime, so he decides to hole up in a rent-a-room held by a man named Craig, played hilariously by James Corden.

The Doctor then proceeds to be the weirdest and yet most helpful roommate in the history of roommates, while also figuring out what's going on with Craig's flat. Leading to some hilarious shenanigans such as The Doctor trying to save Craig in nothing but a towel and armed with a toothbrush (to be fair he would still have probably pulled it off) and of course, The Doctor DOMINATING at football because Matt Smith is a pro football player of course that's how it goes.

It's not the most intelligent episode out there, but it IS a lot of fun and really funny, and frankly that's all you need from a Doctor Who episode sometimes.


10. The Angels Take Manhattan

Amy and rory
BBC

The two perfect companions for the 11th Doctor were Amy and Rory Pond, the former being just as childishly silly as the Doctor she traveled with, and the latter being a snarky realist that kept the two nice and grounded. Unfortunately, seeing as how these two have absolutely no reason to want to leave The Doctor of their own accord, there was only ever one way this could end.

When The Doctor and friends stumble upon an apartment used by the weeping angels as a time energy farm by trapping the residents inside it until they die, Rory and Amy just barely manage to escape a horrible death that seemed inevitable by the very laws of time. Only for one last weeping angel to get them both before they can get back to the TARDIS, first getting Rory by surprise, then getting a willing Amy, who would rather be sent back to the past and have a shot at seeing Rory again, instead of staying with The Doctor and there being no chance in hell.

It's an utterly heartbreaking and yet fitting end to the Ponds as characters, knowing that at least the couple has each other, even if The Doctor can't ever see them again. It's even more heartbreaking when you rewatch the first episode of Smith's run and realize the true tragic significance of the episode's ending with 7 year old Amy seemingly hearing the TARDIS appearing in front of her. Solidifying that this was how it was going to end from the beginning.


9. The Wedding Of River Song

Doctor Who Wedding Of River Song Resized
BBC

Throughout Series 6, The Doctor has been hounded by the knowledge that he WILL die at Lake Silencio at the hands of The Silence. Since it's a fixed point in time, he can't change it, so he does the most human thing he's probably ever done: he runs. But of course, one can only run for so long. So The Doctor goes to face his destiny.

Only for the assassin, in this case River, to say no to shooting him. And since - again - this is a fixed point in time, we get to see what happens when that particular rule is broken. Namely, everything goes bloody crazy. Now, we've seen what happens when fixed points in time are broken before, like with Rose's Dad. But since The Doctor is a time traveler, the consequences are a bit more...shall we say, dire.

All of time unravels and tries to put itself back together, making for a fascinatingly bonkers world that The Doctor has to fix. It's a hell of a finale to one of the best seasons in this entire era of Who.


8. A Christmas Carol

Doctor Who A Christmas Carol Kazran Sardick
BBC

A Christmas Carol is one of those stories where it's repeated so constantly that you can totally get away with The Doctor coming up with a plan just by repeating the name of the book over and over until he puts two and two together. But that's because it's a tried and true formula for a character study that opens itself up for lots of cool spins.

In this case, a ship full of hundred of people, including Rory and Amy, is crashing down onto a planet with an artificial storm system that's run by the cruel old miser Kazran Sardyk, played wonderfully by Michael Gambon. The Doctor decides that instead of ramming his head against this walking, talking brick wall, the best course is to go back in time to when Kazran was a kid and help him grow up to be a better man, with the help of a cryogenically frozen young woman.

You might be thinking "wait that's not how time travel works in Doctor Who!" To which I respond with "Correct...now stop being a party pooper." Because this episode earns its minor rule breaking due to it being in service to a truly fantastic story and one of the best renditions of the timeless classic ever made.


7. Closing Time

Doctor Who Closing Time
BBC Studios

More fun with Craig, who now has a kid to look after, and Cybermen to deal with. With a baby that won't stop crying (and declaring himself the dark lord of all), and his wife leaving on a trip, trusting him to cope on his own, the last thing he needs right now is The Doctor coming back into his life to poke him with a stick, which is of course exactly what he gets.

The Doctor, coming to terms with how he can't run forever from his destiny at Lake Silencio, decides to pull a 10th Doctor and check up on his old buddies before the end. But when he notices electrical disturbances surrounding a local shopping center, he can't help but pull one last bit of heroics before he sets off.

The episode is some much needed levity before a very serious finale to the season, helped immensely by Matt Smith and James Corden having electrifying chemistry with each other, brilliantly bouncing off each other's wildly different personalities. But it's also a very good closer for Craig's character as he completes his arc into the confident, loving father he always was but needed that extra push The Doctor is so great at giving in order to achieve it.

Given what we've seen of Corden's family life, perhaps Moffat was trying to get a message through to Corden.


6. A Good Man Goes To War

Doctor Who Rory Cyber-ships explosion A Good Man Goes To War
BBC

"Demons run when a good man goes to war". Moffat's love of metaphors and mythos got a good bit tiring near the end of his run, but that one will always be a stone cold winner.

Amy has been captured by the militaristic cult known as The Silence, set on stealing and training her soon-to-be-born daughter from childhood into the perfect assassin for hunting down The Doctor. Shame then, for them, that The Doctor is coming to them with an army of the greatest warriors in history that owe him favors. And if they weren't already screwed enough, a very pissed off Rory is coming with him.

Needless to say, a snowflake in hell lasts longer than The Silence's armies. But don't count out Madame Kovarian just yet.

This is the Empire Strikes Back of Doctor Who episodes, a brilliant mid-season clash between our hero and our villain. And while the villain ultimately wins, we know in the back of our minds that The Doctor is going to come out on top somehow. But this episode definitely leaves that "how" looking more mysterious than ever before.

What ISN'T mysterious, however, is what we learn about the lovely River Song at the end of this episode. I won't give it away because any Whovian will tell you why, but needless to say it's a shock to the system.


5. The God Complex

The God Complex Promo
BBC

Steven Moffat is most at home when he's actively trying to give Doctor Who's child fanbase nightmares for the rest of their lives, and this is by far the scariest episode of the 11th era.

In this creeping, haunting story in the vein of the absolute best of Stephen King, The Doctor and crew find themselves sidetracked in a weird hotel with pictures of random people all over the place, and some random folks running around. Turns out the hotel is really some kind of sick maze being run by a mysterious monster whose mere presence drives you to insane suicidal worship of it, before finally killing you.

Every room inhabits something that haunts the humans running throughout its halls. Is it their fears, their doubts, their beliefs? The Doctor can't quite figure it out, and every moment he spends trying, someone else dies. In the end, The Doctor will have to confront the things that he fears even admitting are there, in order to save his friends.

It's a chilling tale of fear and faith that will leave any kid watching shaken to their core.


4. Amy's Choice

Doctor Who Amy's Choice the Dream Lord Toby Jones
BBC Studios

Moffat loves building up the legend of The Doctor, but he equally loves tearing it down with sadistic glee. This episode is the best of the latter examples, as well as a brilliant character study of Amy Pond.

One could argue that Amy, and this episode as a whole, was meant as an agreement with Whovians who were put off by the first New Who companion - Rose Tyler. Sure she was a fun character in her own right, but her flighty nature and flippant attitude towards her friends and family (Mickey Smith deserved so much better) in favour of her boyfriend in the police box, rubbed many Whovians the wrong way.

Amy in series 5 had the same problem, though made a bit more justifiable by her having cold feet from her impending marriage to Rory Williams. She really does love him, but she's still mesmerized by the childish fantasy of The Doctor. Amy's Choice is the ultimate wake up call in the form of a mysterious figure known as The Dream Lord - played by the walking, talking embodiment of sass, Toby Jones - trapping them between two realities, one being real and the other a dream. In both lies a deadly danger, and they need to choose which one to lose to. In turn, Amy needs to choose which life she wants, the bumbling but loyal to a fault country nurse or the fantastical but flippant Doctor who is likely to just run off with the next warm body that wanders into his TARDIS.

It's a fun episode made all the weightier by the deep study of Amy's character, and how she will always choose Rory when the chips are down.


3. The Doctor's Wife

Doctor Who The Doctor's Wife
BBC

If there is any universal rule in these crazy times, it's that Neil Gaiman can do no wrong. So when he came on to write an episode of Doctor Who, Whovians everywhere hooped and hollered in celebration. And the episode in question - The Doctor's Wife - does not disappoint.

The Doctor answers a distress call from what seems to be an old Time Lord buddy of his, from outside of the universe. Not five minutes into landing on the only mass of rock in this vast emptiness, the TARDIS completely shuts down. Turns out it's been downloaded into the mind of a woman, at the behest of the living eldritch miasma controlling the space rock "House" (played by Michael Sheen- because if it's Neil Gaiman, you can bet that Michael Sheen will show up eventually), so that he can devour the Doctor like he did with the other Time Lords he lured here. When he learns that no more Time Lords will be coming, he decides to take the now empty TARDIS and head off to the universe.


2. The 11th Hour

Eleventh Hour
BBC

Opening episodes for Doctors have always been and will likely always be a tricky thing to figure out. You have to both be an entertaining standalone episode, establish the tone, companions, and supporting cast, and get people on board with a new Doctor. Which, for Moffat and crew, was a particularly herculean effort.

They were being tasked to follow up one of the all time best Doctor Who runs, and convince people to keep watching with just one episode. They didn't even have the advantage of an actor everyone wanted to see as The Doctor, like David Tennant or Peter Capaldi after this. NO ONE outside of hardcore football fans knew who Matt Smith was, and given that he's the youngest Doctor so far, it was one hell of an uphill battle.

Do I even need to say how successful they were?

The Eleventh Hour isn't just a fun episode, it is a masterpiece of proper pacing, story and character establishment, laying the ground work for the season ahead. In just 45 minutes, the 11th Doctor wins you over with his whimsical charm, recruits new companion Amy Pond, gets a new screwdriver and TARDIS. He establishes that he's a total badass by scaring off an entire army and then calling them back to scare them some MORE just because he felt like it, and finds a new thread to chase with the mysterious cracks in the universe.

Not once does it feel like as much of a mess as it sounds when you lay it all out like that. It was the perfect gateway to a universe of fun.


1. The Time Of The Doctor

Doctor Who Time Of The Doctor Matt Smith Amy Pond Karen Gillan
BBC

The only thing more harrowing than beginning a Doctor Who run is ending it. The Time Of The Doctor is a more than worthy successor to The End Of Time, especially in comparison to its successor, the just-kind-of-alright Twice Upon A Time.

The Doctor has long since learned that he is destined to die at some point in time on the planet of Trenzalore. So when every single baddie he's ever pissed off gathers above Trenzalore's skies, The Doctor and new companion Clara go to investigate. Lo and behold, they find the last crack in the universe. Through it, a single message emerges. "Doctor Who?"

It's the Time Lords, sending a message through all time and space. If The Doctor says his name, the Time Lords will know they have the right universe and come on through...straight into the waiting gunfire of the Daleks, Cybermen, and everyone else who hates them. Stuck in the middle are the innocent people of Trenzalore.

So The Doctor, realising he can't let his people through nor abandon the people of Trenzalore, decides that he's going to stay and protect both. No matter how long it takes.

This episode is action packed, dramatic, it gives final answers to all of the loose plot questions left hanging, and it shows the true measure of The Doctor's noble and protective nature. It was nothing short of a perfect farewell to one of the greatest Doctors of all time.

Geronimo.


Doctor Who Quiz: How Well Do You Know Matt Smith's 11th Doctor?

Doctor Who The Eleventh Hour
BBC Studios

1. The Eleventh Doctor First Gets His Clothes From Where?

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

John Tibbetts is a novelist in theory, a Whatculture contributor in practice, and a nerd all around who loves talking about movies, TV, anime, and video games more than he loves breathing. Which might be a problem in the long term, but eh, who can think that far ahead?