11 Times Doctor Who Reinvented Itself

"Change my dear, and it seems not a moment too soon."

Doctor Who The Eleventh Hour Amy Pond the Doctor Matt Smith Karen Gillan
BBC Studios

Perhaps more than any other show, Doctor Who has thrived on constant evolution.

This is most obvious with the Doctor's ever-changing characterization, but that is only one of many elements that have been adjusted repeatedly. Over its 50+ years of existence, nearly every aspect of Doctor Who has gone through multiple variations. Most of the audience has come not only to accept that the necessity of this, but to anticipate and embrace each new development.

Indeed, in modern times, the debut of a new lead actor is a media event. Fans eagerly devour details of what the new Doctor will be like, how they will dress, who the companions will be, what the TARDIS will look like, how the theme music will be arranged...and generally what the series will be like going forward.

What has rarely shifted is the premise itself: the Doctor, a time-traveling alien, wanders through the universe, fighting monsters and making friends. But the way that story has been told has been in a constant flux, almost from the very beginning of the program.

Here are the top eleven times Doctor Who reinvented itself.

11. The Timeless Children (2020)

Doctor Who the Doctor The Timeless Children
BBC Studios

First up is the most recent item on this list--in fact, it's from the last episode of the latest season of the show. However, it represents such a huge adjustment to the series' backstory, it can't be ignored.

After some slight hints that were strewn through Jodie Whittaker's tenure on the program, it was revealed that everything the Doctor has understood about her life is a lie. Rather than being an "ordinary" Gallifreyan, she is actually an ancient creature of unknown origin, known only as the Timeless Child, whose apparently natural ability to regenerate was harvested in order to create the Time Lords as we know them.

It's a potentially seismic shift to the status quo of the program--perhaps the largest that we've ever been presented with. To say that fans have been divided by this twist is an understatement.

However, in spite of its significance, the revelation of the Timeless Child remains low on this countdown simply because it's still too recent to know how much of a genuine re-imagining of the series that it will come to represent.


10. The Pilot (2017)

Doctor Who Peter Capaldi Pearl Mackie Bill
BBC

The Pilot was the debut episode of Doctor Who's tenth season, the last one to feature Peter Capaldi in the title role. It represented something of a soft reboot for the series, positioning the character in a way that was completely different to anything we'd seen before.

Suddenly, the Doctor had relocated to earth full-time and taken a job as a lecturer at the fictional St. Luke's University. Along with this new situation, he had a new mission--keeping an eye on a mysterious vault that is hidden beneath the campus. Nardole (Matt Lucas) is still with him, having taken it upon himself to make sure the Doctor doesn't shirk this duty.

Into this comes Bill, a new companion played by Pearl Mackie, whose liveliness and curiosity sparks fresh life in the Doctor. The new dynamic amongst the cast and the unique narrative direction gave the show a new tone, and allowed it to redefine itself for the audience


9. Remembrance Of The Daleks (1988)

Doctor Who Remembrance Of The Daleks
BBC

Sylvester McCoy's 7th Doctor had debuted a year earlier, but it's in Remembrance of the Daleks, at the start of the classic series' Season 25 that we really see the hallmarks of his version of the character come to the fore. The 7th Doctor moves from being a somewhat clownish buffoon to a more proactive and aggressive champion of time.

No longer content to simply wait for trouble to find him, the Doctor begins to actively plan the downfall of his enemies. He manipulates the Daleks into destroying themselves in this story, and takes down the Cybermen in the same way later in the same season.

The production team also began to seed the idea that there was more to the Doctor than we knew--that he wasn't merely a Time Lord who had run away from home. The cancellation of the show just a couple of years later meant that these ideas were never fully developed--at least not on television--but still it all represented a new direction for the program.


8. The Ark In Space (1975)

Doctor Who The Ark In Space
BBC

Tom Baker had made his first appearance as the Fourth Doctor one story earlier, but it was in The Ark in Space that Philip Hinchcliffe began serving as the series' producer, and Robert Holmes as script editor. Even though they were initially working with stories that had been commissioned by their predecessors, the two creators made an immediate impression on the series.

Hinchcliffe and Holmes brought a darker, more violent edge to the Doctor's adventures--a distinct gothic horror aesthetic that even reached to the interior of the TARDIS itself. They shifted the emphasis of the series away from modern day earth and UNIT (major parts of the Third Doctor's era), and frequently drew from classic horror movies for their narrative inspiration.

The era was also characterized by a decreasing reliance upon the show's historically popular monsters in favor of new creations. In doing so they crafted one of the most popular and critically regarded periods in the show's history, which only came to an end when both men moved on and the BBC deliberately embraced a lighter tone for the series.


7. The Leisure Hive (1980)

Doctor Who - The Leisure Hive
BBC

The Leisure Hive, which opened up the classic series' 18th season, didn't quite change everything. We still had the same Doctor and the same companions (mostly--K9's original voice returned), but beyond that, pretty much everything else shifted. It was all due to the arrival of the series' incoming producer, John Nathan-Turner.

Nathan-Turner's arrival upended the entire aesthetic of the show. He gave Tom Baker and Lalla Ward new wardrobes (which felt more like "costumes", and less like simply "clothes" than we'd ever had before). He shifted the stories away from campy comedy that had crept in and toward a harder science fiction tone. And he changed the iconic opening title sequence, the iconic title music arrangement, the style of the incidental music, and more.

John Nathan-Turner's influence over the series is impossible to ignore. He went on to be the producer of the show who lasted longer in the role than any other. He oversaw nine seasons; he cast three Doctors, two Masters, one Davros, and eight companions; and he shepherded the series through one of the most tumultuous periods in its history, and saw the closing off of the entire classic era.


6. The TV Movie (1996)

Doctor Who TV Movie Paul McGann
BBC Studios

Years after the original Doctor Who had ended, a joint production with the United States gave rise to a brand new TV movie. Known only as Doctor Who, nearly every aspect of the series was overhauled. There was a new Doctor, a new Master, and a significantly altered TARDIS interior. The adventure was released as a single two hour movie with commercial breaks, a format the series had never used.

The were other elements that seemed to betray an American influence. The story was set in California, it had a lengthy high-speed car chase, and for the first time, the Doctor romantically kissed someone. Lots of fans were unhappy with these developments, but interestingly, many of them anticipated things that revived series went on to do years later.

The show also introduced the idea that the Doctor was half human. This revelation has been ignored ever since, but it's likely that if the hoped-for series had taken off, it would have gone a lot further.

The movie represented a massive new direction for the show, and would be much higher on this list it had actually gone on to become a series as intended.


5. Power Of The Daleks (1966)

Doctor Who Power of The Daleks
BBC

In some ways, The Power of the Daleks changed the least out of all the episodes on this list. Coming in the middle of the fourth season, the story featured the same companions, the same TARDIS, and the same opening credits and musical theme. Even the threat of the adventure was the series' most iconic and familiar monster.

But what it did change was the Doctor. Nowadays, this is par for the course and something fans even get excited about, but back then, nobody was expecting it. But when William Hartnell's failing health made continuing in the show unlikely, the producers opted to do something a bit radical and to replace him. They did this not by bringing in a new character, but changing the Doctor himself. The completely dissimilar Patrick Troughton took on the role, making no effort whatsoever to try to make his Doctor's persona anything like his predecessor.

It was a massive gamble and a tremendous shift to the series people were familiar with. It completely altered the status quo of the show, and made Doctor Who a program that would never be the same again.


4. The Eleventh Hour (2010)

Doctor Who The Eleventh Hour Amy Pond the Doctor Matt Smith Karen Gillan
BBC Studios

There are only three times in the series history that the show came back for another season without the return of a single cast member. Not surprisingly, each one represented a massive change to the series, and all of them have found themselves in the upper reaches of this list.

In this case, celebrated writer Steven Moffat had taken the reins of Doctor Who as showrunner, bringing with him Eleventh Doctor Matt Smith and new co-star Karen Gillan as Amy Pond. Smith and Gillan had a dynamic which re-energized the show, and Steven Moffat filled his stories with visceral scares, witty dialogue and complex time travel plots.

The Eleventh Hour also introduced a new overarching mystery which involved mysterious cracks in the skin of the universe and the threat of something called the Silence. The show also soon reintroduced River Song, a character central to Moffat's storylines, who uniquely met the Doctor multiple times, but out of chronological order.

The Doctor, supporting cast and plots continued to go through changes over the next few years, but Steven Moffat's influenced was felt strongly for the following six seasons that he served as showrunner.


3. The Woman Who Fell To Earth (2018)

Doctor Who Jodie Whittaker
BBC

Like his predecessor, Chris Chibnall took the reins of Doctor Who with a completely new cast and a new approach in his storytelling. And though he's only been at the job for two seasons, his tenure as showrunner represents one of the greatest departures from previous seasons that we've ever seen.

For example, the opening title sequence uses both entirely fresh imagery and a unique theme arrangement to invoke the spirit of the show. The incidental music is by a new composer and is of a new style. The cinematography is freshly lush and beautiful. Episodes have invoked their social and moral messages more pointedly, and historical characters that are a bit more off the beaten path have played a larger role in the stories.

But most obviously, the Doctor is being played by a woman for the first time. And although Jodie Whittaker doesn't focus greatly on her gender in her performance, the fact that she is female does create a different sort of dynamic amongst the Doctor's "fam" then there has ever been before. It gives the current version of the program its own particular quality.


2. Spearhead From Space (1970)

Doctor Who Spearhead From Space
BBC Studios

More than any other story in the original run of Doctor Who, the opening of season seven--Spearhead from Space--represented something completely new for the program. A new Doctor, played by Jon Pertwee, made his debut in this story (having not even had a cameo at the end of the previous adventure), with an entirely new status quo.

His old companions gone, the Doctor was now trapped on earth--exiled by his own people--where he found a home with UNIT (the anti-invasion military branch who had made a guest appearance the previous year). He had a new assistant in Liz Shaw and was on his way to developing a new supporting cast to go with his new life.

More than that, the show was returning after a much longer gap off the air then there had been before (more than six months, rather than just over the summer). Further, the series had greatly reduced it's episode count (25 episodes for season seven, as opposed to 44 for season six). Finally, for the first time, the series was in color, which combined with its earth-based setting gave the story a completely different feel.


1. Rose (2005)

Doctor Who Rose
BBC

The revival of Doctor Who kicked off with Rose, a good fifteen years after the last regular series had been produced, and nine years since the one-off TV movie. Given the effort to make Doctor Who fresh and relevant again, it is no surprise that aside from the core concept, every element of the series was completely overhauled for a modern audience.

Aside from the new cast and updated design, the show now had a new format, with stories now told largely in 45-minute episodes. The plot, humor and dialogue all now unfolded at a quicker, snappier pace. Modern special effects allowed the show not only to do more with its terrifying monsters, but to throw out awe-inspiring fantastical imagery on a regular basis.

And a new status quo, with the Last Great Time War and the destruction of Gallifrey thrown into the Doctor's backstory, brought a new emotional edge and thematic focus to the series.

This was not only the most wide-spread reinvention of Doctor Who, but the most successful as well. The new approach that was introduced by Russell T. Davies and the production team with Rose have never been put aside. Even though there are four later episodes in earlier slots on this countdown, each of them are still building off the template that was established with Rose.


Watch Next


The Ultimate Doctor Who Day Quiz

Doctor Who Series 3 Chantho played by Chipo Chung in Utopia
BBC

1. Professor Yana's Assistant Chantho Is What Species?

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Ben McClure is a writer and filmmaker. Raised in the United States but living in Australia, he loves stories, gets excited about superheroes and science fiction, and is deeply interested in matters of faith.