Arrow Season 4: 5 Reasons Why The Comics Shouldn't Matter

One of these things is not like the other.

Arrow Season 4
The CW

Back in 2012, The CW premiered an experimental new show called Arrow. The series would follow the misadventures of former billionaire playboy Oliver Queen whose five-year crucible after being shipwrecked on a hellish island inspired him to take up vigilantism upon his return to civilization. He’s a master archer and martial artist, the likes of which had never been introduced as a live action protagonist in a DC venture on television. Oliver Queen is Batman with a bow.

He is also based upon a comic character known as the Green Arrow.

As it happens, however, Green Arrow is one of the more obscure heroes from DC lore. Plenty of viewers who tuned into the show in 2012 hadn’t even known that it was an adaptation of comics at all, and yet they were still able to enjoy it just fine. In the first two seasons especially, the show made sense for comic virgins. The distant source material didn’t matter in the least.

The third season saw the show abandon its tenuous grip on realism to an unprecedented extent, forcing those comic virgins to wrack their brains for reasonable explanations for some of the twists. Arrow has always worked best when producers and viewers alike treat the show as an adaptation rather than a translation.

Here are five in-depth reasons why the specifics of comic lore should really be used as guidelines rather than actual rules for the series. 

5. No Homework Required

Arrow Flashback Maseo Oliver
The CW

Television is a self-contained medium. Even cliffhangers and crossovers such as those that have frequented Arrow throughout Season 3 were designed to entice viewers to return for the next installment rather than to send them to their browsers to hit up Wikipedia for information about the characters that appeared in any given episode. Whether a show is written as a serial in the vein of a Law and Order or toward a single climax a la True Detective, it is designed to be complete within itself. Even series based upon real life events such as the reimagining of the Charles Manson ordeal of the 1960s with Aquarius can be watched without a background in the true crime genre or the American civil rights movement.

If Arrow were to rely heavily on comic lore already known to a subset of viewers with the expectation that general viewers would follow up could backfire rather spectacularly. The show veered a bit to closely to over-reliance on comic lore with the introduction of the Lazarus Pits and Laurel’s receipt of the Canary Cry. As proven by the consistent usage of flashbacks, Arrow is fully capable of incorporating and expositing its own lore on its own terms; there’s no reason why the show should be hamstrung by past goings-on of the comics.


4. Character Destinies

arrow laurel lance black canary
The CW

Part of the fun of any television series is watching characters develop and grow as the narrative finds its footing. Characters are juggled as producers discover which click on screen and which storylines are compatible and which actors play best off of one another. Daryl Dixon on The Walking Dead took on a life of his own when his surly redneck ways meshed with the cast, Logan became de facto male lead on Veronica Mars thanks to chemistry with the protagonist, and both Diggle and Felicity on Arrow carved their niches by bringing qualities that Oliver never thought that he’d need in his life. Developments delight, and organic characterization can make a show.

With the comic lore of Green Arrow and DC at the fingertips of the writers, there is a massive cache of pre-packaged characters ripe for the picking. It worked for Oliver; why shouldn’t it work with some of his comic fellows?

Enter Laurel Lance.

Originally introduced as pre-existing romantic lead and a crusader for justice from within the legal system to foil the Hood, she was turned into a wishy-washy addict as the show treaded water with fulfilling the comic destiny of Dinah Laurel Lance to become the Black Canary. As such, characterization was sacrificed as she was rushed through a journey toward a mask without adequate preparation in-show in Season 3.


3. Focus On Oliver

Arrow oliver queen
The CW

While there is no dearth of shows out there with credits arranged alphabetically or financially due to no established lead, most feature either a protagonist or a protagonist unit. The Doctor undoubtedly outranks his companion on Doctor Who, Merlin deservedly had top-billing on Merlyn, and Sam and Dean Winchester certainly haven't faced any competition on Supernatural. Shows almost always have a lead or lead unit to receive most of the attention and development, because it just works.

The lead of Arrow is obviously Oliver Queen. It’s not because he looks great without a shirt or because he’s a fantastic actor or because his oodles of hard work show in each and every episode. It’s because the show is called Arrow. There should be no doubt of who should receive most attention and development.

Unfortunately, Season 3 chose to advance characters of comic fame toward superheroism rather than focus on the protagonist. Ray Palmer as the ATOM, Laurel Lance as Black Canary, Roy Harper as Arsenal to a certain extent…all were promoted for their roles as comic characters rather than peripheral Arrow characters. The series is not called Arrow And Friends or Arrow, Etc., and even if certain character have journeys in comic lore does not mean that those journeys belong onscreen for Arrow. 


2. Plot Changes

Arrow 2 4 Edited 2
The CW

Most American network series run with upward of twenty episodes per season. As such, few programs can devote every single installment to a certain arc. Most follow a model made prominent by The X-Files with its ongoing “mythology” revisited between standalones. Arrow is no different. Oliver may have an archnemesis each year, but he mostly just faces plain old villains. With decades of Green Arrow adventures documented on page, there were plenty to choose from within his lore.

Diehard comic fans were therefore rather displeased to discover that many aspects of Season 3’s mythology were drawn from Batman rather than Green Arrow. Ra’s training Oliver, Oliver wedding Ra’s daughter, even the image of Oliver skewered by a scimitar…all are derivative of Batman.

While not particularly commendable for the writers, it's actually okay. Arrow isn’t Batman. Oliver Queen is not Bruce Wayne. The two won’t be crossing paths at a billionaire vigilante support group. The only Bruce Wayne on primetime television is pre-pubescent, mostly just weird, and featured on a show on a different network. The universes are separate.

If the producers want to steal from Batman or Superman or Aquaman, they can without affecting the narrative of Arrow. They should perhaps be a bit ashamed of themselves; at the end of the day, however, it won’t actually make a difference to the story.


1. Adaptation

arrow team arrow felicity smoak oliver queen john diggle
The CW

In recent years, adaptations of books for television have become popular. The most obvious example would be HBO’s Game of Thrones. As readers of the five books comprising the source material can attest, there is simply too much material to make it onto the show. Whether because of time or effects or budget, the characters and material are adapted rather than transferred from page to screen.

Transference is even more impossible for Arrow. There are decades of material composed by a variety of writers adhering to a variety of canons within at least one reboot of the entire DC universe. Transference of every major storyline for the Green Arrow to Arrow is literally impossible.

It is therefore essential that everybody both behind the scenes and behind the screens remember that Arrow is an adaptation of source material. Divergences from DC lore have, can, and will happen. The Oliver Queen of Arrow is not the Ollie Queen of the comics. The Laurel Lance of Arrow is not the Dinah Laurel Lance of the comics. Archvillains Dark Archer and Slade Wilson and Ra’s al Ghul of Arrow are not the archvillains of the comics. Felicity Smoak was from a different series, and John Diggle didn’t even exist within the comics until recently. The only way to enjoy both mediums is to accept them as fundamentally separate.


Contributor
Contributor

Fiction buff and writer. If it's on Netflix, it's probably in my queue. I've bought DVDs for the special features and usually claim that the book is better than the movie or show (and can provide examples). I've never met a TV show that I won't marathon. Follow on Twitter @lah9891 .