12 Actors Who Hated Being On Star Trek

Not everyone enjoyed the intrepid journeys where no man had gone before...

Jeffrey Dean Morgan Star Trek
CBS

Some people would give their left arm to appear on Star Trek and some other people feel it cost them the equivalent of it. Many of the actors on this list have recent experience and many have historical experience. There has been 60 years of Star Trek history and in that time, hundreds of actors have passed through the final frontier. It stands to reason that not all of them would have had an amazing time.

Many have spoken openly about how much their time on the show affected them and their careers. Some names have come around in the years since appearing and some have not. Several of the names on this list had such a bad time that they have refused all work within the franchise again, refusing to acknowledge their part in Star Trek.

Some of these names belong to guest stars who had a rough few days but some of these actors are main characters, unlucky enough to have had some of the worst experiences of their careers in Gene Roddenberry's bright, bright future.

12. Denise Crosby

Star Trek The Next Generation Tasha Yar
CBS

Lt. Tasha Yar was a key character of the first season of Star Trek The Next Generation. She was tough, brave and strong, filling the role of security chief aboard the Galaxy Class star ship. It looked to be a juicy role to sink an actor's teeth into and Denise Crosby was brought in to play the part. However, she quickly became frustrated with the way her character was being used.

She has commented in recent times that she felt that if a matte painting of her legs had been done, it could have been slotted in behind the command chairs, underneath the security station. That was the impact she felt her character was having based on the stories she was being given.

In what Sir Patrick Stewart has since described as a mistake, the show failed to keep Crosby on board and she quit before the end of the season. Her character was written out by being killed by Armus, the black slime embodiment of evil. It was both a shocking and underwhelming end to a character with a lot of potential.

She was however brought back for one episode in the third season's great Yesterday's Enterprise, where we see her in an alternate timeline. Fan reaction was such that Crosby then pitched the idea of Yar having a half-Romulan daughter and Sela would go on to appear in three stories. However her first year was somewhat wasted in what could have been some real ground-laying work.


11. Jeffrey Dean Morgan

Star Trek Xindi
CBS

Negan was in Star Trek Enterprise, minus Lucille. However, thanks to the show, he almost quit acting altogether.

Jeffrey Dean Morgan appeared in the third season of Enterprise in the episode entitled Carpenter Street, also starring guest star Leland Orser. The heavy makeup required for the Xindi Reptillian role was overbearing and claustrophic, which meant that filming was a miserable experience for him. Add to that, the role itself was small enough that there wasn't even any legacy to be had in putting himself through that much pain.

Morgan later admitted that there were times he would cry in the evenings from frustration, fatigue and bitterness. Once production wrapped on the episode, he had decided that acting wasn't for him. However, thankfully he would take time and change his mind, eventually becoming the hugely successful Negan on the Walking Dead.


10. Diana Muldaur

Star Trek Mick Fleetwood
CBS Media Ventures

Diana Muldaur has actually appeared as three separate characters in the Star Trek franchise. She began her career in Trek on the Original Series, appearing in the episode Return To Tomorrow. She would later return as a different character in In Truth Is There No Beauty? She described the experience as working with the Original Series crew as enjoyable, feeling a sense of camaraderie.

However, things were not so when she returned once more, this time as Dr. Katherine Pulaski for The Next Generation's second season. She was brought in as a replacement for Gates McFadden, who had been fired at the end of the first season by producer Maurice Hurley. Hurley had strongly objected to McFadden's attempts to beef up her character.

Muldaur then arrived in a situation where she was replacing a beloved colleague, who had been lost in dubious circumstances. It has often been said that the crew of TNG were extremely close for the duration of the show. However, it seems that Muldaur never warmed to the group, nor they to her, during her tenure.

She was always billed as a special guest star and once the season ended, she declined to return for a third season. The fact that she has never returned in any capacity to the franchise again speaks to her experience on the show.


9. Robert Beltran

Star Trek Chakotay
CBS

Robert Beltran was one of the actors who started to voice his criticism of the show long before it came to an end. He was originally second lead on Star Trek Voyager, roles that had been enjoyed by Leonard Nimoy and Johnathan Frakes. However, he never had the same experience that they had. In his opinion, this was due to the fact that the producers simply forgot about his character after a while. He had been brought in as the leader of a separate group within the Voyager crew but the Maquis subplot fizzled out as the show progressed.

He was further irked by the introduction of Seven of Nine. He felt that the show was beginning to aim for a lower denominator of fan base, using sex appeal rather than strong storytelling. He felt that Chakotay, along with Tuvok, Tom Paris and Harry Kim were quickly given less and less to do as the show began to further explain Seven's storylines.

Once the final season rolled around, he allegedly gave as deliberately a wooden performance as possible, as he felt if the show was not going to offer him meaty roles or things to do, they did not deserve his finest work. He was critical of the season finale, quoted as saying 'This is it?' once he discovered the ending. He has softened in his views in recent years but it is safe to say that he was no fan of the show by the time it wrapped.


8. Grace Lee Whitney

Janice Rand And Beauregard
CBS

Grace Lee Whitney has one of the sadder stories when it comes to Trek alumni. She was an actress and singer before being cast in Star Trek. She appeared in eight episode of the first season of the Original Series, playing Yeomen Rand, Kirk's personal assistant. However, she was then released from her contract. She went on to claim that she had been sexually assaulted by a producer on the series and that Leonard Nimoy had been of great support to her during that time.

She returned to the franchise for The Motion Picture, after co-star DeForrest Kelley found that she was unemployed. She appeared in four of the movie, two internet episodes and returned for the 30th anniversary special, Flashback, with George Takei. She also managed to capitalise on her Trek fame by releasing Trek themed music in this period of her career.

She suffered from alcoholism and substance dependency, but was able to get off both as she went on. She was quoted later in life as preferring to be seen as a survivor of addiction than as a Star Trek cast member. She died in May, 2015, just months after her old friend Leonard Nimoy. The Star Trek Continues episode Divided We Stand is dedicated to her memory.


7. Malcom McDowell

Star Trek Generations Soran Geordi
Paramount

Dr. Tolian Soran is one of the most hated characters in Star Trek history - he killed Captain Kirk! However, the actor playing him, Malcom McDowell, liked him about as much as the rest of the fandom.

McDowell had long been known to audiences for his performance in such films as A Clockwork Orange and Caligula, but this was his first and, to date, only foray in Star Trek. He appeared in Star Trek Generations as an El-Aurian scientist trying to get back to the Nexus, wiling to destroy anything in his path to do it.

While he plays the character with endearing subtlty and a quiet rage, McDowell felt that the script let him down. In fact, he was quoted by his nephew, one Alexander Siddig i.e. Julian Bashir, as saying he thought the script was weak and he himself has admitted that he only took the role for the money. He says that he turned it down four times until the producers agreed to his asking price.

He received death threats from irate fans after the film was released as they were unhappy with his characters actions. Perhaps for his own safety, he has avoided returning to the Trek universe ever since.


6. Susanna Thompson

Susanna Thompson
CBS

Susanna Thompson played several characters during her tenure on Star Trek, appearing in the Next Generation and Deep Space Nine (where she was one half of the franchise's first same-sex kiss with Terry Farrell) before appearing as the Borg Queen in Star Trek Voyager Dark Frontier and Unimatrix Zero.

It was the makeup and costuming that Thompson particularly struggled with in these instances. For her first appearance, she was given contact lenses that were so uncomfortable that she thought of quitting outright after the first day of filming. She was in tremendous pain and coupled with the long hours, she felt that she wouldn't be able to do it again.

However, return she did and she completed filming on Dark Frontier. She also agreed to return for the two-part Unimatrix Zero, but on the condition that she was given new and better contacts and that she could take them out more often than she had been allowed while filming Dark Frontier.

She was not available to return for the series finale and Alice Krige was brought back in to reprise the role she had originated in Star Trek First Contact.


5. Leonard Nimoy

Spock Star Trek
Paramount

Leonard Nimoy initially had quite a complicated relationship with Star Trek. He was cast in the original pilot as the alien character with pointed eyebrows and ears, and his appearance brought criticism from conservative viewers as he was deemed to be 'satantic'.

However, it was exactly his appearance that would become the issue. Nimoy discovered after the original series wrapped that his likeness was being used in advertising without his consent and, more importantly at the time, without receiving any royalties. He would grow weary of the constant association with Spock, going so far as to write an autobiography entitled 'I Am Not Spock'.

In 1979, as production was gearing up on the first Motion Picture, Jeffrey Katzenberg had to beg him to return. However, this was successful. While The Motion Picture was a huge financial success, it wasn't a critical darling and Nimoy only agreed to return for The Wrath Of Khan on the provision that he be killed off. Well, he certainly received his wish.

Before production wrapped on The Wrath Of Khan, he approached the studio and asked to be brought back for the sequel. He also asked to direct, which cemented his return to the franchise. Before his death, Nimoy published another autobiography entitled 'I Am Spock' - proving his frustrations with the series were, thankfully, temporary.


4. Jeri Ryan

Seven of Nine Jeri Ryan
CBS

While the franchise is currently enjoying the glorious return of Seven of Nine and Jeri Ryan, her first stint on the show was not a pleasant one. She was brought in at the beginning of Star Trek Voyager's fourth season in an open attempt to boost flagging ratings, replacing Jennifer Lien's Kes, who producers felt wasn't hitting the right notes with the audience.

The cast initially struggled to warm to her and she has been quoted on several occasions speaking about how another actor made her life quite difficult on set.

That actor was Kate Mulgrew. She had been hired as Star Trek's first leading female captain and she felt that the progressive moves of the producers began to fall by the wayside once the character of Seven appeared. She has been open about her coldness to Jeri Ryan on set, making their scenes together (many of which are tender) all the more resonant when one takes into account the tensions behind them.

Robert Beltran was also not a fan of the character was not shy about making his feelings known. Thankfully, in recent years the cast seem to have buried the hatchet and as there is now talk of a documentary to celebrate Voyager's 25th anniversary, perhaps this is an aspect of the show that will be explored in greater detail.


3. Wil Wheaton

Star Trek Wesley Traveller
CBS Media Ventures

Wil Wheaton was coming off an already successful career when he appeared in Star Trek The Next Generation as Wesley Crusher. He had just starred in the critical hit Stand By Me and was fresh in peoples' minds.

He was brought into the show to play the character that, unfortunately, many audiences would quickly come to hate. One such audience member was Rod Roddenberry, Gene's son. He felt anger toward Will as he felt that Gene was replacing the missing relationship between father and son with the relationship he was establishing with Will. As the show began to air, Wheaton became the subject of much negative fan reaction and would eventually leave in the show's fourth season.

In a recent reunion, Wheaton spoke about his feelings of regret for the way he handled his time on the show. He felt sad and ashamed of the way he had left and he felt that for years he was not able to keep up a relationship with his cast mates. Thankfully in later life, he has been welcomed back to the family, returning for 2002's Star Trek Nemesis and is currently hosting the after-show for Star Trek Picard, The Ready Room.


2. Brent Spiner

Brent Spiner Data
Paramount

Another actor who has stepped back into the Trek franchise, 'ole yellow eyes was quite infamously killed off at the end of Star Trek Nemesis. This was a stipulation of Spiner's as, after almost twenty years, he was ready to walk away from the show.

To be clear, not all of his time in Star Trek was a negative experience. He remains very close to the rest of the cast and frequents fan conventions. His return for Star Trek Picard was helped by the time away from the show.

The role of Data typecast-ed him for a long time, despite starring roles in films like Independence Day, one of the biggest films of the '90s. He has often expressed ire at the questions he is asked by reporters and fans about his time on Star Trek, as he has been facing the same questions for 15 years.

However, as time has gone by and enough distance has grown between him and the everyday aspect of the role, he seems to be happier to look back fondly on his time and, though he may forever be Data in many peoples' eyes, he seems to have quietly put his feelings of disquiet behind him and embrace the franchise once more.


1. Garrett Wang

Harry Kim
CBS

To date, Garrett Wang is the only cast member to have had a request to direct an episode refused by the producers.

Many Star Trek alumni and current cast have taken the director's chair along the way. Shatner and Nimoy, Frakes and Burton, Stewart and Brooks - all of them have directed episodes or features of the franchise. So when Garrett Wang put in his request, it may have been with a sense of 'just a formality' to put in the application.

That it was denied seems to be emblematic of a larger issue with Star Trek Voyager. In the seven year run of the show, it suffered from ratings issues and the aforementioned tensions due to the introduction of Seven of Nine. Characters were underwritten and underdeveloped and perhaps the worst victim of this is Wang.

A common joke is that Harry Kim was the franchise's forever ensign, unable to gain a promotion even though he had more experience than half of Starfleet. This is even remarked on in several episodes. However, Wang says that he did ask for his character to be promoted and the response was 'well, someone has to be the ensign'.

Couple this with the refusal of the directing gig and the lack of cast cohesion ala The Next Generation, then there is little mystery as to why Garrett Wang did not have the most enjoyable time on Star Trek. Like many others on this list, he attends the conventions and seems more than happy to be a part of the show regardless.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Seán is the host and head writer/presenter for TrekCulture, as well as a writer/presenter on WhoCulture and WhatCulture Horror. He has authored two novels, dozens of short stories, and hundreds of articles for WhatCulture. He holds a Master of Arts in Creative Writing from University College Dublin. As part of his work with TrekCulture, Seán has been invited to participate in collaborations with Roddenberry Entertainment, as well as contributing to several Star Trek community projects. An avid fan of Star Trek, Doctor Who, and the horror genre at large, Seán's expertise has helped develop these channels to the successes they are today. As host of the Ups & Downs series on TrekCulture, Seán has become internationally recognised for his positive yet critically informed approach to reviewing every episode of modern Star Trek, ensuring he is one of the go-to voices in the Trek community. Favourite Quote to describe himself: "I'm serious about what I do, just not always about the way that I do it"