5 Reasons Why A Friends Movie (Sadly) Wouldn't Work
Before I start this article, Id just like to make it clear that I did, do and always will LOVE F.R.I.E.N.D.S. Seriously, Im the type of hardcore fan who would buy the videos as a kid (God, remember those?) watch the episodes, rewind the tape and watch it all over again. Then, when videos became extinct, I replaced them all with the DVD boxsets, even though the show was, and still is, on TV non-stop. God knows what Ill do when they stop making DVDs. Anyway, therefore, its with a bit of a heavy heart that I write this because, year after year, us Friends fans, the world over, scour the Internet, with that glimmer of hope in our eyes, for a morsel of news that might give some indication to the possibility of a reunion/movie. With next year being ten years since filming ended, were still left disappointed. But, recently, Ive come to realise that I dont think a reunion movie (a la Sex and the City) would actually be of any benefit to the series but would, in fact, be a detriment to it. Here are my reasons for thinking this. 5. Its A Sitcom
To begin with, the show was a situation comedy (obviously) which means it relied on its physical environment for its comedic entertainment. The show has a very stage feel to it and used it to its full advantage. The main characters very rarely veered away from their natural habits; Monica and Rachels Apartment; Chandler and Joeys Apartment; Ross Apartment; Central Perk; and we, as a faithful audience came to love their homes and hangouts almost as much as the character. Its often the case that reunion movies need to be something of a spectacle both to draw in revenue and to revitalise and out-do the storylines from the series. Think Sex and the City in Abu Dhabi or The Inbetweeners in Malia. Yeah I suppose they could send the Friends somewhere again (like London, Atlantic City or the Bahamas), but, for me at least, the whole nostalgia satisfaction would come from the safe familiarity of the good old days. I want to see Apartment 19 and 20 and Central Perk as they are now. However, considering Monica and Chandler dont even live in the city anymore, Im not confident they could really find a story worthy enough to compensate for the losses. In addition, the Friends writers were particularly keen on using live studios and episode, famously, took twice as long to film than normal. In fact, the show was criticised for having the often financially struggling characters living in large, New York apartments. The writers had explained that the sets were bigger as to allow the live audience to see the action as much as possible. So, its pretty hard to deny that this sort of environment would be lost, or greatly diminished. I dont pretend to be an expert on filming techniques but would they suddenly have a multi-cam set-up with four walls and no laugh track? They would have to right? Has a sitcom ever actually been adapted for film? Im not sure but if so, its not a regular occurrence and, honestly, I think experimenting with Friends famous format would result in the magic being lost in mix.
4. Its a Comedy
Friends was comedy in its purest form, it was its bread and butter. Lets be honest, its was not high-class drama, and nor should it have ever been. It never took itself seriously and thats why we loved it. Quite simply it was a laugh! The only problem with this is how would it translate onto the big screen? Along with the filming issues Ive mentioned, one must question whether Friends particular brand of humour could be adequately adapted. And if it could, would it still be Friends, or something else entirely? Unfortunately some people seem to think that because shows such as Sex and the City had successful reunions, Friends would too. Keep in mind, Sex and the City was a completely different genre of show. Yes, it used a lot of humour but, at its core it was a drama, a drama which was considerably more risqué, sarcastic and realistic. Friends is kind of like the pre-watershed version of Sex. In fact, the only thing they really have in common is that both shows are set in New York. Besides, as Ive mentioned earlier, a reunion really needs to pull out all the stops; both aesthetically and creatively. How could we have 90 120 minutes of laughs? Would it then just be an extended episode of the show, or would they have to suddenly make it drama? Of course Friends has gotten more serious at times, but never for a sustained period of time and movies are built around discord and ultimate resolution. You could argue there are plenty of comedy films, but even still, it is a different kettle of fish to a television series. Mult-genre shows which frequently employ humour, such as UglyBetty and Glee, would be much more suited to the big screen, but Friends? Friends was always a comedy show, first and foremost, and tampering with its premise just for the sake of a comeback has the potential to ruin its legacy altogether.
3. The Characters Are Too Old Now
One of the reason that the show became so successful was because of the characters ages. The show documented their lives from about 25 35 (roughly) and thus attracted mass appeal. Unlike other shows, which usually centre on either teenagers or serious adults, Friends had adults who, essentially, behaved like teenagers. Therefore, the writers were unrestrained and it left practically nothing off the table, nothing that they could talk about. Adults appreciated the black sarcasm (Chandler Bing we love you!), teenagers got a giggle from the constant sexual innuendos and younger kids enjoyed the slapstick, physical comedy elements. However, almost ten years on, I doubt the characters would be as appealing in any of those senses. With marriages, kids and new houses it would be disconcerting to have people in the 40s behaving how they did ten years ago. Also, age is often a characteristic of the Other in fiction and unfortunately, Friends had fairly conventional main cast: six young, attractive, white Americans with decent careers. As I said before, its not like Sex, or even Courtney Coxs CougarTown, which are essentially dramas with comedic elements, where older adults have a kind of Other lifestyles (e.g. single, divorced). Most of Friends settled into fairly traditional lifestyles. So, I honestly think it could be too difficult to drum up a storyline funny enough for people their age. The only recent sitcom which portrays Otherness well is The Big Bang Theory but, of course, the characters are the age the Friends were ten years ago. As harsh as it sounds, the sitcom is a fairly traditional format with characters that are rather three-dimensional. The Other individuals are often quirky background characters used for extra comedic foil, such as Gunter in Friends, Sophie in TwoBrokeGirls, Karen and Rosario in Will & Grace and Berta in Two and a Half Men.
2. TV Has Moved On
I touched upon this point in the last section, which is the reality that ten years have passed since the show finished. Pop culture, television and society in general has moved on. The sitcom is not as popular a genre as it was in the 90s, and most of the great sitcoms from the Friends era (Seinfield, Fraiser,Will & Grace) have long since gone. Sure we still have the likes of Two and a Half Men, The Big Bang Theory and How I Met Your Mother, but theyre hardly the talking points there predecessors were. To be brutally honest, when watching these shows, I feel like Ive seen it all before. They can come across as cut-price versions of the originals. Bad remakes! Friends was an original of its time and missing an episode was inconceivable. However, Im not sure bringing it back in the 2010s would necessarily guarantee success. Of course, it would be watched widely, due to pure fan nostalgia, but creatively I believe television has become a lot more scrutinised in recent years. TV series seem to have become considerable more stylised, creative and also, multi-genre. As such, the focus of popularity seems to have passed over sitcoms and landed on high-concept drama, fantasy series an reality shows for the time being. It would be heartbreaking for fans if their beloved series was brought back, only for it to fall into insignificance.
1. Everyones Storyline Was Wrapped Up
At the end of the day, is there really any need to ruffle up these beloved characters' narratives again? Friends is famous for having a particularly long run of seasons, and maintaining its ratings and critical success. As such, the writers were able to tie up all the main characters' stories better than most. Perhaps some things are best left untouched. It would be a disaster for a reunion movie to fail because, given the wild success of the series, the fall would inevitable be much worse. Its true what they say: the higher the climb, the further the fall. Monica and Chandler married, adopted twins and moved to suburbs. Phoebe married Mike and the possibility of children was hinted at in the finale. Rachel and Ross FINALLY hooked-up and, we can safely assume, for the last time. They, of course, already had Emma two years before. The only character who did not get a long term resolution was Joey, and the characters spin-off (adaptly named Joey) is a true testament to why some things should be left well enough alone. The series bombed and the second season did not even finish airing. If a Friends off-shoot didnt work on television isnt that an indication of the damage a movie could possibly do?