11 Doctor Who Rumours That Turned Out To Be Complete Twaddle

Liar liar, pants on fire.

Ah, the British press. They've pretty much lost every ounce of credibility they had (if that was ever any) by this point but they're still managing to spurt out their usual foray of nonsensical stories and ridiculous reports. As one of the most hotly discussed programmes on TV, Doctor Who is often at the forefront of their outlandish claims and over the years there has been a never ending supply of "Earth-shattering" exclusives relating to the Doctor's adventures that have well and truly sent the rumour mill into overdrive. Doctor Who has even taken the time to respond to the endless outpouring of twaddle. Russell T Davies took the chance to make a dig at the tabloids in Partners in Crime when the Tenth Doctor told an enquiring journalist to "just make it up" - and it would seem that the real life ones have taken the invitation far too seriously. Some of the rumours have had truth to them (usually when the 'journalist' has been trawling the Doctor Who message boards) but that has almost always been coincidental. Most of the rumours on this list don't even deserve to be given our attention but it's amusing to see the sort of stuff they'll come up with in order to create clickbait. Extra! Extra! Don't read all about it...


11. The Death Of Amy Pond

Back in 2011 the BBC's decision to split the latest series of Doctor Who into two parts, to be aired in the spring and autumn, was one that was met with the inevitable tidal wave of excitement and frustration from the Doctor's legion of fans. Whether you liked the idea or not, though, you no doubt still took the time to indulge in the foray of fevered speculation that surrounded the inevitable twist that would play out as the cliffhanger of the show's new format. Never one to miss out on a party, the ever reliable Sun newspaper also attempted to get tongues wagging by claiming that the then-current companion Amy Pond would sensationally pop her clogs as part of the show's "game changing" mid-series conclusion. The word "game changing" actually came from the BBC so they only had themselves to blame for the outlandish theories that came their way during the build up to the episode in question. Although she ultimately didn't die, it was still pretty eventful for the girl who waited as it transpired she had actually been a doppelgänger clone for most of the series whilst the real version of her was getting ready to give birth to a psychopathic baby who had been conditioned to grow up and kill the Doctor. In retrospect, maybe killing her off would've resulted in a lot less confusion.

10. The Axe Factor

In some ways Freema Agyeman was always doomed in her portrayal of the Doctor's companion, Martha Jones. Suffice to say, she was already under a colossal amount of scrutiny before she had even stepped aboard the TARDIS owing to the fact that she had signed on as the successor of the ever popular Billie Piper. It didn't really help matters that her character was being constantly compared to Rose Tyler on screen, too, so when she left the role after just one series in 2007, it did all look rather suspicious. Unsurprisingly it didn't take long for the tabloids to come forth with their concocted claims that Freema had in fact been axed from the series after producers decided her performance wasn't strong enough to justify a return. One paper even went as far as describing her as "a struggling actress" which was pretty uncalled for really. It was suggested that her untimely exit from the series would be explained in a new storyline in which the Doctor randomly lost her and embarked on an epic mission through the universe to find her. That would've been somewhat careless, even by his standards. Freema responded to the rumours by confirming that it had always been the plan for her to leave after her initial 13 episode stint and the character went on to prove the naysayers wrong by returning to the show not once, not twice but three times between the years of 2008 and 2010 - and she even even left her mark on its spin off by reprising the role for three episodes during the second series of Torchwood. Not too shabby for an actress who "just wasn't right for Doctor Who", eh?

9. The Meddling Monk

As some younger/newer fans of the revived series might now know, the Meddling Monk is a Time Lord and a former friend of the Doctor's who went on to become one of his adversaries (sound familiar? The Master wasn't the first to go bad, you know!) when he decided to become a renegade and stole a TARDIS to interfere in the events of history for his own amusement. Whatever floats your boat. To date he has only appeared in two serials, The Time Meddler and The Daleks' Master Plan, alongside William Hartnell as the First Doctor but Classic Series fans have long been calling for him to return. They very almost got their wish back in 2009 - that is, if the tabloids are to be believed - when it was reported that he'd be returning to wreak more havoc opposite David Tennant's Tenth Doctor in a timey-wimey two parter featuring the Daleks who, let's face it, at this point pretty much go to the opening of an envelope. And who would've played the new incarnation of the malevolent Monk in all his time-interfering glory? None other than cult legend Sir Patrick Stewart who has already left his mark on sci-fi history for his iconic portrayal of Captain Jean-Luc Picard in Star Trek. Apparently he was more than up for it, too, after forming a close friendship with David Tennant during their stint together in the Royal Shakespeare Company's 2008 production of Hamlet. In 2010 Peter responded to the rumours - at a Star Trek convention, of all places - by confirming that the ship had probably sailed. It's probably good that he didn't appear, anyway. The entire stratosphere of the fandom would've probably imploded.

8. Keepin' It In The Family

In 2007 Joanna Page became a household name - and deservedly so, it has to be said - for her popular performance as the loveable Gwen Stacey in the hit BBC romantic comedy Gavin & Stacey. As such, it was only a matter of time before she was called upon to leave her mark on one of Britain's other best loved shows and that moment arrived in 2013 when she added a touch of royalty to the glittering cast ensemble of Doctor Who's spectacular 50th anniversary special. While her portrayal of Queen Elizabeth I was the actress' first official association with the series, she had previously been linked to a role which would've seen her crossing paths with the titular Time Lord long before The Day of the Doctor. Back in 2010 it was suggested - by the ever credible Daily Star - that Joanna had signed to play an undisclosed member of the Doctor's family (mother? Sister? Cousin? Illegitimate daughter?) and that her role would have the potential to become a recurring one after an initial two episode stint which would've been used to establish her character within the show's mythology. According to an insider she was destined to be the "new star of Doctor Who" and five years later she, and no doubt her agent, are still waiting for it to happen. She'll always be a star in her own right, though - albeit one that's less prominent in the skies of the Whoniverse as initially predicted.

7. Dame Doctor

Doctor Who Helen Mirren Every time a new Doctor is about to be revealed it's the same old argument. Discussions of having a female incarnation always manage to claw their way back to the forefront of the conversation and back in 2013 - with the announcement of Peter Capaldi in the coveted role imminent - it was once again no different. This time the debate caught the attention of Academy Award winning actress, and all around screen veteran, Dame Helen Mirren who got tongues wagging (this time she managed it without swearing) when she claimed during a red carpet interview that it was "absolutely time" for the Doctor to change his gender. Her statement, of course, led to the inevitable turn out of tabloid tripe as it was "exclusively revealed" by practically ever paper going that she herself was in line to take over the TARDIS as the show's first female protagonist. Not to say it wouldn't be great but it was never really going to happen, was it? Suffice to say, Helen promptly responded by affirming that she had definitely not been offered the coveted role and added that she "absolutely wouldn€™t contemplate" it anyway, which made her feelings about the situation pretty clear. A Time Lord with a knighthood would be something very special indeed but at least that box has now been ticked by John Hurt.

6. A Blast From The Past

Doctor Who always finds itself under an intense degree of speculative scrutiny but the far reaching fever reached new levels during the build up to the show's momentous 50th anniversary back in 2013. In fact, no stone was left unturned in the formidable rumour department as pretty much every name under the sun was rumoured to be involved in the commemorations at one point or another. One of the most intriguing claims (this one was from the Express) suggested that one of the show's original leading characters - the Doctor's granddaughter Susan Foreman - would be back to play a part in the landmark festivities. Her name was certainly at the top of a lot of Whovian wishlists and what better way to honour half a century of the Time Lord's than by reintroducing one of his first ever companions? Her on screen comeback untimely came to nothing, though, but her real life alter ego, Carole Ann Ford, did contribute to the celebrations by guest hosting a segment of the 2013 Doctor Who Proms. For Susan fans, though, that was your lot. The same report did foretell the return of Billie Piper but that was always pretty inevitable. It also wrongly implied that Karen Gillan would be involved in the 50th anniversary special but the actress did make a surprise return at the end of the year for the Eleventh Doctor's regeneration, if that counts. (It doesn't.)

5. The Rani Files

Gillian Anderson received critical acclaim for her portrayal of Special Agent Dana Scully in The X-Files and it's a role for which she is still internationally beloved. As another cult icon in the world of science fiction it's no surprise that her name is one that has also been linked to the Time Lord's adventures and as guest roles go, this one would have been quite something to behold. Back in 2009 the American actress was attached - via the Daily Express - to the rumoured return of the Rani, a scientific genius and renegade Time Lord (yes, another one!) who was played with gusto by the late Kate O'Mara in the Classic Series. Gillian's signing was described as "a major coup" by a show insider and her encounter with the then-current Doctor David Tennant looked set to be "one of the greatest sci-fi moments of all time". It all sounds very exciting so it's a shame it never came about. Five years later and fans are still waiting for it to come to fruition.

4. Cyber Kylie

Kylie Minogue has made no secret of the fact she's a self-confessed Doctor Who fanatic. Not only has she written songs about her admiration for everybody's favourite Time Lord but she even enlisted the help of the Cybermen to feature as backing dancers during one of her tours. She must have quite literally been living the Whovian dream, then, when she landed a guest part in the show's 2007 Christmas Special Voyage of the Damned. She should be so lucky! The announcement of any pop princess being cast in the series is always going to result in an explosion of mass media interest (Billie Piper can certainly vouch for that) but with Kylie it was something quite different. Kylie rose to fame for her role as tomboy mechanic Charlene Robinson in the ongoing Australian soap opera Neighbours so it's not like anyone was really in the position to doubt her abilities as an actress. A certain tabloid - it was The Sun, by the way, if you hadn't guessed already from the excruciatingly painful headline - had to find a new way of conjuring clickbait and they accomplished it by claiming that Kylie herself would be playing a Cyberman (or a Cyberwoman, to be more precise) in the festive escapade. Is that really the best they could come up? Evidently, yes.

3. Cumberbatch Master

Here's one for all the Cumberbitches out there. Matt Smith and Benedict Cumberbatch look like they're pretty pally in the picture above but things could have been very, very different. The Sherlock Star - who is currently in line to recieve his first Oscar nomination for his portrayal of pioneering computer scientist Alan Turing in The Imitation Game - found himself in the running to take on the role of the Doctor's arch nemesis (or one of them), the Master, back in 2012. Bear in mind that there was only a grand total of six Doctor Who episodes aired this year so there really wasn't all that much else to talk about. Once again it was the Express that came forth with this Earth-shattering exclusive as they claimed that Benedict's reveal as the renegade Time Lord (seriously, are there even any good ones anymore!?) would coincide with the show's 50th anniversary celebrations. Needless to say, it never happened. Call us cynical, and this isn't to question Benedict's versatility as an actor, but the latest incarnation of the Master, as revealed during the Series 8 finale, definitely was not him. He's the wrong gender, for starters.

2. A Female Doctor

The topic of female Doctors has already been brought up on this list but you must've known that it would make another appearance. Of all the rumours that surround the Doctor's ongoing adventures, this one is by far the most prominent. It's apparently the most persistent, too, as it returned to the surface once again in 2012 (on 2nd April - perhaps publishing it a day earlier would have been more appropriate?) when the Daily Express suggested that the 50th anniversary special would end with the mother of all cliffhangers when the titular Time Lord regenerated into a woman. But it didn't end there. The red top had also been given a secret tip off (one that they evidently felt the need to share) from that ever formidable 'show insider' that Sherlock actress Lara Pulver was "a real contender" to take on the coveted role. Suffice to say, it never happened, though what an almighty cliffhanger it would have been.

1. Too Scary

This one wasn't originally included on the list but it just so happened to surface while it was being written so it had to be mentioned for the sake of coincidence. It goes without saying that the latest series of Doctor Who was darker than ever before but, according to the Mirror, it was ultimately too scary for the show's younger audience - and even some of the adult ones, too - and as a result the BBC have been forced to reevaluate the show's 'edgier' mantra for 2015. They're ditching the darker storylines completely in Series 9, actually, after "a ratings slump" led to fans campaigning for Steven Moffat to be sacked as a result of his "baffling" storylines. It's all very dramatic, isn't it? Yes, not everyone is happy about Doctor Who's new direction but the series is by no means in the state of crisis that the British press persists - far from it, in fact. Statistically the show is more popular than ever so this is just another example of tabloid twaddle that's badly written, poorly researched and generally just an unequivocal waste of (time and) space. Next? What do you think of this list? Have there been any other ridiculous Doctor Who rumours that weren't included? Let us know in the comments section below.

Doctor Who Editor
Doctor Who Editor

Dan Butler is the Doctor Who Editor at WhatCulture.com. When he isn't writing his own articles or editing other people's, he can be found trawling the internet for gifs of Steven Moffat laughing. Contact him via dan.butler@whatculture.co.uk.