12 Terrible TV Shows That Should Definitely Be Cancelled In 2014

TV shows that are practically crying out to be cancelled this year.

If you ever watched Firefly, particularly during its original run, the word 'cancellation' likely still imbues you with righteous anger even after all these years. Firefly's cancellation was an unjust and premature decision which has had fans rueing what might have been for over a decade, but for the shows in this article, cancellation is a gift which can come only too soon. Come and see things from the other side for once, Firefly fans, because these shows deserve cancellation and frankly it's amazing that some of them have made it this far. Without further ado, let's have a look at the stale TV shows that are practically crying out to be cancelled this year, starting with an undead corpse of a series which just refuses to go.

12. True Blood

You might remember back in 2008 when True Blood aired to critical interest, if not acclaim. Its pilot was slick and stylish and thick with obvious metaphors as vampires struggled for equality in a society unwilling to accept them. The Southern accents were hilariously over-the-top and the sex scenes were graphic, and so True Blood garnered a cult following over on HBO. It's now coming up to its seventh season which we've been promised is its last, and for the good of us all, it should be. True Blood has never been particularly grounded, but its last few series reached the line between sanity and insanity and just sprinted right over it. Bill, once the other half of an epic romance with Sookie, is now pretty much crazy and there's a 50:50 chance that the show will acknowledge this in any given episode. Vampires have been joined by fairies and a myriad of were-creatures. Eric, once the show's cold-blooded killer, is now merely an opportunity for naked Alexander Skarsgard. Please, HBO, stake this one for good and burn it in the sunlight to be sure. And if needs be, we can always have naked Alexander Skarsgard in Game of Thrones.

11. The Tomorrow People

This is a new show which is so derivative that it's laughable. Admittedly, it's a remake of a much older British show of the same name, but there's no great mystery as to why it's been resurrected now amid the comic book movie boom. The Tomorrow People is about impossibly good-looking teens with superpowers caused by a genetic mutation who fear persecution and are hunted by a private organisation which wants to do experiments on them. It is the CW's X-Men. The main issue with The Tomorrow People is its unlikeable protagonist, Stephen, who does nothing other than get into irritating love triangles and make stupid decisions. It's a shame because Luke Mitchell is compelling and charismatic as Stephen's rival John and Mark Pellegrino is clearly enjoying playing the villainous Jedikiah, but Robbie Amell is fighting a losing battle trying to make Stephen sympathetic. Peyton List's indecisive Cara is similarly grating. The show won't kill Stephen off, so barring a very last-minute improvement, the CW should cut its losses now and opt for cancellation. Hopefully the cast can go on to bigger and better things.

10. Pretty Little Liars

You're unlikely to be watching this ABC Family mystery show, so here's a quick summary: a year after the murder of their best friend, four teenage girls are stalked by a villain known only as A. Sound simple? In fact, Pretty Little Liars is perhaps the best example of a show flying by the seat of its pants, because it becomes very obvious in the second season that the writers have no long-term plan except to drag the whole thing out as long as possible. The series has transformed from a mere TV show into a kind of fascinatingly terrible viewing experience. Every character, including the girls themselves, has been marked as A at one point or another. Murder is a weekly occurrence and the police are more concerned about their secret role in harassing teenagers than solving any crimes. Everyone hallucinates all the time and everyone is blackmailing everyone else. Pretty Little Liars needs the finality of cancellation, purely to see whether it can wrap things up and also cope with its own labyrinth-like continuity. The viewers definitely can't.

9. Family Guy

Family Guy has been cancelled before and it wasn't a great decision back then, but now we'd welcome it with open arms. Ratings have been in decline for a few years now but it remains one of Fox's most popular shows, despite the growing staleness of its jokes. The cut-away gags are no longer as surprising and amusing as they once were, and the show's characters (particularly Stewie) are almost unrecognisable nowadays. The decision to keep Family Guy on the air is even more incomprehensible when the network had already improved on the Seth MacFarlane animated sitcom template with the enjoyable American Dad!, but has now let it go to TBS. Family Guy has a place in the adult animation hall of fame, so why not let it go now before it just gets embarrassing?

8. Once Upon a Time in Wonderland

Once Upon a Time was a surprise hit in 2011. It's well-acted (with the exception of the child actor playing Henry, but you win some, you lose some) even when the plot gets a bit absurd, so ABC decided to make the daring if cash-grabbing move to commission the spin-off Once Upon a Time in Wonderland. It's exactly what it says on the tin, and although the plan was to make only one season, ABC is clearly testing the waters for future ventures related to the original series. There's one issue with this series, best expressed by the simple question, "Why?" OUATW repeats Once Upon a Time's mistakes, complete with CGI which looks straight out of the 90s, but puts them in the context of a story which has been adapted too many times to count. Maybe it would have worked as a miniseries, but the order for 22 episodes when its parent series is only in its third season and is airing at the same time is just bizarre. Its ratings have suffered accordingly and cancellation looks likely, thankfully.

7. Glee

Glee's creator Ryan Murphy has reassured exhausted fans that Glee's sixth season will be its last, but it's difficult to see why he's even bothering anymore. Glee's first season back in 2009 was a refreshingly cynical take on schmaltzy teen musical fare like High School Musical, and for a while it seemed like an unstoppable TV juggernaut. Fast forward to season five and Glee has succumbed to the melodrama which it once mocked. The show now splits its time between McKinley High, where it follows a number of new characters in whom it only occasionally shows any interest, and New York, where Lea Michele's Rachel and Chris Colfer's Kurt are pursuing their dreams. Whenever the New York storylines become engaging, the high school ones plummet to new lows. The caricatures of the first season were amusing but hardly the kind of nuanced characters who could sustain a long-running series. Glee has been coming apart at the seams for some time now, and cancellation this year would be met with gratitude.

6. Beauty And The Beast

This Kristin Kreuk supernatural procedural and revival of the 80s hit was inexplicably renewed for a second season despite being consistently terrible. It's not even terrible with any flair, but instead plods along at a snail's pace and tries desperately to interest us in the doomed romance of its dull protagonists. The original had Ron Perlman in layers of heavy make-up every episode, so this one was already off to a bad start when the CW revealed its beast to be a hunk with a scar on his face. The horror... the horror... Beauty and the Beast is bordering on unwatchable, so if it's not set for cancellation, there's truly no justice in the world. Having said that, it is the CW, so who knows?

5. 2 Broke Girls

2 Broke Girls is one of those shows which everyone assumes has been cancelled, but then finds is still airing somehow even though all you ever hear about it is how unfunny it is. This show has been nominated for Emmys, people. Technical Emmys, yes, but still. If you like unoriginal sex jokes repeated ad nauseam and the niggling feeling that you've travelled back in time to the 1970s, you must be a part of the audience which is inexplicably propping 2 Broke Girls up in its third season. This series has kept its humour dial set to 'thoughtless and borderline offensive' throughout its run, and yet it's been three years since its pilot and it's still going. The stereotypes persist, as do the constant short jokes targeted at Korean-American Han Lee even though they weren't funny in the first place. The cast's likeability is what's keeping 2 Broke Girls going, but all of them can do a lot better and the show definitely won't be missed if and when it's gone.

4. Revenge

Revenge's first season was full of crazy soapy plotting and glorious overacting as Emily Thorne (Emily Van Camp) tried to take down the family who framed her father. It was literally The Count of Monte Cristo transplanted to the Hamptons, and it was spectacular. The show's second season, however, was an overwrought mess, and much of its third was spent picking up the pieces. Why didn't it realise that all we wanted to see was Emily cross people off her photo of evildoers with a red sharpie? This show took its exciting premise and ran it into the ground in season two, and it's emerged a convoluted muddle with a number of superfluous characters (Charlotte, Aiden and Jack, we're looking at you). Revenge is directionless, and it ought to be cancelled while we can still look back on season one with fondness and not frustration.

3. Dads

Although Dads has been tipped for cancellation since its pilot was met with derision last autumn, the announcement has worryingly yet to be made. Executive produced by Seth MacFarlane, the pilot was criticised for its racist depiction of an Asian schoolgirl played by Brenda Song, and since then it's gone on to feature a heavily accented Mexican housekeeper and over the top Italian mobsters. MacFarlane is unquestionably talented, but he must know that he's on to a loser with this one. Having said that, Fox chairman Kevin Reilly apparently believes that the scores of negative reviews criticising Dads for its offensive and juvenile humour prove that critics are in on the joke. Last month he announced that he'd heard from a few critics who've "quietly admitted that it's actually kind of funny", in the network executive equivalent of Clint Eastwood talking to an empty chair. It's not real, Mr. Reilly. Just cancel this show.

2. Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D.

Hear me out, S.H.I.E.L.D. aficionados. It's up for a second season, but if this show makes it through 2014 without some serious retooling it will be a miracle, especially since Marvel has a number of other projects in the works. Even Buffy had a weak first season, but S.H.I.E.L.D. is showing so little promise of improvement that cancellation would be an effective way of wiping the slate clean for future Marvel TV series. Like The Tomorrow People, S.H.I.E.L.D. is struggling with a set of bland characters when the whole point of its role in the expanded universe is to allow it to take advantage of the hundreds of ready-made and interesting ones in the comics. Skye in particular suffers from the special snowflake curse of the protagonist and is wholly unsympathetic (to the point that €“ spoilers for non-US viewers €“ her shooting in a recent episode was kind of cathartic), and Agent Ward is a meathead whose personality is still a mystery. Coulson's death and resurrection could have been worked into an upcoming film without dragging it out over months of television which requires sitting through cliché after cliché. Formulaic writing is expected from a freshman show still finding its tone, but S.H.I.E.L.D. had it made and has failed to capitalise on it. There are only so many excuses you can make.

1. Two And A Half Men

Two and a Half Men has always been crude, misogynist and lazy, but now it's all of those things and also stars Ashton Kutcher. The series sadly survived the public breakdown of its former star Charlie Sheen and also the loss of the 'half man', Angus T. Jones, suggesting that the show is actually immune to cancellation. It was treading water before Sheen's departure and is a criminal waste of Jon Cryer, who anchors the show with his ability to carry off the worst lines with excellent timing. Nonetheless, it keeps reinventing itself while also keeping the same broad humour which has defined and restricted the show for eleven seasons, and the ratings remain fairly constant. Cancellation is about as likely as a Firefly reboot, so its appearance on this list is unfortunately only wishful thinking. It seems that Two and a Half Men will air indefinitely while better shows wither and die all around it.

 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Grace Murray hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.