American Horror Story: 10 Most Controversial Moments

AHS has always been shocking, but which times did it go too far?

American Horror Story Addiction Demon
FX

American Horror Story deserves a lot of credit. When it debuted in 2011, the likes of Saw and Hostel had turned the horror genre into... well, not a joke necessarily, but certainly a very niche area of entertainment. Narrative and characterisation were not something you expected when you settled in for terror. American Horror Story managed to provide both, without losing any of the blood and gore.

These days, horror movies like Get Out are credible Oscar nominees, but it all started with AHS. The road there has not been smooth though. Several incidents across the seasons have caused outcry from fans, critics, and special interests groups as Ryan Murphy’s show pushed the envelope as far as it could. Many episodes have caused meltdowns of varying degrees on social media as people have both defended and attacked the show’s depiction of murder, gore, and sexual violence.

In spite of, or perhaps because of, these controversies, the show has proved a smash hit success. It should go without saying that some of these entries may be upsetting, as there are very few dark corners the show ever avoids.

10. Misrepresenting The Church Of Satan

Church Of Satan AHS
FX

The Church Of Satan featured in Apocalypse’s Return To Murder House, and it wasn’t so much controversial with the public as it was extremely controversial with the Church itself. The fanbase was more concerned with the returning to Murder House part, debating whether Violet and Tate’s reunion was closure or needless fan service.

The Church itself though did not miss their cameo, and they were not best pleased. Despite their rather attention-grabbing name and inverted pentagram symbol, The Church Of Satan are not Satanists in the traditional sense. They aren’t devil worshippers at all, but atheists within a religious organisation.

The roots and history of the Church are a twistingly complex, but suffice to say, they don’t do the whole human sacrifice deal. In a scathing tweet storm, the official Church Of Satan tweeted that the show had ‘lazy writers’ churning out ‘drivel [that was] unimpressive and boring’.

People were split as to whose side they took. On the one hand, the Church had a point that they don’t do human sacrifice. On the other, AHS has always been over the top and has satirised real life before without anyone directly lashing out.


9. Roanoke’s Episode Ten

American Horror Story Lady Gaga
FX

This one’s controversial in ways completely separate to the rest of the list. But considering it’s a huge talking point for so many fans (including those who defended the show against all claims of gratuitous violence and shockjockery), it simply has to be included.

Roanoke is the most divisive season, in two ways. Most obviously, it divides the fanbase; some have it down as the worst season and know another fifty seasons wouldn’t change that. Others are more defensive of its experimental tone. But it was also quite literally divisive; told in three main acts. The first episodes were the re-enactment of the horror for in-universe TV show My Roanoke Nightmare, and the latter ones are the follow-up show Return To Roanoke: Three Days In Hell. This time around, the violence was built slowly as the show tried to freshen up.

Episode 10 threw all that nuance out of the window. It almost seems like the show was given a nine-episode run, then got handed another at the last second. The finale deals with three different shows reacting to the in-universe real love bloodshed of the Roanoke events, and for many fans it was just a bridge too far.


8. Cult’s Shooting Was Too True

AHS Cult Shooting
FX

The Guardian reported in February this year that the USA had seen 1,624 mass shootings in the previous 1,870 days. So while it might have been controversial to air one so graphically in 2017’s Season 7 Cult, no one could argue it wasn’t true to life.

One of the biggest problems with the episode was that it aired right after the Las Vegas shooting, which along with Parkland, Sandy Hook and Pulse, was one of the most deadly and notorious mass shootings of the decade. Although they happen much more often in the USA than anywhere else, mass shootings still cut the public deep. Especially when they take as many lives as the Las Vegas horror.

Showrunner Ryan Murphy usually never blinks in the face of graphic violence. Several entries here and dozens more besides attest to that. However, he felt the original cut would be too upsetting for victims, and so chopped a considerable 45 seconds out of the aired version.

That cut removes three deaths, including one reaching out for Ivy’s hand. It’s an understandable decision, but both the decision to air the scene at all and to heavily edit it drew criticism from different sections of the fanbase.


7. Madame Marie Delphine LaLaurie’s Redemption

American Horror Story Coven Blood Facial
FX

Madame Marie Delphine LaLaurie doesn’t just have one of the longest names in American Horror Story, she’s one of its best villains too. Her opening scene with slaves chained up as she skulks through sneering is one of the most atmospheric the series has ever managed. And placing the hollowed out bull’s head upon her slave, symbolising her view of him as an animal is a cyanide laced cherry on an anthrax cake.

The show makes it easy to hate her without forcing it; Kathy Griffin hits her Misery level heights in the role.

So when she’s resurrected in the future by a gang of witches including the African American Queenie, there’s plenty of chance for her to get her comeuppance. Her racist attitude rings even harsher against a modern backdrop too.

Then along came Roots. Queenie, who’s a gentle soul underneath her feisty exterior, forces Madame Marie to watch the seminal show charting black history through the ages. And just like that, her racism is cured. It would be terrific if ignorance could be fixed this easily in real life. But since it can’t, the redemption arc feels cheap, unearned, and completely sullies a great villain; cue controversy among the fans.


6. Freak Show: All Of It

Maggie Esmerelda Death American Horror Story Freak Show
FX

Freak Show conjoured a lot of controversy out of its top hat, and while most instances were minor, added together there’s a sizeable chunk of Freak Show mired in the swamp of controversy.

Firstly, there’s the soundtrack. Featuring the yet to be born Lana Del Rey and six year old Jim Morrison, it’s strikingly anachronistic. Ryan Murphy explained he chose musicians who identified as ‘freaks’ to fit the motif, but debate still raged about the immersion breaking song choices.

Next up on the chopping block quite literally is Maggie Esmeralda, whose death by bisection caused controversy for how graphic it became. Like Elsa Mars’ limb removal though, it wasn’t too far out of the ordinary for AHS.

Then there’s the title; by far the meatiest chunk of this controversy stew. While it is set in the era of freak shows, such a title drew instant criticism from disability interest groups. Howard Sherman wrote a scathing takedown of the show for The Guardian, claiming freak to be a ‘slur’ and that AHS were trying to ‘push the vulnerable back into the margins’. The fact the show had used disabled actors like Jamie Brewer prior to Freak Show was apparently lost on Sherman.


5. The Nail Gun Shooting

AHS RJ Nail Gun
FX

There have been many more graphic scenes in AHS, more violent and more blood splattered too. But none were quite as unsettling as RJ’s death by nail gun in Cult.

The scene unfolds slowly; Kai never dehumanised RJ even as he kills him, and this cold, calculating nature is matched perfectly by the choice of weapon. It kills RJ slow, and we see the light slip away from his eyes. In other series, there might have been heads exploding or blood gushing over the assailants. But Cult’s realism is fiercely adhered to for all to see. All those whose stomachs didn’t force them to turn off, that is.

The fact everyone must participate, with some apathetic, some empowered and some so reluctant made this so uncomfortable. It was controversial because it could happen. It’s unlikely we’ll experience witches or demons or spirits, but someone in power convincing a group to turn on the weakest member? Disturbingly accurate.

RJ stays alive through most of the ordeal to, as we first see what Kai is capable of. A scene that made so many viewers change the channel is highly controversial, but it’s brilliantly acted, written, and shot.


4. Lana’s Self Inflicted Abortion

American Horror Story Asylum Lana Winters
FX

Abortion is a controversial topic however you look at it. In American Horror Story’s homeland, it’s single issue vote winner with evangelicals. And while it’s unlikely many evangelicals watched this episode, given the season featured demonic possession of a nun, this still caused a hell of a stir.

The show, perhaps anticipating the backlash, throws all the abortion arguments together. Lana’s pregnancy is a child of rape, carrying it is actively harming her and (obviously this one is unique to the show) is the devil’s spawn. She is truly desperate when she picks up the coat hanger.

Regardless of your political persuasion, watching a woman self-administer an abortion is awful viewing. Made so much worse by the knowledge that while a lot of Asylum’s most torturous treatment of patients is a thing of the past, for many poor women in countries where abortions are expensive, inaccessible or illegal, coat hanger abortion is still very real.

As with so much of AHS’ darkest moments, the camera doesn’t look away. Most tragically for Lana, it doesn’t even work and she’s put through all that pain for nothing.


3. The Addiction Demon Rape

American Horror Story Hotel Addiction Demon
FX

The first of two rape scenes on the list, this scene at least has something to say on a creative level. That wasn’t enough to satisfy those who feel violent sexual abuse should never be shown on television, but it at least has a leg to stand on, while the other scene is decidedly more Elsa Mars in its defence.

The demon is symbolic of grip drugs have on addicts; it claws at them, attacks their deepest vulnerabilities, renders them helpless and turns something positive (the high) into something brutal, painful and raw.

While there’s certainly grounds to call this an artful (if jet black dark) interpretation of addiction, the design of the demon itself has Ryan Murphy’s usual over the top panache. The pale, waxy, faceless body is AHS’ typical brand of terror and no real cause for controversy. What made the scene so disturbing was the sharp, metal, conical strap-on the demon wore and used to penetrate his victim, Max Greenfield’s Gabriel.

There’s symbolism in that too, one could argue, a heroin addict being raped by essentially a faceless needle. But when it’s this disturbing, it’s no surprise so many criticised the scene heavily on social media.


2. Tate’s School Shooting

Tate Langdon AHS
FX

Much like the shooting in Cult, the first season of American Horror Story also featured a controversial shooting, and this time it was not toned down.

Tate’s shooting didn’t air around any majorly reported shooting incidents, although the frequency of shootings in the USA suggests one happened and was not reported. It was also before the Parkland shooting galvanised a movement, but Tate’s nature was eerie similar to the Columbine shooters, and the whole arc made many uncomfortable.

In a move that was surely courting controversy, when Violet searches the internet for information, the results are the same as Columbine’s just with text changed to fit Tate. Even the school’s name, Westfield High, matches the high school of the Virginia Tech shooter before he killed 33 at Tech.

While Tate was a compelling character, he seemed to at least get the retribution he deserved for his crimes. Trapped forever in the Murder House with his love, but destined never to be with her. However, Apocalypse rewrote his ending to give him happiness at last. Does everyone deserve a shot at redemption? Should AHS have taken such strides to humanise a school shooter? Great TV asks the audience questions, and Tate certainly does that.


1. Madison Montgomery’s Gang Rape

Ahs Madison
FX

As brutality becomes more common on television, shows will always look for ways to push the boundaries. However, using rape to propel the narrative forward often comes under fire, most notably with Sansa Stark.

While Game Of Thrones was criticised for panning away to Theon, American Horror Story was criticised for the exact opposite. However, it was made far more horrible by social media’s reaction. There were good faith debates on both sides, but some sick viewers cheered the scene on, fuelled by their hatred of the actress, Emma Roberts, lamenting that they weren’t part of the gang.

While there’s a dark artistry to the rape in Hotel, this scene from Coven lacks that subtlety.

It’s not even the only sexual abuse storyline that season, with Evan Peters’ Kyle molested by his mother. Is this evidence of a deeper theme of abuse, or just piling shock upon shock for a gimmick? Viewers fall on either side, and it’s easy to see why.

If we sanitise our televisions of anything upsetting, the reality of storytelling falls apart. But after this scene, it’s easy to see why some argue the most heinous acts of humanity should not be used for entertainment.

What did you think of these controversial moments? Let us know down in the comments.


Contributor

Self appointed queen of the SJWs. Find me on Twitter @FiveTacey (The 5 looks like an S. Do you get it? Do you get my joke about the 5?)