8 Drastic TV Recastings That Worked

A whole new world of options is opened up, and the show is just as good if not better than it was before.

4ffee81403626027 It's a matter of course in the television world that sometimes, even on the best shows, casting changes need to be made. The goal of these recasts are generally to make the transition as painless and smooth for audiences as they can. Depending on the scope of the role and the popularity of the actor, this isn't always possible. When an actor has to leave a production for whatever reason, it's always a major disruption. Usually people have a Very Serious Opinion about which they like better, and often the newcomer is seen as a sort of usurper. Nothing they do will ever live up to the original. Consider Aunt Viv on Fresh Prince, for example. Everyone loved the original Viv, with her spunky sense of humor, in-control personality, and professional life that served as a role model for women everywhere. Fast forward a few seasons, and we get the new Viv, who's pretty much just another sitcom housewife. She's not terrible, she's just not what we're used to. But then sometimes, actors get replaced, and all of a sudden we discover their character's real potential. A whole new world of options is opened up, and the show is just as good if not better than it was before.

8. Bobby Draper - Mad Men

AMC Mad Men has had more Bobby Drapers than Spinal Tap has had drummers. The role has been recast not once, not twice, but three times, with four different child actors playing Don Draper's son. The first two were harmless, but they seemed to struggle with the logistics of filming (John Slattery once joked that no matter how many Bobby's they had, they couldn't find one who wouldn't look right into the camera lens). Jared Gilmore, the third Bobby, seemed like a step up. He was a reasonably strong child actor who had good chemistry with Kiernan Shipka, his television sister. But then he was cast as the lead on ABC's Once Upon a Time, so they had to go back to the drawing board. (Also playing a factor may have been Gilmore's supposedly difficult relationship with January Jones, who he gave a less than favorable report on, warning the next Bobby to watch out for her and calling her "unapproachable".) For the past two seasons, Mason Vale Cotton has been performing the role since the beginning of the fifth season, and it looks like he'll be here to stay. At twelve years old, he's entirely capable of carrying more complex story lines, although unfortunately any child actor outside of maybe Christian Bale circa Empire of the Sun is going to look like an acting schlub next to the remarkably talented Shipka. Still, we've seen genuine moments from him, like when he comforts the African-American man in the movie theater after Martin Luther King's death.

7. The Doctor - Doctor Who

This one is kind of obvious. After all, like James Bond, the show has made a habit of replacing its lead actor every few years. Before Doctor Who, there was one major stumbling block when hiring a middle aged actor for a television show: what do you do when he is either unable or unwilling to continue to play the role? Do you let the show die rather than moving on without its star, or do you change the game? Doctor Who created an ingenious concept of regeneration, which essentially meant that the lead alien character could change form and personality rather than dying. This allowed them to recast the role whenever they needed to. When William Hartnell's health declined, they hired Patrick Troughton to carry the torch, so to speak. From then on out, they've passed on the role of the Doctor every few years (the usual tenure was about three years, although the iconic Tom Baker stayed on for seven). Now that the show has been rebooted, they've continued the tradition, with three actors having played the role so far, and Peter Capaldi set to take over later this year. It's a clever way to keep things fresh, and has allowed the show to change and grow over the past fifty years.

6. Lily - Modern Family

Lily Modern Family is a show largely populated by young people, with each of the three families featured having at least one kid. Child actors are the most vulnerable to being recast, either for their acting abilities not progressing as well as they should or their looks having changed into something that doesn't quite fit anymore. So the fact that Modern Family only ended up needing to replace the twins playing Lily, the adopted Vietnamese daughter of Cam and Mitchell, was actually pretty lucky. There was nothing wrong with the two little girls, they just didn't seem to enjoy the day to day rigors of on set life (or more likely, their parents didn't), so the decision was made to bring in a new Lily, Aubrey Anderson-Emmons. She quickly grew into the role, allowing the writers to develop an acerbic wit for the young character. These days, with the writing staff not really knowing what to do with a teenage Manny and Luke, she's frequently one of the funniest parts of the show.

5. Becky - Roseanne

Gal Recast Becky Conner 111516 The notably eccentric Conner family on Roseanne featured three children: Becky, Darlene, and DJ. Their working class exploits were a refreshing change from the more white collar family sitcoms we had been used to watching on television throughout the 80s. But as it often happens when shows feature teenage actors facing major life decisions, Roseanne had to be restructured after Becky actress Lacy Goranson left the show to attend Vassar College. For a while, they had her character merely absent, off living with her husband and just not appearing in the episodes. But at the beginning of the sixth season, they brought on Sarah Chalke (of Scrubs fame) to take over the role. If it had ended there, it would have been fine -- just a run of the mill casting revision. But strangely enough, they brought Goranson back whenever she was available to film, the practical result of which was that the two actresses would sometimes appear in alternating episodes. It sort of worked, though. Roseanne was known for its meta sense of humor, and having two actresses play one of the main characters in the later seasons was just one more delightfully odd production decision.

4. Ann Veal - Arrested Development

Tumblr M9xz51boeq1qabnl2 While most television shows on this list had to recast out of necessity, because an actor left for another project or wasn't right for the part anymore, Arrested Development turned it into a running gag. What's brilliant about the fact that they recast Ann is because that's her whole character. She's so forgettable that it doesn't even matter if she's played by two different actresses, because no one even looks twice at her. In fact, the creators originally intended for Ann to be portrayed by a different actress every time she appeared on the show, but as it stands they only used Alessandra Torresani and Mae Whitman. While Torresani was featured in Ann Veal's debut, Whitman took over the role and continued on through the entirety of the show's run. Which is probably just as well, because Torresani eventually grew up to be a Maxim girl and Whitman, while undeniably adorable, possesses more of an Everygirl quality needed to make the Ann ("Her?") character work.

3. Darrin - Bewitched

Recast Bewitched Darrin is probably the most well-known example of a major recasting on a hit television show. Dick York originated the role of Darrin on Bewitched, the befuddled mortal husband of Elizabeth Montgomery's witchy woman. He could normally be spotted flailing his arms around like Kermit in distress, and being consistently overwhelmed by the supernatural hijinks his wife Samantha managed to get into on a weekly basis. York did the show for about five years, until severe pain from a back injury forced him to bow out of the production. They recast him with the slightly more dignified Dick Sargent, who took over the role for the rest of the show's run, which would be another three years. But as it turns out, Sargent was actually the original choice for Darrin. He was offered the role, but at the time had already committed to another television series, Broadside (which ended up only running one season), so the producers went with Dick York instead. By the time York had to quit the show, Sargent was available again.

2. Alice - The Honeymooners

Alice Interestingly enough, the famed Alice on The Honeymooners was actually not the original. In fact, the show featured a different actress, Pert Kelton, in the role of sarcastic, long-suffering Alice, always there with some level-headed wisdom during Ralph's ill-advised schemes. She played the role for the first seven episodes of the show's run, when she was replaced by Audrey Meadows. Kelton brought a bit of a sharper edge to the role, actually sending The Honeymooners into dark comedy territory, where Meadows had a softer touch with Alice. The casting change can likely be attributed to the political climate of the United States during the early days of the Cold War. Officially, she left the show because of health issues that prevented her from continuing. But Kelton's husband had recently been blacklisted during the infamous McCarthy hearings with the House of Un-American Activities Committee, and his shunning by the Hollywood community had a sudden and dramatic effect on her career. One woman's misfortune is another's blessing, and Audrey Meadows is the actress remembered for the iconic 1950s television show.

1. Daario Naharis - Game of Thrones

Pic5rl6f0hil Game of Thrones doesn't exactly have a great track record for maintaining casting continuity in anything other than their main group of lead actors. They are switched in and out casually, and just as we can never be sure if out favorite characters are going to survive their run on the show, we're equally uncertain if they will even be played by the same actors. We've seen a new Tommen Baratheon, but it's more or less understandable that they made the switch from Callum Wharry to Dean-Charles Chapman. After all, the character went for a long spell where he wasn't featured heavily on the show, and no one would have really noticed that they changed actors. In addition, they made the creative decision to age up the character by a few years, and Dean-Charles Chapman has the acting experience to handle the more developed role. But a more egregious example is the recast of Daario Naharis, a crucial member of Daenarys's squad. Between seasons 3 and 4, actor Ed Skrein somehow morphed into Michael Huisman, who is equally attractive but very different looking. Apparently Skrein left Game of Thrones to work on a new Transporter film, which is obviously a better career move than a featured role on the most popular shows on television.

Contributor
Contributor

Audrey Fox is an ex-film student, which means that she prefers to spend her days in the dark, watching movies and pondering the director's use of diegetic sound. She currently works as an entertainment writer, joyfully rambling about all things film and television related. Add her on Twitter at @audonamission and check out her film blog at 1001moviesandbeyond.com.