20 Doctor Who Characters Who MUST Return

Did Romana survive the Time War? How does Fenric feel about the Pantheon? We need to know!

Doctor Who The Sarah Jane Adventures The Temptation Of Sarah Jane Smith the Trickster
BBC Studios

In a way, it's laughable that there are any returning characters in Doctor Who. The Doctor is a Time Lord who can travel anywhere in time and space, and yet they keep bumping into the same faces? That seems improbable.

But of course, we forgive it, because as fans we love to see the Doctor interact with their old friends, or have a rematch with returning foes. And to be fair, in an impossibly large time-space continuum, there is some amount of comfort in the fact that we will probably see our favourite Doctor Who characters again.

However, that's not always the case. Not every great companion gets their Power of the Doctor comeback moment, and not every memorable villain gets a second go at defeating the Doctor.

But now that Doctor Who (with Disney's help) is eyeing a position as a major global brand, it needs this diverse range of heroes and villains more than ever, to establish a rich fictional universe, bursting with spinoff potential.

Not that all of these characters are spinoff worthy – it would just be nice to see them again!

20. Canton Everett Delaware III

Doctor Who Canton Everett Delaware III
BBC Studios

When Canton Everett Delaware III was introduced in 2011, Doctor Who was breaking the American market, and Nicholas Courtney had sadly left us. Against that backdrop, it felt like Steven Moffat was introducing a Brigadier surrogate to honour Courtney's legacy, and appeal to American audiences.

Mark Sheppard was a well-known face to fans of American TV due to his roles in Battlestar Galactica and Supernatural, but alas, Canton never returned. Over a decade later, and with Doctor Who striving to be a global brand, perhaps the time is right for another America-based adventure with the former FBI agent.

How brilliant would it be to see Canton in charge of an American branch of UNIT in the 1970s or the 1980s, leading the organisation like a cross between Fox Mulder and the Brigadier? Yes please.


19. Duggan

Doctor Who City of Death Duggan
BBC Studios

Duggan is the best Fourth Doctor companion that we never had. Just imagine the fun we could've had if he'd joined the TARDIS after City of Death!

While we never got to see Duggan punching his away across time and space with the Fourth Doctor and Romana, that doesn't mean he can't make a comeback alongside Ncuti Gatwa.

The Power of the Doctor and The Giggle established that UNIT hires former friends of the Doctor, so surely a private detective who once saved the Earth with a well-timed punch is a dream hire!

Actor Tom Chadbon may be a bit older nowadays, but age hasn't stopped Sly Stallone or Arnie from landing a few punches, has it? Nor did it stop the likes of Colin Baker and Sylvester McCoy returning to the show either.


18. Rogue

Doctor Who Rogue Jonathan Groff
BBC Studios

Jonathan Groff's Rogue may seem like an obvious character to bring back in Doctor Who Season 2 and beyond, but it's also entirely possible that he'll go the way of Kylie Minogue's Astrid and be well and truly dead.

Rogue was a compelling character – a viable romantic partner for the Doctor who had a dark past. While, yes, this effectively makes him River Song 2.0, Rogue's more stand-offish, secretive side presented a fascinating mirror image of the Doctor themselves.

It feels like there are plenty more stories to tell about Rogue and the Doctor, as long as the Disney money stretches to bringing back Jonathan Groff as a recurring cast member!


17. The Nightmare Man

Doctor Who The Sarah Jane Adventures The Nightmare Man
BBC Studios

The Nightmare Man was a top-tier Sarah Jane Adventures creation who deserves to cross over into Doctor Who. Memorably played by Davros actor Julian Bleach, the Nightmare Man was an extra-dimensional being who fed on – what else – nightmares.

And hey, isn't it possible that the Nightmare Man could be retconned as one of Doctor Who's new Pantheon members, as Sutekh and the Toymaker were? In The Sarah Jane Adventures, he feeds on people's doubts and fears – and in The Legend of Ruby Sunday, Harriet Arbinger said that the God of Disaster has children called Doubt and Dread.

The Nightmare Man could easily fit either of those categories, setting up his long-awaited return in a future episode of Doctor Who.


16. Leela

Leela Doctor Who
BBC Studios

Louise Jameson is one of the few classic Doctor Who companions who has worked consistently since her departure.

A veteran of EastEnders and a regular on Emmerdale, Jameson's return to Doctor Who could even grab the attention of casual viewers who know her from her work outside the series!

The noble warrior Leela would've been a vital asset during the Time War. Imagine her as a great military tactician leading armies against the Daleks. How would that have affected her as a character?

Big Finish and the Collection box-sets have given us some insight into this, but wouldn't it be great to see it fleshed out properly on TV?


15. Harriet Jones

Doctor Who Harriet Jones The Stolen Earth
BBC Studios

Contrary to what you may have seen in The Stolen Earth, Harriet Jones survived her encounter with the Daleks.

In a poem written by James Goss and illustrated by Russell T Davies, it was revealed that thanks to a handy trap door, she escaped on a motorbike.

Then, during the lockdown tweetalong of The Stolen Earth, RTD expanded on this idea further, revealing that Harriet's survival was part of the Trickster's long-term plan.

Given that these lockdown tweetalongs eventually led to Russell's return to Doctor Who, can we expect Harriet, the Trickster, and a cabal of billionaires to appear in Season 2? Stranger things have happened.


14. The Rutans

Doctor Who Rutans
BBC

We've seen the war between the Daleks and the Thals, and we've even seen the seemingly impossible-to-realise Time War!

However, Doctor Who has never depicted the war between the Sontarans and the Rutans onscreen, despite it being mentioned countless times over the years.

The Rutans themselves have only appeared in televised Doctor Who once, in the classic Tom Baker serial The Horror of Fang Rock. While the big green ball of goo might not be the most imaginative design, technology has advanced sufficiently to render these evil green gobstoppers in more terrifying detail.

They're also a fairly blank slate when it comes to backstory, allowing new writers to expand our knowledge of the Rutans and turn them into truly iconic Doctor Who villains.


13. Osgood

Doctor Who The Zygon Inversion Osgood
BBC Studios

Lovable, nerdy Doctor obsessive Osgood was a charming addition to the UNIT team from her debut in the 50th anniversary, to her last appearance in The Zygon Inversion. So where is she?

There are three whole incarnations of the Doctor that Osgood hasn't met yet, which feels unfair, frankly. We know that Osgood was still a member of UNIT at the time of Flux, but she hasn't been heard of since.

Maybe she's running her own separate top-secret division of UNIT elsewhere in the world, or perhaps her work with the Zygon settlers is taking up all her time. Either way, with a UNIT spinoff currently in production, Osgood's absence is hugely disappointing.


12. Sabalom Glitz

Doctor Who Sabalom Glitz
BBC Studios

Yes, Mel revealed that Sabalom Glitz is dead in The Giggle, but Doctor Who is a time travel show!

One of the last characters created by legendary Doctor Who writer Robert Holmes, this intergalactic Del Boy had spinoff potential written all over him. If Doctor Who had been in better shape in the eyes of the BBC in the late 1980s, who knows what might have happened?

Glitz is our way into the seedier side of the Doctor Who universe, which could really open things up from a storytelling perspective.

Sadly, actor Tony Selby passed away in 2021, but there is someone who would be a perfect Glitz in Doctor Who's new era. Go with us here. Ready? Danny Dyer! He's got that exact same vibe, and he's already worked with Disney and David Tennant on the TV show Rivals!


11. The Meddling Monk

Doctor Who the Meddling Monk
BBC Studios

Russell T Davies has "parked" the Master for now, and that's probably for the best. However, that doesn't mean we can't resurrect some of Doctor Who's other renegade Time Lords, does it?

The Meddling Monk would be a terrific addition to modern Doctor Who, particularly as the idea of a villain who rewrites history for fun feels quite pertinent in the age of fake news.

Sure, the Monk isn't exactly a season finale-level villain, but he'd make for a great midseason episode that's lighter in tone. After 19 years, isn't it time we finally have a bit of fun with the Time Lords?

Matt Berry is right there. Just pick up the phone Russell!


10. Jenny

Doctor Who The Doctor's Daughter Jenny
BBC

Ruby Sunday and her mother Louise changed how the Fifteenth Doctor viewed family, so isn't it time that he reconnected with his own missing daughter, Jenny?

As of September 2024, Georgia Tennant is 39 and Ncuti Gatwa is 31, meaning that Jenny will now look a bit older than her father. That's a fun dynamic to play with, as the older and wiser Jenny may struggle to defer to her youthful, yet ancient father. She's also one of the most-requested returning characters, so a comeback would go down very well with fans.

And just think how much fun the promo for Georgia Tennant's return would be: "I'm a Tennant, but probably not the one you were expecting!"


9. The Mara

Kinda Header
BBC

The Mara is a far more sinister Doctor Who villain than the slightly embarassing pink snake would have you believe. This is a creature that feeds on people's darkest impulses, latching onto them and turning them into agents of chaos.

The Mara was referenced in The Legend of Ruby Sunday, so RTD or another writer can easily reintroduce the so-called "God of Beasts" to modern Doctor Who. It would be a perfect opportunity to bring back Janet Fielding, and give us the final battle between Tegan and the Mara.

Unleashing the Mara on contemporary Earth may tread too close to Empire of Death, but a smaller-scale, character-driven story would be an absolute treat – think The Devil's Chord crossed with Amy's Choice. Minus the singing, dancing, and dodgy ponytails.


8. Grace Holloway

Doctor Who Daphne Ashbrook Grace Holloway
BBC Studios

Whatever happened to Grace Holloway? Rights issues meant that Daphne Ashbrook couldn't reprise the role, but now that Doctor Who is part of the Disney empire, could that change the bargaining position?

Long before Donna Noble had regrets over saying no to travels in the TARDIS, Grace turned down the Eighth Doctor in the first minutes of New Year's Day 2000. How did her experiences with the Doctor and the Master change her life? Did they fuel her medical career?

The return of Daphne Ashbrook as Grace could answer all of these questions, giving us a chance to learn more about the '90s companion we never got. And while we're at it, reunite her with Paul McGann's Eighth Doctor!


7. The Sarah Jane Adventures Cast

The Sarah Jane Adventures
BBC Studios

Varada Sethu will be playing Belinda Chandra in the next season of Doctor Who. Have we considered that she may have a connection to The Sarah Jane Adventures?

Belinda's namesake, Rani Chandra, would be an excellent addition to the new series, following in the footsteps of her mentor Sarah Jane as her dogged journalism clashes with UNIT's desire to keep things top secret. The rest of the SJA gang would also bring a sense of continuity between the two RTD eras.

Sarah's adopted son Luke is surely a UNIT scientific advisor in waiting, while Clyde Langer's keen artistic eye and years fighting monsters could make him a valuable asset to Kate Stewart.

And who doesn't want to hear Ncuti Gatwa confidently declare "Mr Smith, I need you"?


6. Fenric

Doctor Who Fenric2
BBC

Fenric is notable by his absence from Doctor Who's Pantheon, so where does he sit in terms of ancient powers? Memorably described as "evil from the dawn of time" by the Seventh Doctor, it's possible that Fenric actually predates the Pantheon.

Does Fenric have beef with the other gods of the Doctor Who universe? Are they scared of him? And what would happen if you put the Doctor in the middle of a battle between Fenric and the Pantheon of the Gods? A pretty epic season finale, that's what.

The Curse of Fenric is such an undisputed classic that a sequel is a daunting prospect. Still, that didn't put off RTD from delivering a follow-up to Pyramids of Mars!


5. Romana

Romana Ii Doctor Who Lalla Ward
BBC

The fate of Romana has been a huge question since Russell T Davies decided to blow up Gallifrey in 2005. Even when the Doctors restored their home planet in The Day of the Doctor, we're still none the wiser about where this particular Time Lord has ended up.

Spinoff media established that Romana became President of Gallifrey in the years before the Time War. It's so firmly established in fact, that it's practically taken as official canon by fans. So what happened to Romana when the Time Lords went to war with the Daleks?

Did she perish in the Time War? Or did she survive in exile after being deposed by Rassilon? Also, were her and the Fourth Doctor actually in love with each other?!

We need to know!


4. The Trickster

Sarah Jane The Trickster
BBC

Russell T Davies' return to Doctor Who paved the way for the return of The Sarah Jane Adventures' big bad, the Trickster. Remember how everyone thought Ruby was a child of the Trickster because her mum wore a big cloak?

The Legend of Ruby Sunday confirmed that the Trickster was part of Doctor Who's terrifying Pantheon of godlike beings. He was named as the God of Traps, taking his place alongside the Toymaker, Maestro, and Sutekh.

Given that the Trickster was last seen being defeated by the Tenth Doctor and Sarah Jane, it feels like the time is right for a rematch. He'd be the perfect overarching villain of a season, or even multiple seasons, quietly pulling the strings in the background before an explosive finale reveal.


3. The Rani

Doctor Who The Rani
BBC Studios

Like the Monk, the Rani is another Time Lord villain that brings a completely different energy to Doctor Who. For the Rani, the ability to travel in time and space afforded her a diverse range of specimens for her experiments with brain chemistry.

In the online commentary for Last of the Time Lords, Russell T Davies can be heard joking that it was the Rani who picked up the Master's ring. It wasn't, but what if it's the Rani picking up the Toymaker's gold tooth at the end of The Giggle? Hmmmmm.

It would be a tall order to replace Kate O'Mara as the Rani, but it could be done. You just need someone with the right balance of high camp, glamour, and menace. Jinkx Monsoon is already taken, but what about Michelle Visage?


2. Martha Jones

Doctor Who Journey's End Martha Jones
BBC

Martha Jones is the most underrated of modern Doctor Who companions, because she worked harder than almost all of them. Not only did she overthrow the Master's reign in Last of the Time Lords, she threatened to use the Osterhagen Key against Davros, and had to endure a few days working for Torchwood.

And does Martha get any credit? Wouldn't it be nice to see the Fifteenth Doctor apologise for not appreciating her more while she was travelling with him. Perhaps while they face down some extraterrestrial threat together?

The Mickey situation would have to be addressed, but there's no reason Martha can't easily return as a member of UNIT, or some other important military organisation. The War Between the Land and the Sea would be a prime opportunity.


1. Susan Foreman

Doctor Who Susan
BBC

Doctor Who spent the majority of the past season teasing the return of the Doctor's granddaughter. However, Susan's return was a red herring to distract from the true identity of Susan Triad, and her connection to Sutekh. But is that really it?

Referencing Susan in such a big way throughout the season makes it hard to put that genie back in the bottle. The Doctor's regret over losing touch with Susan at the end of Empire of Death feels like the setup for a future arc, but is RTD just playing with us again?

Whatever Russell's intention, Susan's return feels inevitable now, whether she's played by Carole Ann Ford or someone else. The Doctor is now more in tune with notions of family – so his own family deserves a call.

Time will tell, as it usually does.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Citizen of the Universe, Film Programmer, Writer, Podcaster, Doctor Who fan and a gentleman to boot. As passionate about Chinese social-realist epics as I am about dumb popcorn movies.