11 Shocking Similarities Between Doctor Who And Sherlock

One travels through time. The other investigates crime.

An alienated human being, who - no matter the occasion - always wears the same black trench coat and blue knit scarf, who delights in the prospect of a murder, and who occupies the fabricated position of London's most qualified "consulting" detective, could not be more far removed from... ...an alien Time Lord who - regardless of the time period - never changes his eccentric and iconic outfits, who becomes excited when an unknown danger is ambushing a mysterious planet, and who calls himself "the Doctor" without even brandishing proof of a PhD. Oh, wait. These two eccentric and unforgettable television serials (that just so happen to be helmed by the same writers) have been grappling for the spotlight ever since their respective inceptions. With such distinct personalities and vibrant characters, Doctor Who and Sherlock have amazed, endeared and thrived in their respective universes and, occasionally, their universes collide. Although the Doctor often faces a peril that threatens to ravage and destroy the human race or disintegrate the space-time continuum, Sherlock encounters discombobulating cases, murder intrigues, scandalous secrets and terrorist schemes that would leave London in shambles if not for the resourcefulness and uncanny deduction skills of a very disagreeable detective. You will find that the similarities between the plots, characters and themes of these two franchises far outnumber their differences - it is a mystery just waiting to be solved and a galaxy of possibilities longing to be explored. Allons-y! The game is on!

11. "Inadvertently" Flipping People Off

Spoon Sparring Gif Both Mr Watson and an ornery Scottish Time Lord managed to flip the bird at audiences, so it seems that even these admired characters can lose control of that impetuous middle finger of theirs. You can't blame them, really. Sherlock committed a false suicide without confiding in his best friend, and well... just eyeing that cocky smirk permanently etched across Robin Hood's face would make anyone acrimonious! These obscenely hilarious hand gestures are timed rather perfectly, however. In The Empty Hearse, Sherlock relays to Mrs Hudson that, in the midst of their reunion (which was a very eventful evening), John basically told him to "Fu€". Meanwhile, John is snapping on his uniform latex gloves, his third finger remaining upright for an extended period of time, and diagnoses his patient with a "cough". How clever. The Twelfth Doctor is slightly more subtle and a re-watch of Robot of Sherwood (unless, of course, you're very observant of such things) will greet you with his notorious middle finger. It seems that he is fancifully twiddling his gloved hand, simply adding a ceremonial embellishment while he introduces himself and his very utilitarian choice of weaponry. But upon closer inspection€ how rude! Then again, rude is this Scotsman's middle name.

10. The Terrible Disguises

Terrible Disguises

When Sherlock and the Twelfth Doctor perform a generous act or sport a gracious smile, it is usually with a manipulative agenda in mind. When either tries to censor their commentary before verbalising it, the biting remark usually forces its way free of their conscience. Thus, when they want to be very inconspicuous, they achieve the exact opposite. During The Caretaker, the Doctor cryptically notifies Clara that he€™s going under "deep cover". By deep cover, he means exchanging his navy jacket for a brown one, carrying a broomstick instead of a screwdriver and giving a "general wink" that is absolutely not directed at Coal Hill's egomaniac English teacher. The case of the Bloody Guardsmen confounded many, but perhaps the most disconcerting piece of information was how Sherlock bypassed the numerous guards on duty (and found a spare moment to ruffle his hair in the meantime). By somehow acquiring a guardsman's busby, Sherlock marches mechanically alongside the other ornately-garbed officers, still wearing his cherished trench coat, accentuated by the ever-present knit scarf. At least one of the guardsmen should have been able to deduce that a fraud was among their ranks (besides Sherlock, obviously).

9. The Deceiving Goodbyes

Rose Tyler died - figuratively, of course - in the fateful battle at Canary Wharf, where an army of ghosts solidified into a formidable foe. She restituted the crumbling barriers between universes, but at a grave price. Well, not exactly. It is true that Rose sacrificed her beloved Doctor and her exhilarating life as a time traveller, but not for long. All too soon, the words "Bad Wolf" were scribbled across our screens yet again and Rose defied the seemingly incorrigible laws of the universe as well as the writers' better judgment. One moment she was desperately confessing her love to a teary-eyed Tenth Doctor, convinced that this was their final parting of ways. The next, she was stalking the streets of London armed with a massive laser gun and pulling at the lapels of a conveniently manufactured replica of Ten, engrossing him in a passionate snogging session. Hellos and goodbyes are practically one and the same for this blonde time traveller. Sherlock and his begrudging part time associate/best friend, John Watson, also enjoy trumping audiences with their short lived goodbyes. After the tragic events at Reichenbach, John spills forth a heartfelt eulogy - a last farewell pleading for one more miracle - before his friend's deserted grave while Sherlock, alive and well, eavesdrops in the shadows. This completely clueless detective later decides to pay a casual visit to the man who, for two years, believed his best friend to be dead.

8. The Anger Issues

Everyone agrees that a provoked Time Lord is infinitely more frightening than an army of allied Weeping Angels and Silence (how would that work, anyway? Can Silence blink? Would the Weeping Angels forget the Silence and assume their true form while still being seen by the Silence? Oh, never mind!), but the wrath of John Watson is far more likely to puncture a hole in the fabric of time. John usually cues the audience when he is about to lash out, as indicated by his hands held rigidly at his side. He contorts his face and inhales deeply due to the effort of restraining himself from wringing Sherlock's neck, but it never works. His Last Vow proved this when a livid and frustrated John intentionally sprained Bill Wiggin's arm because the addict made the mistake of delaying John's purposeful ascent to the top floors of the drug dealing headquarters. Mr Watson didn't even need that lead pipe disguised as a revolver to inflict fear in the souls of men. And don't forget poor Sherlock who was mangled, maligned, nose bloodied and probably suffered a few fractured bones after approaching John Watson a bit prematurely in light of his long absence. He deserved every injury, but perhaps John was slightly harsh? Nah. John's competition, though, does have the advantage of living for over 2,000 years - an estimated 30 additional lifetimes - to perfect the art of infuriated ranting. The Tenth Doctor was probably the most proficient at emitting bouts of Time Lord fury, as seen in The Runaway Bride when he mercilessly drowned the Rachnoss, Human Nature when he severely punished the Family and The Waters of Mars when he became corrupted at the notion of "Time Lord Victorious". But everybody knows which anger-driver mad man should truly be feared.

7. Martha & Molly

Unrequited love is what defined these two female protagonists and gradually corroded their self esteem. Aliens and alienated human beings were just their type. Dismissed as unworthy and cast aside by those whom they admired, Martha Jones and Molly Hooper were often considered as no more than lifeless, humanoid-like scenery, exploited and used as either a distraction from a loss or for performing autopsies on deceased victims (or drug tests on stoned detectives). A stammering, bumbling Molly was always ridiculed or interrupted before she even managed to verbalise her thoughts, but never complained when Sherlock barged in and confiscated her laboratory for his own purposes. Martha, meanwhile, misinterpreted the excessively passionate snog that the Doctor claimed was only a genetic transfer (a very efficient genetic transfer, no doubt), inciting an entire season's worth of Martha's lovesick mooning after an indifferent Doctor. He only had eyes for street-smart, easily-impressed-due-to-lack-of-a-formal-education blondes. Fortunately, these psychologically scarred characters prevailed and confronted their sources of pain. Martha mustered up the courage to reject the Doctor's tempting offer at more adventures to reaffirm her value as a person, a truth that was so often eclipsed by Rose's withstanding legacy. Under great duress, Sherlock found refuge in his unrealised friendship with Molly. She became his confidant and assistant in thwarting Moriarty's plans and, eventually, became engaged to a charming young man named Tom who, coincidentally, bears a striking resemblance to... OK, so she's still a work in progress.

6. The Master & Moriarty

A mad man once said that every fairytale needs a good old fashioned villain, and he was very wise indeed. Where would our favourite protagonists be without their malevolent, loony counterparts? Every consulting detective needs a consulting criminal and every idiot Time Lord needs a sophisticatedly idiotic Time Lord (but which Time Lord is which? That€™s for you to decide!). Both of these renowned antagonists are masters at being masterminded criminals, masters of disguise and, well... the Master of evil. Moriarty may as well be a rumoured incarnation of the rogue Time Lord, somehow marauding London before regenerating into a Mary Poppins-esque killer nanny, bound to ruin your childhood of umbrella flying, levitating tea parties, dancing penguins and magical carousels. A complex, incommunicable relationship exists between these villains and their mortal enemies. Both Sherlock and the Doctor seem to admire their foes' persistence and commendably pernicious triumphs (however gruesome they may be), almost regretting to obliterate whatever domineering scheme is tossing, turning and boiling over in their insane and morally twisted minds. Can't Moriarty and his extensive web of criminal associates win for once? Heroes can be sooooo boring.

5. The Psychopath Wife

River Song mystified fans ever since the flirtatious archaeologist lured the Doctor to a deserted library "with a kiss" (*in sarcastic Donna voice*). Full of empty silence and inky black shadows that slithered through the dark, the library harboured deadly secrets that were all eventually uncovered, but not the ones swimming behind River's knowing eyes. Along with Series 6, these anticipated explanations regarding Professor Song's identity came and came and came until River's timeline was a convoluted mess of timey-wimey, slippery-sloppy nonsense. In between enigmatic eye patch ladies and the-one-question-that-must-never-be-answered conspiracy, however, fans were treated to an unforgettable, unpredictable and voluptuous Time Lady, a vigilante who specialised in seducing the unprepared Time Lord or incapacitating guards with her hallucinogenic lipstick. She always gave mischievous smiles, silently boasting that she knew more than the Doctor. He squirmed and raved under her gaze, which had seen events of his future. Not to mention her unladylike tendency to storm into restaurants while pointing machine guns, demanding people to remove their clothing or her habit of using Fezzes for target practice. Perhaps no other female character can outmatch the galvanising impression River made on television history, but one comes very close, if not succeeds, in doing so. Ever since observing her uncanny code breaking skills, Sherlock and his devoted fan club had speculated much about Mrs Watson. Our suspicions that she was a "liar" turned out to be the truth. An assassin, capable of murdering Magnussen as well as John's best friend, was let loose onto our screens and, despite all of our lurking premonitions, it was still a shocking surprise.

4. Faking A Death

Among the whirlwind of characters that are blotted across the pages of a story, some are thrown into the abyss of white space between the lines, dead forever to produce dramatic effect. Some characters, however, can never be truly murdered without making a completely implausible comeback (unless the writer has a death wish). They've been animated and brought to life beyond the confines of a book and their deaths would be far more impactful than simply a few words written across a page and ending with a finite period. For this reason, the Doctor and Sherlock are guaranteed immortal lives despite whatever perils they may face. It's amazing how our seemingly invincible Time Lord can collapse dead simply from the firing of two gunshots in quick succession. Why has a Sontaran or Dalek never attempted this before? (OK, fine - for plot convenience!). When the Impossible Astronaut presented the unavoidable reality of a deceased Time Lord, rather than grieving, our brows were furrowed and our gears sent spinning to answer the question, "So how's he going to get out of this one, then?!" Well, unlike The Reichenbach Fall, there were really no allusions or hidden clues that would point to the roundabout, mind-boggling solution that transpired in The Wedding of River Song. Apparently, an 1,100 year old Doctor enlisted a droid operated by microscopic people to be disguised as his 900 year self and fool the Silence into believing they had carried out their extensive agenda. All of this was orchestrated at the expense of Amy, Rory and River's well being because, of course, the Doctor could not reveal his plans to them. In a slightly more elaborate (but definitely more comprehensible) sequence, Sherlock, on the precipice of losing everything he holds dear, leaps from the edge of a rooftop, flying with a very definite destination. How anyone could evade a suicide fall without sprouting a pair of wings is beyond reckoning, but London's prolific detective manages to do it... somehow (with a giant inflatable pillow, allegedly). Sherlock's triumph is severely negated, however, as he forgot the small detail of telling his best friend over the span of two years. Not so clever now, are you?

3. Having A Trusty Companion

An unprecedented genius needs a bystander to whom he can show off, a sidekick willing to fulfill the boring obligations of life and an ordinary bloke he can jeer at for being so, well... extraordinarily ordinary. John accomplishes all of these and more with a glowering face, buying groceries and cursing at an uncooperative ATM, carrying a laptop to a crime scene because Sherlock is too disinterested and cozy in his bed sheets or enduring Sherlock's indiscrete denigrations of John's intelligence. These two Londoners make a smashing team, though. Analogous to Clara and the Twelfth Doctor's relationship, John is Sherlock's "carer", the one with more human concerns who is able to discern the priorities of a situation and act promptly. Likewise, the Doctor relies on Clara to mumble apologies to those beaten down by the Scotsman's wrath. She almost acts as a translator, communicating the Doctor's indifferent remarks and clipped responses into a more intelligible language that isn't so unbelievably rude. When the Doctor is miffed (yes, it happens sometimes), Clara acts in his stead. She knows how the traumatic psychological effects of not knowing something can severely hinder the Doctor's performance. And there are no second chances permitted when the universe is at stake. Independent, feisty and unpredictable, these companions are their employers' second shadows. Sometimes, however, it's quite difficult to know who's the boss.

2. The "I'm Not A Hero" Complex

Apparently, the definition of "hero" is only applicable to hopelessly famous adrenaline junkies whose inflated egos surpass the believed human (or non human - whatever!) capacity. Yet they still manage to gain admiration for "subconsciously" saving the world as we know it. Whether it be through trouncing criminals' surreptitious agendas or banishing two dimensional creatures using a trusty 2D-is (pronounced too-dis, if you will), the Doctor and Sherlock have developed irrefutable reputations that are bound to attract some unwanted attention and earn staunch loyalty from people who are certain to be disappointed. With all of their arrogant boasting and unabashed flaunting of skills, God forbid that they be accused of "goodness". The Doctor has spent an inordinate amount of time debating whether or not he is a good man and a hero. Does the answer really need saying? His character simply becomes less realistic when he ponders questions on such a large scale. Brooding over the subject just leads to unnecessary drama. By critically analysing the substance of his character, the Doctor assumes the role of the audience. He becomes less of a person and more of a set of traits to be dissected. Instead of pausing to reflect on this all encompassing, nebulous question, go out and be a good man in whatever way you are capable. Convince us and yourself that you're not an idiot... or you could just do the exact opposite. As for Sherlock, his gimmick of €œI€™m not a hero, I€™m a high-functioning sociopath!€ seems like a snide one liner extracted from a Marvel movie. When it comes to protecting John and Mary, Sherlock transforms into the most valiant hero of them all.

1. Being The Cleverest Person In The Room

If the Doctor and Sherlock somehow found themselves trapped in the same room, the resulting seismic brain waves would raise the IQ of the entire street. The Doctor and Sherlock often take refuge in their seclusive mind palaces, to shelter themselves from the disgracing world of fascinatingly ordinary human beings. Everyone else seems to be unbearably thick, impossibly confused by the simplest concepts. When a hostile alien species slips into the unseen corners of your peripheral vision, the Doctor never misses its fleeting presence. The slightest bit of evidence is always registered by the keen eyes of Sherlock Holmes. Rambling away while their companions' heads nod uncomprehendingly, the euphoric realisations of these ingenious minds are only met with a deadpan stare. Too many timey-wimey words, Doctor, and too much deducing too quickly, Sherlock. Who would win such a heated battle of wits? Who would lose their claim to being the cleverest, most pretentious prig in the room? Perhaps the universe will never know... What did you think of this list? Are there any other shocking similarities between Doctor Who and Sherlock? Join the conversation in the comments section below!

Contributor

Anna is an aspiring writer who has an incurable obsession with Doctor Who. When she is not writing about Doctor Who, she's watching favorite episodes and contemplating what to write next. When she's writing about Doctor Who, she anticipates her reward: watching yet another Doctor Who episode. She also manages to read science fiction (especially Ray Bradbury), recite lines from Shakespeare's Macbeth, and make terrible puns in her free time (she likes to imagine she has great puntential, though)