5 HUGE Plot Holes You Didn't Notice In Crisis On Infinite Earths
The Arrowverse’s latest crossover defied the odds... and logic.
Contains spoilers from DC's Legends of Tomorrow Season 5, Arrow Season 8 Episode 8, The Flash Season 6 Episode 9, Batwoman Season 1 Episode 9 and Supergirl Season 5 Episode 9.
Crisis On Infinite Earths was, without a doubt, the major universe-altering spectacle that both the Arrowverse's creative team and its fans wanted it to be. A triumph that pushed the boundaries of television, it marked the final time that Arrow would join The Flash, Legends of Tomorrow, Supergirl, Black Lightning and Batwoman for one of the annual crossovers and ultimately set up the ending of that show in the process.
An event that fans had been waiting five years to see, there was a lot of anticipation heading into it, as we all hoped that it would succeed - and it goes without saying that it absolutely did, changing the face of the multiverse forever.
That being said, there were a number of things that, although they didn't take away from our overall enjoyment of Crisis, didn't necessarily add up either - some of which were rather baffling. With that in mind, let's take a look at some of the huge crossover's most glaring plot holes.
5. We Need To Talk About Laurel
Arrow's eighth season was the one that finally gave the Laurel Lance character the attention that she deserved, as the former villain was forced to watch as a wave of antimatter ripped Earth-2 apart. With her home destroyed and nowhere to go, she decided to complete her redemptive arc on Earth-1 by joining Oliver's quest to save the multiverse and ultimately stop what happened on Earth-2 from happening anywhere else.
With that in mind, fans were eagerly anticipating what kind of role she would play in Crisis itself, so you can imagine their disappointment when she didn't feature - like, at all. Sure, Katie Cassidy appeared in a flashback to Earth-1 Laurel, but there wasn't a sign of Earth-2's Black Canary. Not only was this a major disappointment, it just didn't make sense.
Now, Marc Guggenheim has since revealed that Laurel's absence was down to the fact that crossovers mean having to pay actors extra - and as Cassidy's notability undoubtedly makes her one of the more expensive actresses on The CW (note the 'With' and 'Special Appearance By' credits she's had over the years), she wasn't used in any episode other than the Arrow one.
An understandable side effect of the television business perhaps, but there were so many insignificant characters that weren't relevant to the plot who could have easily been cut from the crossover - Laurel wasn't one of them due to how prominent the Crisis was in her arc. And by having Sara refer to the original Laurel on multiple occasions - and literally nobody ask where Earth-2 Laurel was - the writers continually drew attention to her nonsensical absence.
4. Characters Mysteriously Disappeared Midway Through
An extension of the previous point, characters who did manage to weave their way into Crisis On Infinite Earths ended up mysteriously disappearing midway through it. And yes, before you say it, we're very well aware of the fact that the antimatter wave wiped them all out. The point is that, when the universe was restored not a single person thought the need to mention their name, simply because it would draw attention to their absence. Ironically, the lack of explanation ended up doing that instead.
Iris West-Allen was always going to play a major role in the Crisis and, upon doing so, she never got her chance to feature in the final installment and share a reunion with her beloved Barry. Similarly, Cisco Ramon had his powers restored by The Monitor and helped Earth-90 Flash save the multiverse. However, upon the rebirth, he was nowhere to be seen and, instead, Killer Frost, Heat Wave and Black Lightning held down S.T.A.R. Labs while Team Arrow's Dinah Drake randomly decided to do the comms work.
Again, this was also undoubtedly down to financial reasons (in terms of which actors could appear in which episodes and so forth), but it did take away from the final offering - making the heroes look unprepared for the final battle and robbing fans of some of the emotional payoffs they had been waiting years for.
3. Earth-90 Flash's Death
The Monitor's emphatic belief that The Flash must die in the Crisis came to fruition during the crossover, but not in the way he anticipated. That's right, Earth-90's Barry Allen decided to return to the cosmic treadmill of which he had been recently freed, and overran it (literally) until he disintegrated - destroying the machine in the process.
However, if running into oblivion was the way in which a Flash was supposed die all along, couldn't either Barry have just created a time remnant in order to stop it? Yes, a version of whichever respective Flash was fated to die would indeed have disintegrated, but that would have allowed the main version of him to survive at the same time.
Now, our Barry Allen learned his lesson with time remnants due to the whole Savitar debacle, but when it's a time-sensitive life-or-death end-of-the-world scenario such as this that could have literally saved both him and Earth-90 Flash from dying and saved the multiverse, wasn't the risk worth the reward?
2. Reverse-Flash's Absence Literally Doesn't Make Any Sense
While Crisis On Infinite Earths was undoubtedly a roaring success, the most disappointing thing about it was undoubtedly the absence of Eobard Thawne himself: the Reverse-Flash. The evil speedster from the future was the one who introduced audiences to the notion of the Crisis back in the very first episode of The Flash when he accessed that now-infamous 2024 newspaper in the time vault - a newspaper that referenced an epic battle between him and the Scarlet Speedster under those crimson skies of death.
Arrow EP Marc Guggenheim explained to TVLine that, as the Reverse-Flash scenario was created by showrunners who weren't part of the crossover they didn't want to be beholden to a headline written six years ago. That's all well and good, but it wasn't just that headline that confirmed Thawne's return, as Nora West-Allen's arrival confirmed that the pair were going to battle in the Crisis - due to a new headline set 25 years Post-Crisis - and the fact that her inadvertent manipulation of the timeline resulted in Thawne's escape from Death Row. And when he made his escape, he explicitly told Barry that he would see him during his next Crisis.
Thus, we're now expected to believe that a fixed point in time that simply couldn't be changed no matter how hard any member of Team Flash tried can now suddenly be manipulated to suit the narrative? Doesn't sound like a good enough excuse to literally come in and change something fans had been waiting half a decade to see, and in all honesty, it undercut five years of wonderful foreshadowing.
1. Heroes Never Tell
Here's the thing; both Barry Allen and Oliver Queen knew that the Crisis was coming for quite some time. The former was aware of its impending arrival for over five years and, thanks to the help of the future newspaper, knew the intricate details of what would go down and what heroes he would ultimately need to stop it. The other, however, discovered it would come a year before it did and proceeded to prepare himself - and his own team for it. With that in mind, it's clear that it wasn't a major secret.
So, did nobody think it would be a good idea to tell Supergirl? Not only would the Girl of Steel have been one of their best hopes for stopping it, the knowledge would have allowed her and her team to prepare for the universe-altering event that was coming their way. However, nobody informed her about its arrival and, thus, she had to watch as a wave of antimatter wiped out her mother, the remnants of her home planet and, at one point in time, even Superman and Lois (who were ultimately saved at the last minute by Harbinger).
On top of that, her partners' baffling lack of discretion resulted in Earth-38 being left completely open to attack. As a result, they only had time to save 3 billion of its population, leaving another 4.53 billion people to die in the Crisis.
Sure, it was all undone when Oliver rebuilt the universe but, at the time, they didn't know that was destined to happen. And thus, fans are still left wondering why two thirds of the Arrowverse's long-standing trinity wouldn't have informed their most powerful teammate about the Crisis' impending arrival.
-
Did you notice any plot holes in Crisis On Infinite Earths? Tell us in the comment section below.
The Hardest Flash Quiz Ever