American Horror Story: 12 Most Dramatic Deaths

So. Much. Drama.

True to American Horror Story standards, AHS: Hotel has continued the hallowed tradition of adding to the current death toll in almost every episode by entertaining viewers with some pretty grim and dramatic deaths; so much so that you question why you even watch the show. From Season One onwards, there have been so many examples of brutality and horrendously gruesome deaths, alongside many taboo themes, that you're not even sure how the series got the green light in the first place. But that's what you love about the show, right? AHS is able to explore the darkness that a lot of television shows simply don't have the guts to do, and that's because a lot of people probably don't want to see people being drowned or killed by having a fire poker shoved up their behind. Luckily the AHS fanbase defies the norm, because we can't get enough of these dramatic and inventive deaths.

Honourable Mention: The Lowes' Dog

Season: Hotel The poor dog. We all saw it coming, right? But why do we get so upset about seeing animals die on screen? Is it because we're desensitised to seeing humans die that it's a shock to our systems, or is it because we just prefer animals? Either way, that dog was hunted down and feasted on by a little boy who was just supposed to love him. RIP the Lowes' family dog.

12. Moira O'Hara

Season: Murder House Okay, so Moira used to be an extremely attractive lady during her day and she knew it. She used her alluring charm and, ahem, stockings, to seduce and manipulate men which unfortunately resulted in her premature death. Although she originally betrayed her friend Constance by engaging in an affair with her husband, she realised the error of her ways and her sense of morality trumped her desire for this man's attention in the bedroom. Enraged by her rejection of him, his ego decided to get what he wanted from Moira by force. As this act of violence and violation was happening, Constance enters the room and believes that it is a mutual agreement. Angered by the betrayal and distrust of both of them, she kills them both, but Moira is the first to go with a shot through the right eye. What means Moira's death so dramatic is not only the accuracy of Constance's shot, but the speed in which the deaths occur. And of course, Moira was being attacked by Constance's husband at the time, so being killed by your friend who definitely got the wrong end of the stick is a bad way to go.

11. Elizabeth Short

Season: Murder House Poor Elizabeth Short. She went to Dr. Charles Montgomery for help in her hour of need and he took advantage of her and then ended her life. Based on the unsolved case of the Black Dahlia, Short's character suffers the same fate as the poor woman who was mutilated in 1947. Her body was sliced in half at the waist and unfortunately, her death has not yet received justice as the case has still not been solved since the tragedy occurred. American Horror Story recreated the death as experienced by Short and they also included the brutal mutilations that the killer performed on her body, including cutting the corners of her mouth open to create a wider smile. For fans of the show who may not have heard of the Black Dahlia case before, the death did come as a bit of a shock simply because of the brutal nature of her murder. Obviously, murder will always be brutal, but the poor girl was cut in half and left on the street.

10. The Teacher

Season: Hotel Is there anything worse than seeing a teacher not able to control her class? How about those kids drinking the blood of their teacher? Yeah, this one was pretty bad. Unfortunately Alex thought she was saving a life but she's just made things a lot worse as now there are a lot of children running around LA who are addicted to drinking blood, and they're killing anyone for it. There's something unnatural about watching children make the decision to take a life as it's usually adults who are responsible for creating such heinous crimes. Having said that, the kids are then draining their victims of their blood. And they're getting away with it too because they're children and who could suspect kids of such unnatural behaviour?

9. Vivien Harmon

Season: Murder House Poor Viv, she didn't have a great time did she? Cheated on by her husband on multiple occasions with a dead daughter haunting her house and the spawn of Satan on the way, the chances of her surviving the house were slim, but you were still rooting for the protagonist to make it out alive. Her pregnancy was aided with the help of the souls residing in the house and they included nurses, so you thought she might have been okay, but no, she dies horrifically during child birth. She is then persuaded by Violet, who is already dead, to just let go and join her in the afterlife. All those emotions...

8. Meep

Season: Freak Show What did Meep ever do to anyone? All he did was "Meep" and bite the heads off of chickens for entertainment, and he was loved for it. Meep was a very innocent character and his use of singular vocabulary meant that he was unable to defend himself inside the interrogation room of the police station and physically inside the prison cell. At the Freak Show he had his friends to protect and defend him, but as soon as he was thrown out of that place of warmth and security, he was like a fish out of water. But what made Meep's departure so brutal was the fact that he was beaten to death by prisoners just because he was born different, as well as the fact that he was imprisoned for a crime that he didn't commit in the first place. He was betrayed by Dell who placed evidence amongst Meep's possessions. Although you didn't see his death on screen, it was difficult to watch Jimmy's and the rest of the freaks' reaction to Meep's little body which was brought back and dumped in front of their tent. Unfortunately the actor who played Meep, Ben Woolf, was tragically killed in a car accident in February earlier this year.

7. Tate Langdon

Season: Murder House It's clear to see that Tate had some issues, but to kill his step father and then a whole load of fellow students was scary to watch simply because of how calm he remained during the whole execution process. He was focused and completely void of any emotion; even when the police raided his house and he was stood at gunpoint, nothing seemed to faze him. However, what made Tate's death so dramatic is the revelation that he is actually dead, and he caused so much devastation during his final hours that it seems impossible for Violet to remain in love with him knowing these things.


6. Ma Petite

Season: Freak Show What made Ma Petite's death so dramatic was her innocence. She was the only Freak who did not harvest any dark thoughts or feelings towards others, and instead focused on providing some positivity to the group. Not only was her death deceitful and shocking, it was also the second attempt to kill her, all for money. When Maggie couldn't go through with the plan initially because she realised at the last moment that she has a conscience, we all thought that Ma Petite was safe. But then in comes strongman Dell, the polar opposite to the Smallest Woman In The World that her death just seemed so unfair. With anyone else, she wouldn't have stood a chance, but to get smothered by Dell who is huge in comparison to a normal sized human, (as well as being a fellow Freak) was just heartless.

5. Maggie Esmerelda

Season: Freak Show What goes around comes around and for Maggie, karma cut her in half for what she tried to do to Ma Petite. Maggie volunteers to perform in Chester's magic trick and, ironically, doesn't see her death coming. Because of Chester's hallucinations, he doesn't see Maggie but the victims of his past and she suffers horrendously when he makes sure that she is unable to escape. He severs her in half in front of the other freaks, but what makes this so dramatic is that no one can do anything to help her and Emma Roberts, who plays Maggie, has one set of lungs on her...

4. Mr March's Victim

Season: Hotel It's easy to look at March and evaluate that he is a psychopath whose hobby it is to murder people; after all, he builds a torture chamber that is disguised as a hotel, but that doesn't mean that watching him in action is going to be any less shocking. In a scene full of bondage and machetes, we see a woman having sex with March who is then sliced open in the chest and stomach with every thrust of his hips. It's probably one of the most gruesome murders on the show to date and it wasn't even given to anyone of significance as viewers didn't even learn her name. However, this particular death exemplifies March's terribly sadistic and masochistic tendencies which reveal just how unhinged he really is.

3. Violet Harmon

Season: Murder House Murder House proved that no one was safe, but Violet's death was so dramatic because no one knew that she was dead. Even Violet didn't know that she was a ghost. What looked like a failed suicide attempt was actually fatal as Tate was too late to save her, and both Violet and the viewers have this epiphany simultaneously. Of course it's AHS, so the way only we were going to discover what happened to her was to physically see it, rotting corpse and all.

2. Pepper's Nephew

Season: Freak Show Out of every character in the AHS anthology, Pepper has probably been dealt with the worst card in life. After her 'husband' Salty is murdered, she is taken to live at her sister's house where she is neglected and seen as a burden. Despite everyone's ill wishes on Pepper, she is extremely innocent and playful and she really doesn't deserve what happens to her. But neither does her equally innocent nephew... Her nephew, Lucas, is also disfigured and seen as a burden by his parents, Pepper's sister and husband, Rita and Larry. Embarrassed and ashamed by the both of them, Larry concocts a plan to get get rid of them both and he plants evidence that Pepper is responsible for infanticide. The poor child is murdered by his own father and his auntie is blamed for his death, because who would miss or defend a couple of freaks?

1. Shelley

Season: Asylum If Shelley had been tortured by the Nazi doctor and kept in the seclusion of the asylum, would her death still have been as dramatic? No, because look at her and she was exposed to poor, innocent children in a playground and it was absolutely horrific. The experiments that Doctor Arden performed on her were brutal, unnecessary and done without a conscience; after all, he was a Nazi. He was warped and although he saw himself as a Promethean figure, he was more of a monster than the creatures that he created in his laboratory. But because Shelley stood up for herself and rejected Arden, she was forced to endure an obscene amount of torture before she died. Her death is by far the most memorable out of AHS to date and the elongation of itjust made it even more brutal. Which AHS character do you think had the most dramatic death? Let us know in the comments.

Contributor

Lover of Tolkien's world, Harry Potter and baked goods. A camel once put his head on my shoulder and it was the best day ever. sara@whatculture.com