12 Saddest Bojack Horseman Episodes

How can an animated show about a horse be so damn emotional?

Bojack Horseman
Netflix

There is some stiff competition, but BoJack Horseman may be the best original series Netflix has ever produced, and is certainly not what you would typically expect from an animated show based on a talking bipedal horse.

Of course there are funny moments in the show, with the likes of Todd and Mr. Peanutbutter guaranteeing laughs in almost every episode, but where the show stands out is its emotion and heart. It has never shied away from dark storylines or tackling real issues like mental health struggles, and this often results in truly heart breaking moments.

The writers of BoJack Horseman were so good at crafting a story to make us cry that almost all of the best episodes are the emotional rollercoasters, usually ending on a depressing note. There is real substance to these kinds of stories, and they always exploit the connections we have made to the characters.

From shocking deaths and dealing with tragic losses, to the way certain characters think and feel about themselves, the series boasts many, many episodes that left us in tears, and unsure whether we were emotionally stable enough to click that 'continue watching' button. Though incredible, these particular episodes aren't always the easiest to watch.

12. The Telescope - S1E8

BoJack Horseman Herb Kazzaz
Netflix

After just seven previous episodes of BoJack Horseman, by the time The Telescope was seen we had no idea just how emotionally powerful the show would ultimately become. This was the first real sad episode, and was centered around the titular character's relationship, or lack thereof, with Herb Kazzaz.

After not seeing him for the 20 years after stabbing him in the back, BoJack went to see his former friend who was dying from cancer. Initially they seemed to be on amiable terms at the very least, but BoJack just had to go back in and try to apologise.

Herb however, simply wouldn't give him the closure he felt his former friend didn't deserve. Instead, he launched into a vicious attack, calling BoJack a selfish coward who doesn't care about who he hurts. The saddest part about this was just how true it was.

As if this wasn't bad enough, on the way home BoJack stopped the car and tried to kiss Diane, the woman he knew was already going out with Mr. Peanutbutter. This changed their relationship, what could have been the healthiest he had ever had, forever.


11. The Best Thing That Ever Happened - S3E9

Bojack Horseman
Netflix

BoJack Horseman has always been a protagonist that we find ourselves sticking with despite the fact that he is very clearly a piece of sh*t, and a self-proclaimed one at that. Princess Carolyn also stood by BoJack for 23 years, but their working relationship finally broke down towards the end of season three.

After she started her own agency, naturally there were teething problems, and Princess Carolyn dropped the ball a few times for the first time in 23 years. Instead of BoJack sticking with her like she has done for his entire career, he immediately fired her, with absolutely no regard for everything she has ever done for him.

In 'The Best Thing That Ever Happened', BoJack and Princess Carolyn came to blows and blew up their entire friendship. She did everything for him, and got him jobs despite his infamous vices, yet he always managed to let her down.

The saddest thing about this episode, with no hilarious Todd adventure to offset the emotion, is the realisation of just how badly BoJack has treated his friend over their time together. Even after their heart to heart, after she showed how much she loved him, and after begging for more time to get her firm on its feet, he still cold-heartedly fired her.


10. That Went Well - S3E12

BoJack Horseman
Netflix

The season three finale follows on from the tragic death of Sarah Lynn (an episode that we will get to soon), and focuses on how BoJack is trying to cope. He lost someone close to him, and because he is BoJack Horseman, he struggled to process and move forward in a healthy way.

The episode opens with a flashback to when he tried to get Sarah Lynn on the BoJack Horseman Show many years ago. She felt let down by her old co-star, because he only reached out and came to see her because he wanted her to guest star on his show. It's horrible to think about disappointing someone when there's absolutely nothing that you can do about it.

A big chunk of this episode juxtaposes BoJack's sadness with a couple of ludicrous Todd and Mr. Peanutbutter angles, while the star of Horsin' Around decides to take a risk and move forward with its spin-off, Ethan Around. After getting scared about becoming a role model once again however, he just gets in his car and drives, abandoning yet another project.

The end of the episode, and the season, is incredibly emotional, as the titular character contemplates suicide. Outside of California and on the highway, BoJack puts his foot down, takes his hands off the wheel, and closes his eyes. It's only when he happens to notice a herd of horses running down below that he stops. For whatever reason, potentially taking his mind back to Secretariat's advice to just keep running in the face of adversity, BoJack decided not to kill himself.


9. Escape From L.A. - S2E11

BoJack and Penny
Netflix

Towards the conclusion of season two, BoJack didn't like the version of himself that lived in L.A., and he was struggling to cope with his work on Secretariat. To try and escape from his life he took a trip to New Mexico to see Charlotte, and spent two months with her and the family he didn't know she had.

This is one of the most iconic episodes, and most important moments in BoJack's entire life. After Penny had no one to go to the prom with, BoJack stepped in, and ultimately got her and her friends drunk. When Maddy clearly had alcohol poisoning, BoJack abandoned her with Pete at the hospital, in a shocking display of how far he is willing to go to protect himself and save his own skin.

In fairness to him, when Penny first came on to him he did the right thing, but after speaking to Charlotte and getting knocked back by her, he let Penny into his bed. Who knows what would have happened had they not been interrupted.

The saddest part of this episode wasn't the obvious mistake that BoJack made, but was the fact that he had never been so sure of anything as how he felt about Charlotte, and how he thought she felt about him, yet he was still wrong. He was basically told by his former friend that no matter where he was in the world, he would always be the problem. He can't just escape from that.


8. Ruthie - S4E9

BoJack Horseman 2
Netflix

Rather than being based on the sadness of the titular character, as most of the episodes on this list are, Ruthie focuses on the life of Princess Carolyn. Named for PC's great, great, great granddaughter, the episode starts with Ruthie giving her class a speech on her ancestor in the distant future.

She actually starts the episode in a fantastic position, enjoying living with her boyfriend and pregnant with his child, but as Ruthie said, this was a story about one of the worst days of her life. First, she broke her priceless family heirloom necklace, was fired by Courtney Portnoy, was forced to fire Judah after he betrayed her, she devastatingly suffered another miscarriage, and finally found out that the priceless family heirloom was in fact nothing special.

Clearly, the focus is on the miscarriage more than anything, as a life-changing, soul destroying kick while she was down, however the fact that Ruthie existed at all suggested that she would eventually have a child, so the happy ending that was promised always seemed likely.

But this is BoJack Horseman, and happy endings are rare. After breaking down, unable to face telling Ralph the news or even going home, she got drunk and broke up with her boyfriend for suggesting other options of having a baby. The absolute gut punch of this episode is the revelation that Ruthie was never real, but merely a figment of Princess Carolyn's imagination she thought up to make herself feel better.


7. Ancient History - S5E9

BoJack Horseman Hollyhock
Netflix

While most episodes on this list feature just one sad story throughout, Ancient History tells three separate arcs that all end in devastating ways at the same time. There is no escaping feeling somewhat depressed after watching this episode.

Still in recovery mode after his stunt accident while filming Philbert, BoJack goes on the hunt for more pain meds after Hollyhock chucked his down the drain. This ended with him having no means of getting more pills, something that he already admitted to not truly needing, with the exception of deliberately getting in a car crash. This was low, even for BoJack.

Todd struggled to cope with his asexuality in this episode, as he desperately wanted to be Emily's boyfriend, but couldn't offer her the sexual intimacy she needed. He even made a working sex robot in an attempt to come up with a solution, but was ultimately left alone, with no one on his app to comfort him.

The hardest moment to watch however once again revolved around Princess Carolyn and her inability to have a child. She was offered the chance of adopting a baby if she could get to the hospital within half an hour, but she inadvertently talked the mother into deciding against adoption. The image of her hugging her car seat after leaving the hospital empty handed is simply heart breaking.


6. The Old Sugarman Place - S4E2

BoJack Horseman The Old Sugarman Place
Netflix

Picking up directly after 'That Went Well', after BoJack skipped out on the first episode of season four entirely, the titular character continues driving away from LA and ignoring every one of Diane's calls. He found himself heading for his family's old summer home in Michigan, where he would spend the next few months.

This is the first real view we get into the life of BoJack's mother, who seemingly had a relatively happy upbringing, until the tragic loss of her brother Crackerjack during the war. It was her mother who struggled to get over the loss of her son, and heart breakingly told Beatrice to never love anyone as much as she loved Crackerjack. This explains so much about her relationship with her own son.

Throughout the episode, BoJack meets and befriends Eddie, the dragonfly who lived across from the old Sugarman place, and who also struggled with the loss of someone dear to him. This was the theme throughout the entire episode, as Mrs. Horseman struggled to cope without Crackerjack, BoJack lost Sarah Lynn, and Eddie still missed his wife Lorraine.

The parallels drawn between many of these characters were portrayed in a hauntingly beautiful way as Mrs. Horseman and Eddie shared a duet on the piano, and BoJack watched the Sarah Lynn miniseries while his grandma searched for Crackerjack's blanket. The icing on the cake of this episode was the lobotomy that Mrs. Horseman was forced to endure, and Eddie's screams of wanting to die without Lorraine by his side.


5. Stupid Piece Of Sh*t - S4E6

Bojack Throws Bea’s Doll
Netflix

The title says it all for this episode. Immediately were are greeted by the inner thoughts of BoJack Horseman, as we truly get to see how he thinks before acting like the piece of sh*t for which the episode is named.

We know that BoJack can be a down right awful person at times, but his inner monologue really gave us an insight into what he thought about himself. He was in a constant internal battle between trying to be better and hating everything about himself.

He wanted to kill himself, he blamed himself for the ruining the lives of Herb, Sarah Lynn, and Penny, he grew jealous of the attention his mother gave to her doll, and threw the toy Beatrice genuinely believed to be a real baby over his balcony and down the mountain. We also got an insight into BoJack's depressing childhood, as he told his mom off for leaving him alone in his room without feeding or changing him.

The saddest moment comes when BoJack takes the time to actually sit down and speak to Hollyhock. She was worried that the voice in the back of her head telling her how worthless, stupid, and ugly she was wouldn't go away. BoJack told her it would, despite the fact that we had been listening to that exact voice of BoJack's all episode long. Life doesn't get any easier when you grow up.


4. Time's Arrow - S4E11

Bojack Horseman
Netflix

After BoJack found out that his mother had been slipping pills into Hollyhock's coffee, he took her to the dingiest, grottiest retirement home he could find in his fury. On the way however, Beatrice's mind wandered back to her childhood, as we were finally told the story of Henrietta.

She had a tough childhood after the death of her brother, with her father blaming her mother and the lobotomy he forced her to have for Beatrice getting ill, and tried to marry his only daughter off to Corbin Creamerman just because it would be good for business.

Her marriage, something she rushed in to as a rebellion of sorts against the lifestyle she was forced into, was even worse than her childhood. She never truly loved Butterscotch, as they both began to resent their little baby BoJack when he hadn't actually done anything wrong.

When Butterscotch eventually got their maid Henrietta pregnant, Beatrice showed her true feelings towards the family that she never wanted. She offered to pay for Henrietta's nursing tuition so long as she gave up the baby Hollyhock, and pleaded with her not to throw her life away like she did. This was even more of a window into her past and the reason she has such a terrible relationship with BoJack, but before the episode is over the two share a genuinely touching moment when she finally recognises her son.


3. A Free Churro - S5E6

Bojack Horseman
Netflix

With the exception of the flashback to Butterscotch verbally abusing his son, this entire episode is BoJack's eulogy at his mother's funeral. At the beginning he is clearly uncomfortable and tries to turn it into a stand up act in some regard, and telling that the only good thing that came from his mother's death is that he got a free churro when he ordered fast food.

He joked that she was a terrible mother, that she was never proud of him and never cared for his comedy, but the last sentence she ever spoke really got through to him. She didn't tell him she loved him or that she was proud, but simply said 'I see you', something which gave BoJack comfort and meant a lot to him, as he was expecting one last jab about how he let her down.

BoJack's childhood was so terrible that he actually envied the orphans on Horsin' Around, because they could imagine their parents to be anything. But his mother's simple dying sentence seemed to calm him, as the closest thing to a connection they ever had. He was at peace with her passing until he realised she didn't say 'I see you', she was simply reading the ICU sign in the hospital.

This upset BoJack as he never actually got the connection and the closure that he thought this moment with his mother gave him, and now that she was gone, there was absolutely no chance of ever getting it. His mother died, and he got nothing but a free churro.


2. That's Too Much, Man - S3E11

BoJack Horseman Sarah Lynn
Netflix

BoJack Horseman has done some questionable things throughout his life, but what happened in season three's penultimate episode was one of the saddest, and affected him possibly more than anything else. It was a demonstration of how selfish he was, and how little he cared about the feeling and welfare of others.

After losing out on an Oscar nomination for Secretariat, BoJack found Sarah Lynn who had been sober for nine months, and dragged her down onto a bender with him that would last months. They both ended up missing the Oscars, and clearly Sarah Lynn's family were very worried about her.

After driving all the way to Ohio on a drunken idea to make sure he didn't ruin Penny's life, BoJack ultimately reopened the wound that had seemingly healed, and that would take many more years to heal again. He didn't do it to make sure Penny had a good life, he did it to make sure he didn't have to feel guilty.

Of course the saddest part of the entire episode, and possibly the entire series, is the death of Sarah Lynn. After a real moment in which she admitted that she didn't like anything about herself, the two went to the planetarium, where she drifted off to BoJack telling her that everything will be alright, never to wake up again.


1. The View From Halfway Down - S6E15

BoJack and Herb
Netflix

The penultimate episode of BoJack Horseman is one of the greatest, most devastating ever. Following on from the previous episode in which the titular character ditched his sobriety after being told he was being retroactively cut from Horsin' Around, he arrived at this mother's house with a young Sarah Lynn.

The dinner party with those that had passed was a recurring dream BoJack had had before, only this time it was slightly different. After the guests discussed their life and death, and the true meaning of sacrifice, they were taken through to the show, something that BoJack usually woke up before.

The episode gets incredibly dark, even for BoJack Horseman standards, as the guests perform on stage and head through the mystery door, never to return again. While BoJack shares a smoke with his Secretariat father, he is given the grim realisation that nothing we do in life really matters since we all end up in the same place eventually. Again, pretty depressing even for this show.

Panic and shock starts to set in for both BoJack and the audience when we see his lifeless body floating in the swimming pool, and it makes sense why he made it to the show this time. This was the end of BoJack Horseman. The final gut punch comes from Herb, who tells his friend that there is no other side to the door, and as BoJack is taken, the heart rate monitor suggests what we're all thinking, that he is dead. This should have, and would have been the darkest and most fitting possible end to the series.


Contributor

This standard nerd combines the looks of Shaggy with the brains of Scooby, has an unhealthy obsession with the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and is a firm believer that Alter Bridge are the greatest band in the world.