American Horror Story has become one of the highest rated FX shows recently and has spurred some of the best and the scariest storytelling told in a while. It is currently enjoying its third season entitled Coven, revolving around a clan of witches. This is the rare kind of show which can change it up every season and still manage to keep its high fanbase. This show manages to both step up its game and possibly become even scarier with each season. With the inclusion of Kathy Bates in the third season, I was thinking, what other actors known for starring in horror movies could make an appearance on the show, and what kind of characters would they play? After consideration, I have devised six iconic horror actors from some of the most famous horror franchises made, who would both be possible to hire and would create a memorable performance for the show. Let's crack on with my first choice.
6. Brad Dourif
Best known for his role as Charles Lee Ray and being the voice of the killer doll Chucky in the Child's Play franchise and a supporting role in Rob Zombie's Halloween franchise as Sheriff Brackett, Brad Dourif has made a name for himself as a horror icon and the fans agree. With talk of the Child's Play reboot, all of the fans wanted him back to voice the character, as no one could replace him. This proves that Dourif clearly has a well built fanbase centering around one of his most iconic characters, and would be terrific for an appearance on the show in a forthcoming season. The kind of character he would play however, would need to be something to do with his voice. His voice is perhaps his most menacing feature when it comes to the horror aspect of his acting. Perhaps if the show wishes to follow the supernatural elements it continues to explore, Dourif could perhaps play a demon or a warlock of some sort. He has the look of a devil, so for a twist of fate he could actually play the Devil. With some make up and enhanced effects, I am sure he could create a stunning, unforgettable performance.
5. Tim Curry
Known for scaring children everywhere with his unique voice and his portrayal of Pennywise the Clown in Stephen King's IT, Tim Curry is definitely one of the more frightening on this list. I for one, blame my fear of clowns entirely on this guy's performance. With the rumour that the next season of the show will include a travelling circus revolved around circus freaks, Tim Curry just screams the role of ringmaster to me. He has the look of an incredibly well sophisticated gentleman who could go from the nice caring ringmaster who puts on a great show for the audience and happily smiles for the cameras, but when the lights are off, he transforms into a cold, heartless abusive master who physically and verbally abuses the other circus freaks. Similar to how Joseph Fiennes was written in season 2 of the show, I could see Tim Curry giving a similar yet more unique performance as to not completely copy Fiennes. You could cast him as a scary clown, but that would be extremely redundant. With his terrifying voice and physical presence, Tim Curry seems to be one of the actors that should appear on one of the most loved horror shows of the past decade.
4. Jamie Lee Curtis
Jamie Lee Curtis became a notable horror icon for being the first incarnation of Michael Myers's sister Laurie Strode in John Carpenter's Halloween franchise. Symbolised as a scream queen, to avoid typecasting she then went on to play supporting roles in comedies such as Freaky Friday or You Again to guest appearances on network television shows like NCIS. She hasn't been in public's eye too often which would make her easy to hire for a season of American Horror Story. With Jessica Lange stated not to return for the show's next season, maybe Curtis could fill her shoes as a similar character, whether she be the loving mother type with a dark secret, or a full fledged villain reminiscent of a psychotic killer. I could see her play any one of those roles and she would be an absolutely joy to see return to the screen back in the horror game. She has a fan base amongst the horror fans for being one of the first 'scream queens' and for creating such an iconic horror character that girls were able to relate to instead of casting the supermodel who is always running out the door. Jamie Lee Curtis would be a great guest on the show.
3. Tony Todd
The man responsible for making us scared to look in a mirror in Candyman and making us scared of any potential environmental disaster in Final Destination. Is there any reason that Death himself should not make an appearance in the show? No? Didn't think so. Whilst he isn't portrayed as a villain in Final Destination but more as a helpful ally to warn them about the accidents, in his roles in Candyman and even Smallville he does a good job at playing both a sympathetic villain (Smallville) and an evil one (Candyman). As for a character that he could play on American Horror Story, this is the kind of actor who I believe should be a villain. He doesn't really have a busy schedule so there is no conflict with hiring him, and he is iconic enough to be remembered by fans of the show as a great character. My idea for a character Tony Todd could be is a demonic satanist cult serial killer leader, which could bring in both the slasher and supernatural element to the show, therefore giving a good balance for all types of horror fans.
2. Bruce Campbell
A fan favorite and great horror icon if there ever was one. Known for his role as Ash in the Evil Dead series, Bruce Campbell would be a welcome choice to joining the cast of American Horror Story. In terms, Campbell is almost like the horror version of Nathan Fillion. He never gets the roles people want him in, he is in fan-casts for a lot of roles, and he is in all terms, an incredible actor. He even kind of looks like Fillion in a way. For introducing Campbell onto the show, I think he should play a protagonist character who knows about supernatural elements, which would in ways be an Easter egg to his character in Evil Dead. He works well with an ensemble cast, which American Horror Story seems to do, and would be well suited to any part. He could play the witty protagonist that everyone loves, or he could play a full fledged villain who you can't help but love. When both of those options end up with you loving the actor, that isn't a bad thing. Hate to say it, but this casting would be..groovy.
1. Robert Englund
Was there any doubt he would be on this list? The man behind the make up as one of the most terrifying and memorable serial killers of all time, Freddy Kreuger, deserves to be on this show, in fact no, needs to be on this show in a prominent role. He is perhaps the most well known horror icon of all time, and in no doubt his recent move into television and smaller movies would leave him available for a role on the show. As for who he could play on the show, this would in no doubt allow the writers to create a season I would like to see, which is a season focusing on a slasher killer instead of supernatural elements as it tends to do, which in sometimes can be more terrifying and more realistic. Robert Englund would no doubt be able to pull this kind of role off. It would also be an interesting idea to perhaps make him a protagonist character who understands the elements of a psychopath, perhaps make him a criminal psychiatrist. Whatever role he is put in for the show, I am sure he could deliver a terrifying and chilling performance that would be unforgettable for the show. So that's my picks for who I think should make an appearance on American Horror Story. So what do you think? Do you agree with my choices? What other horror icons would you like to see make an appearance on the show? And also, what kind of story would you like to see in Season 4 of the show? Whatever you think , leave a comment below and let me know.
Just a regular, everyday guy who loves to write and have his work published. Long time fan of DC and Marvel comics and loves nothing more than to see his fave characters adapted on screen.