12 Abandoned Doctor Who Subplots

You can't just sonic some of these away.

Doctor Who The Day of the Doctor John Hurt War Doctor
BBC Studios

The premise of Doctor Who is gloriously limitless in its imagination, letting us immerse ourselves in unadulterated escapism (depending on the BBC budget of course). As the Eleventh Doctor enticingly put it to Amy Pond:

"So, all of time and space, everything that ever happened or ever will. Where do you want to start?"

There have been so many underlying plots within the hundreds of episodes - a Who-ception - that it becomes a source of fervent intrigue and fan theories.

Some get altered to fit a particular narrative arc. Some get used later on - the Zygon subplot from The Day of the Doctor eventually shapeshifting into a brilliant two-parter from series 9. Others are left as a sort of Hansel and Gretel breadcrumbs for other showrunners to perhaps pick up on, as Russell T Davies did with the mystery surrounding Peter Capaldi's incredible lookalikes throughout the Whoniverse.

Although some of the intriguing subplots on this list have been delved into in other media, they really should be further explored on the small screen (or silver screen!) given their blockbuster potential.

12. Who Is The Mysterious Minister Of War?

doctor who series 9 peter capaldi
BBC

So, pre-Harold Saxon. Pre-the Minister of War. Pre-the moon exploding and a big bat coming out.

The Minister of War?

Yeah.

No, never mind. I expect I'll find out soon enough.

Alas, after the events of Before the Flood, we never did.

The modern series has all been about the foreshadowing. We've had Bad Wolf, Harold Saxon (Yana), Cracks in Time, the Hybrid, and the Timeless Child. The quizzically-concerned look on the Doctor's face when O'Donnell mentions "pre-the Minister of War" is akin to his reaction on hearing/seeing Bad Wolf during series one, and hers from The Ghost Monument, where the blanket audition rejects for an IKEA advert first mention the Timeless Child.

It could be one of those ambiguous subplots that is handily left for another writer/showrunner to use at some point down the time vortex. No doubt there are some (millions) of you who would rather have the Minister of War revealed as the Foundling instead.


11. Harmony Shoal: The Revenge

Doctor Who Head
BBC

We first encounter the head-splitting species as The Shoal of the Winter Harmony in the The Husbands of River Song. By the following Christmas special (The Return of Doctor Mysterio) they've rebranded themselves as "Harmony Shoal" - complete with a twirling Daily Planet-style globe atop a swanky skyscraper, and a very insidiously appropriate "open your minds" tagline.

Eventually, like with every superhero tale as old as time, the Doctor and Superman-lite save the day. Moments afterwards, Mr Brock warns the Doctor:

"The vengeance of Harmony Shoal is known and feared throughout the five star systems!"

This is swatted away with typical Doctor panache. However, whilst UNIT descend on Harmony Shoal's New York HQ, we see one of these multi-nucleate organism, functioning as an infinitely adaptable, independently functioning, peripatetic central nervous system creatures subsume a UNIT soldier. Surely enough time has passed to enact their revenge? What dastardly plans have they got up their sleeves, or in their heads?

Actually, the real question is why haven't we seen poor old Mr Huffle since?


10. The Ungolden Age Of Harriet Jones

Doctor Who Harriet Jones
BBC
"I thought I knew the name. Harriet Jones. Future prime minister, elected for three successive terms, the architect of Britain's Golden Age."

We find ourselves in the honeymoon period of this Golden Age in The Christmas Invasion. Us Brits are leading the way in space probe exploration, and, more importantly, we're £18 a week better off! As the Ninth Doctor would say: fantastic, absolutely fantastic.

But there's a new new Doctor Harriet has to confront after ordering the destruction of the Sycorax spaceship.

It was, arguably, justified - she saw two people callously murdered right in front of her by the Sycorax leader, and the Doctor isn't always around to save the day. Combined with the Doctor saying "the human race is drawing attention to itself. Every day you're sending out probes and messages and signals. This planet's so noisy. You're getting noticed more and more. You'd better get used to it", he inadvertently pushes her into that unenviable moral dilemma. To borrow a WhoCulture article title, the Doctor was actually a bit of a dick.

Less Golden Age, more golden goose. Oh well, this Harold Saxon sounds like a promising chap.


9. Ryan's Dyspraxia

Ryan Spyfall Doctor Who
BBC

Maybe not abandoned per se, more largely forgotten.

The reaction to Tosin Cole's character with a disability was overwhelmingly positive, and personally heartfelt to those who have dyspraxia.

We saw the everyday challenges Ryan Sinclair faced in the first few episodes of series 11: learning to ride a bike, climbing ladders. Actions most of us take for granted. And although this was briefly touched upon in the series 12 opener, Spyfall, you would be forgiven for forgetting he has dyspraxia after those early episodes.

It's emblematic of not enough individual focus on his character development in general - likewise with Yaz - because of the current three's a crowd companion dynamic, a genuine complaint levelled at the show many times.

Moreover, with strong rumours of Cole leaving - along with Bradley Walsh - during the next festive special, it seems Ryan won't be topping regular favourites Rose Tyler and Donna Noble on those best companion lists. Daresay not even above Adric. No, sorry, that's too harsh.


8. How Did The Silence Destroy The TARDIS?

The Pandorica Opens By Shereline D5vm3gk
BBC

With how being the operative word. It's a mystery that was intriguingly and excitingly set-up.

We had River Song exclaiming: "Someone else is flying it. An external force. I've lost control." And then the Doctor said: "Space and time isn't safe yet. The TARDIS exploded for a reason. Something drew the TARDIS to this particular date, and blew it up. Why? And why now? The Silence, whatever it is, is still out there."

We know the when - 26 June 2010. We know who the Silence are, and that they and the Kovarian Chapter were responsible for blowing up the TARDIS. We know why they did it - to try to stop the Doctor from ever reaching Trenzalore.

If we discovered how the precious TARDIS was obliterated - especially when thinking of The Doctor's Wife episode - we'd probably end up losing our minds like poor old Vincent did. Although it was an awesome sight of the stars spectacularly exploding at the end of The Pandorica Opens.

Naturally, there are plenty of theories on this. Maybe the Silence have actually told us but we've just forgotten, naturally.


7. The Legacy Of Adelaide Brooke

Doctor Who The Waters of Mars Bowie Base One
BBC Studios

Now this is a subplot that should be explored:

"Imagine it, Adelaide. If you began a journey that takes the human race all the way out to the stars. It begins with you, and then your granddaughter. You inspire her. So that in 30 years, Susie Fontana Brooke is the pilot of the first lightspeed ship to Proxima Centauri. And then everywhere! With her children, and her children's children, forging the way, to the Dragon Star, the Celestial Belt of the Winter Queen, the Map of the Water Snake Wormholes - one day a Brooke will even fall in love with a Tandonian prince, and that's the start of a whole new species. But everything starts with you, Adelaide. From 50 years ago, to right here, today. Imagine."

Imagine we can! Sadly, it's all we can do. Steven Moffat once said "we could spend Avatar's budget and still ask for more, because it's a show that's set in every point in history and every place in the universe." Indeed, it would be amazing to combine the cinematography from Roger Deakins or Hoyte van Hoytema with the budget of Infinity War/Endgame, to truly render the awe-inspiring wonder of the above.

In fact, there really ought to be a spin-off series created, charting the Brooke family odyssey throughout the cosmos. There we are: "Brooke's Odyssey". That or we'll settle for either Susie or one of her descendants encountering the Doctor one day...


6. Oh Missy, You're So Fine, You Escaping Skaro's On My Mind, Hey Missy! Hey Missy!

doctor who missy
BBC

Ahem, yeah, so how did she do that? What was her "very clever idea" at the end of The Witch's Familiar? Answers in a psychic container please, or more appropriately: explain! Explain!

Missy escaping the Dalek homeworld doesn't surprise us - we're used to her (and her previous and later incarnations in general) pulling many a Houdini.

Perhaps it's best to leave the explanation to Moffat himself. In an interview during a Radio Times Covers Party, he was asked "how she actually came back from certain death?" in The Doctor Falls, to which Moffat replied:

"I don't necessarily want all the gaps to be plugged. Kids out there are making up their own stories about how Missy escaped that place and regenerated into Sasha. They're doing their own version, and that's much more exciting to me than actually filling in those gaps."

In that case, Missy enjoyed a good old gossip with the Daleks about the Doctor's date night with River Song on Darillium, and danced with Davros' dodgem in the pale Skaro moonlight. Of course the real burning question from that episode is: where did the Doctor get that cup of tea from?


5. Just Popping Out... To A Parallel Universe

Doctor Who It Takes You Away
BBC Studios

THE DOCTOR: We're not meant to be here. The TARDIS draws its power from the universe, but it's the wrong universe. It's like diesel in a petrol engine.

MICKEY: But I've seen it in comics. People go hopping from one alternative world to another. It's easy.

THE DOCTOR: Not in the real world. It used to be easy. When the Time Lords kept their eye on everything, you could hop between realities, home in time for tea. Then they died, and took it all with them. The walls of reality closed, the worlds were sealed. Everything became that bit less kind.

Turns out not impossible. Just a bit unlikely, and a bit dodgy, to use the scientific term. All you need is a good old-fashioned dimension jump, as ably demonstrated by Mickey Smith during the series 4 finale. However for those that are environmentally-conscious, each use does rip a hole in the fabric of space. Alternatively, you could just get a PS5 (took a short hop into the future, it's fantastic!) and immerse yourself in a different reality that way.

We saw the Doctor and her, er, fam, travel into the Solitract universe in 'It Takes You Away via a mirror. Perhaps the return of Gallifrey at the end of the universe has done something timey-wimey (official Doctor Who science term) in which travel to a parallel world can be done in small doses.


4. Rassilon The... Returner?

Doctor Who Rassilon Hell Bent
BBC

Although the Master has been the Doctor's main source of scourge, it's that rapscallion Rassilon who has given our time travelling hero the most epic problems.

One of the founding fathers of Time Lord society was brought back by Russell T Davies in spectacularly messianic fashion in The End of Time. Replete with godlike gauntlet, Rassilon's Final Sanction would have resulted in the Time Lords becoming "creatures of consciousness", and the small matter of the end of time itself. Now we know why the Doctor used the Moment to end the Time War.

Of course The Day of the Doctor changed all that - and Rassilon's thanks was to imprison him in his confession dial for 4.5 billion years. Charming. This incarnation of Rassilon in Hell Bent had also regenerated from James Bond into Maester Luwin.

Unfortunately, the face-off between the Doctor and Rassilon didn't escalate into Travolta/Cage proportions (OK that's going a bit too far admittedly). Instead, the Lord President is pretty much unceremoniously banished from Gallifrey. Perhaps he should've gone to Nidavellir to boost his gauntlet firepower - they make some of the best gauntlets there.

But as Rassilon exclaimed: "Gallifrey is mine!" Given the Master's destruction of Gallifrey, again (honestly, give that planet a break), this perfectly sets up an awesome and amazing Time Lord trifecta showdown. Lena Headey as Rassilon, anyone?

Anyway, speaking of the Doctor ending the Time War...


3. The Day He Killed Them All... No More

Gallifrey Falls No More
BBC

Russell T Davies' Time War concept, which integrated the show's 16-year hiatus, or the "Wilderness Years", was simple yet ingenious. It gave the Doctor a renewed mysterious side to their character not seen since before we discovered the Doctor's own race in The War Games.

There were brief, albeit brutal, mentions of this infinite war throughout the Davies and Steven Moffat eras:

THE DOCTOR: They're never going to come! Your race is dead! You all burnt, all of you. Ten million ships on fire. The entire Dalek race wiped out in one second.

DALEK: You lie!

THE DOCTOR: I watched it happen! I made it happen!

We then got to hear how the "War turned into Hell" in The End of Time, and as mentioned in the previous entry, this was the reason the Doctor had to stop the Time Lords. So given the rather crappy hand he was dealt with at the time, his actions were, arguably, justified. Even Moffat said he was "still haunted by the guilt" at reversing the Doctor's fateful decision in The Day of the Doctor.

But the fact he was able to is amazing in itself, considering the entire Time War is meant to be time-locked, which segues us nicely into...


2. Turns Out You Can Pick A Time Lock

Doctor Who The End Of Time Part 2 Weeping Angels Time Lords
BBC Studios

DALEK CAAN: I flew into the wild and fire, I danced and died a thousand times.

DAVROS: Emergency Temporal Shift took him back into the Time War itself.

THE DOCTOR: But that's impossible! The entire War is time-locked!

Again, not impossible Just a bit unlikely.

Yes, "it cost him his mind" and turned him into a babbling prophet version of the Visionary from The End of Time, but Dalek Caan's Emergency Temporal Shift did result in the show's grandest-ever series finale: The Stolen Earth/Journey's End. So we do owe him a lot for that.

That rapscallion Rassilon (yep, him again) managed to circumvent the time-lock during the final day (The End of Time) of the Time War by planting the tormenting rhythm of four into the Master's mind as child, then establishing the physical link to him with an- ooh shiny- Whitepoint star.

Then you've got the Moment, which is more than just your average galaxy eater - it can even bypass time-locks by opening time fissures, as we saw in The Day of the Doctor.

The time-lock mechanism added another layer of mystique to the Time War - the fact that the Doctor couldn't save his people... his family.

Therefore if you're in need of a seemingly working time-lock, head on down to the Torchwood Hub (sorry, you'll have to go back in time as it's now destroyed) and get one of Tosh's trusted time-locks. As parallel Pete Tyler would say: "Trust me on this."


1. The Regeneration Game

Timeless Child Doctor Who
BBC

Have you sufficiently recovered from The Timeless Children revelations? Are you sitting comfortably? Good. Then we'll begin.

Wow, where to begin? There was - and still is - a hell of a lot for us Whovians to process following the series 12 finale. We all felt like the Doctor in the Matrix: mind blown.

One lore changing aspect was the discovery of the Doctor's limitless regeneration ability - 12 changes is for those "mere mortal" Time Lords it turns out.

Questions abounded. How many lives has the Doctor had before William Hartnell's First Doctor incarnation? What's the point in the Time Lords granting the Doctor a new regeneration cycle, if they're not bound by the 12 change limit? Why have you, Chibnall, pissed off the obsessive compulsives amongst us, considering the meltdown we had in reconciling the War Doctor within the Doctor numbering sequence?!

Given the Division's shadiness raison d'etre, they probably used the Chameleon Arch to tweak the Doctor's biology to the bog-standard 12 regenerations package. Conversely, many were overjoyed the moment the "Morbius Doctors" flashed across our screens. Either way, the biggest change has, undoubtably, been to Doctor Who's Wikipedia pages.

Check out other unresolved plot threads, storylines and unanswered mysteries of Doctor Who from my fellow WhoCulture writers here, here, oh and here.


Watch Next


Doctor Who: How Well Do You Know The Time Lords?

Doctor Who Rassilon Hell Bent
BBC

1. Who Has Not Been Lord President Of Gallifrey?

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

The name's Colbourn, James - yeah, doesn't quite have the same ring to it.